11 ms·
Everything happening on Bluesky
- yuliyp 4y agoBasically Bluesky is getting to learn all of the lessons about why running a social network is hard, at an extremely high speed, with lots of public scrutiny. Fun.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoIt is very human to continuously fail to listen to the lessons of history, only to rediscover them.
- pc86 4y agoNot a comment specific to Bluesky at all, but I think it's human to believe that we are different than the thousands/millions/billions of people to try $THING before us. That somehow our intuition is better (it might be, but rarely), or that it will be faster/easier to just experiment our way to our end goal rather than step back and learn first (it might be, but rarely).
- JohnFen 4y agoYes, and particularly for devs. We tend to start to believe our own hype and think we're uniquely smart.
- elliekelly 4y agoSometimes I’ll revisit code I’ve written and think “wow, so dumb, I could’ve just done xyz” only to implement my obviously far-superior method and recall that I’ve already learned this lesson and there was a good reason I hadn’t done xyz the first time.
- JohnFen 4y agoYes! I am humbled every time I look at my old code. I'm always disappointed by it. This is because I've grown since I wrote it, so that's a good thing. I don't want my best work to be behind me. At the same time, I also have to recognize that the brilliant code I'm writing right now will look disappointing in five years.
- kayodelycaon 4y agoI try to leave comments for myself and others when I’ve had to write code that looks less than ideal. It’s nice to know something was hacked in for convenience or because it was the best solution at the time. :)
- JohnFen 4y agoYes, when you're knowingly writing less than ideal code. But we're talking about writing code that you thought was great when you wrote it, but when you come back to it a few years later, you can see how far from great it really was. Which, for me, accounts for about 80% of everything I've written.
- dragonwriter 4y agoYeah, which given that Bluesky is a Twitter spin-off with Jack Dorsey as an identified cofounder, board member, and so much the public face that the actual CEO has to remind people that she, not Dorsey, is the CEO, is a bit surprising. You'd think that they’d know all this from day one...
- taco_emoji 4y agoI mean, it blew up in popularity literally overnight. I'm willing to bet a lot of these features are on their backlog, they just haven't had time to do them all yet.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoPeople elsewhere have said it before, and I'm going to echo their words: It is simply irresponsible to launch a new social media platform without a solution for trust and safety already in place. That they did so puts their judgement in serious question.
- capableweb 4y agoDoes being a private, invite-only deployment count as launching nowadays? We used to reserve that word for when services publicly launch and are ready for the general public.
- ohgodplsno 4y agoWhen you're spamming about yourself throughout the internet, paying for publicity about how you super secret private exclusive club is so much better than Twitter, yes, it's a launch. In the same way that Clubhouse launched, despite being invite only.
- tedunangst 4y agoI don't think bluesky has control over other people hyping them. If they were buying Super Bowl ads, that would be one thing. Exuberant press from extremely online take makers is another.
- capableweb 4y ago> When you're spamming about yourself throughout the internet > paying for publicity about how you super secret private exclusive club is so much better than Twitter I haven't seen either of those things happening from the bluesky team. I've seen them talk about bluesky, which makes sense, but spamming? Neither have I seen any ads to join bluesky, which would be weird considering you cannot really join bluesky unless you get an invite. Where did you see the paid advertisement precisely?
- skybrian 4y agoIf they really can learn at high speed then that would be a significant competitive advantage, more important than getting things right up front.
- v0idzer0 4y agoAmazing how a “slightly sexist” post not being banned from Twitter is definitive evidence of leadership malpractice and direct threats to murder people on Bluesky is just fun “shitposting”. Mainstream media is truly horrified of Elon Musk.
- tkngctrl 4y agoIt's just not. I realize that a large chunk of former Twitter addicts and propagandists have MDS, but Bluesky is dead in the water. People are just gonna have to deal with Twitter's increased freedom of speech if they want to be heard on social media.
- Pxtl 4y agoTitle currently showing in the article is "Bluesky showed everyone’s ass / In many cases, literally."
- bluepod4 4y agoSo funny. It’s also hilarious that the users are using the term “skeet”. (Interestingly and semi-related, a TechCrunch article said that Bluesky needs sex workers and Black Twitter in order to thrive.)
- pelagic_sky 4y agoI wonder if Bluesky is going to Google+ itself by staying in Beta too long.
- WFHRenaissance 4y agoThey're going to Clubhouse themselves by being stingy with invite codes.
- capableweb 4y agoWasn't the thing that killed Google+ that it just didn't have enough engagement for it to be worth for Google to run it? I seem to remember that at the time, Google was saying that 99% of the user sessions were less than a minute, or something like that, and that's the reason they are shutting it down. If I remember that correctly, it seems it wouldn't have mattered if they had a Beta label on it or not.
- morkalork 4y agoThat and the ill-will generated by forcibly cramming it down everyone's throats a la the youtube debacle.
- MengerSponge 4y agoGuess my age: I'm mad at Google for 1) Reader 2) Breaking + as a search operator
- DueDilligence 4y ago[dead]
- rvz 4y agoSo far Bluesky has learned the mistakes of Mastodon's awful search and 'choose an instance' confusion and has a default server ready for users to use, instead of being forced to choose. But it risks repeating the same mistakes as Clubhouse if it doesn't open its invite system once another wave happens. The next wave of users running away from Twitter will happen when the orange man takes back his Twitter account and sends his first tweet in years, with the media screaming about it. Probably later this year, but who knows. We'll see how Bluesky really performs on adoption when that next wave happens.
- mg 4y agoI have not yet tried Bluesky, but paradoxically, I think the "success" that currently everybody wants to try Bluesky might be an indicator that it will fail. If there is so much demand, why does nobody offer a free and open client? This might be a sign that it is hard to write and/or run one. I tried Nostr and it was extremely easy. Because it is so easy to write and run a client, there are plenty already.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- brundolf 4y agoPeople have released multiple open-source alt clients (mostly in beta states, because it hasn't been very long). I've played with the API myself and it's really quite easy to use, especially with an SDK (there's an official one in typescript and community ones are sprouting up in almost every major language). I'm in a discord for people doing stuff with the API that has almost 1k members
- mg 4y agoI tried Nostr on a web client. It was pretty easy. Just going to the website was enough. I have not seen such a thing for Bluesky yet. Is there a client online that one can simply use by visiting a website?
- brundolf 4y agoYou could definitely build a read-only one; only account creation and the things that go with it are invite-only, the rest is already public and distributed. I don't know of a client like you describe existing yet, but I could use the API endpoints I've already worked with to build one if I wanted to take the time. Edit: here's one https://skypulse.dvy.io/ https://skypulse.dvy.io/
- mg 4y agoThe invite-only aspect is part of the protocol?
- Hizonner 4y agoThe answer to existing centralized for-profit systems blowing up, or to existing federated systems having various problems (some of them caused by an inadequate federation architecture), is not another centralized for-profit system with vague promises of future federation.
- rchaud 4y agoThis is the irony inherent in the desire of many to plant a flag on something, anything, and call it Twitter 2.0. Many of the negative aspects of Twitter that drove people away (incl pre-Musk era) are repeated here. The ownership is centralized; why would a protocol need a CEO? The network will lean towards centralization as well; let's be real, the default instance will be 1000x bigger than any federated offshoot). It's frankly unfortunate to see so many of the tech bloggerati trying Mastodon, an actually decentralized solution without a for-profit mission, and then bandwagoning on to this new thing under the guise of wanting some lols, because Mastodon is too boring, they are no slapfights over celebrity/social media nonsense.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoAmen. Meanwhile, folks are crowing about how great the vibe is on the platform, and how welcoming it is to victimized communities. It's, what, 60,000 people? All invite-only? With a campaign specifically targeting Twitter power-users? And very actively curated to push out troublemakers? Yeah, of course the vibe is good. Now. Let's see what it's like when there's a few million folks on the platform with a small but vocal percentage actively engaging in harassment. Edit to add: Now, if they do live up to the hype--if they succeed in building an open, federated, protocol-first social platform that somehow also manages to bolt on opt-in algorithmic curation, moderation, and so forth--then that's great! But they're a private company, operating a very small platform right now, so it's simply too early to tell if they'll manage to live up to their promises.
- Pxtl 4y agoYes. Moderation is a hard problem. "Black Twitter" power-users complained about the racism on the incredibly anodyne Mastodon because Mastodon being volunteer and not-for-profit run, did not hire an army of 3rd-world moderators to handle the problem and still needs volunteer admins to take care of bigots, spammers, and other problem-users. It basically has broken down that the nerds and idealists have moved to Mastodon, the twitter elite have gone to BlueSky, the Bitcoin bros have gone to Nostr, and the people who have to use Twitter professionally have stayed with the bigots and conspiracy-theorists that are taking over Twitter.
- carlivar 4y agoI'm not a fan of Elon Musk, but why would we celebrate Jack Dorsey rebuilding the same flawed system that went too far towards censorship in the name of "misinformation"? https://reason.com/2023/03/17/researchers-pressured-twitter-to-treat-covid-19-facts-as-misinformation/ https://reason.com/2023/03/17/researchers-pressured-twitter-...
- Pxtl 4y agoBecause Jack Dorsey may have funded BlueSky, but he's not involved in running it, he's instead focused on Nostr, the web3 answer to the problem. And as for "misinformation" vs "censorship", I think Fox News just demonstrated over $700 million reasons to care about misinformation.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Because Jack Dorsey may have funded BlueSky, but he's not involved in running it Aside from being on Bluesky’s board of directors.
- carlivar 4y agoI'm fine with the courts deciding what is misinformation. That's a huge improvement.
- capableweb 4y agoNot to say if it's the best or worst, but considering his experience of running a platform he himself say failed at what he wanted it to do, wouldn't he be a good person to have on your side in order to stay clear of making the same mistakes? He openly say he fucked up with Twitter, and his involvement as funder of both Bluesky and Nostr is him trying to correct his mistakes with new platforms that cannot be abused in the same manner.
- dtrailin 4y agoHaving a waitlist was a smart approach for Bluesky. Gives them an opportunity to scale and polish the user experience while building hype for people without an invite.
- dehrmann 4y agoWe'll see. It depends how long the window for launching a twitter replacement is.
- lapcat 4y ago> Although Bluesky is currently hosted on only one server under the control of the Bluesky team, its intention is to eventually become a decentralized protocol for a multiplicity of federated servers with a variety of different moderation practices At this point they're just kicking the can down the road, postponing the problems that Mastodon already had to face. If mastodon.social were the entirety of Mastodon, it would seem a lot more user friendly.
- yarg 4y agoMastodon's user experience issues should be perfectly resolvable - you can follow accounts on other instances, I don't see why you shouldn't be able to create accounts on other instances as well. Go to an instance, select a bunch of interests, and have it return a set of instances that are accepting new accounts. It's meant to be a federated service - it should act like one.
- FireInsight 4y agoIf mastodon.social was the entirety of mastodon it would be pretty bad and I wouldn't be using it. But oh well, guess people just want Twitter 2.0.
- brundolf 4y agoBluesky made some key decisions that are different from Mastodon: - Profiles and posts are portable across hosted instances. If you have a problem with your admins, etc, you'll be able to hop away without much fuss. - Moderation is decoupled from hosting. They're still working out the details, but the overall vision is that the global firehose is public, and you'll be able to opt in and out of different moderators which operate on that stream. If you don't like what a moderator is doing, you'll be able to just turn them off for yourself. Moderation doesn't prevent people from posting, it allows people to prevent themselves from seeing.
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoWhich is all good in principle, and it'll be interesting to see how it works out. The profile portability story is good, save that as far as I can tell, Bluesky server operators don't actually do much save for provide storage and a place for clients to connect to, specifically because the algorithms and curation are being treated as a separate layer. So ironically I see far less reason for identity portability in that ecosystem since (to my knowledge) the server you're using doesn't have much of an impact on your experience. Additionally, this layered functional architecture creates new kinds of problems. For example, with Mastodon, if I'm helping fund my instance (which I do) I'm also helping fund the moderation staff, because the instance architecture and the moderation story are tightly coupled. With BS, moderation is a separate service which has to be funded... how? Same goes with curation. So I still have a lot of questions about the Bluesky model. And this is all assuming they actually pull off what they claim, and it's still waaaay too early to say if this'll all work in practice.
- 0zemp2c 4y ago[flagged]
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoYou're literally participating in an online community right now. Why did you create an account 8 days ago, and proceed to participate in conversation here, if places like this are just a "fake shitnozzle"?
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoThe issue is not online communities per se, it is creating yet another social media site that tries to house everyone. HN is a focused audience with active moderation, that's why it works. Social media? Completely different story. Scale is off the charts so it is difficult to moderate. Lots of noise, people trying to be brands and brands trying to be people. Idiotic clamoring for blue checkmarks as if they actually mean something. Collective belief in the metrics of the platform meaning something overall. Little pushback against unpleasant individuals, and few people questioning the pace or mechanics of platforms that actually create toxic environments. But yeah, other than that, social media is great. :)
- BaseballPhysics 4y agoYou're drawing some arbitrary line where a "focused audience" isn't "social media" whereas a "media site that tries to house everyone" is. All of these are social media. Tik Tok, Reddit, Hacker News, Facebook, Twitter, Bluesky, Mastodon, Github (yes, Github), Discord, and on and on... they're all social media, in that they provide places for individuals to connect and communicate. Which is what the OP seemed to be objecting to. Personally, I 100% agree with you: I don't believe winner-takes-all social media platforms must necessarily be the future, and in fact I think it'd be better if there was far greater diversity, which is why I strongly believe in a protocols-over-platforms future.
- riffic 4y agoit's still in doubt who exactly owns bluesky pbllc, but there has been some discussion and the claim is that it is owned by "the team" (which is vague and doesn't specify who or quantify how much stake is held by a shareholder). again, who owns the PBLLC? after clearing that up, I suppose my other question concerning Bluesky is if they intend to submit their protocol to the IETF or something. It's weird they're doing this whole thing parallel to protocols like W3C ActivityPub.
- brundolf 4y agoExplanation of how it actually works, please read before making assumptions: https://atproto.com/docs https://atproto.com/docs
- monkaiju 4y agoWhat is the monetisation strategy for Bluesky?
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis article started out interesting but rapidly degenerated into society gossip. I would feel embarrassed to have written this.
- arrakeen 4y ago> the service was straining under something that would become known as “the hellthread” hellthreads have been a thing on the fediverse since forever, it's as if the people behind bluesky didn't even bother to spend any time there before deciding to do their own thing
- capableweb 4y ago> hellthreads have been a thing on the fediverse since forever "hellthreads" have been a thing on the internet since people started interacting with each other on the internet. I don't think people on the fediverse invented the word either, the first time I saw something named "hellthread" I think was on early Twitter. Also, I don't think anyone is claiming that Bluesky invented the word. The article just says that a particular thread started being called such, and specifically "the hellthread" instead of the general "hellthread".
- brundolf 4y agoThe people on bluesky are not actually upset about the "hellthreads", they're mostly reveling and laughing about it. It's a fun piece of chaos, feels very early-internet
- ZacnyLos 4y agoMastodon is terrible because it’s hard to join—unlike Bluesky, a social network that is hard to join, which is great. Journalists are flocking to Bluesky, and not Mastodon because Bluesky allows retweets—which Mastodon doesn’t allow. Oh, and about hashtags, direct messages, and post edits not being available on Bluesky? Journalists don’t need them.
- FireInsight 4y agoMastodon does have retweets, and the joining is really easy after you pick a server. I think it's better that people have to pick and can still communicate with others who picked differently, instead of there being one obvious choice.
- FormerBandmate 4y agoBluesky is literally just full of Twitter addicted journalists who still use twitter
- INTPenis 4y agoMost end users want a simple centralized solution, this is just yet another proof of that. The fedi will remain a sub-cultural thing. I said that way back in the start of 2022 waves.
- brundolf 4y agoYou can have a nice centralized layer over a robust decentralized back-end, which people only have to use if things go south. And then that will keep the big players more honest, because users can just leave when they don't like what the client is doing (instead of being held hostage, like they are on twitter right now)
- dahwolf 4y agoSeems like the early mover effect. Regardless, these fediverse wars are fascinating to watch. Mastodon has the interesting situation where enthusiasts want to grow the network by having high profile characters join yet paradoxically the culture is exactly opposite to that. They frown upon influencer culture, anything remotely capitalistic, famous, etc. They're also against basic features like search, quote tweets, recommendation algorithms, anything proven and essential to make a network grow. Admittedly, those mechanisms do tend to lead to the culture seen on Twitter. Hilariously, that's what people seem to want. The high profile Twitter users that had every chance to join Mastodon, never did. Yet immediately jump to Bluesky. In response, Mastodon (the company) seems to finally come around and make some changes (easier to join, quote tweets coming, etc). Ultimately, the moderation approach is going to be decisive. In my view, Mastodon is "toxically safe". It leads to a culture unfit for the masses. Bluesky's long term culture is unclear to me, but I imagine it will be Twitter-like on the main server.