8 ms·
Their argument is basically that while normally a company raising prices would mean that some of their customers move to a competitor, in today's environment th
by paxys 4y ago
Their argument is basically that while normally a company raising prices would mean that some of their customers move to a competitor, in today's environment there is an implicit agreement that every company will keep prices high.
So are they saying that the free market is basically not a thing anymore because of covid, and no company wants to get an edge over its competitors by undercutting on price despite having record margins?
- rhacker 4y agoTechnically does that mean the FTC can literally go after all the companies for collusive price fixing?
- paxys 4y agoWell they are saying there is no collusion. Companies are all individually deciding to raise prices and not bringing them down.
- klysm 4y agoTacit collusion isn’t illegal
- rhacker 4y agoIt probably should be in the internet age. There is a huge cottage industry out there for fixing prices. I hope that the feds discover all the OTHER companies out there that are similar to RealPage.
- klysm 4y agoYeah especially with the advent of algorithmic pricing it's going to get a lot harder to regulate
- medion 4y agoAnecdotal, but it feels like there are less competitors. So…
- arcticbull 4y agoThat is certainly part of the story yes. Especially in grocery. It's wild how much better a job restaurants did controlling their food costs than individuals could.
- bugglebeetle 4y agoNo, it’s the result of the massive shift in antitrust regulation from the Reagan era on, where US largely abandoned anti-monopoly enforcement, resulting in corporate concentration and collusion. The free market is “not a thing” because of a lack of real competition.
- gjulianm 4y agoI don't think it's about the free market not being a thing. It's that, in a context where every company is increasing prices and customers have resigned and accepted that reality, the increased profit from extra clients is less than the increased profits from higher prices.
- arcticbull 4y agoGood Odd Lots episode goes into this theory. [1] Basically companies found that by raising prices, they were able to increase profits despite shipping fewer units - and they wanted to see how much they could do so. When Pepsi had to leave Russia, which accounted for 4% of revenue, they just increased the price in the rest of the world to compensate without issue. And seeing that, Coke followed suit. However at this point in the arc, companies are losing their ability to push prices. They won't pull them back or anything, but we are seeing reversion to the mean. That stabilization should be sufficient to see much lower inflation levels moving forward. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIpcfmAfOJo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIpcfmAfOJo
- yanderekko 4y agoThis story is not incompatible with a more-basic one where inflation debases the currency, so when a company starts exploring price hikes for whatever reason they unsurprisingly realize greater profits (since they were implicitly lowering the price by selling for the same quantity of a less-valuable currency). Imagine that Pepsi was selling for ETH in 2021, then "discovers" after the price of ETH halves in 2022 that they can get away with hiking the price - in this case the price hikes are the consequence of the currency devaluation, not the cause.
- arcticbull 4y agoInflation is measured from a change in purchasing power, it's not a function of supply - because what you do with the supply is what matters, not that it exists. These companies raising prices would be inflationary in and of itself. Supply may or may not yield inflationary pressure, but a change in supply is just that - a change in supply. Inflation is measured from a change in prices. For instance, a 100% sales tax would be massively inflationary (at least initially) and wouldn't be reflected in supply of currency units. ETH like BTC prices are just high-beta derivatives of US dollar liquidity in the global financial system. And that's pretty generous, assuming it's not just a rigged mob casino run by a small handful of insiders. It's not really comparable because it's not really a currency. In the sense that nothing is actually priced in ETH or BTC - it's an open loop system. Everything's priced in dollars and converted at the last second to a BTC/ETH price, and then those are usually immediately sold for dollars to pay suppliers, etc. There's at best a negligible closed loop BTC/ETH economy.
- ars 4y agoIt only works for a while, then customers start switching to cheaper brands and they reduce prices again. See this article: https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/tide-maker-pg-dialing-up-discounts-us-consumers-pull-back-2023-04-20/ https://www.reuters.com/business/retail-consumer/tide-maker-... which has more detail on this.
- whitemary 4y agoThe "free market" has never been a thing
- contravariant 4y agoEspecially not in the short term.
- _fizz_buzz_ 4y agoI assume that at some point prices will normalize again. But my assumption is that the feed back loop of the free market also has a time delay and needs time to self-correct and I guess this time delay can be longer than expected. Especially when supply chains are disrupted, for many products customers often cannot simply switch to a competitor. Covid kind of "broke" the free market, and it will heal itself, but it takes longer than expected.
- _cenw 4y agoI'm not sure COVID is a root cause rather than a convenient occasion. The free market is supposed to work through scale and optimization; scale is still a relevant force, but mostly serves market consolidation. Optimization is not something that can be frequently innovated on. So everyone has pretty much the same cost basis in long established industries like food. There is simply no incentive for these corporations to start a price war; they all know starting one will only result in a very brief competitive advantage until everyone returns to baseline profits. Funnily enough, a lot of recent reductions in cost basis in "innovative" startups is not done through optimization; it is done through VC speculating on their competitor finding a more permanent place in a (supposedly) new market after consolidation and prices adjust back to reality. An example I can come up with of this is food delivery services in Germany: For a while, several providers were undercutting each other in price and service level. Now all of Germany is dominated by Takeaway, and their service level is slightly above "we don't care". We'll see the same in instant grocery delivery in a year or so. Getir seems to be winning that one. Until then, enjoy ridiculously cheap instant grocery delivery, powered by VC funding and extra dirty worker exploitation (only one of those will continue to exist).
- mjevans 4y agoThings I pay a lot for: * Rent (they're all high; and can't afford to buy anywhere near where I work) * Food (prices are pretty much the same everywhere) * Internet (Cable's the only modern-speed option where I currently rent) * Energy / Gas - either utilities or again, the same everywhere I think most everyone else is in the same boat. I can scale down some of these a little bit, but they're all fairly __inelastic__. I can't stop eating. I need all of these for life and work. Want to tame inflation? Tax the hell out of profits above X%!!! Someone's making money on this.
- yanderekko 4y agoA good where consumers have inelastic demand does not mean that individual companies face inelastic demand curves - that's the whole point of competition. ie. It doesn't matter if you're willing to pay a lot to avoid starvation since no individual company is making profits off of having some market power to starve you. The thought that food providers are colluding to raise prices is absurd and should serve as a reductio ad absurdum in these arguments, not a fundamental explanation for "greedflation".
- NLPaep 4y ago> The DOJ, explained forbes.com, charged that company “executives worked together to keep prices paid to poultry farmers low while raising costs for consumers at grocery stores and restaurant chains.” https://www.producer.com/opinion/u-s-government-strikes-out-on-food-price-fixing-prosecution/ https://www.producer.com/opinion/u-s-government-strikes-out-...
- yanderekko 4y agoSeems relevant to note that these charges failed..
- sobkas 4y ago> Seems relevant to note that these charges failed.. As USA lives in post law age it only means that relevant corporations carpet bombed regulator with lawyers, paid politicians, lobbyists, job offers for key bureaucrats(after they retire/leave) to make it go away. And to prosecute corporation regulator needs money, money they have is finite so they need to choose their fights. And they need don't know if around the corner some corporation doesn't produce fentanyl out of baby skulls. On top of that fixing plight of chicken producers won't translate into them spending money on lobbyists, hiring retired bureaucrats or financing PACs, everything corporations that gain from it will definitely do.
- neilwilson 4y agoWhy are prices controlled at all? Because as a consumer you can go somewhere else. If there is insufficient excess supply capacity we can't do that in aggregate and prices can be hiked with impunity. Inflation is always, everywhere, a lack of effective competition.
- makomk 4y agoFor almost all goods, price increases will decrease the amount purchased. If there's still insufficient excess supply capacity after substantial price increase and decreases in people's purchasing power and consumption, then the reason competition isn't lowering prices is because that's the actual market-clearing price where demand is equal to the amount that can be produced. This can't be fixed by forcing companies to lower their prices since they won't be able to supply the demand that exists at a lower price, and attempting to do so anyway via price controls inevitably leads to empty shelves.
- bell-cot 4y ago> For almost all goods, price increases will decrease the amount purchased... Except that housing, at least in America, has dynamics which are nothing like that. And housing is by far the largest living expense for a very large fraction of Americans.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoHigh housing prices do reduced demand, just not by much. People living with roommates or parents are example of people priced out of the market. This is demand reduction.
- dragonwriter 4y agoNo, that’s a just lower quantity demanded, not lower demand; demand is the function mapping price to quantity demanded. Its possibly that price level could over time effect actual demand (as well), that is, it could convert people who would buy at price $X to people who would only buy at a price lower than $X or not at all, but that’s not what your example is. (It does, actually, induced demand from availability it observed, anf the reverse from the opposite condition would be logical.)
- scotty79 4y ago> So are they saying that the free market is basically not a thing anymore because of covid, and no company wants to get an edge over its competitors by undercutting on price despite having record margins? Covid has nothing to do with it. Market always worked this way. There's really very little reason for a company to lower the prices below what consumers are already willing to pay. When the market is saturated and all customers are accustomed to paying certain level of prices for a given good and you try to lower your prices for that good it won't automatically mean you'll sell more. You might even sell less because people will assume you sell a good of lower quality. It can take decades for the customers to learn while you are leaving profits on the table. Profits that you might have used for marketing to actually get more sales at higher price. Try to buy a box of crayons in Florence, Italy.
- atchoo 4y ago> Try to buy a box of crayons in Florence, Italy. What is this a reference to?
- scotty79 4y agoIt is what helps one understand that demand and supply are not only things that dictate the price of even a very common goods, even in absence of advertisement. Affluence of customers play a huge role.
- fallingknife 4y agoIf the market always worked this way, why is it being blamed for inflation that has only existed for the past year?
- scotty79 4y agoAs US and western customers are getting poorer for the first time in decades they are just starting to notice the inflation. The inflation was there before and companies were milking it at least since 2000, but since customers still had money nobody was really thinking about it. Of course only recently inflation got as high as it is, because of all the money printing done in the pandemic and a bit before.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThe last two years has been such a clear downgrade in standards and quality across the board. One product I've bought for 20 years used to be sold in clear glass bottles. Last year, they replaced it with cheap plastic bottles. Then they reduced the quantity by 20% while keeping the same price. That's just one example, but practically everything I used to buy has either increased in price, decreased in quality/quantity, or often, both together.
- Geee 4y agoYes, they are saying exactly that, and those economists are idiots. They think that prices are the result of costs+profit, rather than optimized to maximize demand*profit; demand being a function of price.
- DannyBee 4y agoAn efficient free market was never a thing except in the fever dreams of economists. Most forms of the efficient market hypothesis have been formally proven incorrect. The remaining ones are harder to disprove but can be tied to other things (ie only true if p=np). There are literally mountains of evidence that you have to ignore to believe in efficient free markets at this point. The evidence for them has always amounted to "I have a theory, I looked at a market for a while and it was sometimes true. Therefore my theory is proven" All countervailing evidence is "no true scotsman"'d. No inefficient market is free enough you see. It’s one of those things that people feel like should be true, but just isn’t. meanwhile, if you start from the theory that there’s no particular reason for free markets to be efficient, stories like this aren't even news.
- RugnirViking 4y ago> the free market is basically not a thing anymore The free market was never a real thing. It's like spherical cows in a vacuum. It describes what you would expect to see given a sufficiently large number of buyers and sellers, with no network effects, with perfect information for buyers and sellers, no players with controlling stake of the market, and over a long enough timespan. In this case, the fact that most industries have literaly been reduced to one or two players, the powerful force of competition isn't very effective at reducing prices. It might eventually, but because there are so few competing sellers, we'll have to wait a long time.
- naasking 4y ago> and no company wants to get an edge over its competitors by undercutting on price despite having record margins? They have record profits, why disrupt a winning formula?
- jongjong 4y agoThat sounds about right... But if we want to get to the root cause, we'd have to look at the design of the monetary system and the last decade of monetary policy. Never in history have there been so many market oligopolies; and it coincided with a transition to a global soft money standard as global fiat currencies became increasingly more decoupled from gold. Before, a dollar could be exchanged for a certain fixed amount of gold; this had clear and objective economic value. Nowadays, money is decoupled from any hard/objective economic value. Today, banks issue credit proportionally to asset prices which are themselves determined by how much new credit enters the system... A vicious cycle which forces banks to keep loading new generations with more credit at a steadily increasing pace to avoid bursting bubbles.
- toss1 4y ago>>the free market is basically not a thing anymore I'd say this has little to do with COVID (beyond that it is a random event that decreased then re-increased demand), but the accumulated effect of decades of failing to enforce anti-trust law. The most propserous times and bigges middle class ended with the Reagan administration, who in 1983, ordered the DOJ, FTC, and SEC to stop enforcing anti-trust laws dating back to the Sherman Act of 1890[0]. This massively destroyed small businesses and concentrated corporate power. E.g., the closer a store was to the Walmart location, the greater the likelihood it would close. Persky and his colleagues found that for every mile closer to the Walmart, 6 percent more stores closed. Close in around the store's location, between 35 and 60 percent of stores closed. [1] Previously, anti-trust laws were enforced so aggressively that when Buster Brown and Kinney shoe companies wanted to merge in the 1960s the Supreme Court blocked the merger because the combined company would control about 5 percent of the US shoe market. Nike alone today controls around 20 percent of that market.[0] Obviously, when anti-trust laws stop being enforced and massive corporations gain oligarchic market and pricing power, they can create inflation at will. This power needs to be rebalanced. Again, recognize, that the "free market" is ab absolute fiction — there is no such thing. Every market has rules and regulations, explicit and/or tacit. The only question is what are the regulations and who enforces them. Absent sufficient regulation, the market dynamics will always end up with all power in the hands of a few major players. This is what is happening here. Looks like is is not the FED that can fix it, it is the SEC and DOJ. [0] https://www.rawstory.com/amp/gop-party-of-business-2659944730 https://www.rawstory.com/amp/gop-party-of-business-265994473... [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-09-14/radiating-death-how-walmart-displaces-nearby-small-businesses https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-09-14/radiating...
- listenallyall 4y ago> The most propserous times and bigges middle class ended with the Reagan administration Reagan took office in 1981. So you're claiming that the late 70s -- oil embargo, hostages, double-digit inflation and unemployment -- were "the most prosperous times"? Really?
- toss1 4y ago