6 ms·
5.3B Mobile Phones Will Become Waste in 2022
- quaintdev 4y agoGoogle likes to mention that they are carbon neutral since 2007 on their homepage. They don't seem to consider Android phone and it's footprint. People have to keep buying phones because they can't support old phones.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoPixel support is fine. Are you talking about Android updates in general on third-party devices? That's a chip-related problem. Vent at Qualcomm.
- AshamedCaptain 4y ago> That's a chip-related problem. The chips are fine, or at least they are as fine as they were when they were bought, so it is not a chip problem. It is a Google problem.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoNote the word "related". It's doing a lot of heavy-lifting in this sentence. The drivers for the SoC are closed source. Qualcomm refuses to update the drivers, meaning more sales. The modern Pixel uses Google's Tensor, not Qualcomm's Snapdragon.
- AshamedCaptain 4y agoIf only there was one entity that literally controls who has access or not to the Google Store, and could enforce practices like actually respecting copyrights (like the GPL) or even using an upstream kernel for any device that ever wants to access the Google Store... This is all Google's fault. They are the ones who develop most of the software. They are the ones who decide what to deprecated and what not. They also set the rules about what is acceptable and what is not ('open' handset alliance my ass).
- dmbche 4y agoYeah I'm on a Pixel 2 still and it's snappy as ever, I would see no improvement at all by buying this year's flagship. I'm sorry to hear other androids aren't the same.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoBut the Pixel 2 got its final update in 2020 and doesn't get security updates anymore, right? I'll take security over performance if it's my daily-driver and I'm doing things that might actually make sense to protect (banking et al), but threat models vary of course.
- dmbche 4y agoYou're right - I forgot about that - I assume my device is already unsecure to the bone, but I doubt that's fine for most people
- ikekkdcjkfke 4y agoPhones worked perfectly fine years ago. As soon as you update, suddenly you're RAM is innsufficient and paging slows down the phone. Now you need to buy the new model
- hammyhavoc 4y agoName those phones. Contact your device manufacturer and complain if they aren't unrealistically old.
- lukeschlather 4y agoAnything with a locked bootloader should have lifetime support. Even with an unlocked bootloader 3 years of software support is not remotely fine. Most phones with decent care can last 6 years fine. Realistically even with unlocked bootloaders a lack of perpetual android updates is going to result in waste.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYup. So complain to Qualcomm and apply pressure to your device manufacturer on their forum, social media, your blog, the media, a YouTube video. Right To Repair didn't gain traction by nerds preaching to the choir. They're a corp. Threaten to hit them where it hurts: bottomline, and negative press causing damage to the bottomline.
- mindslight 4y ago> Pixel support is fine Uh, what? I just bought a new Pixel 7 (after my perfectly good S7 was deliberately obsoleted by carriers discontinuing some 4G cell service (and the FCC allowing this!)). The Pixel's official software updates are slated to end in less than 3 short years, and the security updates are slated to end in less than 5 short years, leading third party distributions Graphene/Calyx to project ending of their own support in 5 short years as well. This is most definitely not "fine" ! If the various drivers required to get the device running were actually upstreamed into the mainline kernel, and Google stopped churning Android major versions like it was fashion week, then my phone could happily function for 10+ years just like my laptop and desktop.
- hammyhavoc 4y ago3 years is a huge step up on where Android support was a few years ago, let alone 5 years. There are Android tablets and phones I've bought in the past that never got one update or any kind of security update, and were out of date before they were even released in terms of software. They couldn't even run the apps I'd bought them for as I'd naively assumed they'd be running the latest OS when they launched. Plenty of manufacturers also promise updates and don't deliver because they're at the mercy of Qualcomm providing driver updates. The last Nokia I had got a couple months of updates then nothing for over a year, yet was in the Android One program. Like I said: it's fine. If replacing the phone in 3 years or 5 years time is going to be a problem then perhaps you should have bought a cheaper phone and replaced more often, IMO. The cost of ownership per year assuming 3-5 years is the price of a piece of crap that gets updates for a few months to a year. By the time year 2 hits on most phones, the battery is mediocre versus what it used to be. Google has a trade-in program that gives pretty good credit towards the next device. It's a cellphone. It's not a desktop computer. They aren't built to last or assumed to last. Buy it, use it, trash or trade it in, get the next one. Sure, I wish that there was an ATX-like standard for cellphone chassis and parts, but there isn't, and the support is much better than it was. Cellphones are garbage versus what they used to be in build quality and durability, but they also do much more than they ever did. Maybe an iPhone would suit you better? Hell, I didn't even use a phone for quite a few years as I shared your sentiment, but I aged out of it and found other things to worry about, and a few hundred bucks every few years is whatever to have one less problem with something I use for a good chunk of every day. My modded ThinkPad T440p is still going strong. The missus's X201 is still going strong too. I use 30-50 year old tech elsewhere because it still works, I love the design, and/or it's easy to service. I get the sentiment.
- bushbaba 4y agoGoogle isn't carbon neutral. They are neutral-ish. They still use coal and natural gas based energy generation to power their DCs. They just buy an equivalent amount of energy in other locations as 'offsets'. If all coal and natural gas generation went offline today, Google would have an outage of their datacenters.
- kelnos 4y agoPixel support is at 5 years now for security updates (only 3 years for major OS updates, unfortunately), which is still not as good as Apple in general, but is pretty good considering where they were just a few years ago. Google isn't responsible for the support agreements Samsung, Motorola, etc. make with their suppliers.
- culi 4y agoE-waste is a massive problem that's growing exponentially and needs to be talked about more publicly We're currently at around 50 million metric tons of e-waste every year globally. By the 2050s solar panels (average lifespan of a panel is around 2 decades) alone are expected to be around 50 million metric tons of waste Unless we start taking seriously right-to-repair and full life cycle analysis, the move towards electrifying everything is just more of us kicking the can down to road
- lukeschlather 4y agoWorldwide coal consumption is over 7 billion tons. So we could just burn those solar panels to ash and it would still be a dramatic improvement over what they're replacing.
- sephamorr 4y agoI dislike trash as much as the next person, but 50MT is 2% of global waste production (2000MT from my search). Is 50MT or (<1% of predicted 2050 waste) really that bad for generating most of the world's energy? This is before considering that solar panel lifetimes keep increasing; some solar panels are sold with 40 year warranties (88.3% @40years, SunPowerMaxeon), so that number could come down perhaps by half.
- Gustomaximus 4y agoAlso a 20/40 year warranty is what manufactures guarantee. There is every likeyhood panels guaranteed for 20 years are still in use decade(s) past their warranty.
- culi 4y agoBy year 5 a panel is already down to 95% efficiency. Year 25 is around 80-85%. That may not sound like much but in many environments, that difference is enough to make solar panels not worth keeping. And ask yourself as a consumer if you really think other consumers are going to keep a solar panel because it's "the right thing to do" when they could probably buy and much better solar panel for very cheap at that point in the future. It's like keeping a 15 year old graphics card when you could buy a 5 year old graphics card for $50 and get 100x the performance
- m3kw9 4y agoThere should be requirements for phone makers to recycle their own phones.
- cjensen 4y agoOne per person on the planet in a single year? Never preface your talking point with an obviously wrong statistic.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThat was my gut impulse, too. But then I realized that I've got three laptops. One for personal use, and 2 for jobs. And I think I have my previous two phones in a drawer.
- xboxnolifes 4y agoThose previous, now unused, devices didn't become waste in 2022. They became waste when you stopped using them and don't end up ever re-using them.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoYes, that addition was a side-response to the linked article.
- mb7733 4y agoIronic comment considering world population is 8 billion
- rcstank 4y agoNot too ironic considering many are too young to have phones, or too poor to have them.
- cjensen 4y agoFair.
- kurthr 4y agoI'm gonna support your point. I'm not buying that 3x more phones were trashed as sold. New cell phone sales are under 2B/year. Industry hoped they would continue rising after 2016, but they've plateaued around 1.8B. Of those about 200M are still flip/dumb phones. Ownership time (in the pipeline) is increasing not falling. I don't believe 5.3B became waste unless many B people suddenly decided to do without (in 2022). That seems unlikely unless it just some random definition of watste. Sure there might even be (8-9 years of production) 16B phones laying around somewhere outside of landfill so why did they become get trashed in '22? Can we blame 3G? https://www.sellcell.com/how-many-mobile-phones-are-sold-each-year/ https://www.sellcell.com/how-many-mobile-phones-are-sold-eac...
- osigurdson 4y agoI'd happily use my current phone for the rest of my life. It shouldn't be necessary to replace every ~2 years.
- LeBit 4y agoAre you 95 years old?
- osigurdson 4y agoNo. I just feel that phones are in the asymptotic phase now and don’t see any reason to upgrade other than unfixable battery life issues, worn out charging ports and other such things.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoAll I want to use my phone for is to occasionally talk, easily text, and snap photos or videos. It's ridiculous that I have to own a smartphone to do this with.
- osigurdson 4y agoSame. Except I need a browser, internet access, as well as a GPU and large screen for games. If only I didn't need a smartphone for this.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThe thing is I had this until 3G went away. Now texting is more of a bitch than it was with the chiclet keyboard, and the battery uses about 4x more energy (in standby, with the screen off) even with everything extra disabled or removed. And the phone is larger. The only gain is a better camera. My wife's situation is even worse. Why can't these mother fuckers still make at least one non-touchscreen phone with a chiclet keyboard??!!!!!!!! Even "old people" like to fucking text. They could sell it for 300% profit. Hell, even 1000% profit. People like me would pay. Toss 5G onto it so they do a manufacturing run once, and continue selling the same model for 10+ years until their stock runs out. This can be done, and done profitably. They just don't care.
- vondur 4y agoI wonder if we can get more use out of cell phones now that the CPUs are tending to plateau in terms of performance? For a while the Apple A series were were on an exponential curve but seem to be leveling off. Also making it easy to turn in items for proper disposal (actually harvesting metals from them) would help?
- evo_9 4y agoWe’ve reached the photoshop moment in phones a while ago now where what was offered probably 5-8+ years back was all anyone really needed or wanted. Now it’s just more and more features nobody asked for or uses. I honestly put off upgrading my phone as long as possible now, they’re like tires for my car - I need em but man I hate hate hate replacing them and spending the money.
- calvinmorrison 4y agoThe features I want? Universal video calls to any phone. Larger attachments.
- chemmail 4y agoHow about just all day battery life.
- bee_rider 4y agoI hang on to my phone as long as I can, although mostly out of laziness and cheapness. It would be nice if phones could converge to absorb laptops somehow. Fold or roll out maybe?
- parker_mountain 4y agoiPhones receive 5 years of support from when the device was _last sold by Apple_. Functionally, that means that buying a new iPhone when it's released will mean that it receives 7 years of OS updates, including security fixes to the baseband and other hardware. I was using an iPhone 8 until last year, and it was functionally fine until I replaced it. This is one area where Apple is unambiguously leading the pack on mainstream manufacturers. The iPhone 14 is winning accolades for its (relative) ease of repair-ability, as well. It is not inconceivable that if you buy an iPhone 14 today, it will receive software and hardware support until 2029 - or even 2030 if you're lucky.
- throwaway81523 4y agoBut people upgrade their iphones instead of replacing the glued in battery. Make the battery user replaceable with no tools or at most a small screwdriver, dammit.
- srj 4y agoI've had my current phone for 3.5 years and if there are features on newer phones I'm missing I guess I'm happier to not know about them.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm pretty sure the waste from cell phones pales in comparison to televisions. Which again pales in comparison to things like cars. Phones are tiny and lightweight. Yes let's try to recycle them better, but they're just not a very noteworthy source of waste at all. A lot of people throw away more plastic food packaging in a week.
- bee_rider 4y agoIt would be nice to save the resources that go into their batteries though.
- bboygravity 4y agoAnd let's not forget a significant part of the third world still either dumps ALL their trash into the jungle, which rains it into rivers and then into the sea. Or they burn it nightly in their gardens. This includes places with serious income from tourism, such as Bali.
- dendriti 4y agoLet's not forget that a significant part of the first world ships much of their trash to the third world, often illegally.
- charlie0 4y agoI've kept my phones for around 5 years before replacing them. Especially now, wfh I'm always a few seconds away from my laptop. The most usage I get out of the phone is when on the throne, reading HN or browsing memes.
- Eric_WVGG 4y agoImagine how many terrific little robots and gadgets could be made from six-year-old iPhone motherboards and screens. Imagine if Smart TVs just used old Samsung Galaxy boards instead of custom hardware? (yes I also prefer dumb teevees) Could the Raspberry Pi even survive a market of rooted boards?
- jacknews 4y agoOne problem is that it's difficult to reuse these still very capable devices. Sure there's postmarketos and others, but they only support few devices, and it requires a huge amount of work to add new ones. Perhaps manufacturers should be forced to release at least the kernel and essential drivers source for obsolete devices, which would reduce the effort required to make them useful for other things. And some other issues, like allowing them to still boot with no battery, broken screen, stuck buttons, etc.
- sys_64738 4y agoDon’t blame me. Still got a 6S.
- xnx 4y agoIs this the same bad statistic as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33219302 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33219302 ?
- WirelessGigabit 4y agoI've gotten to the age where I want my software to remain the same. But instead it gets expanded, which makes my hardware feel slower and then I have a need to upgrade. From a security point of view it's sad that that fixes & new software go hand-in-hand. There is no LTS iOS, or LTS Android available. And then I have this brand new iPhone which isn't actually faster in browsing than a 5 year old one. Windows suffers from the same. My laptop has gotten a LOT faster over time, yet sorting by CPU on task manager literally takes 3 seconds on Windows 11. Why?