7 ms·
I got a job as a Waffle House server that pays $2.92 an hour
- jleyank 4y agoDo they provide health insurance and other benefits, or is that all on your dime as well? One would think that service operations truly facing a staffing shortage would be a bit more interested in rewarding their workers. Maybe it’s not as bad as they’re saying? Does the author and other people working in such places see customers going unserved and food growing cold? If not, what’s the problem from the businesses point of view? Might be bs, but: https://ca.talent.com/salary?job=mcdonalds#:~:text=The%20average%20mcdonalds%20salary%20in,up%20to%20%2432%2C994%20per%20year https://ca.talent.com/salary?job=mcdonalds#:~:text=The%20ave.... Remember that health care is provincial not employment connected.
- ghaff 4y agoAt the end of the day, staffing shortages (outside of professions requiring unique scarce skills) are always about pay. But I know I'm not--and I assume most people won't be--paying arbitrarily large amounts for the privilege of eating out, especially at some local waffle house. Which is fine. There are lots of services I would like that I'm not willing to routinely pay what it would cost me to get.
- vidanay 4y agoMy wife bought lunch for our son and his friend yesterday. $32 for a 6" sandwich, chips, a cookie, and bottled water at Subway (x2). $32 for barely better quality than a fucking Lunchable. Oh, and the POS system automatically presented a 15% tip in the payment screen. Casual dining in America is not going to survive the next five years IMO. I know we will be doing our part to no longer support the system (we already quit McD's because it is almost $40 for our family of three to eat a meal there.)
- ghaff 4y agoSubway takes the cake of mass market chains that seem like they ought to be a lot better than they are. I directionally agree with you. There are already a lot of relatively labor-intensive things in the West that even upper middle class people don't routinely have like personal drivers, chefs, and even housekeepers, or lawn care. Given demographic shifts, it wouldn't shock me if thoughtlessly eating out at fast food restaurants joined the list for a fair number of people. (More automation too though you can only do so much. Eating at home is generally going to be cheaper.)
- brodouevencode 4y agoThe Western appetite for convenience is at all time highs. QSR growth is in the double digits YoY largely driven by app prevalence w.r.t. rewards and loyalty and delivery services. There was a slight downturn after re-opening from COVID, but it is back up to nominal levels.
- UncleEntity 4y agoYou can’t print trillions of dollars and not expect prices to rise. My casual take is prices of fast food has roughly doubled since this whole inflation thing took off. And they all have universally decided in the last month that a “large” drink is what was formerly the medium drink so double the price for less meal — not sure if that’s a “healthy choice” thing or they’re just being weasels though. I’ve never once had subway try to get a tip out of me and I eat there fairly regularly, not even the “tip cup” that employees like to put out to guilt you into tipping for things like watching you use the automatic checkout robots. —edit— Oh, and McDonald’s is still semi-reasonable if you use their app (to get free stuff) and pay attention to whatever their current loss leaders are. Yeah, I eat way too much fast food…
- vidanay 4y agoIf you build an online order at the Subway website, you will see a line item for "Sandwich artist tip". In-person ordering has the same thing on the POS during checkout (like so many places do these days)
- jleyank 4y agoYet the queue at McDonalds and other fast food places here in Ontario are full. People adapt to what their situation presents. Perhaps there will be a messy transition in the US when jobs have or wish to reset their compensation? Given the currency exchange rate US/Canada (per the Economist), Big Mac's are cheaper here than down South: https://www.economist.com/big-mac-index https://www.economist.com/big-mac-index
- ghaff 4y agoAlthough there was an article from the Wall Street Journal just yesterday with data showing the sales at a lot of chains are still somewhat down. I do suspect that there are a lot of people with at least midrange incomes who will continue to eat out, even if only fast food, before they'll more seriously contemplate preparing meals at home. >Perhaps there will be a messy transition in the US when jobs have or wish to reset their compensation? I'd bet on more automation where practical and people just doing without--or doing without as often--certain things that have a large labor component.
- vidanay 4y agoAbout six months ago, Starbucks opened their THIRD store in our medium size town (~60k pop). It's a rare moment to not see a car in the drive thru line, and typically four or five cars. Crazy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TexanFeller 4y agoAlmost certainly not. Only a tiny number of similar jobs offer health care benefits. Waffle House is not a high profit place, I used to go there, they serve the blue collar crowd on a budget.
- matthewdgreen 4y agoHuge fractions of the US service industry are catastrophically understaffed right now, to the point where it's driving smaller businesses under. Somehow we seem to have developed a series of industries (from fast food to hotel cleaning to receptionist work) that entail a combination of low prices and labor intensiveness which is completely unsustainable when you pay people living wages. For years the labor market was weak and this worked out. Now it isn't, and many of these businesses don't make sense anymore. Presumably we could rebuild them with a more European model that's more automated and less dependent on replaceable super-cheap labor, but most likely we'll just rely on the Fed to engineer a recession.
- ghaff 4y ago>more European model that's more automated and less dependent on replaceable super-cheap labor You see plenty of fairly obviously immigrants cleaning hotel rooms in Europe. To some degree, higher labor costs can also drive efficiencies with no real harm to consumers. I'm perfectly fine with (and may even prefer) a weekly "serviced apartment" sort of hotel model rather than daily room cleanings which invariably happen when I'm on a call or something.
- brodouevencode 4y agoGoing to assume that you have some level of price increase in mind that would not be considered a harm to consumers. What would that be?
- ghaff 4y agoI had no level of price increase in mind. (Obviously any increase has some harm at the margin.) Rather, I'm saying that certain services that cost money to provide--especially given higher labor costs--like daily room cleaning don't deliver much value, if any, to many consumers. Pre-pandemic some chains would even let you opt out in exchange for some points.
- brodouevencode 4y ago
- danielvf 4y agoLooked up a Waffle House job listing in the Deep South. Looks like the answer is yes on health insurance: Server Requirements: · Entry level, no experience required · Must have a positive and friendly attitude · Teens welcome but must be 16 years old + Benefits: · Dental insurance · Employee discount · Health insurance · Paid time off · Vision insurance https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Waffle-House/jobs?jk=a214a1778ba9cbb9&q=&l=South%20Carolina&start=0 https://www.indeed.com/cmp/Waffle-House/jobs?jk=a214a1778ba9...
- hackeraccount 4y agoThat's insane that they provide insurance ; it give you an idea of just how tight the labor market is in the U.S. Around where I live the starting salary at McDonald's is $15. Maybe this is inflation but that's a crazy amount of money.
- xref 4y agoCrazy on the low side? As I’ve seen quite a bit higher for just fast food line workers. Shift managers were advertising $25.50/hr
- hackeraccount 4y agoI'm saying crazy high. I don't know though - I don't really have a feel for it because of inflation but I have a teenage child making $20 an hour at a summer job and while they (because teenager) complain about being underpaid it seems to me like they're doing pretty OK.
- nickstewart 4y agoWhy is the author including the commute and taxes in the final figure? I mean doesn't the apply to pretty much everyone?
- tapland 4y agoThey are pointing out that the wage is so low it's net zero and any money made is from tips
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey’re also adding in a one time cost for shoes in their calculations on 8.5 (IIRC) shifts to come up with their low number. Shoes which should last a few hundred shifts minimum. And are tax deductible if you itemize. Also the food credit is only a loss if you don’t use it, it’s a net gain if you get the maximum amount of food because I highly doubt it’s capped at $3.whatever. Bad math is just bad math.
- jleyank 4y agoThey apply everywhere, but for a job to be economically useful to its occupant it has to be a net gain in wealth.
- boringg 4y agoYah but you choose a job and its commute time etc. Those are individual choices that arent the responsibility of a commuter. Its like saying i make 100k in new york but i commute to new york by airplane and thus k only make 2k a year
- blakesterz 4y ago"I make about $75 in tips, on average, during a seven-hour shift as a server at Waffle House" That headline is technically correct, but also really misleading. Also, she only pulls in about $10 an hour in tips? Does that sound really low to anyone else?
- aarondf 4y agoWaffle House customers aren't traditionally known for being big spenders.
- mdorazio 4y agoShe doesn't mention what shifts she's working. Waffle House is open 24/7 in many locations. Given this is a "side gig" for her, there's a good chance she's working slow shifts.
- 100721 4y agoI don't see how the headline is misleading at all. Tips are not part of your pay, and only in America is it seen that way.
- HelloMcFly 4y agoIt's not just some quirky viewpoint in America, it's built into our labor laws. The $2.92/hour is the rate that Waffle House pays her provided she makes (and reports) enough tips to exceed or equal either the higher of the federal/state minimum or a higher agreed rate. At the moment I can't recall whether this calculation is per pay period or per shift though. Requisite disclaimer: I'm do not support tipping as a primary means of paying for labor. I'd love to outlaw the practice, not the least of which because it's highly discriminatory.
- wil421 4y agoThat sounds extremely low. During the Great Recession I worked at Chili’s bar and grill and made similar amounts on a 4-5 hour weeknight shift. I know people who worked at Waffle House and made decent money for a 20 year old server. A lot of them switched to normal hour restaurants due to Waffle House hours. $75 a shift sounds very low, it must be a slow Waffle House.
- flippinburgers 4y agoFrankly one of my most enjoyed jobs was working as a waiter once I got used to it. I was working at a high end restaurant where some wait staff were making $45K+ a year so not perhaps the same situation. There was definitely a sense of satisfaction not just from serving but also taking a moment to rest after moving your body for a four hour shift. Believe it or not it was a bit of a workout.
- hackeraccount 4y agoI worked at a crap restaurant when I was in H.S. and ... I actually really liked it. The people (who were all over the map - crazy, sane, fun, boring, good, bad - just everything ), the work (which was that tedious physicality that you can just do totally spaced out) and everything that went with it. It didn't have the same kind of sanctification as the work I do now but it also lacked the level of frustration I get now. Note that unlike flippinburgers I was working in the back - way back.
- hkt 4y agoThe (american) thing of paying pittance to waiters because they get tips is weird. Why do people think this is OK? (Apart from the obvious justifications of people who pay virtually nothing for labour)
- revscat 4y ago[flagged]
- komali2 4y agoThose Americans who think this is ok and therefore allow the practice to continue have the following justifications: 1. It's been this way for a while, and change is bad 2. If restaurants were forced to increase wages, prices of food would go up 3. Service workers like waiters are less-than, and don't deserve to make that much money 4. There are restaurants that pay well on top of tips: all the servers who don't like working at the bad paying restaurants can just leave their jobs and go work there 5. The only way to motivate good service is to extract it at the threat of poverty. American tipping culture thus extracts excellent service. 6. If the restaurants have to pay more, they'll instead fire workers, and make the remainders worker harder and more hours These are points I've been told in person by actual Americans, so I don't think "strawman" is a valid accusation here. I have my personal feelings about each one: 1. changing bad things to good, is good 2. Price of food may go up, but that's ok if it means workers get paid fair wages. If the prices go too high presumably people won't go to those restaurants, and the restaurant will bring prices back down. I do personally believe though that many restaurant owners will be willing to stick to too-high prices to the death of the restaurant rather than cut their own personal profits of the place. That's also ok with me though. 3. Every person deserve a living wage. 4. There aren't enough of the magical good-paying jobs, especially not local to current ones. 5. Money is actually a poor motivator, as any sales team lead would tell you. Also, it's unethical to try to extract labor at the knife-point of poverty. Also, people are nice to me in countries that don't have tipping culture, probably because I'm nice to them, so it's not a truism that people only work hard if you dangle the carrot of a tip in front of them. 6. This is almost certainly true, but it's not a reason to not force restaurants to pay more. Other labor protections should also be implemented.
- 4y ago
- mdorazio 4y ago> When I added that to my tips it came to a little over $660 — or $12.24 an hour. Author then deducts all the things that apply to every job - taxes, commuting, etc. and concludes she makes a take-home $9/hour, which is still above federal (and North Carolina where she is working) minimum wage. Of course, living wage is much higher than that in Asheville where I believe she lives [1]. And to those wondering, yes Waffle House does offer insurance and a few other benefits [2]. [1] https://www.citizen-times.com/story/news/2023/03/02/asheville-buncombe-living-wage-shoots-to-20-10-an-hour/69960244007/ https://www.citizen-times.com/story/news/2023/03/02/ashevill... [2] https://www.wafflehouse.com/careers/ https://www.wafflehouse.com/careers/
- Macha 4y agoCommuting is a basically fixed cost from "I'm driving to mcdonalds for my 4 hour shift" to "$500k/yr FAANG dev", so is it not worth pointing out that that's a much higher proportion of low wages? Nor am I charged for my top of the line macbook pro, despite it costing many times more than the work shoes in this low paid jobs.
- LeanderK 4y agocommuting should definitely be factored in. You don't commute for fun, you only commute for the job. It's an expense that occurs every time you work and, as you said, a fixed cost that becomes more important the lower paying your job is. In the end, it's what you take home and that's what the article is about.
- prepend 4y agoIt’s funny that people still don’t understand taxes and any time I see someone complaining about “take home” being below minimum wage, I tune out. There’s no way to legislate minimum take home pay. I feel empathy for people making this discovery for the first, or tenth time. But waiter jobs in general pay pretty low and the minimum wage for server jobs is harder to compare because of the tips aspect.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI've never understood why anyone talks about their pre-tax/cost earnings. We should compare the amount that hits our bank account, not the top line item on paystubs, because that's the amount we actually have available to spend. Not looking at true take home pay is how gig driving companies are able to get drivers even though the pay is absolutely shit after accounting for taxes plus wear and tear/gas costs.
- wand3r 4y agoTipping should be illegal but short of that it should NOT be a component of wages factored into minimum wage like this. The proliferation of square and other POS systems has normalized tipping in new sectors and significantly increased the percentage with presets like 18.5, 20 and 25 as default. If Waffle House can't hire employees at a price point the market demands then it shouldnt operate. The restaurant model makes no sense when customers subsidize the wages of employees directly.
- zahma 4y agoI have seen the proliferation of these POSs, but I never assumed they meant total tips have gone up. How do you know that total tips have gone up across the board?
- ghaff 4y agoI don't have any data but it seems logical to assume that shoving a default 18% tip in people's faces on a POS device means that some people tip when they otherwise wouldn't or would just drop some change in a jar.
- beepbooptheory 4y ago20% is pretty baseline right? Those presets make sense to me. And while it is indeed factored into minimum wage like this, don't you mean to say: "Not* tipping should be illegal"? Like if you agree that this is all just an allocation strategy on the business side, and really it should be factored in from the beginning, it shouldn't be that much of an affront to just follow it through and give them a good tip. Not to deny this is an imperfect state of affairs, but if the complaint amounts to simply having an extra social responsibility to make sure the people who serve you get paid well, I don't see why we as individuals need to feel angry or cheated.
- wycy 4y ago15% was the baseline for a long time. It's inched its way up to 20%.
- gamesbrainiac 4y agoI really don't understand tipping culture in America. Are you required to tip? Why do restaurants not pay their staff enough to live?
- djbusby 4y agoNot required but there is social pressures. They don't have to pay, so they don't. There is a nearly endless supply of folk willing to take the job.
- hotpotamus 4y agoIt doesn't feel that endless any more though, does it? It's sort of like Amazon doing the math and realizing they're going to burn through all the "human capital" or whatever euphemism they might use for "humans" in the labor market in certain regions because of their labor practices.
- ghaff 4y agoSome restaurants have also tried eliminating tips. The details of how tipping pools are distributed varies a bit but, in general, the servers (especially the young good looking women who research has shown get higher tips) revolt and go work something else if you disallow tips. I'm not particularly a fan of tipping culture in the US but I would note that "optional" (but not really) 10% service charges for table service is pretty common in the UK these days as well.
- Hendrikto 4y agoAs far as I understand it, the system is to not pay employees a living wage, and then guilt-trip customers into making up for that. I consider this an abhorrent system, that should not be supported.
- prepend 4y ago> I consider this an abhorrent system, that should not be supported. I agree it’s abhorrent. But we must support it by tipping. If you don’t tip, you’re not fighting the system you are harming the workers. My approach is to tip and also advocate/vote for/support businesses that don’t allow tipping and instead just pay a higher wage and they factor that wage into the food price. This is pretty rare though and even the restaurants that say “we pay our servers a wage so please don’t tip” still allow tipping so that’s not good. I’m not sure how you break this in the US unless you pass some strict law disallowing tipping. Maybe something where the advertised price is all inclusive and no add-ons are allowed, so it must include tip, taxes, service charge, whatever. I don’t see that passing.
- 20wenty 4y agoFinally, an interesting article on Insider that doesn't feel like a hit piece.
- tyingq 4y agoTips are also effectively less valuable than they were when they were mostly cash. It was VERY common to not report them (or under-report them) as income back then. Credit card tips, though, flow through to your paycheck reported income automatically.
- mqus 4y agoIf tipping is 90% of your income, isn't this a kind of tax avoidance scheme? Or are tips taxed just like normal?
- brodouevencode 4y agoYou are required by law to pay taxes on your tips. The avoidance comes when you don't report tips that, say, come in the form of cash.
- Aloha 4y agoI was pretty friendly with the servers at Waffle House - they all told me that their gross wages including tips were ~$25 an hour and they would often go home (of their own choice) if it was sufficiently slow. The servers who worked first shift at Waffle usually made good money - good enough money to pay for a house or an apartment to rent in DFW, which by my estimation takes around 20 dollars an hour. None of this is really a defense of the server wage - but seeing other customers and what they'd leave for tip, a 50% tip was not abnormal - in part because food at Waffle House is so cheap.
- brodouevencode 4y agoAround the holidays it's not uncommon to see regional news stories like "person leaves $1000 tip at Waffle House".
- jaclaz 4y agoMaybe naive question, but I haven't seen anything about the taxation on tips. From the little I understand of the US taxation, tips are in theory subject to taxes but in practice many (most?) low wage workers omit to declare them?
- ghaff 4y agoHistorically that was probably true but I assume the vast majority of tips these days are on credit cards.
- UncleEntity 4y agoThere’s some sort of formula the IRS has for a percentage of income you need to claim in tips to keep them happy. Probably isn’t as important anymore than in the 90s when I was living with a waitress who I learned this stuff from who got almost all her tip money in cash, credit card tips get reported on the payslips. As an aside, I used to watch in pure wonderment when she would do laundry or need money for something and go through her dirty clothes easily pulling a couple hundred dollars out of pockets.
- jaclaz 4y agoI hadn't thought of tips with credit/debit cards or other electronic payments, so they go to the bar/restaurant that then (when the actual money arrives in the bank) gives them back to the waiter(s), it must be some serious complication in accounting.
- alkonaut 4y agoSeriously just make it a federal law that each states minimum wage be a living wage for the living costs of the area, and disallow employers from counting tips towards wages. US workers need to stop waffling (pun intended) and demand things workers in the developed world all successfully demanded over the last century.
- alkonaut 4y agoApparently this (which to me seems obvious and completely uncontroversial) is controversial. So please enlighten me on why that is.
- lunarboy 4y agoNot directly related to the article, but I've never understood why tipping is a % of the meal price. Like yes, the service you get is loosely related to the price—I'm getting much better service at 3 star michelin than some local shop. But assuming 20% these days, is the service at a $300 vs $100 place really that much better to warrant a $40 extra in tip alone? (of course I'm using the extreme upper end example here) It should not exist at all, but even if it does, it should be based on the staff's actual service, not the all the other things that go into the price of a plate like ingredient, chef's name value, etc
- babelthuap 4y ago[flagged]
- bell-cot 4y agoReaction: Author is wearing really tight blinkers, in pursuit of a clicky headline. Multiple mentions of coworkers, but no mention of even asking about their tip income. (Let alone their strategies for encouraging better tipping. After hinting that she has zero experience at tipped serving jobs.) If she doesn't like Waffle House food well enough to eat her $3.15 meal credit every day - if only to know the menu better, and talk the food up to customers - why the heck did she apply for a Waffle House job in a tight labor market? Let alone one that's kinda distant from her home. And trying to depreciate the $28 pair of shoes over "almost 9 shifts" is laughable. [NO, I am NOT asserting that serving at Waffle House is a good job. But this article smells more like a hatchet job than an attempt at honest reporting.]
- josephd79 4y agoWaffle House charges you a meal credit even if you do not use it. Someone who works 5 days a week and 'brings' their lunch still gets charged a $100 a month for nothing? That's straight up bull shit.
- brodouevencode 4y agoPoll: does anyone (mostly in the US) tip outside of restaurants? Like valets, hotel staff, grocery store staff, etc.
- ghaff 4y agoSome. Taxis/"ride share" it's probably about the same semi-mandatory that wait staff is. Barber. Dollar bills here and there for luggage storage or other things at hotels. Sometimes a thank you gift around Christmas, e.g. for housekeeper.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoDrivers and hotel staff yes. Domestic workers and usps deliverer(my city's post is fucked and I consistently didn't receive mail before tipping) for christmas. Grocery store no. Many people "tip" their police department for the cop license plate or windshield sticker.
- brodouevencode 4y agoOne thing I've noticed about this thread: there's a lot of ideologue driven discussion based on a minimum amount of economic comprehension.
- joeman1000 4y agoWhenever an older person mentions the “labour shortage” I always make a point of telling them it’s really a *pay shortage*. Older people don’t realise that wages haven’t truly increased for a long time. Our buying power is incredibly small now. Why the hell would people want to work for peanuts? It’s very simple, but I guess others need to feel good by putting people down.