3 ms·
International agreements are hardly tried and tested. The Nonproliferation Treaty has been somewhat effective with nuclear weapons largely because refining oper
by nradov 4y ago
International agreements are hardly tried and tested. The Nonproliferation Treaty has been somewhat effective with nuclear weapons largely because refining operations are hard to hide, and even with that several additional countries have acquired such weapons. Agreements on chemical and biological weapons are largely moot because it turns out that such weapons aren't even very effective compared to kinetic alternatives. The ban on land mines was never ratified by the countries that do most fighting, and such mines are being heavily used by both sides in Ukraine. The Washington Naval Treaty was a total failure. The ban on space weapons is breaking down right now.
It is impossible to have an effective international agreement on autonomous weapons. No military power would ever agree to let a third party inspect their weapon source code in a verifiable way. It's too easy to hide the real code, and we would never trust potential adversaries not to cheat.
Fully autonomous weapons have already been deployed for decades. The Mark 60 CAPTOR mine could sit and wait for weeks until it detected a probable target matching a programmed signature, then launch a homing torpedo at it. After the initial deployment there is no human in the loop.
- stareatgoats 4y agoFWIW, you make a good point, albeit a pessimistic one - at least if you like me dread the chicken race towards doom that is the obvious alternative. Agree that international agreements may not always have been the success stories I implied. But even the fact that some states have not signed certain treaties prove that they are effective (otherwise they could have signed and then just ignored them). Once a state has signed a treaty you won't need to rely on outside inspectors exclusively - inside whistleblowers will do just fine.
- nradov 4y agoHow many inside whistleblowers do you think we will get from China, North Korea, and Iran?
- stareatgoats 4y agoWhistleblowers, spies, side-channel intelligence. Not that many tools but enough to make most states avoid entering agreements they won't honor. No state wants to be exposed as a deceptive liar, it goes to their legitimacy. Impossible? well believe what you like. I'd like to believe that it is possible.