3 ms·
Because placebo works only until you realize you're being fed bullshit, while the real thing continues to work even as your beliefs change.
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
Because placebo works only until you realize you're being fed bullshit, while the real thing continues to work even as your beliefs change.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoI was under the impression that placebos work even when you know they're placebos.
- kleene_op 4y agoAre people who have been given the information that they're using a placebo trully convinced of that or do they just have a mental barrier preventing them from further acknowledging it and just resign to respond: "yeah, I know it's just a placebo"
- AlecSchueler 4y agoTry it yourself. I take placebo for all sorts of small ailments and it's surprisingly effective.
- chii 4y agoBut a true placebo effect is only _if_ the ailment _did not_ heal if you hadn't taken the placebo. Otherwise, you're just taking a nonactive ingredient, and your body is merely healing itself from the ailment. A true test of placebo effect must be one where you'd have a group who does not use a placebo, and a group that does! But then how would you study it blind?
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> A true test of placebo effect must be one where you'd have a group who does not use a placebo, and a group that does! But then how would you study it blind? Maybe a better (and possible) test would be to give everyone the placebo, but divide participants into three groups. One would be told they're given a real treatment, the other would be told they're given a placebo for the real treatment, and the third would be told they're given a sugar pill for no specific reason other than to see what happens. 1+2 would then tell you about whether or not knowing if you're getting a real treatment or placebo matters; 2+3 would tell you how much knowing you have a problem to treat in the first place matters.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoHuh? I thought the point of the thread was that placebo works even when you know it's a placebo.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThe point of the wider thread is that placebo generally does not work. It only may create an illusion that it does - but that illusion alone does not cure the underlying problem (unless that problem is highly affected by your perception, at which point it's not really a placebo, but a proper treatment).
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThey may have heard of "placebo effect" (i.e. the popular take on it), and figured "hey, this means it might still do something; better not dwell on it too much".
- coldtea 4y agoSome work even after you've been told. You still get the psychological/physiological boost from them, even after you know it's just a "sugar pill".
- dean2432 4y agowhat is really intriguing about this is that placebo is shown to have an effect even if the subject is told it's a placebo https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-29624-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-023-29624-7
- criddell 4y agoThe real thing may not work if you think it is bullshit.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoWe do not live in the wizarding world. There is a limit to how much your perception can influence your own body, or physical processes around you. That applies in both directions - belief alone can't move a mountain, but it also can't stop the excavators already moving one.
- criddell 4y agoPlacebo / nocebo effects aren't magic.
- nebulousthree 4y agoI would argue that because your body is the one doing the perceiving, there is likely no limit to the ability of our perceptions influencing our bodies. Belief alone can't move a mountain, but is that not because the belief is not strong enough, rather than because beliefs don't physically have hands with which to hold the pickaxe?
- oh_sigh 4y agoBut if a placebo works, it isn't bullshit.