6 ms·
Orbital Mechanics
- belter 4y ago8 years ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10345734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10345734
- dang 4y agoThanks! Macroexpanded: Basics of Space Flight: Orbital Mechanics - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10345734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10345734 - Oct 2015 (57 comments) Orbital Mechanics - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6228016 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6228016 - Aug 2013 (1 comment)
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoIf you want to learn orbital mechanics, just play KSP.
- loloquwowndueo 4y agoBetter to not say “just” - from HN front page https://justsimply.dev/ https://justsimply.dev/
- NotYourLawyer 4y agoNo this really is a “just.”
- lucgommans 4y agoNot for me at least (though I think loloquwowndueo was mostly joking)
- wongarsu 4y agoThen how about: One common way to learn orbital mechanics is playing ksp. For this you need to [buy a computer] [purchase and install the game] and [do the tutorial]. For maximum enjoyment it is recommended to watch [Scott Manley's playthroughs on YouTube] between sessions to deepen your understanding.
- actinium226 4y agoNice website! Dunno if you're the owner but I'd add "obvious" to your list of words to scan. Nothing's more frustrating than when the author says "and obviously [not obvious thing]" Actually this reminds me of a funny story about a math professor. He's teaching a class and is going through a proof and skips part of it, saying "I'll skip this part because it's trivial." A student comes up after class and asks about the trivial part. He tries to explain it for a few minutes, and can't quite get it, and the student has to go to her next class, so they agree to revisit the issue next class. The next day the professor tells the student "I stayed up all night working on this and can confirm that it is indeed trivial"
- misnome 4y agoThis _specific_ page was instrumental when learning orbital mechanics via playing KSP.
- teddyh 4y agohttps://xkcd.com/1356/ https://xkcd.com/1356/
- lucgommans 4y agoSort of. KSP teaches you rocket building and how precious fuel is. You need to invest a lot of time to get to the stage where you transfer between planets. You also can't just pick up the resident star, give it a whack, and see what happens to the solar system (because it's all two-body mechanics). That's what I wanted to learn about: orbital mechanics, but as a game. I could not find anything online so I built it myself. The UX is bad, I've been meaning to improve it but you know how it goes. Apologies in advance if the interface is beyond comprehension: it's not you, it's me. Default 3-body demo: https://lucgommans.nl/p/badgravity/ https://lucgommans.nl/p/badgravity/ Earth orbit: https://lucgommans.nl/p/badgravity/#b64params=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 https://lucgommans.nl/p/badgravity/#b64params=eyJ0aW1lcGVyc3... Use arrow keys to control the space craft that looks oddly similar to the letter "A". You're orbiting Earth (denoted with E) and there is also the international space station roaming around, as well as the moon if you scroll to zoom out. Try getting near the ISS or even the moon! It's tricky if you're doing this for the first time. For me, this really helped to get a feel for orbital mechanics. I never played KSP more than a few minutes on a friend's PC, but based on Juno:NewOrigins (simplerockets2) being rather similar, I don't really enjoy the engine building aspect or the aspect of constantly being out of fuel. It's more realistic obviously, but spacecraft design wasn't my goal. I wanted to understand how things in orbits affect each other and this lets you do that. You can also take control of the earth in the "bodies" menu. Set engine thrust to some giganewtons or whatever and fly the earth to a new place :). Or try some of the scenarios in the menu. Also note the simulation speed on the top left, otherwise getting to e.g. the moon takes a while.
- teraflop 4y agoThe mathematical explanations on this page will teach you lots of stuff that will be useful when playing KSP, but the reverse is much less true. Yes, KSP will help you build an intuition for orbital mechanics, but you can play it for years and never learn how to calculate something as simple as the length of an orbital period at a given altitude.
- hgsgm 4y agoI don't work for NASA, so my calculations would be useless.
- sdenton4 4y agoI find the intuition extremely helpful - without the intuition, it's hard to build a gut feeling for the interrelation and relative importance of the bits in the jargon soup for any given question - apijove vs ascending node, and so on. What works best is therefore a combination of the two: I have often found myself digging into the math when I want to get something /really working/ in KSP. You start the game by trying to keep the burning end pointing down (and eventually sideways), but the Rocket Equation forces us learn about Hohmann Transfers if we want to get anywhere interesting. (And maybe even get back again.) Notably, it's the /constraints/ that create the need to optimize, which push us from playing back to the math. The sibling commenter who doesn't like dealing with fuel misses the point: Caring about fuel pushes us to find the mathematical tools to solve our problems. Compare to Outer Wilds, which has a really fun physics simulation - you can whip around planets like a madman - but there's no real constraints on fuel, and the solar system is small enough that speed isn't really a problem, either. No constraints means no one ever has to figure out a Hohmann transfer.
- baq 4y agoIf delta V isn’t a concern, you can optimize for brachistochrone trajectories instead.
- rdlw 4y agoKSP drove me to learn those things. While attempting to reach further planets, I ended up researching specific impulse, calculating Δv, relating altitude to speed to orbital period, and so on. I even downloaded a program that calculated optimal launch windows. So yes, none of this was in the game per se, but I wouldn't have done any of it if it wasn't for the game. The median person has exactly zero use for orbital mechanics, and KSP is about as close as it gets to a practical application unless you work at a space agency.
- HelloNurse 4y agoIf you want to play KSP, learn orbital mechanics. Seriously, understanding dynamics and other basic physics in depth never hurt anyone, while real use of orbital calculations is much rarer than playing games, writing SF and so on.
- z3t4 4y agoI think I used this site or a similar one when learning KSP - learning is easy when you make it fun.
- moffkalast 4y agoThen you install Principia and realize that everything you know is a lie and it's all about N times more complicated.
- actinium226 4y ago> is a lie I think the word you're looking for is "useful model" :D
- antegamisou 4y agoThis type of learning material, lacking any desperate 'ELI5' oversimplifications and laying out the proper amount definitions and equations without having to resort to fancy animations to keep the -quite often indolent- reader engaged, is unfortunately scarce in today's web, as is evident from the website's layout. Here are two favorite readings for anyone willing to delve more into the subject: Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students by Howard D. Curtis https://www.amazon.com/Orbital-Mechanics-Engineering-Students-Aerospace/dp/0080977472 https://www.amazon.com/Orbital-Mechanics-Engineering-Student... Fundamentals of Astrodynamics (aka BMW) by Roger R. Bate, Donald D. Mueller, Jerry E. White, William W. Saylor https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Astrodynamics-Second-Dover-Physics/dp/0486497046 https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Astrodynamics-Second-Dov... Another great textbook as suggested by musgravepeter in the comments is Fundamentals of Astrodynamics and Applications by David A. Vallado, Wayne D. McClain https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Astrodynamics-Applications-David-Vallado/dp/1881883140 https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Astrodynamics-Applicatio...
- sritchie 4y agoBetter yet, keep proper definitions and equations and then drive interesting animations from "real deal" code! I've been working for a couple of years on a computer algebra system written in Clojure (named "Emmy") designed for writing this like. It's a port of Gerald Sussman's scmutils library, plugged in to a bunch of modern graphics libraries. Here are a few examples, shamefully lacking exposition since much of this is JUST working and I was powering through demos for a talk: - particle in a quartic potential well: https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/quartic_well.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... - Phase Portrait of the Pendulum: https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/phase_portrait.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... - Colin's torus geodesics: https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/toroid.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... - Taylor Series https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/taylor_series.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... - (p, q) torus knot: https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/pq_knot.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... - Dual Number Visualization: https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/talk.html https://sritchie.github.io/clojure-conj-2023/notebooks/conj/... I'd love a textbook like the one you link above with figures that feel almost like Kerbal games, powered by the real code in the book that is ALSO generating the math you see. See https://github.com/mentat-collective/emmy https://github.com/mentat-collective/emmy for more information if this is interesting.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoWhen I saw the reference to conic sections right from the start I felt a familiar cloud settling over my mind. Without telling me how orbiting bodies (or the Solar System as an example) are like a cone, I find even the mention of conic sections to be tangential at best (perhaps distracting at worst?). I got off the rails a bit staring at the diagram. A circle is of course a very specific case of an ellipse — seems off-topic to even include that specificity except for the fact that everyone does include it in a conic section diagram. A parabola looks like another very-much edge case where the slice has to be exactly parallel to a line running the length of the cone. Not as steep and it is instead a very long ellipse. Steeper and it stays within the cone all the way down to infinity — a hyperbola, I guess. Or is it only a hyperbola when the slice is exactly vertical? (The diagram has no response.) It looks like if I read the text some of these are explained. Maybe I'm a picture-book kind of guy. But then there are all the edge cases one can imagine if the slice goes through the very vertex of the cone. Leaving those possibilities on the table without explanation also leaves my mind wandering, probably derailed from the original intent of the discussion.... Maybe I'm overthinking it, ha ha.
- adastra22 4y agoYou are overthinking it. Conic sections are critical to the math here, and the difference between elliptical and hyperbolic orbits is the difference between capture and slingshot.
- PaulHoule 4y agoPersonally I’ve seen a privileging of geometry over algebra that leads people in the wrong direction. Who cares what you can do with a straightedge and compasss? Based on what we know now the ‘conic sections’ would better be called the ‘gravitational curves’ or something like that.
- adastra22 4y agoPeople learn in different ways. Abstract equations make no sense to me, but if I see a little picture of conic sections, it makes perfect sense to me. Because I'm a visual thinker with a strong geometric intuition. The pieces are there for the people who need it.
- agys 4y agoLove the clarity and crispness of the pixelated illustrations/graphs.
- phcreery 4y agoI wonder how they are created
- aj7 4y agohttps://spsweb.fltops.jpl.nasa.gov/portaldataops/mpg/MPG_Docs/Source%20Docs/gravity-SphericalHarmonics.pdf https://spsweb.fltops.jpl.nasa.gov/portaldataops/mpg/MPG_Doc...
- detrites 4y ago> Satellite orbits can be any of the four conic sections. This seemed to leave out something important. All "orbits" are in reality, spirals. Away, or toward things they're orbiting. Seems like it should be made clear at the outset that the ideal of an orbit as these ellipses or cones is only an idealised version of reality that is actually impossible, without additional, specific input generated to reach it.
- pdonis 4y ago> All "orbits" are in reality, spirals. Away, or toward things they're orbiting. What are you basing this on? In Newtonian gravity, which is the model used by the article in question, it's false.
- detrites 4y ago> in reality
- biorach 4y ago... well this is embarrassing
- rhn_mk1 4y agoAs long as we don't have a Perfect, True, Unified theory of gravity, I don't think you get to say that "in reality" is self-explanatory. It can reasonably mean Newtonian dynamics or relativity, or I don't know what else. Would you clarify?
- detrites 4y agoSure. Let's meet again on this site in about 7 or 8 billion years, maybe 9. I'm sure it'll become crystal clear.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThen you're confusing what the dscussion is about. All "lines" "in reality" have thickness and none are infinite. "Orbits" "in reality" are not conical sections. But they are not very useful to talk about because there is no model which describes them accurately to an arbitrary level of nitpicking. But orbits as discussed here are the the are conical sections, and that's why they are discussed: they can be modelled and predicted. The nitpicking that makes them impossible to model is deliberatly left out.
- OhNoNotAgain_99 4y ago[dead]
- fwlr 4y agoProbably the optimal way to learn orbital mechanics (n=1 it worked flawlessly for me): 1. Install KSP, try to get to orbit. Don’t overthink it, just use the base game in sandbox mode, don’t bother with science, just build something that looks good and pilot it the way you think it should work. Do a few iterations to fix problems if you think you see an obvious fix, but don’t spend too long here or drive yourself to quit in frustration. 2. Look up a guide to orbit. Scott Manley has a comforting accent and good pedagogical skills, so I recommend https://youtube.com/watch?v=F0KiePxOuuc https://youtube.com/watch?v=F0KiePxOuuc 3. Implement the guide and get to orbit. (If you did achieve orbit in step 1, compare your orbit with what the tutorial achieved and make changes to your approach if the tutorial orbit looks better to you.) Save your game once in orbit, you can try again from this position multiple times. 4. Use the in-game intercept planner / orbit planner (click on your orbit and drag the handles to plan burns and see where it takes you) to try to get to another stellar body. The Mun is a good first target. Don’t overthink it or do much research, just do what you think should work. Try a few times restarting from orbit. You may need to restart from Kerbin building a bigger launch rocket so you end up with more fuel once in orbit. Aim to get a stable orbit as close as possible to the surface to marvel at how it looks, don’t worry about landing or returning to Kerbin, that’s more advanced. Don’t drive yourself to frustration, your goal is just to familiarize yourself with common difficulties. 5. Open this linked article on orbital mechanics and implement its teachings to get to Mun orbit and then to other stellar bodies. They’re all very pretty and worth seeing up close!
- frumper 4y agoJeb’s wife made me promise to get him home. No Kerbals left behind.
- fwlr 4y agoI figured out rendezvous pretty late, some time after figuring out landing on other bodies but before returning from other bodies. I think I had five Kerbals in orbit around various planets before I decided to go rescue all of them and it was an awesome experience planning and executing the rescue missions to bring them all back home.
- 4y ago
- jmorenoamor 4y agoThis was my favourite bookmark site when I started playing KSP
- foobarbecue 4y agoI wish I could read this but it displays as white text on an off-white background on chrome for Android. Is everyone else seeing it that way?
- ivanjermakov 4y agoA lot of interesting topics are not listed there: - Interplanetary transfers[1], phasing[2], and Lambert's problem - Gravity assists - Rendezvous and launch window planning (porkchop plots) - Rocket equation, dV planning and staging [1]: https://orbital-mechanics.space/orbital-maneuvers/non-hohmann-transfers.html https://orbital-mechanics.space/orbital-maneuvers/non-hohman... [2]: https://orbital-mechanics.space/interplanetary-maneuvers/interplanetary-transfer-phasing.html https://orbital-mechanics.space/interplanetary-maneuvers/int...