25 ms·
If the story is good, I'll read it, regardless of whether it was written by an AI, a human, or a dog. I don't really see humans as being special, of only wantin
by satvikpendem 4y ago
If the story is good, I'll read it, regardless of whether it was written by an AI, a human, or a dog. I don't really see humans as being special, of only wanting to read stories that have the "human touch," whatever that is.
- Freire_Herval 4y agoSo if humans aren't special at anything, then humans don't really have a purpose. I envision a future similar to the one in Wall-E and it's not exactly bad so long as the AI actually acts in our interest.
- satvikpendem 4y ago> So if humans aren't special at anything, then humans don't really have a purpose Well yeah, one of the fundamental discoveries of nihilism. Our purpose is that which we make ourselves.
- Freire_Herval 4y agoMy purpose is to sit while AI takes care of everything and keeps me happy. I want to live in the matrix where I have 30 hot model wives and not know any better. The simulation of course will make me a chad and emperor of the world. That's my purpose.
- ChatGTP 4y agoThis is what I believe we already have with social media , a primitive version of the matrix where you fish for likes and validation, and it’s what VR will create, there may not be a technological singularity but rather, a place where each ego is stroked so intensely that we care less of reality. You can be totally distracted from your real existence for 90% of you life, you won’t need anything else. Just have “20 hot wives” or whatever superficial thing makes you happy.
- satvikpendem 4y agoThat's great, if that's what you want your purpose to be then go for it. Lots of people already live similarly, like hikikomori. Your comment changes nothing about the fact that a person's purpose is not driven externally by society or by the fact that one is human, it is derived entirely from oneself.
- kevin_b_er 4y agoIt will not. It will serve the capitalist class as an instrument to enrich at the expense of the masses. And it will be done while telling most people that they just didn't "work hard enough".
- satvikpendem 4y agoThat's not what I see daily as a non-capitalist class member using Stable Diffusion and other open AI tools.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- whyenot 4y agoAn evolutionary biologist might say (in a candid moment), that our purpose is to increase our fitness (=fecundity) and the fitness of those genetically related to us.
- Freire_Herval 4y agoBrain facilities that were previously evolved to gain a darwinian competitive edge through strategic intelligence can now be utilized to break the mold of natural selection. There was no direct selection pressure that coordinated the development of your ability to understand evolutionary psychology. Evolutionary psychology is a side effect of intelligence. Breaking past our darwinian purpose is a side effect of our meta understanding of evolutionary biology and intelligence. As someone else said we, to a limited extend, can make our own purpose.
- JohnFen 4y ago> I don't really see humans as being special Fair enough, but I absolutely see humans as being more special than machines. What interests me in a story, art, poem, whatever, is that it's a human communication. Even if a machine can do it technically as well, or better, I want the human one, not the computed one. A world where everything is generated by a machine is a dystopian world, in my view.
- satvikpendem 4y ago> What interests me in a story, art, poem, whatever, is that it's a human communication. I guess we are different in this case, as I primarily read something for its content, rather than its author (although the author is often a good proxy for the quality of the content). A world where I can instantly generate whatever content I want is a utopia for me, rather than a dystopia.
- JohnFen 4y ago> A world where I can instantly generate whatever content I want is a utopia for me, rather than a dystopia. And I don't want to deny you that. My fear is that your preference will be the only choice. One person's heaven can indeed be another person's hell.
- satvikpendem 4y agoI doubt human created art will ever go away, if only for the mere fact that there are people who share your view who want human made art. People still buy artisan, handcrafted products.
- JohnFen 4y agoHuman-made art becoming so rare that it's "artisan, hand-crafted" is such art not really existing, in my view. It would mean that 99% of all the "art" I see around me is effectively alien and meaningless. It would be very hard to actually take part in such a society.
- rchaud 4y agoSo what was the last dog-authored book you liked? /s Most people can distinguish good writing from that which is merely serviceable, but un-engaging. Reading the latter is like a slow death if its in book form or attempting to be literary fiction. For news articles and other stuff that's being automated, it's replacing what is already a heavily templated process. The writing there is fine. It's not what I'd call interesting though. That's the difference an actual writer can make.
- cableshaft 4y agoHere's a cat book (Red Dwarf clip): https://youtu.be/V5Ks8wp110o?t=211 https://youtu.be/V5Ks8wp110o?t=211
- satvikpendem 4y ago> Most people can distinguish good writing from that which is merely serviceable, but un-engaging Sure, but you're talking about the current reality of AI written content, there may very well be very engaging content in the future by AI.
- et1337 4y agoI think the “humans are not special” idea will lead to some really bad places. Jaron Lanier said it better than I could: https://twitter.com/etodd_/status/1638932095551836161 https://twitter.com/etodd_/status/1638932095551836161
- sph 4y agoI think there is something fundamentally wrong and blasphemous about a human, the apex living being we know of, in some ways the most incredible achievement of nature itself, to say "we are not that special" compared to a machine that can write an EULA in Speakesperean English. I mean that's cool, but have you seen life itself? What about conscious matter that can observe itself? The goodness of AI is relative to us, the one that invented it. By some definition we will always be better than it because we created the damn thing in the first place. Seeing ChatGPT and saying we're not that special is just utterly wrong to me. Even if it is true, accepting that as a fact is dangerous, if not traitorous in some way — reminds me of the Adventists in The Three-Body Problem (massive spoiler ahead) having such a low opinion of humanity that they would rather be destroyed by an alien race. /philosophical rant I keep coming back to and I need someone smarter to expand upon
- satvikpendem 4y agoI meant "special" in terms of uniqueness of ability to reason and perhaps have sentience and sapience. If there were life on other planets, it might be wholly new and also be very interesting, but that doesn't necessarily mean that life on Earth is somehow more special than life on another planet. So too with this regarding AI in the future.
- wongarsu 4y agoI'm not sure I understand the argument (granted, twitter is not always the best medium for that). If I understand the quote correctly, Lanier's argument is "if we don't believe humans have a soul beyond the phyiscal then we can't make a society or make things that serve humans"?
- Freire_Herval 4y ago
- gregraygun 4y agoAgreed, and there is always a wide range of people that just do nothing but complain about new things. It is true, that there is a strong human nature to go against change.
- anon3242 4y agoWhat if I tell you that this page ,including all our comments, is entirely created by LLMs? Sometimes the process of creation is just as important as the end result. You would not go to the concert to hear hi-fi speakers playing pre-recorded or generated music, although with your eyes closed you won't hear a difference.
- chownie 4y ago> You would not go to the concert to hear hi-fi speakers playing pre-recorded or generated music, although with your eyes closed you won't hear a difference. I would. Concerts are pretty bad, people go for the atmosphere or the drugs, strictly speaking the actual music is usually objectively worse than the studio recordings for the same tracks. It's coming through the speakers either way, the artists are not my friends, I do not care.
- satvikpendem 4y ago> You would not go to the concert to hear hi-fi speakers playing pre-recorded or generated music, although with your eyes closed you won't hear a difference. What do you think EDM concerts are? They're all prerecorded, the DJ most of the time doesn't actually do anything up there on the stand. And yet people go to these concerts, because it's about the music itself, not who makes it. > What if I tell you that this page ,including all our comments, is entirely created by LLMs? So what? If it's good content, it's good content. I've had debates with ChatGPT on a variety of issues and sometimes it brings up a good points that I hadn't considered before on the topic, so if HN were entirely AI driven, it doesn't really matter either. Hell, solipsism is entirely built on the notion that no one besides oneself is real, this would simply be an extension of that concept.