3 ms·
> The minimum requirement for a language to take off: first class Windows support. Swift is doing quite well, and it didn’t need Windows support to drive adopt
by latexr 4y ago
> The minimum requirement for a language to take off: first class Windows support.
Swift is doing quite well, and it didn’t need Windows support to drive adoption.
- zerr 4y agoWindows support... OR being a native SDK language for a popular platform, which Crystal is not. I also hear ABAP is doing fine on the SAP platform.
- metaltyphoon 4y agoSwift is necessary on macOS and is doing fairly poor outside of it because it didn't have Windows and Linux support on par.
- latexr 4y agoThe original comment claimed a language needs first class Windows support at a minimum to take off. Swift proves that is not a hard requirement, regardless of the reason for its popularity: that it’s the official vendor-supported language for a family of platforms that have been profitable for developers. That Swift isn’t as popular outside the officially supported platforms isn’t surprising and doesn’t matter. The point is precisely that it didn’t have to cater to a specific one (Windows) to achieve success.
- poulpy123 4y agoYes you don't need to be on windows if you have a quasi monopoly on 1 billion devices. But except swift and java there is no language that can pretend to it.
- notmypenguin 4y agoIf it wasn’t for the fact M$ preloaded Windows on nearly all OEM computers due to some seriously mafia-esque business practices we wouldn’t have to consider that OS at all. Two can play at that metaphor game
- poulpy123 4y agoYes but the fact is that windows has a 75% marketshare of personal computers. If you want your language to be widely adopted it has to be supported
- booleandilemma 4y agoI have never looked into Swift, because it seems to me, as a non-Mac developer, like a niche, Mac-only language. In my mind, if I'm not developing for the iPhone, why would I use Swift? If I need to write a CLI app, why, of all languages, would I pick Swift?
- latexr 4y ago> I have never looked into Swift Which is a valid choice, but it doesn’t mean that it isn’t successful or that it hasn’t taken off. Swift has achieved exactly the goal it was supposed to: become the official language for Apple platforms, replacing Objective-C as the entry point. > If I need to write a CLI app, why, of all languages, would I pick Swift? You probably wouldn’t. Other people might, for a variety of reasons including enjoying the language itself. I write CLI apps regularly and use several languages; Swift is one of them.
- anta40 4y agoSwift is different niche, though. Rust, Go, Nim, D etc can be used for writing Mac, Linux, Windows apps. Swift is practically limited on MacOs & iOS.
- latexr 4y agoThe comment I quoted claimed that for a language to take off it needs first class Windows support. If we’re going to limit the discussion to languages which “can be used for writing Mac, Linux, Windows apps”, then the argument is pointless. By definition, any language which can be used to write Windows apps has Windows support. That’s circular logic. To address the argument, it only makes sense to discuss languages which don’t have¹ first class Windows support. Everything else is irrelevant. ¹ Or didn’t but were still popular at that time.
- ezekg 4y agoSwift has support for server web apps (https://vapor.codes/ https://vapor.codes/), so I assume it has some interoperability with other operating systems.