5 ms·
Mobile phone calls linked with increased risk of high blood pressure
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> researchers analysed the relationship between mobile phone usage and new-onset hypertension after adjusting for age, sex, body mass index, race, deprivation, family history of hypertension, education, smoking status, blood pressure, blood lipids, inflammation, blood glucose, kidney function and use of medications to lower cholesterol or blood glucose levels Seriously? No control for non-mobile phone use, or even using a headset (i.e. not raising your arm)?
- rcme 4y agoThis was done over 12 years. It seems like that would be hard to control for over such a long period of time.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> seems like that would be hard to control for over such a long period of time Controlling for those over six months with a smaller sample would yield a more-meaningful result. This study fails to rule out the hypothesis that getting calls correlates with hypertension, which neighbours stress causes hypertension, which we know. (I am trying to find the study, because a quote near the top cites hands-free use.)
- jwilk 4y agohttps://academic.oup.com/ehjdh/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/ehjdh/ztad024 https://academic.oup.com/ehjdh/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/eh... (linked in the References section)
- onion2k 4y agoThe researchers analysed the relationship between mobile phone usage and new-onset hypertension after adjusting for age, sex, body mass index, race, deprivation, family history of hypertension, education, smoking status, blood pressure, blood lipids, inflammation, blood glucose, kidney function and use of medications to lower cholesterol or blood glucose levels. But not having a job or a family member that calls you with stressful crap?
- doubled112 4y agoFor me these are linked. The fact that I’m now expected to answer their stressful crap 24/7 definitely raises my blood pressure.
- htag 4y agoI just leave my cellphone places on purpose. Later I call them back with an excuse like "Sorry, I left my phone in the kitchen and was at my desk." Anyone that calls me regularly knows to expect this. I do keep my phone on and near me during standard business hours, but even then I might not answer a family call and give a work excuse.
- doubled112 4y agoI'm not taking the work phone anywhere I don't have to, that's for sure. I get to them when/if I feel it's appropriate. I've had zero problems there so far. I don't always have MY phone on me either, and even if I do I don't always answer. It is this phone where I have the biggest problem with people and boundaries. Sometimes I feel like I'm surrounded by needy children but they're in their 40s, 50s, and 70s. A phone call, a voice mail, a call back, another voice mail to remind me about the first call, maybe a call that night too. Nobody even died. It's not always the same person either. So the next call I do answer will be mostly a shaming about how I don't answer the phone. You're right and your behavior right now is why. Have a nice day mom. Does it sound stressful? I don't care probably even as much as I should, but one day it will be something important but the boy cried wolf too many times and got eaten. Just remember. If you have them, teach your kids that while they may be the main character in their story, they are not the main character in the story, and the difference between the two.
- tpmx 4y ago(from the actual paper) the cross-sectional and case-control designs limit conclusions about causation and directionality Busy people spend more time on the phone?
- suddenclarity 4y agoMy thought as well. Anecdotes but there's a very high correlation in my environment of people working 12+ hours a day, having high blood pressure and spending most of that time on the phone putting out fires or keeping up-to-date. With that said, I'm sure some of them would benefit personally from less phone use and just isolate themselves a bit from what's going on in the business.
- rcme 4y agoI hate studies like this. The researchers controlled for age, sex, body mass index, race, deprivation, family history of hypertension, education, smoking status, blood pressure, blood lipids, inflammation, blood glucose, kidney function and use of medications to lower cholesterol or blood glucose levels. But there are a million other potential causal factors that could be correlated with talking on the phone. For instance, stressors in your life can be a reason to talk on the phone, and stress is linked with hypertension. I think these types of studies can be fine if it's clear that this is just a correlation, but the researchers seem to be presenting this as if they've established a causal relationship. > Professor Qin said: “Our findings suggest that talking on a mobile may not affect the risk of developing high blood pressure as long as weekly call time is kept below half an hour. More research is required to replicate the results, but until then it seems prudent to keep mobile phone calls to a minimum to preserve heart health.” I really wish more work was done to establish a causal relationship before publishing something like this.
- freitzkriesler2 4y agoPretty much this. Maybe the sample size were all wall street traders. Regardless, it just sounds like someone publishing to not perish.
- toxik 4y ago> Years of use or employing a hands-free set-up had no influence on the likelihood of developing high blood pressure So… radio waves cannot be the cause.
- davemp 4y agoYeah I imagine the average dosage of RF across populations has been increasing enough overtime along with rollout of new technologies that you’d be able to correlate some function of adoption of these technologies to population level effects if there was any real significance.
- krunck 4y agoHands free being what? Keeping using the speaker and setting the phone on a table? Using Bluetooth ear plugs with the phone in a breast pocket? So much we don't know...
- fnord77 4y agohow often is an unscheduled call going to be good news?
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI'm a 35 year old man and I still talk on the phone with a couple of old friends for an hour plus every couple months
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Aardwolf 4y agoVideo calls, or actual voice phone calls? Ironically, video calls use more bandwidth yet are cheaper (for voice calls using the standard phone dialing functionality I mean, I don't know too much about plain old voice calls over wifi and their cost structure)
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoVoice. Like actual phone calls. I have unlimited minutes so it's the same price. I don't like video calls
- antegamisou 4y agoThis title deliberately invites smartass correlation does not imply causation type of comments.
- torstenvl 4y agoCorrelation truly does not imply causation. There's nothing "smartass" about it.
- arcticbull 4y agoIt even says so in the paper, lol.
- clarkevans 4y agoThe answer is easy... be healthy and wealthy enough where you don't need to answer a cell phone.
- TechBro8615 4y agoI'm not rich and I literally never answer the phone. All calls are muted and the only time I call anyone is when I video chat my parents.
- throwaway40506 4y agoIf you don't start out rich, not answering your phone seems like the reason why you're not rich, though. Why fix the phone issue if you still have the not-rich issue anyways, I imagine both of these have outsized impact on risk of high blood pressure...
- TechBro8615 4y agoYeah I suppose I'm missing out on phone calls from Publisher's Clearinghouse notifying me I won $10,000,000. It's true that there are plenty of other sources of high blood pressure which are unrelated to phone calls but may be correlated to lack of wealth. :)
- bedast 4y agoReading the article, I failed to see what link they found. The headline here matches the one on the article so I'm not calling that into question, but what seems to be more accurate is "Mobile phone calls correlated with increased risk of high blood pressure" since no actual causal link is established. The article repeatedly calls it out as a link as well. It'd be easy for certain groups to fill in the blanks and claim this proves mobile radiation is a health risk, while it doesn't at all establish that causal link. Just as easily, it could be inferred that longer calls are more stressful. And also just as easily the link could be established that those with a family history of hypertension or have other risk factors are more likely to have longer phone conversations. So I'd argue there's no established link, but there might be an obvious correlation that might warrant more study.
- dinkblam 4y agowould have been interesting to compare with non-mobile, i.e. landline calls. my hunch would be that talking over the telephone is stressful and causes the high blood pressure and it doesn't matter that the device is mobile. as-is the article seems to suggest radiation as cause, not the act of talking-without-seeing.
- jeron 4y ago>my hunch would be that talking over the telephone is stressful and causes the high blood pressure and it doesn't matter that the device is mobile. if this is the case, then how do teenage girls spend hours talking with friends on the phone? I have doubts on this hunch
- porkbeer 4y agoA teenage girl talks to friends, an adult talks to responsibilities. Very different response.
- jackson1442 4y agomy thoughts as well. with digital compression, words cutting out, and trying to decipher what the other person's saying without looking at them, mobile phone calls just require a lot of cognitive load from me in general. I do find it easier to understand when I'm looking directly at them in-person, partly because I can infer a lot of meaning from their facial expressions and match what I'm hearing to how their mouth is moving. not to mention that almost all of my phone calls fall into two categories: calling my family to catch up, and calling services to wait on hold and deal with an underpaid support rep on the other end. category 2 is almost always stressful and irritating in and of itself, and would be similarly stressful (albeit less so) if I went to their location in-person to deal with the support issue.
- monkeyjoe 4y agoThis study would be a lot more credible if they asked about cell phone use on follow up and then differenced everyone against their prior reporting, to determine if *changes* in cell phone use (and other control factors that might change over time) increased risk of hypertension. Still not perfect because of the long time lag to follow up, but much better. Either they didn’t know to do this or they did but then didn’t find the desired results… either way, not a good look.
- fsiefken 4y agoSo the article mentions: "... suggested that long-term exposure to radio-frequency electromagnetic fields (RF-EMF) emitted by mobile phones was related to oxidative stress, increased inflammation, and DNA damage, all of which could lead to the development of hypertension." I'd assume that talking through DECT or WiFi has similar effects, which would mean that there is no safe way to phone wirelessly longer then 30 minutes a day. Should I put my aging mother on a wired phone and internet connection just to be on the safe side? Or is that tinfoil hat territory?
- b112 4y agoMaybe people stressed out, feel the need to talk to friends/family more. The calls are a sign, but not the cause.
- JohnFen 4y agoI get anxious anytime someone actually calls me, because (aside from two of my friends), the only time someone is calling me rather than texting is when there's an actual emergency happening.