13 ms·
Help make mass surveillance of entire populations uneconomical
- tivert 4y agotl;dr: This is just your typical list of "privacy focused" and "self hosted" alternatives (e.g. use Signal not Facebook Messenger), with some attention-grabbing framing. Some of the recommendations are pretty suspect, too: how is using Thunderbird for email supposed to "opt you out of PRISM and XKeyscore"?
- etiam 4y agoDo you realize that page was established in 2013? If the reference is keeping all your messages, and potentially your PGP keys, in "cloud" storage at a PRISM provider it's not particularly hard to understand some ways in which using Thunderbird instead is supposed to help. It's a fair point it's not a particularly satisfying mitigation though.
- tivert 4y ago> Do you realize that page was established in 2013? No, but that makes sense. The framing would have been much more apt back then than it is now, with the Snowden stuff being fresh. > If the reference is keeping all your messages, and potentially your PGP keys, in "cloud" storage at a PRISM provider it's not particularly hard to understand some ways in which using Thunderbird instead is supposed to help. It's a fair point it's not a particularly satisfying mitigation though. The reference is just "instead of Gmail, use Thunderbird" (e.g. https://prism-break.org/en/subcategories/macos-email/ https://prism-break.org/en/subcategories/macos-email/). They don't mention PGP in that section at all, though there's a later one about "Email Addons, which does, which is easy to miss (e.g. skipping b/c you don't already use addons). Their (broken HTML) recommendation to run your own email email server is also suspect, because it's a bad tradeoff. Unless you want a second, unpaid job as email server administrator (with a pager!), you're "protecting" yourself against a rare hypothetical threat (government surveillance) by making yourself vulnerable to a much more common one (run of the mill hackers). Realistically, they probably should have just said something along the lines of "email surveillance is practically unavoidable," so don't use it for anything you don't want monitored. PGP failed because it's too hard to use, so no one uses it, and any reasonable use of email will mainly involve exchanging messages with some "monitored provider's" servers.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoI guess using Thunderbird would get many people away from relying exclusively on the web interface of gmail. Then the next step would be to make an e-mail account at another e-mail provider. Later maybe switch away from gmail entirely.
- Qem 4y ago> how is using Thunderbird for email supposed to "opt you out of PRISM and XKeyscore"? The mail client may help improve privacy if you configure it to erase data in the server as it is downloaded to the client (POP), instead of letting it stay in the server for a indefinite amount of time (IMAP). If people are going to break into your provider, a empty mailbox would limit compromise.
- acapybara 4y ago[flagged]
- rngname22 4y agoIs this AI generated? The first paragraph sounds sort of Chat-GPT-esque to me.
- wafflemaker 4y agoWouldn't be surprised if GPT-4 learned it's style from higher quality HN comments.
- graderjs 4y agoPlease don't post shallow dismissals. It ruins what this site is for. Interesting that the message content is not what’s being adjudicated by down votes here. If a mod says it: all good. If a cocommenter says it: very bad.
- vpribish 4y agosame. turing test failed. it's over-wordified, too formal, message-light. how did it get to the top?
- saagarjha 4y agoConsidering it sounds nothing like their past comments, I'm guessing they're asking ChatGPT to rephrase their words.
- deleted 4y ago
- marcrosoft 4y agoThe suggestions here are not great. For example file syncing has no mention of syncthing and recommends something I’ve never heard of.
- evilspammer 4y agoThe site hasn't been updated since 2021-08-02 per the footer, and probably sparsely before that. I think this site was most popular around when Snowden did the leaks and hasn't had as much hype since then. A more modern alternative is https://www.privacytools.io/ https://www.privacytools.io/ but I haven't checked it in a while and can't vouch for the current contents.
- flangola7 4y agoprivacytools had a hostile takeover by its long absent domain owner and now pushes several crypto services. The previous maintainers created and moved to: https://www.privacyguides.org/en/ https://www.privacyguides.org/en/
- joshuaissac 4y ago> For example file syncing has no mention of syncthing and recommends something I’ve never heard of. It does mention Syncthing. From the site: > File Storage & Sync > Prefer > EteSync > Encrypted calendar, contacts and tasks sync. > Syncthing > Direct file sync between devices.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- graderjs 4y agoBut if your phone OS / cellular firmware is compromised then e2e or even at-rest encryption won't matter. Anything you can see on your phone can be seen. I think a more rational alternative is to consider that everything except your unexpressed thoughts and emotions is already logged. At some point, this will become true (if it ain't already), so....then you at least will be ahead of that curve. So if everything you do is monitored, how do you achieve privacy in such a world? That is the question, I think. In fact, it's similar to how a corporation or nation needs to think about protecting their own secrets. They have to assume compromise (of people, systems, etc)...how do you confuse and compartmentalize what you want to protect?
- LinuxBender 4y agoSo if everything you do is monitored, how do you achieve privacy in such a world? I might put a physical paper notebook in a reporters pocket then meet with them and buy them a coffee or tea. Or I might give them a USB drive with a self-decrypting file and instructions for how to use it securely. Or if I am feeling silly I might borrow a few hundred digital billboards and just broadcast the data to everyone and let the public sort it out. FoghornBlowing?
- htag 4y ago1. It's completely possible to treat your phone as an insecure device. Maybe I'm naive, but I think it's possible to run a daily Linux system with a reasonable assumption of privacy. 2. When you act as if you are being monitored and judged for your words/actions, you begin to self govern them to be more acceptable to the presumed omnipresent agent. Sometimes the fear of being surveilled is as powerful as actual surveillance.
- graderjs 4y agoBut not if we assume compromise. How would you hide in plain sight? That is the question. Bruce Lee said: be water. But maybe you need to: Be Hamlet
- blatant303 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoIn general it's a good thing that more and more people are aware of the necessity for good security practices for all online interactions - but the belief that individual technological efforts can defeat large-scale corporate and nation-state monitoring is pretty silly. At best you'll just have an added layer of security against things like theft of credit card information by criminal gangs. If you actually want to do something like communicate with a journalist while hiding your own endpoint from exposure you have to go to fairly ridiculous lengths, such as acquiring a laptop used only for that purpose and which has no associated identifying information, use random open Wifi networks to log onto, and have a decent understanding of the concepts of public-key, asymmetric and symmetric cryptography. Note that there is simply no way for two known parties on the internet to hide the fact that they are communicating with one another from government-corporate managers of the Internet - although it's possible to keep the content hidded, to some extent, unless your passwords get compromised, which seems fairly easy to accomplish for such actors via keylogger malware installed through backdoor attacks using secret zero-day exploits and so on. The only real solution is the passage of data privacy laws that provide criminal penalities and which allow class-action lawsuits against corporations and governments that engage in warrantless mass surveillance or the retention and aggregation of customer's personal data in searchable databases.
- scarface74 4y agoYou mean you want the same government that is interested in putting back doors in phones and other surveillance techniques to pass laws that keep them from doing so?
- titzer 4y ago> by encrypting your communications and ending your reliance on proprietary services. Well, unfortunately, you can't encrypt your location and pretty much every mobile phone is sending detailed GPS, accelerometer, barometer, WiFi, and other sensor data back to the mothership multiple times an hour.
- kornhole 4y agoThis is technically easy to fix on any Android or Linux phone. Willingness by people to make the changes is the challenge.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoThis is interesting: https://www.theregister.com/2023/04/27/qualcomm_covert_operating_system_claim/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/04/27/qualcomm_covert_opera...
- titzer 4y agoGoogle Play Services is not easy to rip out, and it installs itself as a "better" location service provider for the device, meaning that app requests for location go through it. And it can and does upload "anonymized"[1] data of all these types constantly as part of its normal operations. You can withhold consent to uploading "anonymized" data by paying careful attention to click-through agreements[2] and explicitly turning off "high location accuracy"[3] in your Android settings. [1] The technical details of how this data are anonymized, nor how it is analyzed and used to "improve products" are not public. [2] The implications of each click-through agreement are, as usual, non-obvious. [3] The name of this mechanism keeps changing and it is harder and harder to find and disable.
- kornhole 4y agoWithin a few minutes I can deactivate Google Play Services on an Android phone using ADB. The universal android debloater available on Github makes it easier. The better solution is a custom OS forked from Android, but what is possible depends on the device.
- scarface74 4y agoAnd they recommend using a Google free Android phone to prevent surveillance. Ignoring the fact that Qualcomm based phones will still leak data. https://www.nitrokey.com/news/2023/smartphones-popular-qualcomm-chip-secretly-share-private-information-us-chip-maker https://www.nitrokey.com/news/2023/smartphones-popular-qualc...
- Zetobal 4y agoDid you understand the article you just linked or do you just wanna throw shit on a bonfire? They pull GPS data and nothing else.
- scarface74 4y agoYes because worrying about your location being tracked is silly and never used by government - especially in the case where they want to arrest everyone who was protesting in a given area.
- Zetobal 4y agoAh yes... the dystopian sci-fi argument without merit.
- scarface74 4y agoThey are doing that today. The FBI asked cell phone providers for everyone who was around the capital January 6th. https://freebeacon.com/latest-news/google-gave-fbi-location-data-for-thousands-of-cell-phones-near-jan-6-riots-court-records-show/ https://freebeacon.com/latest-news/google-gave-fbi-location-...
- cynicalsecurity 4y agoMass surveillance helped the UK Counter Terrorism Police identify Russian spies Ruslan Boshirov and Alexander Petrov in Salisbury investigation who were trying to kill a family of dissidents. Granted, the website is dedicated to mass surveillance in the IT. But then think, generally speaking, is the mass surveillance on some reasonable level really so bad? It's helping identifying Russian soldiers who are committing war crimes and atrocities in Ukraine. It helps preserve the free and democratic society rather than creates a road to dystopia. Of course, I'm speaking of some reasonable levels, not of something like real-time client device scanning. It doesn't make any sense and it would simply not work.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoIt's a dangerous train of thought. You will end up like China where it's acceptable for the "greater good". And nobody will ever give the power back once they have it.
- ChatGTP 4y agoI agree it's dangerous but what are governments supposed to do? In a world where individuals or very small groups of people are increasingly gaining the power to do potentially catastrophic damage using increasingly powerful technology, what are the actual alternatives? Trust? How can society functionin going forwards without at least some oversight ? Don't get me wrong, I don't want society to go this way, but I'm starting to see fewer and fewer options presented to Governments. I can see both sides of the story. I wouldn't pretend I know the right answer, but I think we have to admit the world has changed quite a bit recently.
- moremetadata 4y ago[dead]
- inglor 4y agoIt is ok as long as you are not the target :) It is basically only ok if you can guarantee it’s users always use it in good faith which is virtually impossible.
- Maximus9000 4y agoWhat's wrong with 1Password? I've seen several famous cyber security pros recommend 1password (like Troy Hunt).
- chaxor 4y agoI think most segments against online password companies is that they get hacked so often. The most practical problem is having to switch all your passwords around after such a leak occurs, which seems to be more and more permanent these days. Contrary to popular belief, the best reason to store passwords offline is actually convenience, so that you don't have to change them so often (your single password dump is not a target, but all people's data is).
- Invictus0 4y ago1Password doesn't have my passwords, they exist in an encrypted vault on Dropbox which is itself encrypted. The whole thing is extremely secure.
- cosmolev 4y agoWhich version are you currently using? I used to have the same setup back in the days when 1Password was only a standalone app, before it became a SaaS as it is now. Can you please explain how you have organized your current setup?
- Invictus0 4y agoHmm, seems that version 8 and above discontinued Dropbox sync. I haven't updated my app in ages so I still have the dropbox setup.
- itslennysfault 4y agoMy guess would be that it is because it is not open source, but I am surprised that there is no mention of BitWarden.
- hermannj314 4y agoIs it legal to have private conversations discussing actual plans for acts of terrorism? I assume you have to pierce some veil of reality, make a purchase, buy a ticket, etc. before it becomes a crime. My point is if we can make surveillance costly by filling the airwaves with false positives that are just a group of bots plotting a terrorist act? I assume that is legal to do. Edit - ok, so it definitely seems like this is not clever at all and almost certainly a crime. Don't do this!
- citizenkeen 4y ago> Is it legal to have private conversations discussing actual plans for acts of terrorism? Not in most countries, no.
- bragr 4y agoNo, that would likely constitute criminal conspiracy, even if you have no intent to commit it. https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=182&lawCode=PEN https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...
- nashashmi 4y ago> (2) Falsely and maliciously to indict another for any crime, or to procure another to be charged or arrested for any crime. So this means police informants in connection to the police are also committing a crime? Far too often people with recorded criminal activities are baited into getting another person caught for a more severe crime like terrorism, in exchange of being let go.
- coldtea 4y ago>So this means police informants in connection to the police are also committing a crime? It says "falsely and maliciously". So, if what say is true, it's not a crime. If what they say is false but they believe it to be true, it's not done "maliciously", so it's not a crime. If what they say is false and they know it, yeah, it is a crime. But if the police and court believes them, or if it's the police itself that pressured them to point their fingers to some person they wanted to get, then it doesn't matter whether it's a crime or not, as it wont be prosecuted, and the police not only doesn't care, but explicitly wants the false testimony.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Nifty3929 4y agoThe main problem I see is that people are completely distracted by privacy from corporations - when what we really need to be worried about is privacy from our own governments. So much ink is spilled talking about cookies, ads tracking, etc. But really what's the worst a corporation is going to do? Try to sell you something? Meanwhile, we continue to allow our governments to regulate and legislate ever more intrusive invasions of our privacy. And they can put us in jail, or worse. This also gets blurry as governments take increasing control of companies, to the point that some are just about arms of the government, surveilling us in ways that the government can't (yet) do on their own - and being forced to pass that data to the government under penalty of law themselves.
- Applejinx 4y agoI'm completely uninterested in the distinction you draw here. Actually, several distinctions. What do you mean 'our OWN governments'? This is a world where hostile foreign governments can wreak absolute havoc… including by popularizing arguments literally the same as the one you're making, for the purpose of undermining that government and fomenting revolution for their own selfish, imperialist purposes. I can think of two great powers (okay, one formerly great) actively doing this within my lifetime, and the formerly great one was doing it as hard as it possibly could, within the last ten years, and is still doing it. I don't trust your argument at all. You're leaving out significant things, conveniently.
- Nifty3929 4y agoThe difference between my own government and a foreign government is twofold: 1. It has always been illegal for a foreign state actor to surveil me, and in any case has no authority over me and can't put me in jail (as long as I'm not in their country). 2. My own government is legally entitled to surveil me and collect my personal data, and can indeed put me in jail.
- ipaddr 4y agoIt is not illegal for a foreign state actor to surveil you. In fact governments sign agreements with other governments for them to surveil you while we surveil their citizens and trade information. This gets around the illegal act of government spying on it's own citizens. Your government mass surveil's foreign citizens. But they can't mass surveil citizens legally.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 4y agoI used to semi-joke the real way to break these systems is to have multiple AIs on everyone’s phones constantly talking to each other. You do this over encrypted chat and tag if it’s real or not. Only display the real ones to the users. Then when you send a message it can be hidden. And it becomes too expensive to review.
- monkeynotes 4y agoGetting regular folk, myself included, off of these popular platforms - especially Gmail isn't economical for most people. Just changing your email address and migrating to another provider isn't an easy sell. Whilst the motivation of this project is commendable it's not going to reach the volume of folks needed to make a difference.
- timcavel 4y ago[dead]
- vladharbuz 4y agoWhy? Signing up for FastMail or Migadu and redirecting your mail is very easy. If you use a custom domain, you don’t even have to change your address when you migrate to a new provider.
- psd1 4y agoI spent several days evaluating mail providers and migrating. It is work.
- monkeynotes 4y ago> Signing up for FastMail or Migadu and redirecting your mail is very easy... > If you use a custom domain... I'd suggest trying to talk the average American into doing that. You'd have to be quite out of touch with everyday people to think this is a battle you can win.
- bragr 4y agoThis seems great until you dig into some of the recommendations. A tool to save webpages is not an alternative to a news reader. A dynamic DNS service is a not an alternative to Google public DNS, etc, etc I can't see the this making any kind of dent on the average person with these kinds of recommendations.
- pickledish 4y agoWord, I was a bit surprised by the "email" section as well. As a better alternative to Gmail, I would have expected to see e.g. protonmail or fastmail, but instead saw... thunderbird, an email client? Which doesn't make a lot of sense
- Applejinx 4y agoIf it is actually a malicious site trying to herd people toward exploitable behaviors it'd be following the Nigerian Scammer tactic of pre-screening by allowing simple errors to scare off more savvy inquiries. This would go along with the rather crude emotional appeal. That said, it hardly seems an efficient way to exploit people… though there are useful points. If you can get somebody credulous to use something that's compromised, and you're acting like a baleen whale and accumulating whole populations of credulous government-suspicious folks whom you've steered towards some mechanism where YOU can surveil them, that's got to have some usefulness. People absolutely don't take into account the effectiveness of loosely manipulating entire populations in selective ways. You never need to select an individual and 'make' them take any action at all. You only have to cultivate the conditions for the outcome you want. Facebook might have discovered this first, but the idea sure caught on quick.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoMaybe you should raise these concerns on https://gitlab.com/prism-break/prism-break/-/issues https://gitlab.com/prism-break/prism-break/-/issues ?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoIt makes plenty of sense. On https://prism-break.org/en/all/#email https://prism-break.org/en/all/#email, they state "For more email providers, take a look at Privacy-Conscious Email Services. Please decide for yourself whether if you trust them with your data. For more discussion about safe email providers, please see issue #461.". They even state that Thunderbird is a "Extensible, cross-platform email client.". The implied idea being to use Thunderbird to access a "Privacy-Conscious Email Service". I use Gmail as an email client more than than I use it as an email provider because it has an External Accounts function. I apply Google's "App Script" system to my email to do things that you could do in Outlook's full-fat client or maybe in Thunderbird with some extensions.
- 8K832d7tNmiQ 4y agoShould've add (2021) at the end because the site itself hasn't been updated in years.
- stefncb 4y agoThat would imply it's out of date, which it apparently isn't. The website itself doesn't need updating if it stays relevant.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoPlenty is out of date on it. They also still link to https://prxbx.com/email/ https://prxbx.com/email/ from https://prism-break.org/en/all/#email https://prism-break.org/en/all/#email, which doesn't consider https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/06/protonmail-logged-ip-address-of-french-activist-after-order-by-swiss-authorities/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/06/protonmail-logged-ip-addre...
- jonhohle 4y agoIt would be helpful to have some description regarding why some entries made the naughty list. For example, is there evidence that iOS sends data to PRISM? Has any analysis shown that Safari leaks any more data than Firefox?
- swapfile 4y agoIt probably goes along the lines of: "It is impossible to download and examine iOS's source code, which means that it is impossible to prove that iOS is not spyware. Any program which does not make its source code available is potential spyware." Which I agree with. I'm not going to trust and put as much personal data as a smartphone usually contains into a proprietary black box.
- KennyBlanken 4y agoYeah, this bit: > "Apple iOS devices are affected by PRISM. Even using the software tools we recommend here, your privacy may be compromised by iOS itself. The operating system of any device can unfortunately lever out any privacy protection that a program tries to offer you." ...made me conclude that these people are idiots. You don't need to activate iCloud on an iPhone and you can use standard stuff like IMAP and WebDAV to sync contacts and calendars etc. There's also a huge list of telemetry controls you can shut off in the OS. Not to mention they have the best physical and OS security of any mobile device. Suggesting that a small homebrew Android ROM, maintained by anonymous individuals, which hasn't seen any security updates in almost a year, is comparable in terms of end-user privacy is ludicrous.
- amatecha 4y agoI didn't use iCloud yet Apple Customer Support was able to directly send a "remote access request" to my iPhone, years ago, which I simply had to press "accept" and they were able to remote-control my phone and see everything on screen. There's no reason the OS can't allow that exact same comprehensive remote access, without asking my permission. There's also no reason Apple can't surreptitiously introduce new back doors with any given iOS update -- especially considering the new "urgent update" functionality they recently introduced.
- itherseed 4y agoI was surprised to find Authy in the "Avoid" column of the 2FA apps in Android. Anybody knows why? I prefer something open source like Aegis that I can backup myself but didn't hear anything bad about Authy in particular.
- turnsout 4y agoYeah, kind of surprising. I guess it's a private company that manages your 2FA code backups, and they could theoretically lock you out. I avoid Authy for a different reason: after upgrading phones, my backup password (which is 100% correct, trust me) is not unlocking my archive. I switched over to iCloud Keychain and will never look back.
- thekingshorses 4y agoI use google authenticator. I backup the QR code in the TrueCrypt vault when I add a new account to the google auth. I am not sure how secure it is, but I am very scared of losing access to google authenticator.
- pipingdog 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33444223 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33444223
- raybb 4y agoRelatedly, does anyone know about 2fas.com ? They have a very nice app and a lot of installs but it's unclear how well vetted the oss is.
- avodonosov 4y agoAn important part of the problem is that super complex software and hardware stacks are required today for even basic tasks. This limits customer's chioce, essentially forcing customer to use these bloated, insecure, obscure products. Even browsing the plain text Hacker News forum requires a web browser, so complex that only few companies in the world can produce it. And runs on super complex OS. I wish we had something like "basic computing / commnication device" specification. Simple, limited and transparent, that everyone can produce. With small software, That would allow to exchange messages and browse information online. Not all data formats, but a limited set of formats, good enough for basic communications. Better a frozen spec, not a moving target. (Or a very careful evolution, with very rare release of new versions) Good publishers, web sites, etc, could test their systems against the "basic comp / comm device".
- jraph 4y ago> Even browsing the plain text Hacker News forum requires a web browser, so complex that only few companies in the world can produce it. This not take anything out of your point, but HN can be browsed with simpler browsers like lynx, w3m, Ladybird or NetSurf, which are all written by a small set of people. (they do rely on quite complex operating systems though)
- avodonosov 4y agoMaybe the main lock-in is in drivers for proprietary hardware. Platform software like bare bones Linux / Android and Firefox is probably not the root of the lock-in. If so, maybe it's better to think of two devices: trusted device, and fancy device. The trusted device is a simple, low power and cheap device, maybe without even a camera. Just touchscreen, wi-fi and mobile internet. Fully open drivers, and hardware spec. Running bare bones Linux / Android, Firefox. Easy to root and reinstall the full software stack. There can be an open specification for at, as a "basic comp / comm device": 1 GB memory, CPU of certain performance, etc. The fancy device is a cutting edge proprietary flagman device. Great power, but risk of tracking. Every user can have both types of devices.
- turnsout 4y agoThanks to this article I learned about Nextcloud[0], which at first glance looks like a really nice self-hostable alternative to the Google Suite. [0]https://nextcloud.com https://nextcloud.com
- tgv 4y agoAnd Dropbox.
- mkoubaa 4y agoWouldn't it be more viable to just curate multiple personal identities? It's not illegal and as long as they don't need your SSN they won't care. I've thought about doing this to have a pen name with a pseudo anonymous identity but I also have burner emails to avoid spam.
- psd1 4y agoMy concern is leaking through browser sessions. If browser adware finds traces of two identities in a session, your secret is out. If browser fingerprinting works (it does), your secret is out.
- loteck 4y agoWhat, Slack just gets a pass?
- shadowgovt 4y agoThis has big "Society getting you down? Just go live in a cave on a mountaintop" energy. It certainly a choice an individual can make. But it will have about as much societal impact as domestic recycling has on global warming. Especially since we're talking about internet communications technologies here... The alternative to using Discord for most people these days is not corresponding with the people they need to correspond with.
- wintogreen74 4y ago"If you're on Windows click here". OS > Avoid: Windows. I get it, but not very helpful. The premise of making it "uneconomical" for a nation-state to perform mass surveillance is a bit naive; at best we can make it more expensive for our own governments to perform, which is backwards in IMO. We should make it cheap, efficient and easy to get too much garbage data.
- jevgeni 4y agoOk, so according to this, to one should EtherCalc web service for productivity. Why? What are the guarantees here that no surveilance is taking place.
- hot_gril 4y ago"Avoid PayPal, use Bitcoin." Wish it were that simple.
- Nextgrid 4y ago> Avoid PayPal, use Bitcoin. So instead of the government being able to spy on you, you want the government and anyone else capable of monitoring the blockchain to spy on you? That seems worse on all fronts.
- hot_gril 4y agoIt still seems a lot harder to track if you don't reuse addresses. The same entry did also recommend Monero. Meanwhile I purchased brandy with a credit card for the first time, in-person at a small liquor store, and immediately started seeing web ads for more brandy.
- can16358p 4y agoWhile I'd definitely want a huge win for privacy, the current (that we need to avoid) suite of tools is extremely convenient (especially the collab/social ones) and are affected by network effect. We should be aiming for a solution that is private while also convenient as the centralized ones. Otherwise even if we (HN audience) switch, many others won't and only a niche set of users will be using the private technologies and services.
- swapfile 4y ago> Otherwise even if we (HN audience) switch This is a problem. Even the HN audience seems to struggle greatly in choosing non-proprietary and privacy friendly solutions. While the amount of privacy advocates are certainly greater here than in many other places, the general sentiment I get from reading a lot of these threads is that "If you have nothing to fear, you have nothing to hide". Why do you think that is? Certainly a community like this shouldn't be bothered by the slight obstacles you would be challenged with.
- JohnFen 4y ago> the general sentiment I get from reading a lot of these threads is that "If you have nothing to fear, you have nothing to hide". > Why do you think that is? I think it's because a lot of people think that there's nothing that can be done to change the situation, and so they adopt that mental stance in order to be OK with it. Whether or not that stance is correct isn't important. It's an emotional "safe space".
- win32k 4y ago[flagged]
- maerF0x0 4y agoWho is Peng Zhong, and why should I trust their curated list of 0days err Safe bets? Also btw we should put 2021 in the title because it hasnt been updated since.
- dadrian 4y agoAlmost nothing on this list is actually positive for security, and most of the applications provided are not actually substitutes. Good luck replacing Discord with Signal.
- sundarurfriend 4y agoAgreed with the second part, but what do you mean by "Almost nothing on this list is actually positive for security"?
- doodlesdev 4y agoYeah an actual substitute to Discord would be matrix.org, not Signal.
- chillycurve 4y agoFor a better and more up-to-date list of alternatives, see https://www.privacyguides.org/en/ https://www.privacyguides.org/en/
- snowwrestler 4y agoIt has been clearly reported, but in case folks are not aware: PRISM is not a system for deep persistent access into tech platforms, it is the internal NSA designation (code name) for data sourced via FISA court orders. The FBI actually secures the court order and then requests the data. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM If a company stores data about you, it is possible it could be subject to a FISA request. Data which is end-to-end encrypted would still be provided if it satisfies the criteria in the FISA court order. But it would be up to the NSA to try to break the encryption. Metadata might or might not be encrypted.
- sdfghswe 4y agoThat's.... not as bad as originally advertised, is it?
- bdav2418 4y agoIt is important to mention that FISA requests have something like a 98% approval rate and have a history of being overly broad allowing for dragnet data collection. So PRISM does still allow for very wide sweeping data access from tech companies. But yes, end-to-end encryption is one of the few things that can help with this.
- roody15 4y agoToo late. Not to be a downer but this ship has sailed. No matter the cost governments and big business will unite in using mass surveillance to monitor and control the population. In a sense its a new feudal system enforced with complete surveillance.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y ago> No matter the cost governments and big business will unite in using mass surveillance to monitor and control the population. The cost has almost always been ~0 for gov officials performing unnecessary surveillance. I trace this low cost back to news orgs. Most editors & journalists opt out of honoring their extra constitutional protections because they don't serve as an adversary to the powerful. Instead they favor publishing sportsball or celebs or parroting gov/corp/leo pr without any analysis, etc. We don't know how officials will behave if they have to pay a persistent, meaningful cost for surveilling us. We've never tried it.
- mandmandam 4y ago> We don't know how officials will behave if they have to pay a persistent, meaningful cost for surveilling us. We've never tried it. To try that, step one would be making people aware of what's even happening. As you say, news orgs are failing us all. Assange and Snowden took Step One toward that end... And were made an international example of. The institutions and news orgs who ought to have been their main support failed, and even turned on them in most cases.
- nathanmcrae 4y agoI think pen-and-paper one-time pads are an underestimated tool for private communication. Granted they are cumbersome and limited, but they provide almost perfect secrecy and bypass issues of compromised computers completely. And with some basic steganography (section h in the guide below has a good example), you can pretty easily hide when / who you're sending a message to. 'The Complete Guide to Secure Communications with the One Time Pad Cipher' is a really good resource: https://www.amrron.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/one_time_pad.pdf https://www.amrron.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/one_time_p...
- 29athrowaway 4y agoProfiling people requires you to provide clean data. Just do not provide clean data. Search for random shit occassionally so that the entire profiling gets poisoned with fake data points.
- guywithahat 4y agoI wonder how useful even this list actually is. Famously Tucker Carlson was being spied on by the NSA through his signal app, and while I don't trust them to be able to figure out exactly what the point of entry was, it does imply without regular whistleblowers from throughout the NSA/etc, we won't know exactly what their capabilities are and I'm not sure how meaningful a list like this can be.
- milofeynman 4y agoFamously? I've never heard of that. Is that even true?
- Perceval 4y agoTucker made the claim that an internal USG whistleblower told him that his communications were being monitored by the NSA. Tucker stated that he sought the counsel of a Senator, and that the Senator told him that he should go public with the information. Tucker then discussed the claims on his television show. The NSA issued a statement saying that Tucker was not a surveillance target. Later, there was information that Tucker had been setting up an interview with Putin, and that those communications were intercepted, and Tucker's name was unmasked (when a U.S. citizen has communications picked up by the NSA, their name is redacted as part of the normal intelligence reporting, and it requires a high level official to request to see the actual name of the U.S. person). Subsequently, the NSA's internal watchdog began an investigation into whether Tucker was improperly targeted for surveillance. After investigating itself, the NSA cleared itself of any wrongdoing.
- JohnFen 4y agoThat sounds like a far cry from Carlson being spied on. More like Putin was being spied on, and Carlson walked into Putin's surveillance aura.
- SassyGrapefruit 4y agoHe meant to say "Famously Tucker Carlson claimed that the NSA spied on him". Given that the man is a bastion of journalistic and personal credibility I can't see any reason not to believe him /s
- Orangeair 4y agoI wish it would expand on some of its recommendations. It says to avoid Authy, but doesn't give any reasons. Is this just a FOSS absolutist site? That doesn't really seem to mesh with the title for me, I was expecting to see some actual info about curbing data collection.
- 93po 4y agoSame, I want to understand why I'm avoiding any of these.
- ROTMetro 4y agoI finally realize that all those weird face tattoos in futuristic scenarios were to throw off facial recognition. Who here is starting an AI defeating temporary face tattoo business?
- denton-scratch 4y agoEmail addons: Enigmail is no longer an add-on for Thunderbird; it's built-in (and has been for years).
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoI think OSS developers should adopt ethical licenses. Licenses that specify you can't use the software for a variety of use cases, such as violating human rights, or mass surveillance. Oppressors will still buy or make software for those purposes, but we don't have to hand them the tools they use to oppress us.
- Kwpolska 4y agoThat is against the spirit of open source. People and corporations will be wary of using such software, since someone someday may define their use as "unethical". And the "oppressors" don't care about following your license anyway.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoMy goodness! We mustn't make it hard for corporations to use the software! And if criminals will get guns one way or another, we might as well hand them out like candy, right? The purpose of an ethical source license is not to be a fool-proof fix for all unethical behavior. The purpose is to send a message that human rights violations are not okay, and to make it harder for unethical corporations/users to defend their actions. If the reason someone doesn't want to use ethical software is "someone might find my actions unethical", either they're morons or they're unethical. Ethics aren't t-shirt slogans. Human rights don't constantly change with the wind. Either you are abusing people or you aren't. If you are abusing people, then you can, you know, stop doing that. Or go find different software. Finally, licenses are contracts which are legally enforceable. If someone breaks the license, that carries the force of law. You can absolutely stop someone from using the software if they break its terms, even internationally.
- deafpolygon 4y agoRight, because people who violate human rights are going to adhere to a software license term. I can see it now, while beating the crap out of someone the panic that they'll experience when they realize the software they are trying to use has an ethical license.
- motohagiography 4y agoThe only meaningful use case for privacy tools is to use them to organize to create enough influence that you can reduce the need for privacy tools. If you aren't doing that, the tools are just tolerated by govts because they neutralize your resistance and explicitly enable mass surveillance, imo. How many Signal users are there, and why aren't there enough of us to drive the political agenda? One big problem with most privacy tools is they don't name their threat actor (it's your own governments), and using the tools doesn't translate to a vote for anyone who will do something about the problem. On top of it all, installing these tools acts as a reliable political metric for popular intelligence community approval.
- unstuck3958 4y agoSaw wallabag in there. Unfortunately, it's a paid service unless you self-host. I just finished hosting my own wallabag instance today! read.fahads.net Feel free to register. Though you won't get an activation mail, I would be happy to activate your accounts manually. Though you shouldn't probably use it for anything too serious, since I'm not an expert sysadmin.
- spokeonawheel 4y agoso they can just raise taxes?
- klntsky 4y agoSure thing, next time I'll use Thunderbird instead of Gmail, and pay with Monero instead of Paypal. I will also use Riseup instead of Google Docs.
- pizzalife 4y agoRecommending people to use Monero instead of Paypal? That is ridiculous for several reasons and makes me question their other recommendations.
- jifoxym 4y agowhat are the reasons?
- kristopolous 4y agoI've been a proponent of fuzzing - having systems that do noisy inauthentic engagement that is statistically indistinguishable. Essentially it's to give an intolerable SNR to this scraping where they have to discard their metrics as useless
- brentis 4y agoBack in my old network engineering job at MCI, there was a secret Prism project. Rumors claimed it was to optically split the fiber without introducing delay for eavesdropping. I'm sure naming is related and glad to see the initiative.
- throwawaylinux 4y agoEven mass surveillance of people who are Dangerous To Our Democracy™??
- jbm 4y agoWas feeling concerned when I read this: > Canonical’s Ubuntu is not recommended by PRISM Break because it contains Amazon ads and data leaks by default https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/10/privacy-ubuntu-1210-amazon-ads-and-data-leaks https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2012/10/privacy-ubuntu-1210-am... I clicked the link and it was from Ubuntu 12.04. This is something more than 10 years ago and has been unmaintained for years. It becomes hard to take this seriously when they make it seem like it is an ongoing issue (or do not link to a newer article if it is).
- jostiniane 4y agoYou are free to step in and help :)
- jostiniane 4y agoWe need more awareness, normies should understand we can exchange a slight inconvenience + less features some times for a middle finger to mass surveillance.
- arendtio 4y agoI like to use Thunderbird not just for e-mails, but also for RSS. When using the global inbox, you can have emails and RSS in the same list without noticing the difference. I don't have many RSS sources (11) and some have news just every other month. That way I don't have to open a separate program and when something comes up, I see it right when I read my emails. Did you know that you can use RSS to get notified when someone writes a reply to your HN comment? I love it: https://hnrss.github.io/#reply-feeds https://hnrss.github.io/#reply-feeds
- hatsune 4y ago[Privacy guides](https://www.privacyguides.org/en/ https://www.privacyguides.org/en/) is also a great site for this. Prism-break updates fairly slow unlike privacy guides. However, PG leans heavily into usability and commercial software, recommanding questionable software including 1password. Also, PG prefers updating system (so mostly non-ubuntu based) but including opensuse and arch, which has questionable risk from rapid upstream update. Overall, both sites are great info. Also they promote Brave way too much, stick to Firefox/Librewolf/Mull. That's a bad rec.