7 ms·
> residents of Appleton, Wisconsin [...] convinced their City Council to suspend their weed ordinance for the month of May. This reminds me that there are many
by kelnos 4y ago
> residents of Appleton, Wisconsin [...] convinced their City Council to suspend their weed ordinance for the month of May.
This reminds me that there are many municipalities and homeowners' associations that essentially require you to mow your lawn weekly or bi-weekly, lest your grass gets too long and they fine you, because... reasons.
It's really gross that we allow people to be such busybodies.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoNever really understood why people have lawns in the first place, no-one ever sits on them. Really shocked me when I moved to the US, people value having backyards and just don't spend time there (yeah I'm watching you commenting down on how much you use it and challenge you to actual journal how much time your family spends in there)
- throwaway894345 4y agoWe use our yard every nice day. Technically we use it every day because our dog has to go to the bathroom somewhere and it’s nice just to let him in the back yard, but most days we play outside with him and/or read and/or work outside. Coming from the suffocating city, it has been really nice to have just a bit of private green space.
- madoublet 4y agoLooks nice. Soft to walk on. Great for kids and pets. Fairly inexpensive to maintain. Never really understood why people don't like lawns TBH.
- dgacmu 4y agoIn western and more arid states they're a huge waste of water. Really depends on the climate. In other areas they're just a lost opportunity for biodiversity. Mixing in some clover or other small perennial soft small flowers can help a lot with making it both self-fertilizing and more pollinator-friendly. (We kept part of our grass for exactly that reason but it helps that we don't have to water the lawn here. With added clover I'm quite happy with it.)
- morkalork 4y agoMixing clover and other small flowering plants with grass is definitely the way to go. I can sit on the swing in my backyard and lose count of all the bumblebees and small butterflies bouncing across the lawn. What I don't understand is, is the need for huge front lawns. It's all the work with none of the benefits. Just a waste of space really. People don't use them the same way at all.
- asow92 4y ago> What I don't understand is, is the need for huge front lawns. It's all the work with none of the benefits. Just a waste of space really. People don't use them the same way at all. Have you considered that some people just like looking at it and that's enough? It's their private property after all.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoThat's not a sufficient reason to have bylaws and HOAs that enforce front lawns. Which is amazingly common.
- Tagbert 4y agoThe lawns aren’t the reason for the HOAs. The HOAs are intended to try to protect the investment value of the homes by enforcing a level of maintenance in all of the properties. Not saying they are a net good but it doesn’t start with the lawns.
- ethbr0 4y agoIn my experience there are effectively no HOAs that don't legislate lawns (and usually landscaping with them). They may not be the reason, but HOAs are absolutely the cause of outdated, environmentally unsustainable, bullshit lawn requirements.
- deleted 4y ago
- roflyear 4y agoTakes a lot of time to maintain. Or like $300/m.
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhat kind of lawn needs that, rather than 1-2 hours of mowing per month? (I'm assuming an area where grass actually fits the environment. If grass won't just grow then that's a problem that doesn't need more explanation.)
- chao- 4y agoThe HOA in the neighborhood I grew up in mandated grass from a narrow list of types, and live oak trees. That's fine for about 15 years, give or take, but then the trees start to kill the grasses below them. This wasn't a groundbreaking horticultural discovery, but the rules were written that way nonetheless. It took years for the neighborhood to convince the HOA to allow other kinds of ground cover (jasmine, frog fruit, etc.). In the mean time, people were paying yearly to resod with new grass, or have to pay fines that cost more than just paying for new sod.
- Auracle 4y agoI mean, our yard is large enough where each mowing session takes somewhere in that 1-2 hours on a riding lawn mower.
- roflyear 4y agoOnce a week at $80/w is not insane. Adds up.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIt's not insane but it sure sounds like overkill to me. That's a good bit for just mowing, and once a week is significantly more than I would expect from someone who views lawn mowing as an expensive necessity.
- 4y ago
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Fairly inexpensive to maintain. Lots of things are inexpensive when ignoring externalities.
- badpun 4y agoThe noise from all the grass mowing is really annoying (second only to leaf blowing). Fortunately, people are slowly switching to much quieter electric mowers.
- dgacmu 4y agoI'm probably not normal. We use it all the time. Probably helps that we have a playset and a trampoline and a garden back there - we were in the yard for several hours today (adults gardening, kids and their friend on trampoline). Of course, we've also eliminated half of the grass that used to be here in favor of more garden + perennial shrub/flower space, and I'd like to eliminate more over time as the kids get older, and we're the weirdos who compost and make our own mulch for the yard, etc.
- RHSman2 4y agoYou sound like me from another mother! I am 2 years into compost. I am obsessed with the concept and reality. Magical nature.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 4y agoThat's the beauty of freedom (which France helped us gain) - I don't really need to justify my yard usage to you. But I'll give you one anyway - it's a nice buffer between me and my stupid neighbors.
- brewdad 4y agoWhat does a buffer have to do with a lawn? You have chosen a lawn. At least own it.
- asow92 4y agoTo release us of our ennui, we mow and landscape our lawns. While many disagree, to others it's a status symbol and key part of the American dream. This is just how it's been since victorian times in the US. I live in upstate NY, where grass grows more or less on its own. You can have a lush lawn here without weeding or watering if that's your choice.
- hanszarkov 4y agodogs, camping out-at-home, and sledding with kids, baseball/catch. I practice my golf swing in the summer, family fun
- camhart 4y agoWe never sit on our lawn. But we play soccer on it. Have water gun fights on it. Let the kids run through the sprinklers on it, etc.
- pdntspa 4y agoThe dog (a german shepherd) uses the backyard to run literally all day long. She'd go crazy cooped up in the house. We both use it for fetch all the time. I use it to smoke since I can't do so in the house. The shade from the big tree in the center is nice for reading. Pulling weeds (they got really thick and stalky this year) and leveling the ground around the holes the dog digs helps keep me in shape. It's a nice background for a twitch show I've been thinking of doing. It's a nice space for parties. But yeah fuck off with the judging. I like space and I like living in the city.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoUnless you live in an arid area... if it's not grass ... something else is growing there. Something usually far more labour-intensive to maintain. If humans displace natural grazing animals, something has to replace them. A lawnmower. I live on 6 acres. Half of it I leave wooded. I have a small hobby vineyard. And the house and garage. The rest, well, it has to be mowed. Because I don't have sheep or goats to do it for me. Even when I lived in Toronto on a 25'x100' property, I had to mow almost weekly to keep weeds down. Yes, the lawn thing is a bit silly. But people who act like a native plant or whatever garden or landscaping is less labour intensive are fooling themselves. I've tried both. Around here, it'll fill with burrs and dandelions and pigweed and ticks and whatever in no time at all.
- jonnycomputer 4y agoIt absolutely is more labor intensive. Partly because its a regularly disturbed area without a buffer zone to protect it from new weed intrusions. I get weeds I've never seen before each year on my lawn. It's not just grazing animals btw. It's fire. Large parts of the US Southeast, for example, used to be savanna, basically grasslands interspersed by trees. Fire is necessary to maintain that, to beat back woody growth.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoThere's good evidence that indigenous people along the whole east all the way up from the SE to the NE were managing forests with deliberate fire, too. For the purpose of maize agriculture, but also by keeping underbrush at bay they encouraged open grazing areas for the deer they hunted. Also long before that, there were now-extinct species like mastodon that cleared forest floor, etc. Anyways, all that is side-ramble. The reality is that in humid temperate areas the things you replace a lawn with end up being just as much or more work. Nature is not the self-maintaining self-balancing paradise that it is often sold as. It is a world of constant intense competition (Say this in a Werner Herzog tone). If you leave ground bare, and there's water, something will grow there. That's fine in the woods. In the city, it's usually something you don't want that takes root.
- thedougd 4y ago
- munificent 4y ago> no-one ever sits on them. Doing stuff on your lawn is only part of its function. Much of the value it provides, arguably most of the value is a combination of: 1. More distance and acoustic isolation from neighbors. A larger property with a house in the middle of it separated from others by space means you hear your neighbors less and they hear you less. It makes your home a little more of a sanctuary. 2. A better view out the window. Windows and the views they afford are a critical part of the indoor experience. They provide a connection to a larger space so that the house doesn't feel claustrophobic or too artificial. A window that opens onto a calm expanse of green can make the house feel more spacious and tranquil. Now, of course, those benefits have to be weighed against the trade-offs. But, in general, people are not completely stupid and if millions of them have lawns, it's probably at least somewhat because they actually like having lawns and aren't mindless sheep manipulated by culture and nefarious HOA laws into having them.
- bluefirebrand 4y ago> More distance and acoustic isolation from neighbors. A larger property with a house in the middle of it separated from others by space means you hear your neighbors less and they hear you less. It makes your home a little more of a sanctuary. This purpose does not necessarily need to be serviced by a lawn, which is just a patch of grass. Lawns are stupid.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoAs opposed to a lawn made of asphalt?
- KMnO4 4y agoTrees, shrubs, naturalized landscape, pollinator friendly fescues, etc etc. There are lots of options.
- bluefirebrand 4y agoTrees are even better because they offer some privacy for the house and rest of your yard. I swear the back yards of suburbs are designed to be flat and open so your neighbors can always snoop on everything from their windows. Panopticon design.
- bombcar 4y agoSo lawns are literally natural in some parts of the country; you can grind the land down to dirt and it'll grow a grass and become a meadow if you do nothing; if you mow it it'll be a lawn. Those areas were instrumental in the "American Dream"-style imagery so the rest of the country imitated it, even though it's absolutely insane in some places. Also the amount yards are used varies greatly by area, and by family size.
- Sir_Vic_Smasher 4y agoI believe lawns came to the US after WWII with the returning GIs. The idea of lawns began with the French aristocracy a few hundred years ago, pre-industrialized agrarian society. The lawn and heavily manicured garden was a way to show off how rich you were. “Look at me. I’m so rich that not only can I afford to take a portion of my land and not use it to grow a crop or pasture livestock but I can afford to pay people to just grow useless grass and flowers in symmetrically shaped gardens and plant trees that get haircuts into the shapes of spheres and cones”. Yes, I participate in no mow May. And I know my golf course fairway yard neighbors judge me. Especially with all the dandelions and clover patches I let go un-mowed all year long.
- landoftheice 4y ago[dead]
- zikduruqe 4y ago>Never really understood why people have lawns in the first place It is really dumb that we spend so much time, energy and costs on something that is only visual. Imagine if people spend the same amounts on something that produced food. https://freakonomics.com/podcast/how-stupid-is-our-obsession-with-lawns/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/how-stupid-is-our-obsession...
- pfannkuchen 4y agoI’ve never seen this aspect discussed, but a lawn does look like a whole lot of baby wheat, aka food in the near future. Any chance agrarian peoples developed an instinct to consider baby grain specifically attractive and perhaps comforting?
- cafard 4y agoI am too old for most of the activities I will list, but in my childhood our lawn (we had a double lot) served for kickball whiffle ball touch football tag hide-and-go-seek "Mother, may I?" throwing baseballs, softballs, footballs the neighbor's teenage son practicing his golf swing with a plastic ball
- guepe 4y agoThere is a strong advantage to regular mowing in my area (new england): way less risk of ticks. It's a real problem a'd with kids that spends time outside, ticks can be real scary. I got a few bites on myself and once on a kid, thankfully without side effects. What is impact of more natural landscaping wrt ticks in 'ew England?
- giantg2 4y agoSimilar for mosquitoes in FL
- ethbr0 4y agoPeople are insane about lawns in Florida. Sandy soil that's so nutrient-deficient that you can't grow anything without chemical fertilizer. And then the damn St. Augustine that everyone obsesses about (a) still needs watering during the summer if it rains too little & (b) gets aggressively eaten by fungus if it rains too much. It's seemingly not uncommon for people to resod their lawn every few years. And they replant the same grass type that just died!
- rqtwteye 4y agoI remember visiting people in Vero Beach and they told me that I shouldn't step barefoot on their lawn and not let my dog on it because they sprayed it so much.
- InfamousRece 4y agoMany HOAs require a specific type of grass so they might have no choice.
- Auracle 4y agoIt’s funny to me how people have such crazy reactions to ticks. Don’t get me wrong, they can carry some scary stuff - but a few bites? I get a few bites a month during the spring and early summer, and probably take off 10x that amount before they attach. Some are deer ticks. I’ve heard of people taking ticks that were attached to the doctor. I guess my point is chances are you’ll be fine. Do what you can to prevent bites but don’t freak out about them.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoFreedom of choice and mutual consent. Everyone owning a house in a HOA signed on the dotted line. Not for me, but some people hate long grass and are willing to waive their property rights so they don't have to see it. I'm glad there is an outlet where they can do their own thing without involving me. The fact that this sometimes becomes a municipality issue is a major failing.
- hgsgm 4y agoHOA doesn't have an opt-out, and does have a monopoly on homes within a geographical area. And often nearby areas have HOAs also. And HOAs can be kept secret from home buyers until after they sign a purchase contract. So meaningful consent is often absent.
- Volundr 4y agoAnd in fact most new developments are built with HOAs already intact, meaning finding a home without an HOA is constantly becoming harder. This isn't a free market customer choice thing. The supply comes with the burden whether the customer wants it or not.
- adriand 4y agoI think having property standards is an important part of ensuring that people keep up their properties and by extension, maintain (and ideally beautify) their neighbourhoods. I can see how someone who puts the time and effort into creating an alternative to a lawn (such as a garden featuring wild species) may take issue with an ordnance that doesn't take into account alternatives to a traditional lawn, but when people don't maintain their properties and their yards are full of tall grass and weeds, or worse, tall grass, weeds, trash and dog shit (it all kind of goes together), it's unsightly.
- hgsgm 4y agoWhy would trash and dog feces go together with a meadow? The trash is obviously a problem, which can be addressed directly.
- wkdneidbwf 4y agothere’s definitely a difference between a meadow (and the suburban front yard conversion thereof) and an unkempt traditional grass lawn. the latter suggests a resident that doesn’t keep up their property.
- hgsgm 4y agoYour prejudice shouldn't be my problem.
- floatrock 4y agoBecause by lumping them together, the pearl-clutchers create an association between people who go for alternative lawns with degenerates who leave dog feces lying around. We've been suggesting The Others are dirty, unkempt, and irresponsible in order to ostracize them since the dawn of protectionism.
- mattnewton 4y ago> it's unsightly. Personally I think the burden of unsightly-ness is usually far overblown. I just don’t think it’s that big of a deal if my neighbors don’t maintain their lawn as long as it doesn’t spill into mine.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoLong grass encourages insects which encourages rodents which encourages snakes. Also, grassses tend not to survive the summers here, so there's an increased fire risk which is probably not then covered by my insurance policy as it would arguably be negligence. I left my back yard go one spring, my partner wouldn't go out there sue to snake risk, grass was over 5ft. It's now back to something approximating the standards implied by the surrounding houses. Launceston, Tasmania.
- WheatMillington 4y agoHoA areas are voluntary, you don't have to live in them. I wish we had that kind of thing in New Zealand that I could voluntarily buy into. I don't see anything wrong with having high standards where you live.
- pavon 4y agoFor most of the west coast it is only voluntary if you are in the 1% who are rich enough to be selective about housing. The rest are lucky to find someplace they can afford that is within reasonable distance to their jobs at all, and all new development is covered by HOAs so the already small percentage of housing not covered by HOA decreases every year.