3 ms·
> I think we ought to consider a system where the Government or Fed provides the core functionality... I have been told that the Chinese government own the big
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
> I think we ought to consider a system where the Government or Fed provides the core functionality...
I have been told that the Chinese government own the big Chinese banks. Is this a good or bad thing? (Or am I mistaken?)
- Mtinie 4y agoAs a depositor, you might be better off. As an investor, I presume you’d be better off with the current situation, even when there are occasional hair cuts.
- MSFT_Edging 4y agoWhen you consider the % of people globally, or even country by country, most just need a safe place to keep their money to participate in institutions. Most don't have enough money to place bets on the stock market. When most folks(US and China) don't have spare cash to bet with, safe retail banking is incredibly important. In the US, tons of service workers take their paycheck with cashapp because so many retail offerings for low earners are notorious sharks with punishing overdraft fees and account minimums. If people in a society are required to participate in an institution, there should be options for people that are not profit motivated. Anything profit motivated will also be motivated by increased profit which in turn will cannibalize their userbase when rate of profit declines, which almost always sends many people into the woodchipper until it is corrected. This should not be the default.
- jpgvm 4y agoYou are mostly correct. The largest retail banks in China are SOEs, so called State Owned Enterprises. However while these banks are the backbone of the retail banking sector the rural banks and investment banks are increasingly more relevant when doing business in China because the state owned banks are very risk adverse and operate with gigantic capital reserves. It's an interesting system because it basically insulates the retail banking sector from any and all shenanigans however has led to explosion of risk in the private sector. China has been trying to pare back this risk and leverage of the financial sector for over 10 years but every time they start some global crisis starts and they have to stop.
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoTo be fair, they don't really want to. Lots of interest groups against it. Heaven is high and the emperor is far away, as they say.
- godzillabrennus 4y agoThe multi trillion dollar real estate bubble in China was state funded…
- jpgvm 4y agoState enabled would be a better way of looking at it. The state (well more correctly the provinces) have been incentivised to perpetuate this real estate bubble because they derive a ton of their funding through the sale of land. Actually -funding- the developers is an entirely different matter however. They are partially funded through pre-purchases of off-the-plan apartments, this is then leveraged mostly through bonds, primarily sold to said private banking sector but largely to off-shore buyers seeking high yield corporate paper. The SOEs and large Chinese banks like ICBC, BOC, HSBC and insurance/finance provides like Ping An have largely kept their distance for the last decade - in part because of that risk adversity and very large safety capital requirements that prevent them from owning such high risk debt. China -did- learn their lessons from 2008, unfortunately they have fallen victim to other ways of generating extreme financial leverage. Right now the de-leveraging is still happening, the Three Red Lines stipulations have been relaxed somewhat in the last few months to try ease up pressure on the real-estate market during global downturn but are still limiting debt expansion in the sector. I would say they have successfully staved off a crash/collapse but I would expect the real-estate market in China to enter a long period of stagnation at this point.
- opportune 4y agoI don’t want the government to get into lending because there is a lot of opportunity for corruption or really destructive populist policies. I think regular banks should do that, that’s what they’re supposed to be for, they take your deposit and lend it out so you get a nice little return. What I’m proposing is less like a full service bank and more like a lockbox or mattress where you can stuff dollars for later. You wouldn’t get interest (or if you did it would be tiny) in this system, because the money would not be lent or otherwise put to work like it is in normal banking