7 ms·
Most people around here buy enough battery or generators to keep the power on. PG&E is way below one nine of availability this year, but the outlets inside our
by hedora 4y ago
Most people around here buy enough battery or generators to keep the power on. PG&E is way below one nine of availability this year, but the outlets inside our house are at 6 nines followed by an eight.
Granted, once the propane rationing started, a few of our neighbors lost power for extended periods of time (weeks). The phone company doesn’t maintain internet if the power is out, but there is starlink, and fiber co-ops are starting to spring up.
This is the SF Bay Area, so it’s pretty much a third world country if you measure things by quality of government services. I assume this isn’t typical for most other parts of the country.
- WalterBright 4y ago> a third world country if you measure things by quality of government services And yet Californians pay enormous taxes.
- peter422 4y agoCalifornians actually pay lower overall taxes compared to other states due to low property taxes. Also, my power in San Francisco has probably been out for no more than 6 hours over the last 10 years. I don't know how many 9s that is, but it's more than 1.
- giantg2 4y agoThis seems to indicate otherwise https://www.prudential.com/financial-education/tax-burden-by-state https://www.prudential.com/financial-education/tax-burden-by...
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoMileage varies a lot in California. A high-income single person who just bought a place is paying a lot more than an older couple who have lived in the same home for 4 decades. To critique your link based on its footnotes: > 1 Calculated based on “State Individual Income Tax Rates and Brackets for 2020” from the Tax Foundation and “Median Household Income by State: 2018 and 2019” according to the U.S. Census Bureau. What is the distribution of households in each state by marital and dependent status? > 2 Calculated based on “Property Taxes by State” from WalletHub and “Median Home Values Across the U.S.” from Experian. Various propositions in California affect actual property taxes. In the chart in your link the property tax tax burden is shown the same for California and Texas based on Median income, but the actual property tax rate in Texas is almost double that in California (at least last I checked, a couple of years ago). Housing in California has just been more expensive compared to income, which is a con in affordabilty, but a pro in net worth for property owners (especially those who have owned for a long time, and thus pay lower taxes on their primary residence). I've got nothing to say about the sales tax burden, except to wonder how much of the "per capita personal consumption expenditures" are taxable transactions, and how much aren't. I've got no clue here though.
- WalterBright 4y agoThis article disputes your claim: https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-highest-lowest-tax-burden/20494 https://wallethub.com/edu/states-with-highest-lowest-tax-bur...
- anonymouskimmer 4y ago> And yet Californians pay enormous taxes. Part of this is because California is the most populous state with a high average personal income. When talking about actual tax burden averages the best way to calculate is by dividing the total state and local taxes by the total income in the state. https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/state-and-local-tax-revenue-percentage-personal-income https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/state-and-local-t... In 2020 the total tax rate in California was 10.01% of total personal income. This put it at 37th place among the US states, and 0.52% above the US average. For the other most populous states, Texas was at 8.56%, Florida at 7.21%, and New York at 13.92%. The cheapest state was Alaska at 7.13% (with Florida the second cheapest), and the most expensive state was New York (with Hawaii the second most expensive at 13.16%). Some of this data is confounded by state revenues not being solely from taxes (or especially from personal taxes). Regardless though, California isn't that much above average, and is one of 30 states with a graduated state income tax that hits higher earners harder than lower earners, whereas 11 states have a flat tax structure.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoYour tax burden in California is also less if you are poorer. For example, you’ll pay more income tax in Alabama than California if you just make $40k/year, since AL taxes are more regressive in general.
- armatav 4y agoThat’s what causes the problems.
- andbberger 4y ago[flagged]
- zmgsabst 4y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Most third world countries don’t allow organized crime Depending on whether you mean de jure or de facto when you say “allow”, this is either not a difference or not true.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> organized crime and persistent retail theft the way SF does Those were in a single grouping. I’m currently in SE Asia: factually, they don’t allow organized retail theft akin to what I’ve seen in Seattle or SF. Their downtowns also aren’t littered with drug zombies.
- nickstinemates 4y agoI love SE Asia, spend a lot of time there. Your characterization is incredibly misleading. There's different tradeoffs between, say, Bangkok and San Francisco in terms of what is tolerated (i.e, drugs) and what isn't.
- zmgsabst 4y agoYes — my point was the narrow one: That it’s very strange that SF (and Seattle) are so much wealthier and developed, but I routinely see organized retail crime in those cities — but not in much poorer countries, who maintain a stricter social order.
- janalsncm 4y agoTo add some nuance, third world countries can be very different. Crime isn’t just a matter of “3rd world” or not (I don’t even think that’s a meaningful term). Guatemala City felt extremely dangerous even during the day. In contrast, Fez felt very safe from crime. In contrast, Singapore might be considered “3rd world” by some definitions but it is by far the safest place I’ve lived.
- sokoloff 4y ago> PG&E is way below one nine of availability this year You’ve been without utility power for two full weeks in 2023?!
- nucleardog 4y agoCan’t speak to California, but where I am in Canada (national capital region) I’ve been without power for over 14 days total in the past 12 months and we don’t have half the problems they do. There was an eight day outage, a four day outage, and a couple ~24 hour outages. Surprisingly very few short outages or brownouts or anything. I’m sitting at having utility power ~95% of the time over the past 12 months. I’d have no problem believing two weeks… or more.
- OkGoDoIt 4y agoYes. There’s been a lot of storms this spring and the wind has brought down power cables left and right. That’s in addition to whatever other crap is up that’s causing power and even occasionally gas to be shut off for days at a time. Depending on where you live in the bay area, you might’ve had a few hour long shut offs, a few day long shut off’s, or worse and that’s just this year. I personally have had almost 3 total days without power where I live in the inner sunset of San Francisco, including 6 incidents of between 1 and 5 hours, and 1 period of two whole days. I have friends elsewhere in the city who’ve had it a lot worse. I don’t personally know anyone who has had 14 days total outages, but I would absolutely believe it given what I have seen. Also my personal PG&E bill for my home of two people and a baby is over $500 a month between electric and gas. I also run a small-midsize 400 seat theater in SF Chinatown and the monthly power and gas bill for that is almost $3000 a month even though we only run events two or three days a week. It’s absolutely ridiculous.
- throwaway892238 4y agoEverybody should listen to The Dollop's episodes on PG&E. It's pretty nuts. https://www.reddit.com/r/TheDollop/comments/11e1c8u/the_dollop_572_pge_part_one/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheDollop/comments/11e1c8u/the_doll... https://www.reddit.com/r/TheDollop/comments/11kmmsk/the_dollop_573_pge_part_two/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheDollop/comments/11kmmsk/the_doll... Amazingly this is not the worst US utility company. They are all pretty horrible.
- mcculley 4y ago> Most people around here buy enough battery or generators to keep the power on. This is a surprising assertion to me. How can “most people” afford batteries and generators?
- Waterluvian 4y agoDepends on what “here” means. If it means California I’m going to guess 99% of homes don’t have battery backups.
- hedora 4y ago$50-60K is enough to buy a backup system, and not much compared to the price of a house in this area.
- toxik 4y ago$50-60K is more money than most people I know make per year.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoWhich is why "around here" is 65% renters, when "here" is San Francisco: https://thefrisc.com/sf-is-65-rental-households-but-knows-almost-nothing-about-them-585adc80c68e https://thefrisc.com/sf-is-65-rental-households-but-knows-al...
- toxik 4y agoYou mean almost half SF owns and it's incredibly expensive?
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoIf I read the criticisms correctly another 34% is homeless. But that 1% who owns can afford battery backups! :P
- danans 4y ago> This is the SF Bay Area, so it’s pretty much a third world country if you measure things by quality of government services. I assume this isn’t typical for most other parts of the country You would assume wrong. California's grid reliability statistics are actually better than the national average: Electric Utility Performance: A State-By-State Data Review https://www.citizensutilityboard.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/Electric-Utility-Performance-A-State-By-State-Data-Review_final.pdf https://www.citizensutilityboard.org/wp-content/uploads/2021... The only statistic where it falls last is "AVERAGE AMOUNT OF TIME TO RESTORE POWER PER CUSTOMER, IN MINUTES (CAIDI) WITH MAJOR EVENT DAYS" Compare the California's power reliability with West Virginia's before making any assumptions.
- armatav 4y agoPretty big miss on that particular statistic don’t you think? It’s like if your a top basketball player but you come last in movement speed.
- danans 4y agoIt is absolutely a big miss, but it's in the context of long tail events (in the magnitude of the event severity), which California by its very nature experiences more than most other large population states: relentless storms, heat waves, wildfires. Should California utilities be better at restoring power in these situations? Absolutely, and we shouldn't cut them much slack in that regard. But that doesn't mean it's a "3rd world country" situation with respect to power reliability like the GP described. The typical power problems faced in developing countries are daily power reliability problems that are due to poor grid management in normal conditions, not exceptional conditions.
- armatav 4y agoI’m from a third world country, and now live in the Bay. To give you context our place in SA was having a couple hours loadshedding a day, and here in one of the wealthiest neighborhoods our power was gone for three fucking weeks, and just yesterday was in and out three times. It’s absolutely third world country level when the weather is anything but exactly 70 degrees. You have zero idea what you’re talking about, the original guy is correct.
- hx833001 4y agoIn the Boston area, I almost never lose power, at all, ever. One hour five years ago in an ice storm was an aberration. Something is very wrong in Cali.
- blisterpeanuts 4y agoWe’re in the Boston area (west suburban town) and there are outages about every 4-5 months (Eversource). It’s quite annoying and I’m contemplating getting a whole house generator. My solar panels do nothing during an outage. Would love to get a couple of Tesla Powerwalls but too expensive and long waiting list.
- azinman2 4y agoCalifornia is a far bigger state in both population and area. Much of that area is also uninhabited, but power lines cross it. Many are quite old and not well maintained, and either start fires or are subject to other climate issues (fires, snow, high winds, etc). It’s a more challenging environment, plus PG&E is basically incompetent.