5 ms·
22% jump in airfares expected as airlines tackle climate change
- jillesvangurp 4y agoTwo flaws in this article: - it's written from the point of view of businesses that in any case have been struggling for a long time: airlines. - it discounts the inevitable disruptors that will do things differently than the current companies in this space and makes the (broken) assumption that aside from fuel prices nothing changes. So that's companies that have struggled to adapt historically struggling to adapt some more and not seeing a way out. In other words, a business ripe for disruption. The question is not if that disruption will come but when and in what form. What this article spells out is what would happen if the only disruption that will happen is higher fuel prices. Which is interesting only in the sense that it really makes a case for other disruption to happen. IMHO, battery electric aviation will start disrupting short haul aviation towards the end of this decade. Adoption will be initially slow and people will be dismissive about the whole thing happening at all. But basically all the raw tech we need for this is already in place (e.g. 500wh/kg batteries by companies like CATL, Amprius, and others) and it's just going to be a matter of building/designing vehicles and infrastructure and improving the tech further as we go. All this actually started happening about half a decade ago and is actually well under way at this point. Lots of companies transitioning out of R&D into commercialization in the next few years. Some of them this year already. Not all will succeed. But the basic premise of a small, cheap electrical plane with about 600 miles of range is basically going to happen. Why is that disruptive? Because we go from increasingly higher fuel prices to a state where the cost of fuel is a fraction of what it is now. And you can fly with zero worries about climate change because that will all be clean energy. That's going to change a few things. A related disruption is going to be that these planes are not going to be the same size as today. The main reason that big planes are interesting is fuel cost. Only rich people can afford to fly in small planes and pretend they are sitting in a "flying" car. Because burning a few hundred gallons of fuel just isn't cheap. Flying small electrical planes on the other hand is dirt cheap and you don't get to share each other's farts. Win win. Small electrical planes/drones are going to fix the cost of flying in a big way by at least an order of magnitude: fuel, maintenance, the ability to avoid big airports with their landing fees, etc. Companies focused on their current business of burning fuel to move big jets full of economy class cattle around are going to have to figure out how to keep up with that. Most of them probably are not going to figure that out. E-fuels might keep some of them going and that may be the only thing that is economical for long haul at least the mid term. But most of their current short haul business is going to struggle and die. And that's not going to take 40 years to happen. Finally, another disruption that's coming will be in the form of autonomous flight. Lots of small airplanes would require lots of pilots. Except those pilots don't exist and long before they can be trained, a lot of these planes will be able to fly themselves. That's more cost savings because once you eliminate fuel cost, pilots are the next cost bottleneck. And of course the manually operated planes also getlot easier to fly . Meaning the training of new pilots gets a lot easier over time as well. All that together is starting to happen this decade. It will take ages for the aviation world to adjust of course. But that doesn't mean it's not happening. And once it starts happening it will start happening a lot quicker driven by cost savings and investors waking up and smelling money.
- gadders 4y agoObviously this won't affect the billionaire oligarchs and politicians, only the regular working people.
- ejb999 4y agothats the plan isn't it? We all give up our suv's, big houses, gas stoves, meat and travel so that the elites that preach to us from their 500' yachts and private jets as they travel the world collecting global warming awards?
- gadders 4y ago“The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.” ― Anatole France
- nivenkos 4y agoLike Bill Gates saying he's part of the solution - https://finance.yahoo.com/news/im-part-solution-bill-gates-140000674.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/im-part-solution-bill-gates-1... "Billionaire philanthropist" - the definition of an oxymoron.
- gadders 4y agoHonestly I preferred billionaires when they just blew their money on jets like Larry Ellison. At least they weren't making my life materially worse.
- justinzollars 4y agoI rented a 5-10 million dollar home in Silicon Valley (an Airbnb). And as I imagined, the shower was a torrent. It wasn't conserving any water like my home in the Bay Area was regulated to do.
- nivenkos 4y agoIn the EU private jets are exempt from the new fuel duty as long as they make less than 243 flights every 4 months: https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PETI-CM-731622_EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/PETI-CM-731622... They don't even try to hide the hypocrisy. They're unelected and steal our money with ever-increasing taxes which they exempt themselves from.
- CGamesPlay 4y ago> The World Travel & Tourism Council reports that the travel industry generates between 8% to 11% of the world’s greenhouse gas emissions—much of which comes from transport and a lot of that, from aviation. Does anyone know what actual percentage of the total this represents? From the article it sounds like "2-3% of the world's green house gas emissions", which is not nothing but not particularly huge either.
- jl6 4y agoThe global total of emissions is made up of a lot of things that are not particularly huge on their own. It all adds up, and everything needs to be tackled.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agohttps://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/09/Emissions-by-sector-%E2%80%93-pie-charts.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/09/Emissions-by-sect... Though since aviation is generally seen as hard to decarbonise, and likely to grow, it is usually estimated to account for a growing fraction of total GHG over time.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThis doesn't sound like a whole lot, considering that the travel industry is one of the largest employers in most countries and a substantial part of most economies.
- paulcole 4y agoIf (big if) this is true, then good. If (again, big if) society is interested in tackling climate change then individuals should be willing to pay the true cost of their actions. But I suspect neither statement is true. Airline executives will raise prices because they want more revenue. Rich (in the global sense) people in the developed world are in love with $20 toasters from halfway around the world and $99 flights to a beach that will be underwater in a century. Ignoring the cost of our modern lifestyles is a big part of how we get by.
- A_D_E_P_T 4y ago> The International Council on Clean Transportation predicts that it might cost as much as $1 trillion for decarbonizing the industry and that ticket prices will have to rise as much as 22% by 2050 to foot the bill. By 2050. Inflation alone will probably cause prices to double by then, and we're in the middle of a very unpredictable period of technological development (thanks to AI, etc.,) so I wouldn't worry about an estimated 22% price increase that's nearly 30 years away.
- nindalf 4y agodang could you modify the title to include "2050"? The title feels a bit clickbait right now, like the price increase is imminent.
- mathgeek 4y agoIt’s not just clickbait, though. It’s also designed to acclimate consumers to the idea that not only will prices always go up, but the prices today should be considered a good value while they last. It adds a sense of FOMO to purchasing decisions, while simultaneously pushing previous price increases into the background.
- 1980phipsi 4y agoI haven't read their piece, but implicitly they are making an argument about a supply shock that is tangential to the underlying inflation rate in the economy.
- 1980phipsi 4y agoThe 22% figure comes from this report, I believe, https://theicct.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Aviation-2050-Report-A4-v6.pdf https://theicct.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Aviation-2050...
- justinzollars 4y agoTo be poor in the United States or Europe is just becoming horrible. First of all nothing works anymore. Washing Machines are designed to use as little water as possible, so your clothes don't get clean like they did a few decades ago. The gas stovetop range is replaced with electric, so it takes 20 minutes to boil water. Toilets are low flo, which is just disgusting. I'd say soon the average Chinese citizen will live a better life than their western equivalent, not having to deal with sin taxes "For the Climate".
- swader999 4y agoJust trying to eat and live healthy is far more an issue than what was cited above.
- justinzollars 4y agoThese are just my annoyances. I love to cook - so the electric range issue really bothers me. I feel like many of the people who wish to impose these devices eat pizza pockets
- nicolaslem 4y agoYou have to be more precise, both resistive and induction are technically electric but one is much better than the other.
- arcticbull 4y agoYou should get an induction top. They're just as fast as - if not faster than - gas. There's no way I'd switch from my induction top back to gas. I haven't had any trouble cooking a lot more than 'pizza pockets.'
- nindalf 4y ago> The gas stovetop range is replaced with electric, so it takes 20 minutes to boil water. Unable to reproduce. I can reliably boil water within 2 minutes.
- tyingq 4y agoSome of these things overlap into reducing fuel costs, which is the thing airlines spend the most on, aside from employee salaries.
- neom 4y agoI have these weird "future stories" I like to play in my head. One is where we end up in a situation that mystically some global policy comes into place that gives each human a limit to fly 5,000 miles every year, and then a market for flight miles emerges. People sign into a website and trade their miles for their local currency, flight miles eventually become a pseudo currency. It's super weird, but I think about it often.
- CalRobert 4y agoWe could just use money, of course.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoA global universal basic income in conjunction with a global cap on fossil fuel extraction would be the simplest, assuming politically possible.
- ben_w 4y ago"Just use money" is kinda part of why we've not already solved the problem. This is more like UBI denominated in rations of air-distance, that happens to be tradable for things people care about, and thus essentially funded by a tax on travelling more than that each year.
- arcticbull 4y ago
- taude 4y agoIt's already up over 25% in the last year anyway. Not sure why we're worring about long term. Anyone try booking a trip to Europe from US lately?
- psychlops 4y agoBecause the headline says "climate change" and everyone loves to sling around pseudo factual percentages.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spaceman_2020 4y agoIt's up 50-100% for most of the places I wanted to visit :(
- Semaphor 4y ago> It's already up over 25% in the last year anyway. Germany to South Africa was 550-750€ (roughly KLM/Air France/British Airways to Emirates range) pre-pandemic, and that was also what we were seeing this year, so maybe that’s more route dependent?
- taude 4y agoUS -> anywhere I've looked (or booked) in Europe is up from about $900 -> $1800 in May -> September. So for my personal flights, it's about 100% up. In talking with friends booking family trips, it sounds the same. Even my local US-based trips along the east coast are up from $325 -> close to the $550 range for some of the same JetBlue flights I take quarterly.
- CalRobert 4y agoFTA: "it is likely that some of this cost will be picked up by travelers in the form of much more expensive airfares." Maybe, but it's disingenuous to make that comment without also noting who will pay for the cost of negative externalities arising from _not_ making these changes (spoiler: it's all of us, but disproportionately it's the people who can't afford to fly who will pay the most)
- jl6 4y agoAm I reading this right? Only a 22% fare increase? For completely decarbonizing air travel? That's less than the price variance of just flying at a different time.
- Ekaros 4y agoI don't particularly care about climate change, but 22% sounds acceptable. Or even surprisingly cheap. Taking fifth less trips even would be acceptable to me.
- amelius 4y agoI think it's the wrong approach. Rich people should not escape climate measures. Flying should be rationed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ration_stamp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ration_stamp
- hackeraccount 4y agoThey wouldn't though would they? They'd be paying just like the rest of us.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoI wonder if they do escape - my definition of a really rich person would include they have their only plane - are the costs of those flights artificially cheap or do they pay the actual price?
- Ekaros 4y agoIf they pay for carbon neutral things, is there an issue? Ofc, maybe we should make all but bare necessities carbon negative, with taxation for example.
- danielrpa 4y agoLet me guess... With you in charge of deciding the fair allocation and who should get exceptions? Another idea: eliminate business travel to attend meetings now that we have amazing remote presence tools.
- spacephysics 4y agoYes, I’m sure the execs at airline companies are solely looking at climate change as rationale why to increase prices in a very very tight margin industry, with recent record high inflation and record high borrowing rates. Perhaps if everyone agrees to a price hike, then customers won’t be incentivized to switch to a cheaper airline. Climate change movement has lost its original gestalt and now is used as a means of price action, policy changes that really make no sense. why are the US policy makers hyper focused on reducing carbon footprint of the country and destroying QoL by pushing more expensive but more ‘green’ alternatives. We’re 13th in the world per-capita emissions [0] And yet, we’re okay pushing child slave labor to mine cobolt for batteries of electric cars that, if even a small majority of Americans had, our electric grid could not handle. It’s fine, just add an additional tax to it, while millions of families are suffering from economic conditions that are likely to get worse. The green cult, like many, started for great reasons. And now it’s been high jacked for corporate interest and power grabs. I would like the planet to be more green. I think most people would. But not at the fire expense of large populations. We can transition to a greener future more slowly. People have touted “the next 10 years is the end” for 40 years. [0] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/carbon-footprint-by-country https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/carbon-fo...
- CalRobert 4y agoWhy is it any time a user fee related to fighting climate change comes up the comments are immediately astroturfed by concern trolls?
- nivenkos 4y agoBecause people don't want to pay more for things. It isn't astro-turfing.
- bojangleslover 4y ago“Tackle”
- melling 4y ago100,000 flights a day, every day of the year is 2% of all emissions. Burning all that coal to make electricity is 20-25% of emissions. When will we fix the big problems? If we’d started 40 years ago, we’d likely be worrying about aviation being carbon neutral by 2070 instead. Time to watch Carl Sagan’s 1985 warning again https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI
- mrpopo 4y agoCoal is on the decline, and flying is on the rise (I'd give numbers but recent numbers are inaccurate because of the pandemic-induced crunch). With data from 10 years ago it was at most 6 percent of the worldwide population who ever set foot in an airplane [0]. Probably today it's still single digit. [0] https://www.quora.com/What-percent-of-the-worlds-population-will-fly-in-an-airplane-in-their-lives https://www.quora.com/What-percent-of-the-worlds-population-... What do you think will happen when the Indians and Africans fly as much as the Chinese, and when the Chinese fly as much as the Americans?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- melling 4y agoNo, coal usage is reaching all-time highs of https://www.iea.org/news/the-world-s-coal-consumption-is-set-to-reach-a-new-high-in-2022-as-the-energy-crisis-shakes-markets# https://www.iea.org/news/the-world-s-coal-consumption-is-set... 10 years of coal is 100 years of aviation. Maybe we solve coal immediately and worry about aviation in 100 years? Technology a 100 years from now…
- mrpopo 4y agoGlobal coal consumption is 8MT, same as 2012, whereas world population is 15% larger and also richer, it is absolutely on the decline as a percentage of primary energy. Coal is also unfortunately an essential resource for many impoverished countries, flying is a privilege that very few people can afford, and has a huge per-capita impact. We should absolutely try to reduce coal usage as fast as possible, but it's more complicated. Stop coal today, and billions of people will die (the same people that would be impacted by climate change). Also, it costs money, whereas taxing flyers makes money.
- aceazzameen 4y agoThe cynic in me expects them to make zero progress or impact on climate change by their deadline, but still end up with a 22% increase in fairs.
- tialaramex 4y agoIdea: Pandemic lockdowns called people's bluff on a lot of bullshit. The "need" for routine long distance business travel was an example. Which means airlines now have less leverage when trying to get something from government than they would have in say 2018 because who cares if your higher fares mean less people fly if the government's model says that has negligible larger economic impact.
- kibwen 4y agoGood. This doesn't mean that the cost of flying has increased, it just means that the externalized costs are now being priced in properly. If you're a fan of markets, you should be celebrating that the market will now be more efficient as a result of more accurate pricing.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI'd generally go to the source for such claims, it's usually a bit more HN-level: https://theicct.org/stack/net-zero-aviation-mar22/ https://theicct.org/stack/net-zero-aviation-mar22/ And indeed their graphs on carbon price (and other points they make) are far more interesting than the headline. > Taxes, like a ticket tax, could be designed to shift some of the cost of technology from those who fly infrequently to relatively prosperous frequent fliers. Indeed, almost two-thirds of aviation CO2 is emitted by upper-income country residents, while countries representing the poorer half of the world emit only 10%. Any discussion of the prospects for decarbonizing air travel should recognize that air travel’s benefits skew toward prosperous people, while its climate impact affects everyone.
- paws 4y agoWhen I purchase flight tickets I like to review the breakdown of associated fees and taxes - usually plenty of entities taking their pound of flesh. So I was pretty surprised to learn that airlines have enjoyed tax exemption for jet fuel for international flights, on a worldwide basis apparently since the 1940s. IATAs position is unsurprising [0]. I find it curious that the airline industry has enjoyed such generous tax treatment for so long [1]. Granted, unlike today, in the 40s when this tax treatment was being established I doubt any government was considering taxes as a way to tackle climate change. [0] https://www.iata.org/contentassets/ebdba50e57194019930d72722413edd4/iata-position---tax-exemption-on-jet-fuel.pdf https://www.iata.org/contentassets/ebdba50e57194019930d72722... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerosene_tax#Criticism_of_kerosene_tax_exemptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kerosene_tax#Criticism_of_kero...
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoThis will be only logical output of any proposed "carbon tax". Making things expensive for poor people. At the same time society can be surprised why those people are voting for extremist or outright clima-sceptic parties. Not because they don't believe in existence of climate change, but because they can't afford to exist in the New Green World.
- Tommstein 4y agoThey jumped more than that when the pandemic ended and they apparently decided to try to make back all their pandemic losses overnight.
- lonelygirl15a 4y agoRealizing that there are other issues with which to contend, why not just start slowing down airline flights? Drag, and therefore fuel used, is a function of velocity squared. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics)#Aerodynamics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics)#Aerodynamics Slowing down from 500 to 400 knots adds a half hour to a 1000 nm flight, but could provide maybe 25-30% fuel savings?
- jackweirdy 4y agoJet aircraft typically already fly at their most fuel efficient speeds rather than their max speeds
- lonelygirl15a 4y agoNo, they typically fly at the most profitable speeds within the constraints of the flight and airspace parameters. Which results designing the planes to be efficient at those speeds. https://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_4_07/article_05_1.html https://www.boeing.com/commercial/aeromagazine/articles/qtr_...
- danielrpa 4y agoIt's more complex than that. There factors other than drag. Planes wouldn't be more efficient if they simply used roads at 60mph all the way to the destination (no takeoff)! Fuel is expensive so they do a lot of work to figure out the optimal speed.
- lonelygirl15a 4y agoUse roads at 60mph? I guess they're most efficient if they don't start the engines at all and you put the plane on a boat or a train.
- penguin_booze 4y agoI suspect this is just another green washing scam. The outcome I predict is fatter executive pockets.