8 ms·
Deadly heat threatens the well-being of 1B people in India
- briantakita 4y agoSo we should spend the money to directly help these people?
- bwb 4y agowe should spend the money to help all humans, its already going to be bad. We need to move faster and prob manhattan project carbon removal tech
- briantakita 4y agoSo don't help these people directly but fund large projects instead?
- bwb 4y agoWhy does it need to be one thing?
- tomcam 4y agoWhat percentage of Americans’ income should go to these projects? And should we take care of our own citizens first?
- techsupporter 4y ago> should we take care of our own (American) citizens first? We should take care of the planet. We all live on it and catastrophic heat waves and extreme weather are not polite and do not respect the thick black lines we've drawn on maps. For avoidance of doubt, I am absolutely saying that if those of us who are citizens or residents of the United States, European Union (with or without the United Kingdom), Australia, Canada, Japan, and anywhere else anyone might think of needs to take a hit to our net incomes and economic circumstances in order to keep the planet habitable, I am all for it.
- tomcam 4y agoI asked for a percentage.
- throwaway049 4y agoI'm only seeing policies which seem designed to change the behaviour of the less well-off: a daily charge for driving in certain areas that is priced the same whether you are an average Joe in a compact car or millionaire in a super-car is not going to influence the latter.
- crabkin 4y agoSuch a project will take care of our citizens. Maybe not "first" because technically it takes care of ALL people first, and therefore no one is "second." The US gov would be in a unique position to do it owing of course to the pool of talent and resources it can draw from. I don't have a clue where you live, but I live in the Mountain West and the water wars are constant issue on peoples minds. Not to mention, changing climate will induce immigration. Where do you think people will immigrate if they can? If your argument is about "American's first" with falling birthrates and neoliberal supremacy and whatnot, you're going to have a whole lot of new neighbors if their climate gets worse, because America first.
- tomcam 4y agoThat’s a long answer that doesn’t address my question.
- crabkin 4y agoAddresses the second question. It's impossible to answer your first. And if you're looking for short answers to those sorts of questions, well then you should already know ;)
- tomcam 4y agoWhy should I already know? I’m not the one volunteering even more of Americans’ hard-won tax dollars to save people in other countries when we have many, many people hurting in our own country. Those in favor of taking more of my money are responsible for presenting a compelling reason to do so.
- crabkin 4y agoYou are naive if you don't think your tax dollars right now are going to a million things in a million different ways that don't benefit you, and that it's not intentional. In the end such decisions aren't made by convincing people like you or me they work in our favor or the American people's favor. I won't try to convince you. You didn't understand what I meant by "you already know" and you didn't respond to anything I said, just kept parroting your line of reasoning.
- bwb 4y agoWe should take care of earthlings first. Then we can help the creatures from Venus. I really hate them though because their flag is red.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWhat solutions are available?
- briantakita 4y agoWhat would directly help people in a heat wave on a timescale that matters to them?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoI don't know, I also don't know if 1bn people could be helped on a timescale that matters to them, hence asking. It's well outside of my area of expertise, but I'm curious.
- briantakita 4y agoHow about some tech to provide cooler living spaces for these people?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoSuch as what? The article states "Even as power plants burned more coal to provide the power needed to keep people cool, the country experienced a nationwide electricity shortage.", so AC units aren't going to solve the problem.
- lusus_naturae 4y agoIve always wondered if houses and buildings could be architected to absorb heat and use it for energy Maybe even providing heat proof shelters (like bus stops etc) every x km may help immediately. Maybe.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoHeatproof shelters aren't solving the problem. If you assume the hypothetical impact on well-being to a billion human beings, and potential deaths of 100-300 million human beings, what kind of physical scale are we looking at to shelter a billion human beings assuming one shelter every x km? It's about on a par with only equipping a large commercial airliner with a single oxygen mask. How about the materials required? The scale of manufacturing? The impact of the manufacturing on the environment? The impact of shipping and installing them on the environment? It would sooner make sense to create underground cities, but that's no small endeavour.
- vasco 4y agoI think it's more realistic to move out of areas that will be uninhabitable (edited typo) than fight nature, but that's me. Move north, escape the heat, don't buy property in coast lines or future deserts and emigrate now so your family doesn't have to deal with useless real estate or become climate refugees. Moving now is way easier than in a couple generations. Most people are worried about "the end of the world" when they should be worried about way more practical things which are much more likely.
- JimDabell 4y agoThe displacement of a billion Indians brings with it its own set of problems.
- zo1 4y agoMaybe we shouldn't have allowed 1 billion of them to accumulate in the first place in such an inhospitable area. This is yet again a direct consequence of technology advances and government meddling that has created a down-the-line humanitarian crisis by propping up unsustainable behavior. We will sadly have either a billion dead bodies, or the rest of the world incurring the cost to house an extra billion.
- briantakita 4y ago> Maybe we shouldn't have allowed 1 billion of them to accumulate in the first place in such an inhospitable area. Was the British Empire was too lenient to their subjects?
- zo1 4y agoI honestly don't get why you have to take such an extreme interpretation of my comment. Since it may not be so obvious, my main criticism was of government in general.
- eldaisfish 4y ago
- eldaisfish 4y agoQuoting the article: >But government authorities have underestimated the danger, the study found. Officials rely on a climate vulnerability assessment, designed by India’s Department of Science and Technology, that indicates a smaller percentage of the country faces high risk from climate change than the new findings suggest The Indian state's persistent denial of science and criticism will continue to cost Indians their lives. It happened during COVID and will happen again in years to come. There is a worse problem here - heat causes electric power demand to rise. No gigawatt-scale power grid anywhere on the planet has supplied increased demand through renewables. What will happen is simple - coal and gas output will increase and this is an unfortunate but vicious cycle. Carbon emissions will only make the problem worse in the short term.
- briantakita 4y agoThe Indian government is funding implementation of Dense Plasma Focus devices which harness energy from a Plasmoid. Apparently, these power generators can fit on a large truck. I wonder what the current status of this is. https://asiatimes.com/2020/07/focus-fusion-is-the-hottest-idea-in-nuclear-energy-2/ https://asiatimes.com/2020/07/focus-fusion-is-the-hottest-id...
- netsharc 4y agoThe urban legend is, the weather reports hide the actual upper temperatures (replacing them with lower temps) because the true numbers would drive more farmers to suicide... At least the fact that the heat/dryness lead to suicide is true, although I can't verify if they would give up after hearing the weather predictions or after their crops failed: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=india+hot+weather+farmer+suicides&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=india+hot+weather+farmer+suicides&... Well this was a morbid comment...
- switch007 4y agoFarmers don’t own thermometers?
- hammyhavoc 4y ago
- passwordoops 4y agoKim Stanley Robinson cutting it a little too close here... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ministry_for_the_Future https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ministry_for_the_Future
- ideashower 4y agothis was my thought as well
- CatWChainsaw 4y agoIf he's cutting it a little too close, perhaps that's because society/civilization is, too.
- panarky 4y agoI learned about the wet bulb temperature from his book. Wet bulb temperature measures heat and humidity at the same time. It's the lowest temperature that can be achieved through evaporative cooling, measured using a thermometer covered in a water-soaked cloth to simulate the cooling effect of evaporation on the surrounding air. If the wet bulb temperature stays above body temperature for a long time, you will die since there's no way to cool off. The book speculates that even when tens of millions of Indians die from the heat, that won't be enough to get nations and corporations to fix the problem. In his narrative, the only solution is a global clandestine black-ops campaign of sabotage and assassination to target the powerful individuals blocking progress to protect their own wealth.
- willmadden 4y ago“The only way to prevent this scary thing is regime change.” This narrative sounds familiar.
- panarky 4y agoBy definition. ------ regime, noun 1) a regular pattern of doing something 2) a method of rule or management 3) a system of principles, rules, or regulations 4) a governmental or social system
- PicassoCTs 4y agoIndia will turn to geo engineering i guess. Either sulfur into the atmosphere or low orbit dust rings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0273117712006746 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S02731...
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWill it? It's merely a proposed idea. There are uncertainties: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injection#Uncertainties https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio...
- plainOldText 4y agoAs well as other possible side effects such as: ozone depletion, stratospheric temperature change, deposition and acid rain, effects on crop yields, etc. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injection#Other_possible_side_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stratospheric_aerosol_injectio...
- yogthos 4y agoCountries will obviously start taking risks with uncertainties when it becomes certain that they risk destruction due to rising heat.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoIs that obvious? The proposed method has the possible side effect of ozone depletion. Increasing UV creates a whole new set of problems.
- yogthos 4y agoPretty obvious that if a billion people finds themselves in the conditions that the article describes they will take drastic measures.
- known 4y ago[dead]
- v3ss0n 4y agoIts a lot worse here in Myanmar (Burma). Due to On-Going War and revolution against Coup ,junta cut of power just to starve revolution supporters to death. Yesterday 3 died due to heatstroke near us. Now very hard for business: 12 hours a day power outage even in cities like Yangon (Rangoon) . 2 days ago it was 105 degree F and due to no power we can't have air conditioning . It was so hot in the day that I cannot even sit in-front of laptop for more than 1 hour. It is totally killing.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoGreat example of the echo chamber/filter bubble effect: this is the first time I've heard about this, and it's been going on since 2021. Wow.
- throwaway049 4y agoI wouldn't really expect this to get regular coverage outside the region. Just something in the foreign news section when there's a major event. But you can mitigate the bubble effect by bookmarking news sites in multiple countries and browsing all of them.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoI follow quite literally thousands of RSS feeds, and this is still the first time I've heard about this. It might be the quantity problem: because there's more coverage on x, coverage on y is easily overlooked because it's such a small percentage of cumulative reporting.
- throwaway049 4y agoThousands of newsfeeds sounds like a quantity problem in itself. Even at one post per feed per day doesn't that take up an inordinate amount of your time?
- hammyhavoc 4y ago
- dh303 4y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAn electricity-free technology to cool an area by reflecting all sunlight energy and simultaneously emitting black body radiation in the atmospheric mid IR window (unlike metals, which have low emissivity) is useful here. They are an existing emerging technology. White paint helps somewhat but doesn’t work well in the IR. The current best performing film is made by 3M: https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/energy-conservation-us/applications/passive-radiative-cooling/ https://www.3m.com/3M/en_US/energy-conservation-us/applicati...
- ip26 4y agoThis part of the world needs something cheap and low tech. No one who is at risk has the money for cutting edge building materials. Mirrors on every roof? Polished steel? Brick or concrete walls? At a city level, low tech could still make a difference.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoMetal and mirrors retain heat due to the metal being near the air surface. A real life example: think of your experience with a hot stone/glass surface and a hot steel surface. It’s much harder to tell the steel is hot until you touch it due to how it emits radiative heat.
- ip26 4y agoYeah, but maybe they can reflect enough back into the sky to be a net win. Ultimately you need something simple with the highest possible net energy rejection, whether by radiation or reflection or both.
- mistrial9 4y agowhite paint
- mensetmanusman 4y agoNeeds anti dust surface performance or else it absorbs soon, also doesn’t reflect on the mid far IR.
- lusus_naturae 4y agoI think there is something to finding creative technological solutions. It seems unkind and impractical to ask people to avoid such regions or not live there. People have histories, communities and culture. It can be abandoned in a time of need, but displacement can create trauma, which may have multigenerational effects. I don't study climate science or climate justice, but my bet is that those who can take these environmental threats and instead turn them into a boon, e.g. a new manufacturing technique that reduces carbon emissions or optimizes carbon sequestering for energy production, will have something everyone will want.
- seventystuff 4y agoQuoting. "OTEC (Ocean thermal energy conversion) can also supply quantities of cold water as a by-product. This can be used for refrigeration and can help crops and fish grow. OTEC can also produce large amounts of salt-free water" ... heck I read all the stuff written here and am thinking now 'someone may have patents for that...' (-;
- olalonde 4y agoIt's surprising that the article doesn't seem to consider the potential benefits of heating, especially when it comes to mitigating the adverse effects of cold weather. For instance, this study conducted in India [0] found that cold-related deaths significantly outnumbered heat-related deaths. Given this, I think it's important to weigh the advantages of heating against its drawbacks when discussing this topic. [0] https://phys.org/news/2022-01-cold-deaths-india.html https://phys.org/news/2022-01-cold-deaths-india.html
- akritrime 4y agoIs there any co-relation between heat waves and the temperature during the winter months? Anecdotally, it just seems like we are caught between an ever-lengthening gap of higher temperatures during summer and lower temperatures during winter.
- bequanna 4y agoThis isn’t surprising. Mentioning facts like that would violate the narrative.
- tomrod 4y agoWalk me through how knowing that people also die of cold exposure violates the narrative that there is a deadly heat wave threatening 1B people in India? Is this something logically consistent or a non-sequitor?
- bequanna 4y agoFewer people are dying globally due to climate change net decreasing extreme cold events. This is an unpopular fact to state for obvious reasons.
- omginternets 4y agoIf you’re going to make this kind of utilitarian argument, then you have to demonstrate that global warming harms fewer people overall, not just that there are fewer cold-related deaths.
- skilled 4y agoI was in Delhi maybe 5-6 years ago for a week before going to the North. It was May/June. The temperatures in the morning (7AM) were around 100F or 40C. I'd walk out on my hotels tiny little balcony with little sunlight seeping through the cracks of the streets, and I'd still get an instant burn on my skin. At that time I had visited many different countries in Asia (Cambodia is the only one that could compete with India in terms of raw heat), but to this day I will never forget that feeling of just rapid heat acceleration in such early morning hours. Imagine what that does to the environment "behind the scenes". Right now, I am in Norway (northernmost part of Western Norway) and it will be May in two days. Last night, we had a snowstorm so strong all the mountains in the area got covered in snow. The Winter itself was average, with hardly any cold periods except for a month of "expected" Winter. I don't know how anyone plans to address global warming, I really don't, but I know for a fact that weather 20 years ago was much different to what it is now. Where I grew up - Winters used to be -30C (-22F) for 3 months straight and Spring would kick in. For the last 10 years or so, in many places in Eastern Europe - a Winter consists of a little cold a bit of damp weather, that's it.
- iJohnDoe 4y agoWaiting for the HN expert to chime in that temperatures in India are actually at an all time low and the article is indeed wrong. Also, they were in India recently and the temperatures seemed fine and people were outside enjoying the beautiful weather. Furthermore, an increase in temperatures in India is actually a positive thing for the people and economy and the article should be ignored.
- mwnn 4y ago[flagged]
- BigCryo 4y agoDon't sweat it, we live on a ice planet that has regular ice ages... And we are overdue for the next ice age
- MagicMoonlight 4y ago[flagged]
- karakot 4y ago[flagged]