13 ms·
That is what the first two weeks of economics teaches. The rest of the curriculum is about how wrong that is.
by jfengel 4y ago
That is what the first two weeks of economics teaches.
The rest of the curriculum is about how wrong that is.
- silisili 4y agoPerhaps you went to a better school than I did. I only did 101 and 102, but even then the professor always spoke in terms like we were some old village, probably to make things easier to understand. But obviously those analogies don't apply to the world today, mostly.
- tiedieconderoga 4y agoThe problem is that people aren't rational, and they don't have perfect information. So the history of finance and commerce has been a cat-and-mouse game where the cats find new ways to cheat people, and the mice try to recognize and prevent those schemes. One example: cartels. If an industry is dominated by a small number of large players, they can collude to set prices and stifle competition through regulatory capture, acquisitions, cornering supply chains, etc. It works like a monopoly, but no individual member is large enough to pursue as a monopoly. It falls apart with too many members, because the rewards for defecting are high.
- 7speter 4y agoI didn’t take tooooo many econ classes but it sure seems like there are a lot of monopolies, oligopolies, and potential cartels these days.
- listenallyall 4y agoWhen every company has easy access to the entire world, or at least an entire country, the natural direction is towards far fewer, extremely well-capitalized companies eventually squeezing everybody else out. And we're seeing that in almost every industry, for sure.
- piva00 4y agoI'm not that old yet, in my mid-30s, and still during my lifetime I've seen an incredible amount of corporate-consolidation in multiple countries. It's happening in multiple societies, across multiple different industries: food, media, banking/finance, tech, auto manufacturers, etc. Last time I looked into some companies from my home country that were part of daily life in my childhood I see that most have been acquired by a larger corporation, or became corporations with multiple mergers themselves. It's been happening pretty fast the past 20 years.
- xyzzyz 4y agoIn practice, the markets still work pretty great even without perfect rationality and information. Those are just assumptions for a mathematical model, not something that must always be satisfied lest everything collapse. Econ classes will show you how things can break if these assumptions are not satisfied, but in actual practice, they don’t need to be satisfied perfectly in order for actual operations to match mathematical models very closely.
- vjk800 4y agoThe lack of information (or information asymmetries) are such a huge deal and not often appreciated. I would pay a lot more for many small electronic gadgets if I knew that they would 1) work better and 2) last longer than the cheap ones. However, It's basically impossible for me to find out how good is the signal on my bluetooth usb stick or how long my plant LED lights are going to last without breaking so I just buy the cheapest since the price doesn't seem to be a very reliable indicator of either of those things. I'm sure there are players on the market who make things that I'd like to buy, but it's impossible for me to find them and verify that they actually do what I want so they are not getting my money.
- otikik 4y agoThey don't even need to "collude". They can just look at what their "competitors" are doing. I raise my prices a little bit. You see me raise the prices a little, and you raise them a little. And then I see that and raise them a little more. Then I do a tiny round of layoffs. You also layoff some people. Then I do a bigger round of layoffs and communicate big profits publicly. And you follow suit. You and I never talk, never "collude". But we are effectively communicating through our numbers. As long as we have captured a big enough market, we don't need to talk, and we both benefit. I don't know if there's even a term for this kind of "tacit collaboration". Perhaps "anticompetition"?
- camgunz 4y agoYeah exactly. What we're looking at here are similar actors reacting to the same incentives. Pepsi raised prices because they can and their shareholders demanded it. Coke raised prices because they can and their shareholders demanded it. Thus 80% (or whatever) of soda worldwide increased in price, without collusion. So you have the failure case of collusion without the cause, which sucks because we didn't really consider that this failure case might have two causes (which, I would argue that we should have, probably back in like 1920). It's an important first step to realize this is happening. Larry Summers was like, "I don't think suddenly corporations got more greedy", implying that because corporations have been maximally greedy the whole time that that can't be the cause of additional inflation. But it can be that it causes a new, unfortunate reaction with a new set of incentives, and this is exactly the situation we find ourselves in. It used to be OK (well, not really but let's stipulate) for corporations to be maximally greedy, but now it's not. So what's the next step? I don't really know. People float stuff like a tax on profits or price controls. I generally think those are probably too blunt, though I could get behind a tax on profits I guess. I might prefer some kind of blanket industry regulation ("Hi Coke, Pepsi, we know you didn't mean to exactly but you inadvertently increased the price of 80% of world soda by 20%--please stop") because this kind of thing seems like it can be nuanced and tailored to a specific situation. Maybe also a prohibition on stock buybacks to lower investor pressure to juice short-term profits--but I haven't thought this one through very much.
- 4y ago
- snapplebobapple 4y agoThats not really accurate. The rest of the curriculum is about how that is still correct but how people attempt to gain market power so they can stop others undercutting them, bringing market back to efficiency.
- kristopolous 4y agoThere's this strange thing that is done. We have economics departments and business schools and they aren't the same thing. Mainstream neoclassical economics is mostly preoccupied with what ought to happen in some mathematically defined fantasy world and business school is the study of what actually does happen. In fact when you get into post-graduate classical economics, it's mostly just a formal branch of mathematics with models and axioms. It's got nothing to do with how people actually engage in the real world with the distribution of resources. It's based on some mathematically defined homo-economicus and has a bunch of assumptions like infinite knowledge, exclusively rational and always correct based on some utility function calculation, etc... as if every single person, without exception, pours over arbitrarily complex excel spreadsheets covering a wide variety of properties for every single purchase and they all, in unison, arrive at the exact same conclusions and without any more thought immediately respond to the price signal. Oh and they also are acting only in their self-interest without any regard, at all, like some kind of narcissistic psychopath, for anything but themselves. That's why the advanced economics books are just proofs, axioms and math while the business books are things like real world sales numbers. Classical Economic theories predict real world human behavior about as much as an astrology chart. (There's lots of revolutionary work in economics in the past 30 years that present other models but many people outside the discipline haven't gotten the memo yet and think James M Buchanan and other Virginia and Chicago school people from the mid-20th century are all of economics - it isn't and never was) I've given a pretty good multi-year study into both. One of them reflects reality more. Price signal is real, don't ignore it. $100 packs of gum won't sell ... unless they do (https://www.mastika.store/products/mastika-gum-gold https://www.mastika.store/products/mastika-gum-gold) It's part of the "4-6" ps of marketing. (usually price/place/promotion/product - sometimes people and presentation). As you can see in that link, those things are part of it. It's way more complicated than sellers stupidly slashing their profit margins in some purely competitive feeding frenzy for your dollar. That does happen - but usually only in collapsing markets where price, speculation, information, and value are counterintuitively all unknown. Robert Shiller has documented this, how the predictive capacity of neoclassical models reach their highest accuracy during market panics. So there is that
- baryphonic 4y agoThat wasn't my experience. Intro to micro had the simplified model throughout. Intermediate & advanced macro are all math. Macro at all levels is Keynesian theory plus increasing levels of math. IMO, much of macro resembled alchemy. Several upper-level classes, though by no means all, took the assumptions in earlier classes, tore them down, and then re-built economics from there. These are assumptions like preferences being transitive, perfect information, rational self-interest, etc. Many of the claims of econ are defensible even when the assumptions are not. Game theory, for instance, is a very solid defense of economics (albeit one I don't agree with). Institutional econ, political econ & public choice are another family of approaches. Some approached like behavioral economics attempt to "debunk" old theories, though these have had problems with things like replication. Also, econometrics is quite widespread now. Undergrads typically must take at least one semester of it, and OLS regression is essential for understanding certain papers in most upper-level classes. Econometric models are empirical and have only a tenuous relationship with the mainstream theoretical models like supply & demand, AD-AS, ISLM, or the various growth models. It's not too dissimilar from physics (economists are infamous for physics envy), where Newtonian physics is wrong but still worth learning.
- jfengel 4y agoWhat the OP is describing is the frictionless, perfect-cylinder, massless-pulley version of Newtonian physics. Even a first semester econ class can talk about things like startup costs, inelastic demand, information asymmetry, and other things that make "a new business will spring up with lower margins" Just Plain Wrong. Economics has "friction", too.