6 ms·
> I'm not using a VPN or Tor, just AT&T Fiber. I don't have ad-blockers. No weird extensions. Nothing special (besides being on Linux). Even if you were doing
by ryandrake 4y ago
> I'm not using a VPN or Tor, just AT&T Fiber. I don't have ad-blockers. No weird extensions. Nothing special (besides being on Linux).
Even if you were doing any, or all of these things, you are no less a legitimate internet user than anyone else. This whole "rain dance" supplication to show you are worthy of browsing a web site has got to go. Stop visiting sites who treat their users this badly!
- hammyhavoc 4y ago[flagged]
- kevincox 4y agoThis reminds me of the origin of "jaywalking". People used to walk wherever they wanted but when cars became a thing they found that people where in their way. So they started to blame people for "jaywalking" to turn it into a bad thing that the pedestrians are doing rather than framing it as cars wanting to take some of the road away from pedestrians. We are trying to frame people who are trying to protect their privacy as "suspicious" rather than saying that we want to track them better.
- kube-system 4y agoLikening packets on the internet to people in a street is not an accurate analogy. The reason people use these solutions is that they're inundated with garbage traffic that is often automated. The internet is more like a street with 5 real people and 1,000 malicious humanoid robots.
- jacquesm 4y agoIf it needs a checkbox to confirm you're a human then I would say that's a lost battle. A bot would be just as able to click that as I am. And I keep being hit with these over and over again. It's well beyond just annoying, especially when it is sites that I have a long standing relationship with. Which I wonder: are those sites even aware that Cloudflare keeps popping up that check dialog?
- kube-system 4y agoYou are right that scripts can check a checkbox. Which is why the "checkboxes" that cloudflare/recaptcha display to you are not actually checkboxes. They're fingerprinting and behavioral analysis scripts.
- ipaddr 4y agoYou get 1005 requests for a file. They are all real requests. You simply send back the data. You want to determine who is manually asking vs automated so you can ignore requests that aren't manually generated.
- Wazako 4y agoWe are more in the case of adding a turnaround on footpaths to block motorbikes and other 2-wheel scooters. captcha also exists in the real world.
- codedokode 4y agoInstead of Cloudflare there should be a protocol that would allow host to notify upstream providers that they should reject incoming traffic from specific address ranges. If there was such protocol all Cloudflare business would be zeroed in a minute, but sadly that is not going to happen.
- kube-system 4y agoConsidering that a lot of the internet is still behind a NAT I’m not sure that’s a completely bulletproof solution.
- warrenm 4y ago>there should be a protocol that would allow host to notify upstream providers that they should reject incoming traffic from specific address ranges At the server or datacenter level, it's call a firewall :)
- account42 4y agoThere is no reason whasoever you should need to prove you are not a bot in order to view an effectively static website. For interaction you may need anti-spam measures, for viewing no.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoThe FUD and moralization of groupthink conformance. When not in a vehicle and there are no cops around, I do the New Yorker thing: I completely ignore signals and focus on traffic. The prima facie and prime directive is safety over conformance. I will not waste my life at the behest of some Christmas lights.
- rrdharan 4y agoStatistically you're at such a higher risk on the road than anywhere else, it's best to minimize the amount of time spent in a motor vehicle. This is why I don't waste time putting on my seatbelt, run all red lights, and always floor the gas pedal for the duration of my trips.
- jacooper 4y agoYou forgot the /s
- Philadelphia 4y agoSame thing with fraud against a business being turned into “identity theft”.
- justizin 4y ago> Stop visiting sites who treat their users this badly! The problem is the individual sites aren’t making these highly technical decisions, people are using what seems to them an innocuous security product. Not visiting a random website places no pressure on CloudFlare to change, since there’s no way to correlate your choice with the decision to use CloudFlare.
- thewebcount 4y agoNot to mention that you may not have a choice. I've seen government sites have this shit on them. We're quickly approaching the satirical society of the movie _Brazil_.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoUnverified: 27B/6 derives from George Orwell's address. I'm wondering how long it will be before we have memory holes considering how, apart from the internet archive, there is perpetual bitrot and silent updates.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoIt's a form of digital totalitarianism. Submit to the rule of a few corporations or be left out socially, economically, etc.
- anonzzzies 4y agoWhat is the alternative though; we had a millions of requests from 100000s of IPs from all continents a few months ago; literally the only thing that got our site back up was bot fight from cloudflare. How do you do this another way?
- notatoad 4y agothere is no alternative. it sucks, and so people complain. the only solution is to just let people complain. there's no way to solve this problem without having some sort of tracking system to determine who's a legitmate user.
- xcdzvyn 4y agoSo, if somebody so wishes to take down a website they dislike, we should just put up with it? If a state actor DDoSes a journal documenting war crimes, we just ask them nicely to stop?
- notatoad 4y agothat's absolutely not what i'm saying. if somebody wishes to take down a website they dislike, we (as website operators) should block their bot traffic. and we should use whatever reasonable methods we have to detect what traffic comes from bots and what traffic doesn't come from bots. that includes putting cloudflare in front of our sites. and when some legitimate users really, really look like bot traffic because they circumvent whatever methods we use to determine whether traffic is coming from real people, they might sometimes get blocked along with the bots. they're going to complain about that, and the only thing we can do is listen to their complaints.
- viraptor 4y agoThat only works for you while you're not involved in the second group. We get to complain and make noise and push on both websites and CF, so that the "non-bot" user group doesn't become "latest chrome user on latest windows in the approved country running proprietary CF extention for id verification" one day in the future when it's an easier solution than dealing with the actual issue.
- mikae1 4y ago> Stop visiting sites who treat their users this badly! Too bad that basically means you can't surf the internet anymore as a majority of websites use Cloudflare. One of my Firefox installations on Linux are also plagued by this. I can't use Firefox to browse the web.
- hinata08 4y agoI already do that tbh. The internet is pretty redundant and you can find what you want anywhere. CloudFlare blocks me from a part of the internet when I use anonymizing tools like Tor. I assumed they just do that to fingerprint and track you. Even the crypto thing to get a dozen or so passes after solving a riddle never worked. So I have just moved on to websites protected by Akamai, or virtually anything but CloudFlare. It's not just a political decision btw. It's just easier to move on than to try to fight CloudFlare or to become viral on HN to get support. It shouldn't be up to the user to adapt, but to the website.
- jackmott42 4y agoagreed, especially when you are trying to BUY something. the modal popups trying to get you sign up for newsletters, the demand to prove you are human, fuck right off.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoI see you're using an ad-blocker. You must disable it to see my low-effort content that's available on the next search result.
- petre 4y agoIt's funny how many sites with news or (propaganda) opinion pieces do that.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> This whole "rain dance" supplication to show you are worthy of browsing a web site has got to go. This is just whining. I don't necessarily like it either, but you conveniently ignore all the reasons why that rain dance supplication exists in the first place. All ears if you have a better solution for DDoS attacks, malicious bot traffic, etc.
- tyingq 4y agoI know CloudFlare has market share that would push their complaints to the top, but they aren't the only bot traffic blocker, DDoS shield, etc. Do other providers get a (proportionally) similar amount of complaints?
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoI get CAPTCHA fails from my work's corporate network. We are on VPN and it makes us look like a sketchy VPN provider. Heck, StackOverflow blocks us half the time without a CAPTCHA challenge.
- stjohnswarts 4y agothis is what I do. "Fuck 'em" if they think everyone is trying to hack their site. They could use any number of standard protections but they choose to use a hammer. The only place I'll kind of jump through hoops for is my personal bank or CC companies. I set up a socks5 server for that so I wasn't using the VPN that cloudflare and IAmVeryImportant.com sites hate.