7 ms·
FBI warns hackers are planting fake QR codes in restaurants
- LinuxBender 4y agoProbably not as lucrative but I could envision people pranking others by replacing QR codes that take them to a "shock" site with obscene loud sounds but I do not know what would be considered shocking or obscene by today's standards. Perhaps this is already a thing.
- prng2021 4y agoNot sure about Android but iOS doesn’t allow sites to use audio without user interaction (ie tapping a play button)
- temp2022account 4y agoEasily worked around, video element w/ the restaurant's opening doors as frame 0.
- autoexec 4y agoRestaurants are also planting QR CODES in restaurants that steal your data, but the FBI isn't warning anyone about it. Just stick to physical menus. That way, nobody collects unnecessary data about you and your devices, and best of all you can make sure that you're getting the same prices and options as everyone else.
- saulpw 4y agoAn increasing number of restaurants don't have physical menus anymore. "Just scan the QR code" the waiter says, as blithely as you say "Just stick to physical menus". Just nothing. These are societal-level changes, same as not accepting cash or requiring an app to pay for parking. It's easier for the business and 90% of consumers will go along with it. Too bad for everyone who gets hacked or doesn't have a smartphone or can't get a credit card.
- andirk 4y agoRequiring hardware to order a meal at a restaurant is classist period. We all think everyone has a QR code readable device and a credit card so it's no sweat. I have those things but not always on me and it is laughable when I can't order something because of it. Paper menus, cash, and paper ballot counting. If someone in certain situations can't accept cash, I understand that. And I had this man-in-the-middle idea first time I saw QR menus, but, instead, the bad actor DOES make the dish nextdoor so the customer is fine!
- asdff 4y agoIts also such a worse user experience. Reading a menu off a smartphone screen is like having the menu printed out for you on post it notes. The big thing is great. I can see everything of the entire category at once in one skim. The mental load is minimal, which makes for easier conversation than when its mobile menus, and everyone sits there in silence with a craned neck.
- jacquesm 4y agoI've had this happen. Then I told them I don't have a smartphone. In some cases the restaurant will then provide a tablet and in others suddenly paper menus are available. It hasn't happened yet that a restaurant decided to forego a bunch of income on account of my not having a smartphone, so maybe just say you don't have one and see what happens next?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoThis is also a perfect case for "voting with your feet". If it doesn't work to claim you have no way of viewing the QR code menu, turn around and walk out the door. (Obviously, this is more difficult to do with large groups but it's something which could be decided on beforehand, especially with smaller groups.)
- iamdamian 4y agoI wish more people would do this. I do. That said, it only works if enough people do it and if the feedback actually gets back to the restaurant owners. I would love to see “had QR menu” as a label on Apple and Google Maps so that I’d know not to bother with the restaurant in the first place.
- leptons 4y agoI have no problem with a restaurant knowing that an Android user (me) looked at their menu. Beyond that, there's very little they would know about me from reading their menu. What data do you think they are stealing by visiting a link to read a menu??
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sneed_chucker 4y agoJust another reason to hate the QR code menu trend
- tedunangst 4y agoCan you be juice jacked by a QR code?
- pengaru 4y agoThis is such an obvious vulnerability. It blows my mind that out here in SoCal - especially post-COVID LA-proper, you'll often encounter restaurants only providing menus via QR code. Between that practice and the increasingly common outright refusal to accept cash, every time I visit friends in Santa Monica it's become an exceptional experience just to get a morning espresso using cash and no smartphone. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wd4YgudTcnM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wd4YgudTcnM
- yawnxyz 4y agobasically every restaurant in Sydney right now
- throwaway22032 4y agoYeah. It's honestly just really weird and a bit cringe. I started to choose holiday destinations based on whether it's like, a normal business environment. This began during coronavirus, but now with the whole cashless thing becoming sticky it's become a seemingly permanent choice.
- JohnFen 4y ago> you'll often encounter restaurants only providing menus via QR code. What?? > increasingly common outright refusal to accept cash Well, those two things alone are excellent reasons for me to avoid going there.
- brundolf 4y agoThis is common here in Austin too. I don't usually mind; paying on my phone from the table is more convenient for everybody than waiting in a line to order, and if you're with friends you don't have to figure out splitting the check But I'll definitely start giving the QR codes a closer look before scanning now
- JohnFen 4y agoOh, great. If that ever starts happening in my parts, that will be a huge pain in the ass.
- pvaldes 4y agoI told you
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- c-fe 4y agoDailyMail? Why are these low-effort articles posted on hacker news? Also, > Instead of taking you to an online menu or checkout, the links instantly download malware onto your device, stealing your location and personal information How is that supposed to work? Specifically on iOS?
- seattle_spring 4y agoThere's unfortunately a large subset of HNers that find rags like DailyMail, New York Post, and ZeroHedge reputable. Makes it really important to check the source before engaging.
- ss108 4y agoNYPost is in a liminal spot; for example, if it's saying something happened in NYC, that thing likely happened in NYC, in my experience. Its commentary on said event can likely be ignored if it's the kind of event that gets right-wing voters riled up, but it doesn't just make shit up. It's not Breitbart or something lol, and if the issue isn't a political hot topic, I don't know if one needs to avoid it
- chaxor 4y agoIIRC, you can put entire binaries in QRCodes, and some have shown this by putting the game 'snake' in a QRCodes, such that if you point your camera towards the QRCodes with the camera on, it will start the game automatically. Fun... but yes, potentially an avenue that can be misused.
- crtasm 4y agoI could only find a Windows executable: https://hackaday.com/2020/08/17/fitting-snake-into-a-qr-code/ https://hackaday.com/2020/08/17/fitting-snake-into-a-qr-code... Or one that runs in a browser: https://github.com/ingSlonik/QR-Snake https://github.com/ingSlonik/QR-Snake Opening a URL automatically would depend on how your camera/scanner app is configured.
- arghandugh 4y agoWhy is an inflammatory story from a foreign rightwing disinformation outlet being posted here?
- throw352023 4y ago[flagged]
- AlecSchueler 4y agoForeign? From whose perspective? Is there a reason to disbelieve foreign sources?
- arghandugh 4y agoSo you agree it’s a rightwing disinformation outlet.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoYes, of course. My questions were about the other aspects of the assertion. Is there a reason to be distrustful because it's foreign? From whose perspective is it foreign?
- arghandugh 4y agoI’ll pass on all that, thanks.
- burnished 4y agoDid that article seriously never once link or present the primary source they are reporting on? I feel as though I know less now than I did before I started it, and not in a 'the world is so much larger than I knew' way.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThey do link to sources, but the sources are shit. Notably the ABC7 source cited every assertion except for the most dramatic: zero-click malware
- pixelbath 4y agoOk, taking this story at face value _despite_ it being from the Daily Mail...if your phone can "instantly download malware onto your device, stealing your location and personal information" without any prompting or further user action by simply visiting a URL, that seems like something the FBI should be warning device manufacturers about instead of the average person. "QR codes scary and bad!" isn't a very productive line of discussion.
- rolph 4y agoHow To Hack Using QR Codes https://hackeracademy.org/how-to-hack-using-qr-codes/ https://hackeracademy.org/how-to-hack-using-qr-codes/ a nontrivial amount of effort has been applied to this topic
- pixelbath 4y agoThat article is stunningly light on actual substance, other than "you can generate QR codes with this repo" with a link to a repository that doesn't exist anymore. The best case they give for "issuing commands" is encoding a WiFi access point into a QR code. So you can encode a URL, or you can encode your WiFi data, because the data in a QR code is _literally text strings_. You could _possibly_ stick some malicious Javascript in it, but again, if your device is allowing JS to randomly exfiltrate data from your phone through your browser, something worse is going on. The actual statement from the FBI on this subject says "While QR codes are not malicious in nature, it is important to practice caution when entering financial information as well as providing payment through a site navigated to through a QR code." So the danger is really visiting malicious URLs, which was the entire point of my previous post.
- iudqnolq 4y agoIt's funny how info travels. A local news site did a story about fraudsters covering up the "scan to pay" qr codes on parking meters with qr codes that take you to a fraudulent site. Totally plausible. They throw in an unsourced assertion at the end that maybe hacking is possible. That then becomes the focus of this daily mail article. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35809719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35809719
- jandrese 4y agoNot that I don’t implicitly trust a tech article on the Daily Fail, but are there any documented cases of this actually happening? The article was very light on specific details.
- 1letterunixname 4y agoFBI warns hackers are living in your shrubberies. FBI warns hackers are eating your children. FBI warns (highly unlikely thing). How about the media actually find out how often X is happening before parroting government and corporate press releases?
- JohnMakin 4y agoas long as you don't like, enter your financial information or download an app from the QR link you'll be fine.
- iudqnolq 4y agoAbout a month ago we saw very similar headlines that turned out to be misleading. The FBI posted a warning about juice jacking. The FBI left off that there's no evidence it has ever happened and their post was only based on a 2019 press release by another agency stating that the hack might be possible.[1] This article is source to a local news article.[2] The assertion that scammers could use QR codes to deliver malware is the only fact in the article without a citation. The security expert they interview is warning about phishing pages, like a sticker on a parking meter that leads to a fraudulent payment site. It's also odd they cite only to "the FBI". These articles tend to cite either to a specific FBI spokesperson or to a specific FBI office. It's possible the journalist took the interview with the security expert and merely found something on some FBI website in order to get the better headline. [1]: https://slate.com/technology/2023/04/free-public-phone-chargers-fbi-warning-bad-actors-threat-bogus-debunked.html https://slate.com/technology/2023/04/free-public-phone-charg... [2]: https://abc-7.com/news/cover-story/2023/05/01/fbi-warns-of-qr-scamming-trend-on-the-rise/amp/ https://abc-7.com/news/cover-story/2023/05/01/fbi-warns-of-q...
- asdfman123 4y agoWhether or not this particular thing is true, everyone should automatically downvote Daily Mail articles when they see them unless they’re specifically looking for fun celebrity tabloids to read. It’s not a good news source. Find the story written by a better publication and link to that.
- 2c2c2c 4y agoLove the newish square payment flow where you're handed a receipt with a QR code that directly takes you to a payment page. use apple pay and you're out in 20 seconds! No idea how they know if you're dine and ditching though. Saw several places with this in NYC in march. Have only seen it at El Techo and Freekeh in SF.