4 ms·
I'm going to keep saying it - unionising has been a bad stratagy that loses. That has been true pretty much forever. Trying to muscle and threaten the organisat
by roenxi 4y ago
I'm going to keep saying it - unionising has been a bad stratagy that loses. That has been true pretty much forever. Trying to muscle and threaten the organisation in the world most willing to give you money is wildly silly. Red Hat doing layoffs doesn't change that.
Software Engineers have been massive winners of the hyper-capitalist faster-than-regulation world of software. The salaries are outrageous relative to the amount of effort put in. Changing strategies because of a 5% workforce reduction would be stupid.
As a body of engineers we all stand to gain far more by breaking the anachronistic guilds in law, medicine and other trades than from unionising in software. We'd see some real progress in medicine if it was easier for people to get in and fix the rather obvious problems that plague the industry. I know that'd do much more good for my family than me avoiding the pain of sending out a lot of resumes every 2 decades.
Locking down software companies did not work in Europe. They just ended up playing 2nd fiddle to more cut-throat approaches. It won't help. People might get an emotional kick out of it, but we'll end up paying more and getting less if people keep trying to force companies to make irrational decisions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jselysianeagle 4y ago> I know that'd do much more good for my family than me avoiding the pain of sending out a lot of resumes every 2 decades. Every 2 decades?! I'd say it's more like every 2-3 years. Also I'm not sure the salaries are "outrageous" except for a select few devs working at FAANGs, and those only make up a small fraction of all developers out there. The majority are making at best a comfortable but not "outrageous" salary wherever they happen to be working.
- roenxi 4y agoIf you're getting sacked every 2-3 years, with all due respect, you are doing something wrong. > The majority are making at best a comfortable but not "outrageous" salary wherever they happen to be working. I've talked to a lot of old people, seen plumbers and tradespeople at work and visited Asia a couple of times. Read a bit of history in my spare time. The majority may believe that but they are working from instinct rather than evidence. The evidence is they have one of the most comfortable, low risk existences in the history of humanity. Both in an absolute and relative sense, also when compared to currently living humans. But that isn't even important. What matters here is unionising won't make it better. It'll probably cause them to revert to the mean by driving wealth out of software companies. Companies don't sack people out of a love of sacking people.
- jselysianeagle 4y ago> If you're getting sacked every 2-3 years, with all due respect, you are doing something wrong. Sacked?! If you think the only time people switch jobs in the tech industry is when they get sacked, with all due respect, you know nothing about the tech industry, and your views and understanding about most corporate jobs today is most likely very, very outdated.
- roenxi 4y agoIf you're already voluntarily switching jobs every 2-3 years, then nobody should care that Red Hat is forcing its employees to switch jobs every ... when was the last time they had a layoff, I dunno... years. It is barely an inconvenience.
- em-bee 4y agowhen you switch jobs voluntarily, then you can do the job hunting on the side and you can reject offers that are not obviously better than your current job. when you get laid off then you may have to take the first offer that comes along, even if it pays worse because (at least in the US) many can't afford to be out of a job for long. in germany you have to take any offer that pays at least 80% of your current salary if you don't want to loose unemployment benefits. getting laid off is a massive difference compared to switching jobs voluntarily.
- majormajor 4y ago> But that isn't even important. What matters here is unionising won't make it better. It'll probably cause them to revert to the mean by driving wealth out of software companies. Companies don't sack people out of a love of sacking people. Hollywood talent having unions hasn't driven wealth out of the entertainment industry. How would you "drive the wealth out" without eliminating demand for software, which has been on a long upward trend because it underpins so much and because increased productivity leads to demand for further productivity increases + maintenance of the existing increases? If it's just some "unionized employees are lazy and don't actually do stuff" trope, I don't buy it. The Hollywood model has always seemed like it could work quite well for software companies, especially startups or "release-oriented" things like games. * wildly different success rates for different project, resulting in wildly different compensation depend on what project you're on * generally short "try to make a big hit in just a few years" time frames * sometimes things turn into long-lived recurring series * incentives to push crunch time and other crazy work practices if not checked by something Obviously it's not a perfect 1:1 match everywhere, but a lot of similarities and it's an example of creative, flexible work happening with collective bargaining and better-than-government-mandated minimum standards. The union/non-union split could even end up looking like a split between top-tier VCs and studios and everyone else hustling trying to break in...
- interactivecode 4y agoIt’s a bit of a balance, more aggressive approaches work well when there is high growth. But are more painful when things are bad. Unions often slow down change, in bad times this means more job security and protections. In good times they might act slower.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ipcress_file 4y agoCorporate shareholders are permitted to form a union of owners. It works for them. Workers should have the same rights. That's just balance. As far as the bad strategy comment goes, I've been working in both public and private unionized organizations since the 1980s. They seem to do quite well and I'm happy to have benefited from good salaries, benefits, company-matched savings plans, and a great pension plan that is -- contrary to all the propaganda out there -- very well managed and sound. That being said, your comment does capture the "race to the bottom" mentality that free trade agreements have produced. I agree that if countries choose to allow capital to move freely and constrain labour at the border, the result is sub-optimal for the majority of us.
- sokoloff 4y agoWorkers are permitted to form a union. By and large, technology workers choose not to exercise that right.
- ipcress_file 4y agoWhich is fine. I'm happy when they have that choice, because that's balanced. Owners have the choice to go it alone or combine too.
- andromeduck 4y agoPretty sure employer cartels are illegal.
- ipcress_file 4y agoI wasn't talking about cartels. A corporation is a union of owners. We've just been trained not to see it that way.
- lucidone 4y agoCompanies generally exist to make money. Law and medicine are fields I personally do not want optimized for profits. I believe a better approach to be making governments more efficient and more aligned with the interests of their constituents (e.g., rewards for meeting targets that indicate a benefit to society - improving gdp, reducing health care spend, reducing criminal recidivism, whatever).
- majormajor 4y ago> We'd see some real progress in medicine if it was easier for people to get in and fix the rather obvious problems that plague the industry. I know that'd do much more good for my family than me avoiding the pain of sending out a lot of resumes every 2 decades. But would that be good for doctors' paychecks? This pivot midway through from "unions are bad for the people in the unions" to "unions and similar mechanisms are protecting the people in them at other people's expense" doesn't seem fully consistent. It's consistent from your point of view - "give me what I think is best in the situation regardless" - but that "I just want what's best for me" is exactly why collective action is so often appealing. A view of the field as "the salaries are outrageous relative to the amount of effort put in" sounds like a management POV, not an engineer POV, and similarly focusing solely on the "effort" to frame software engineers poorly instead of "the value created by the work for the organization" which paints the engineers as more critical to the business.
- roenxi 4y agoWell they'd see job growth far in excess of the 5% that is causing this fuss. There is a shortage of medical care and a lot of good people who want to go in and make life better for others. Warms the heart to see their efforts, even if legislation is causing a lot of the work to go to waste. I expect the average wage of doctors are paid would rise, employment would certainly rise, and if we look at the real outcomes the doctors would have a better quality of life (as would we all) because medical care would be better. So I think they'd probably see nominal pay rises, but even if you want to be pessimistic and assume they were nominally paid less, their quality of life would probably improve. The basic strategy of unions is to not work sometimes and pick fights with employers. That isn't making anyone better off in the real world.
- majormajor 4y agoOrrrr you have more doctors and some of the "obvious problems that plague the industry" get way worse because now the power shifts even more to non-practicing administrators who push less face time with patients, more paperwork, etc, as they try to maximize a certain particular definition of "efficiency" over everything else... I'd need a lot more details on how you'd expect more competition for medical jobs to result in rising salaries to buy the claim.
- flangola7 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hfYJsQAhl0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5hfYJsQAhl0
- sidlls 4y agoUnionizing is a bad strategy that loses when governments captured by the elites who own the capital help those same elites squash the power of unions. When governments get out of the way (marginally better) or work to actively balance the power structure (much better) it's not such a losing strategy: workers' lives improve, and companies generally end up doing better.
- clipsy 4y ago> I'm going to keep saying it - unionising has been a bad stratagy that loses. Perhaps rather than repeating yourself, you should consider defining what you mean by losing and backing up your claim with data.
- misssocrates 4y agoDear sir, are you suggesting that something that worked well for certain things at certain times may not automatically apply to all 21st century industries in the year 2023?
- gred 4y agoYeah, I think I'm happy with outsized rewards for outsized contributions. You guys feel free to spend time worrying about how to split the pie equitably, I'll be over here making more pie (and demanding a share).
- jleyank 4y agoUnless you’re bill joy or an owner with a chunk that must be noticed “demand a share” often equals “exits the business”. Why would they have to pay attention to somebody when they’re probably leaving in 2-3 years or can be replaced anywhere in the world? Gotta have leverage to threaten.
- Convolutional 4y ago> unionising has been a bad stratagy (sic) that loses. That has been true pretty much forever. If lowering hours, raising pay, better working conditions are a losing strategy. > Trying to muscle and threaten the organisation in the world most willing to give you money is wildly silly. Glad these organizations never muscle and threaten. I think you have the direction of money mixed up. The workers create the wealth, and the heirs who own IBM stock parasitically expropriate dividend profits from those workers surplus time. The money flows from the workers creating wealth to the aristocratic expropriating parasites. There are two parties here - the workers creating all the newly created wealth with their labor, and the heirs who parasitically expropriate profits from their surplus labor. We know you're not on the side of those of us doing the work, so it's clear which class you're representing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- davidguetta 4y agolaugh in 5 week vacation minimum thanks the the unions fighting for worker rights in the past in Europe