13 ms·
An end to pop?
- biscuits1 4y agoJim Morission accurately predicted "the machines" or "single person" in this context. I've also been reading more on Bob Moog, as one of those first engineers to birth the liminal device. What Seth says here is a bit more dramatic, but its a natural evolution to information access, tech, and single author productions. In fact, really this is the next step, where the single person is no one, its scaled "nobody" based on mixed IP.
- 52-6F-62 4y agoA lot of confidence in such predictions with zero precedence... I think a lot of people will think AI is their meal ticket to pop stardom. I think they misunderstand how the music industry has operated: it's a club. There are hundreds of thousands of 'brands' and 'stars' out there with no dedicated following but enough money to pump themselves into the image of stardom. There's a difference between looking like you're impacting lives, and actually impacting lives. Like there's a difference between a machine-generated image of a mountain on a computer screen, and standing in front of a mountain.
- jhbadger 4y agoIs there a difference in practice? Don't a lot of celebrities get pictures of themselves "helping" people after a natural disaster or something when in reality they were there for not much more than the photo session?
- nextworddev 4y agoAI is fundamentally deflationary. That's due to simple rules of supply / demand. Our demand is pretty constant. We can't simply consume any more software or content than we do now. But with AI, supply is going to get jacked maybe another 5x-50x. That's great news as a hobby content creator, but for professionals it just means much stiffer competition for smaller rewards. Same applies to Software. It has become pretty trivial to reverse engineer any software with AI now, except for the best in class AI models. All of this is probably bearish for most AI startups' hopes for hitting it big. Just too much supply of software.
- nsxwolf 4y agoExamples of trivial AI reverse engineering? Are people like, just cloning things like Adobe Premiere overnight and undercutting Adobe?
- ultra_nick 4y agoYes, in the same way automatic checkout has replaced humans.
- asynchronous 4y agoGonna go ahead and say there literally isn’t unless you’re counting a small increase in programmer efficiency over using tutorials/blogs/stack overflow.
- skinnymuch 4y agoWhat is being reverse engineering triviallyv
- shampto3 4y agoI don’t agree with this. Sure, maybe AI will start producing some hit songs but I don’t see it ending pop music as we know it. Fans of popstars are not just fans of the music, but of the persona. Do you think Taylor Swift would have as much success if she were just a computer writing emotionally charged songs? I don’t think so, because the appeal of those songs is that the listener feels like they get to know a real person.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoAre there even pop-stars now? Seth is right, stars in the previous century were known by everyone. Even the old-timers knew (and loathed) that bug group that invaded the U.S. in the 1960's. For better or worse, we once had a shared cultural reference. No longer.
- shampto3 4y agoNot sure if you’re just blinded by nostalgia, but I would consider Taylor Swift one of the most well-known popstars in history. You realize that she just broke the record for most attend U.S. concert for a female performer right? Regardless, it’s not just about popstars. People like listening to music that they can connect to on a human to human level. They do also like listening to music that is just there to dance to. Both can coexist, but I don’t see people connecting with music that AI writes simply because there isn’t a persona there to connect with.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoTaylor Swift (sometime around 2008?) feels like the last pop star before we fully long-tailed into our own niches.
- skinnymuch 4y agoKanye West, Drake, The Weeknd peaks anre after 2008. Adele could be in there. Justin Bieber and One Direction were her contemporary starting. While peaking after her. BTS is possibly on track to be bigger than Taylor Swift’s highest peak I follow a bit of indie music but that’s about it personally.
- sfpotter 4y agoWhat do people get out of reading Seth Godin's blog posts? Genuinely curious. It's a blog post with 9 "paragraphs". The number of "sentences" in each "paragraph": 2, 1, 2, 2, 1, 5, 2, 3, 2. Many of the "sentences" aren't actually sentences but are just sentence fragments. The post consists purely of vague assertions and observations, which aren't researched, aren't argued meaningfully, and don't seem very insightful. Do people just enjoy the nostalgia of reading a popular blog from way back and the feeling it gave them when this kind of thing was novel and exciting?
- operatingthetan 4y agoIt's reading candy in the purest form. I got to the end and wondered what the point was? Things change? Okay, where's the marketing insight Seth?
- tgv 4y agoHere it is: > PS my friend Paige has a new book out.
- operatingthetan 4y agoWow, they are putting out a blog series called "SEO for rookies" in 2023...
- biscuits1 4y agoIt's a natural progression of his writing style. It's reductive romantic style, tuned for virality in a sea of endless info. Of course, its shallow, but this one invites conversion of an observation that is quite impactful. I thought it was well done for a general audience, and probably some target to an aging generation. No one around me listens to McCarthy, and if they do its all regression.
- moritzwarhier 4y agoEven without any knowledge about the author and without having read TFA, the comment exchange of you both makes for a satisfying and interesting read. I'm not sure if this can be shoehorned as "curiosity", but it dangerously touches on a meta level that HN has historically been keen to avoid (as opposed to other, more common social media platforms) This is not meant as a critique of our comments, just a self-observation.
- babyshake 4y agoOne thing I would be interested to see would be a new type of instrument that takes advantage of foundation models in a way that results in a user experience that is considerably more difficult than a toy guitar with a few buttons, but considerably easier than actually playing your favorite songs on the guitar. Even better if it can be used for a type of sound that is unique and can't be replicated on more traditional instruments.
- HKH2 4y agoWe already have synthesizers.
- theK 4y agoI think the doom and gloom about the arts dying by generative Ai is a bit overblown. Yes, generative Ais can significantly outproduce humanity in the arts, sure. But in the end it’s never only about the final piece of music/canvas/etc it is about the person that did it. I am very certain that when the output loses its value due to endless supply, as the article fears, we will return to other more human values in order to judge what we like
- cubefox 4y agoThe article isn't doom and gloom at all, it just predicts what will happen, not that it is bad. It sounds rather positive.
- HKH2 4y agoThe GP seems to agree with you. How can you construe the second paragraph as being negative?
- HKH2 4y ago> But in the end it’s never only about the final piece of music/canvas/etc it is about the person that did it. Nope. Good art stands on its own merits. The only useful thing about knowing who did it is that you can find more of it. > I am very certain that when the output loses its value due to endless supply, as the article fears, we will return to other more human values in order to judge what we like Wonderful. The less attention that people give to celebrities, the better.
- jaxboxer 4y agoOf course it is totally overblown. People have been saying "art is dead" for 150 years+. This is just the latest iteration of "art is dead". "This time it is different". As if no one has ever said that before. Marble sculpture had its time as the dominant medium of the day. These articles are no different than lamenting the demise of marble sculpture.
- mjr00 4y ago50,000 new songs are uploaded to Spotify every day. On Soundcloud, it's over 120,000 per day. Is Seth not aware that people were already making lots of music, and that more music is released beyond Drake and The Weeknd...? There is already "too much" content to consume, for some definition of too much. If AI-assisted music creation boosts the number of songs on Spotify from 50,000 to 500,000 per day -- does it really matter? If you're an artist who doesn't have a fanbase, you're currently releasing music into the void, and you would be in a world of AI-generated music spam, too. Making a popular pop song is 10% about the song itself and 90% a combination of marketing and luck. AI isn't going to change this. Thinking that people are going to stop listening to Nicki Minaj or Taylor Swift because other music exists is, frankly, really stupid.
- mlyle 4y agoAI might instead significantly increase the quality of the lower 80th percentile of those 50,000 songs, though, which is a different thing. In turn, that could widen the long tail of what people are interested in a lot.
- nluken 4y ago... or it will homogenize that lower 80th percentile (which needs to do something out of the ordinary to stand out) and decrease interest in it even more.
- checkyoursudo 4y agoAs AI becomes the largest producer and consumer of all new content, eventually the median song will just be 440 Hz for 2.5 minutes.
- mjr00 4y agoThere's already a ton of really, really good music in that 80th percentile, that barely ever gets heard. Some of my favorite songs ever have like 10,000 plays on Soundcloud. Lack of quality is not the reason that bottom 80th percentile doesn't get heard (or the converse: it's not the reason that most people don't listen to that bottom 80th percentile).
- cubefox 4y agoWe already see a lot of this "rise of the long tail", even without AI. Through the rise of individualized music streaming and the demise of the relatively few radio and music TV stations, there is much more fragmentation now than before the Web. This trend will only be further amplified by a surge of AI enhanced music, as Seth Godin argues. And after that, fully AI generated music will be the final nail in the coffin of Pop. Everything will be highly individualized. We may still occasionally have songs going viral, but those will be only short flashes of popularity, nothing that lasts for weeks or even months, and they will be forgotten quickly, lost in the flood.
- Thlom 4y agoIn this future, what is the point of music at all? Music used to be a communal thing. First it was songs around the camp fire, slave music, clubs. We have always experienced music together. Even after Spotify we have shared our favorite songs and playlists. We still go to concerts. But if no one has the same frame of reference anymore and all music is atomized and personalized. And nothing means anything anymore. What’s the point? Just background noise?
- cubefox 4y agoYeah, I think increased fragmentation already has significantly moved music from the communal aspect to the pleasant noise aspect.
- HKH2 4y ago> We have always experienced music together. That hasn't been true since at least gramophones. > And nothing means anything anymore. What’s the point? Just background noise? I'm gathering that you generally don't listen to purely instrumental music. Ultimately the beauty in harmonies or a certain rhythm etc. is ineffable (you judge words and lyrics with another part of your brain). Can you enjoy visual art without sharing it? Can you enjoy food without sharing it?
- HKH2 4y ago> We may still occasionally have songs going viral, but those will be only short flashes of popularity, nothing that lasts for weeks or even months, and they will be forgotten quickly, lost in the flood. Good. The latest is not necessarily the best, and there is plenty of lost treasure just waiting to be found.
- jzb 4y agoInteresting - I used exactly this example (AI used to give recent McCartney music his young voice) not very long ago. While there are a lot of applications of this technology that make me uncomfortable, I'd love to see this used in this way. McCartney's last album suffered a bit because of his voice, IMO, and I'd love to hear it re-cut using this technology. (There's another conversation about whether Sir Paul should be leaning into his current voice and writing material that's better suited for it, but... in a world where we've got ample autotune and other vocal effects being deployed for younger artists, I don't see any harm in giving McCartney's voice a boost with technology too.)
- williamcotton 4y agoNone of this affects live music. All I’m really interested in is live music, be it playing or listening. There is no dearth of gigs for solo musicians playing music for wineries, breweries, restaurants, weddings, etc, and especially here in Texas!
- cubefox 4y agoWe already seen a lot of AI generated art recently. But these were just pictures. What about AI generated music? There are substantial differences between music and pictures: - For artistic pictures there is no pop. They do not have nearly the same popularity as music. - Music follows changing fashions and even progress of some sort. Each time period (e.g. decade) comes with distinctive music styles, and while there are some revivals, usually they do not repeat. Artistic pictures are much more static in comparison, at least in the last few decades. Pictures are influenced by available tools (e.g. Photoshop and graphic tablets), but a painting today doesn't look markedly different from a painting 30 years ago. Since music follows fashions, just imitating past music genres may not be as popular as it is popular to imitate existing art styles with Stable Diffusion and Midjourney. But imitation is exactly what current generative models do. Which may ultimately limit the popularity of fully AI generated songs created by amateurs. Musicians may still have an edge by using AI tools to create new music styles.
- bazeblackwood 4y agoWhile I agree that art has become more static since the dawn of the internet, the same can definitely be said about music, particularly pop music, which hasn't advanced significantly since the 2000s. However in various corners, sampling and synthesis have advanced by leaps and strides over the past decade. Also if you're just limiting visual art to painting, I think you're skipping over an entire era of installation-based and generative art (not necessarily machine learning-based) that has only recently flourished. And just to touch on your first point, "pop art" has been a term since the 50s. It overlaps pretty significantly with the visual style of comic books, which are most prominent in animated features and video games today. Corporate art similarly has its own style (think those flat diverse figures with bright colors). I'm not even sure how one would start to compare the relative "popularity" of these two domains, let alone determine that "music" is more popular than "art".
- cubefox 4y agoHm... Regarding the last sentence: Many people pay for Spotify, and in the past they paid even more for records and CDs, but people rarely pay for pictures, if ever. Maybe once to decorate their new flat. People also go to concerts of their favorite musicians, while they basically never visit art exhibitions.
- nluken 4y agoGenuinely confused how people think AI will "democratize" music by allowing people to "create without a gatekeeper". What exactly does this mean? Music has already been democratized. You don't need a label to release music and build a following anymore. Mainstream acts like Radiohead and Chance the Rapper have proven this over and over again. The catch here is that you need to do something new and original to attract a following that way. Training a computer to generate a Drake song (or imitate McCartney's voice) doesn't empower new artists like AI evangelists think it does. If UMG can pay someone else to copy Drake's flow and release a new Drake track for 1/10 the cost, that isn't "democratizing" artistry, it's extricating the artist from the art altogether. If you do want the support of a label for your own work, you need to meet the right people. AI-generated music doesn't change that. The only "gates" these people want to get by are ones put up by practicing music enough to make something novel. AI might be useful as a tool to assist actual musicians in their processes, but in my experience the musicians that create interesting music do so because they have a strong vision, not because they're exceptionally technically proficient.
- steppi 4y agoA Radiohead album is an incredibly sophisticated feat of audio engineering requiring a team of people beyond the band itself to make. The production costs are substantial. It takes more than just practicing enough to make something like that. If AI gets to the point where I can record something in my bedroom with similar production values, I’d count that as democratization.
- dmbche 4y agoWhat do you think the AI could do that you couldn't by searching the web? And is the difference between the hypothetical bedroom-produced version of the same Radiohead album and the actual album actually that noticeable? I work in film/video, and you definitely can produce something that would have cost millions of dollars 10 years ago by yourself, with minimal costs. I struggle to compare the scale of engineering needed to make albums versus movies.
- 4y ago
- gumby 4y agoCurrent pop music is the result of an industrial process (teams of writers, complex recording and post processing, and of course, focus groups all along the way) so a transformer system just automates some of that. The process is rather fascinating, actually, though personally I find the output mostly pretty dull. I don’t know about “democratization” — what incentive is there for someone to make that kind of stuff at home? Once upon a time you could imagine being found like, say, Bieber or Elvis, but if the factories can pump that stuff out easily, the commercial sphere will be fully populated, as with other industrial consumer products like breakfast cereal (how much cereal is sold at Farmer’s markets?). Homemade music will remain what it has always been — fun.
- skinnymuch 4y agoThere’s tons of small changes AI will be able to do to make albums sound better. Many indie artists will continue to stay clean but many will embrace AI. Tech always ends up getting used. Using AI as a supplement isn’t overall being mainstream or conformist.
- chasing 4y agoHis first sentence is wrong. Pop culture absolutely exists, even today when anyone can basically put any kind of media they want up online.
- precompute 4y agoPop(ular) music will never go out of fashion, AI or not. Also, like 80% of whatever Seth Godin writes is crap. The rest is barely passable.
- deafpolygon 4y agoUnder OP's definition, pop has gone out of fashion years ago.
- EyeSayUntoThee 4y agoI think it's rather the opposite. Those tools are controlled by large capital, at the level of being capable of wowing people with cutting-edge realistic content. I predict a renewed interest in human scale art and culture and socialization. The lines for the toilet at the worlds biggest party are surely long...
- flipcoder 4y agoAI music will be cool for 10 minutes and then you realize one of the reasons you listen to music is about shared human experience. If it’s just a generated blip that everyone is generating and resharing it’ll eventually have the same appeal as blogspam. AI music will cause people to go back to seeking out performed music played on instruments or in a live setting. You'll have music sites that only allow music that has videos of humans playing/creating it. Every AI action will have an equal but opposite human reaction.