3 ms·
I've never heard any justification for having "college education" as a job requirement. Or at least no justification that didn't amount to "keep out people who
by bell-cot 4y ago
I've never heard any justification for having "college education" as a job requirement. Or at least no justification that didn't amount to "keep out people who aren't like us", or "pretend to be competent", or "posture as exclusive".
- efitz 4y agoA college degree is a signaling mechanism that you are willing to stick it out until the end in a large bureaucratic environment and not quit. An Ivy League degree is a signal that “you’re one of us”.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- willcipriano 4y agoThose sound like just the people you want to hire if you want to build a lumbering bureaucratic organization.
- gtop3 4y agoDo you think U.S. Representative Staffers are not interacting with lumbering bureaucratic organizations? Being able to navigate and succeed in these organizations is a skill every organization with employees needs.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYes, but what if you want to alter, restructure, or abolish parts of that bureaucratic apparatus? A lot of US officialdom (and business) is operated by unquestioning drones.
- TheFreim 4y agoThis is correct. It proves you're willing to jump through hoops and not think enough for yourself, since being creative often means diverging from the grading criteria.
- tekmate 4y agomaybe if you went to college you could come up with one
- jedberg 4y agoA college degree from an accredited institution shows that you can see through a task that takes 4+ years to complete. There are many other ways to show that, and it's silly to limit anything to only people with college degrees, but that's why people do it.
- paxys 4y agoAll that it shows is that you had enough money to pay for 4 years of college. If that were the only criteria then holding on to a job for 4+ years should count for 1000x more than a college degree, because at least you are accountable for results.
- hot_gril 4y agoHaving a previous similar job helps a ton too. I don't know if they'd even care about college once you have experience.
- tivert 4y ago> All that it shows is that you had enough money to pay for 4 years of college. No, it also shows you can show up on time for those years, and regularly complete a series of reasonably complicated intellectual tasks on a deadline. > If that were the only criteria then holding on to a job for 4+ years should count for 1000x more than a college degree, because at least you are accountable for results. No, college is far more standardized, and the students have their performance evaluated throughout, which can then be easily provided in a digested form. The main issue with college is that many people who could complete the requirements can't, only because they don't have the money.
- juve1996 4y agoThis just isn't true. Our public education is very bad now in much of the country. The fact is what you get out of high school from a huge portion of the population is...not great. No one is stopping anyone from hiring these people. If there is no difference, people will pay less for the cheaper labor.
- Ensorceled 4y ago> I've never heard any justification for having "college education" as a job requirement. Really? Never? "A degree shows they have learned how to learn." "A degree shows they can stick with something for 3-4 years." "A degree shows they have learned how to write." "A degree is needed because high school education sucks so bad now."
- kcplate 4y agoThose may be justifications people use, but ironically they are all statements that people take as true but in reality often are complete bullshit.
- Ensorceled 4y agoSome are, but many are lazy short cuts But can you honestly say you've never heard ANY justification.
- kcplate 4y agoI have heard a lot of attempts at justification, but short of highly specialized STEM oriented careers, there is hardly a job out there that requires a degree in my opinion.
- justincredible 4y ago[dead]
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoHiring employees is a risky prospect and firing a bad hire can be an expensive and lengthy process, depending on the jurisdiction. So naturally employers want to minimize the risk of hiring someone incompetent. Decades ago the use of IQ testing for job applicants was made illegal. Requiring a college degree serves as a legal and socially acceptable proxy for a level of intelligence. Whether or not that is actually valid is another matter. From an employer’s perspective the amount of effort to require a college degree is virtually nill and it helps to cut down on the sheer number of applicants they have to process.
- polski-g 4y agoIts all here: https://spectator.org/how-the-supreme-court-created-the-student-loan-bubble/ https://spectator.org/how-the-supreme-court-created-the-stud... > The solution for businesses post-Griggs was obvious: outsource screening to colleges, which are allowed to weed out poor candidates based on test scores.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> The 1971 Supreme Court decision remains largely unknown, but no ruling of the past forty-five years (except for Roe v. Wade) has done more harm to the American way of life. Rolls eyes so hard they nearly come out of skull Yeah, it probably had some effect, but I'd say there are a lot of reasons, probably starting with the GI Bill. Why settle for a high school grad when there's a glut of veteran-college-grads suddenly on the market, all looking for jobs? Plus it gives you an excuse for excluding most women, who are suddenly in the job market in much greater numbers, from higher-paying jobs... oh, and would you look at that, black veterans are having trouble actually getting the benefits they're owed, so aren't going to college at as high a rate as white veterans! How convenient that is. Clearly, there are a bunch of reasons this would have been appealing to employers well before 1971, and once the ball's rolling, it's easy to see how this new situation becomes self-perpetuating (good jobs now require degrees, since there are plenty of degree-holders around -> kids aspire to college at much higher rates -> repeat)
- polski-g 4y ago> Why settle for a high school grad when there's a glut of veteran-college-grads suddenly on the market You didn't need to "settle" for anything prior to this decision. You could simply screen for candidates based on innate cognitive ability. Going to college or not does not change that attribute.
- yamtaddle 4y agoWhy have we seen a similar rise in crendialism in countries without similar rulings or laws? Where's the demand for Griggs-compliant intelligence testing? Such a thing is permitted! Where is it? This may be a small—very small—part of the puzzle, but I don't see a compelling case that we can point to it and say, "yep, that's what did it!" I don't even see enough to make it look like that's a valuable direction to further examine. The evidence is scant, and behavior we see doesn't look like it ought to if that were the main cause. > You could simply screen for candidates based on innate cognitive ability. You could apply racist or sexist requirements laundered through "testing". The whole reason the case was brought was that that was actually happening.
- fourseventy 4y agoDo you want a Dr operating on you who didn't graduate from college or medical school? There is a reason why degrees are requirements.
- AlbertCory 4y agoWay to change the subject. I thought we were talking about cops here.
- AlbertCory 4y agoDo you not want an EMT who didn't go to college keeping you alive in the ambulance, until the real doctor at the hospital gets to look at you? You'd rather die? OK, your choice.
- gadders 4y agoA lot of places are dropping all lowering their degree requirements as part of a move to increase diversity. McKinsey [1] and Harvard Business Review [2] have both written on the topic. [1] https://www.mckinsey.com/about-us/new-at-mckinsey-blog/tearing-the-paper-ceiling-mckinsey-supports-movement-for-upward-mobility-of-millions-of-workers https://www.mckinsey.com/about-us/new-at-mckinsey-blog/teari... [2] https://hbr.org/2023/03/the-new-collar-workforce https://hbr.org/2023/03/the-new-collar-workforce
- photochemsyn 4y agoHighly technical jobs in chemistry, physics, engineering, molecular biology require a certain kind of college education that involves a lot of hands-on experience in research labs. The traditional college coursework is not nearly as important as what amounts to vocational training working side-by-side with technicians, grad students, postdocs etc. There's no real way to acquire the needed experience without getting into a four-year research-centric university. A private company just isn't going to invest the time and energy needed to train an apprentice in these fields from scratch, and two-year community colleges rarely have access to the latest modern technology. Other than that, your comment seems pretty accurate.
- metalspot 4y ago> a private company just isn't going to invest the time and energy needed to train an apprentice not as long as they can force people to pay for it themselves and have the government and the tax payers subsidize it. universities were never meant to be vocational schools though, and they do a horrible job at it. to take computer science as an example: a 4 years bachelor degree only has about 500 hours of classroom instruction in comp sci subjects. a 9-5 vocational training program can provide 480 hours of classroom instruction in 3 months. the idea that students benefit by going to a university where they only spend a few hours a day learning and the rest of the time playing games, socializing, drinking and doing drugs, is absurd. put people in a 9-5 40 hour a week program that has the same attendance and performance requirements as the job they are training for and they can be trained to the level of any bachelors degree in 3-6 months.
- ejstronge 4y ago> to take computer science as an example: a 4 years bachelor degree only has about 500 hours of classroom instruction in comp sci subjects. > a 9-5 vocational training program can provide 480 hours of classroom instruction in 3 months. This feels like a disingenuous response - are you suggesting that solely 500 hours of a computer science degree confers utility to a graduate? Even then, 500 hours taken consecutively can hardly be compared to 500 hours spent over multiple years, interspersed with hands-on projects and internships.
- logicalmonster 4y agoMy opinion is that the Supreme Court Case Griggs v. Duke Power Company helped make college education effectively a job requirement for anything other than very simple labor. Before that, employers for any kind of professional job could offer some kind of IQ or other test so they could figure out if you had some basic level of competence and were capable of being trained to perform whatever task they needed. Since it's now legally risky to use any kind of filter similar to that as a proxy for basic competence and trainability, college has become (an extremely expensive and time-consuming) proxy for measuring basic competence and ability to learn. I think this Supreme Court Case had devastating effects on society in just some of these ways. > People lose 4 of their prime income earning years. > Not only that, but they start out life in mega-debt. Achieving something like the American dream gets delayed or put totally out of reach for many people. > The combination of losing 4 years as well as being in debt means that many people, particularly society's most responsible, are going to be the ones delaying reproduction. This is bad news if you want to avoid something like Idiocracy, and has many other negative social consequences as well. It's an all-around waste to incentivize a college degree as the standard proxy for demonstrating competence. And truth be told, outside of pretty specialized roles, college is completely unnecessary for average people. Most normal people have the capacity to be trained in a short amount of time for pretty much any typical office job.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoIf you're right then we should expect countries where IQ tests are not illegal, to have experienced a slower increase in the % of young adults with degrees. I wonder if you've seen any data like this?
- logicalmonster 4y agoAnecdotally speaking, all I can remember hearing drilled into me in the American school system as the path for life success was going to college. The implication was that you'd be a loser who worked flipping burgers at McDonalds for the rest of your life if you didn't go to college. As far as the data you ask for, I'm all for doing that kind of research, but there's probably many variables that are hard to directly even start to compare and interpret. For instance, consider the impact of countries that are overall poorer than the US. It might be the case that this incentivizes a lot more people in other countries to go to school to try and escape a bad living standard. Or it might be the case that they don't have the resources to get to school even if they were desperate to educate themselves as much as possible. Even if you had this data, interpreting it would seem to be really tough. Or what about countries with more homogenous populations? Perhaps IQ tests provide more value to employers in the US with a significantly heterogenous population and are far less useful in countries where just about everybody has the same overall background.
- csa 4y ago> I've never heard any justification for having "college education" as a job requirement. In many cases, it’s just an easy way to thin the applicant pool. Given EEO requirements (which have their place), having an easy way to thin the pool (often by a lot) is seen as convenient.
- bell-cot 4y ago> In many cases, it’s just an easy way to thin the applicant pool. True. Though one might pay less, under-advertise the job opening, require N years of experience, or many other means to that end.
- baryphonic 4y agoMany employers once used IQ tests, but the Supreme Court made this much costlier for employers under the "disparate impact" theory.[0] That is, employers had a burden of showing that their tests were sufficiently related to the posted job if the test results were any different among different ethnic groups, e.g. blacks scored lower than whites. Making a degree a literal requirement for the job is a low-cost proxy for IQ (or was in the past), and since it is earned, it can be listed as a job requirement, unlike IQ. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Griggs_v._Duke_Power_Co.
- metalspot 4y ago> employers had a burden of showing that their tests were sufficiently related to the posted job so why not just create a test that actually tests for the skills needed for the job? that would be the obvious way to optimize profit from a business perspective. the fact that employers don't do that is a pretty clear sign that the purpose of degree requirements is explicitly discriminatory, the same as "IQ" tests (which are completely fraudulent).
- bell-cot 4y ago> so why not just create a test that actually tests for the skills needed for the job? IANAL, but my cynical guess is America's legal system. Being ever-so-obviously in the right does not pay your attorney's bills for you.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> "IQ" tests (which are completely fraudulent) No, not really. Up for debate is pretty much only the overloading of the word 'intelligence'. But whatever it is, it correlates well with job performance and maximum level of education attainable. But they are culturally sensitive, and thus racially sensitive, and you need to apply the right test to people, for the right goals, to get meaningful results. If you want to hire only people n-sigma above the norm, in an area of rich and well-educated locals, and you apply the same test to them as to foreign applicants, you'll likely never hire a foreigner - they won't test as well as they would on a test in their native tongue/tasks/etc. But if you try to estimate the level of abilities needed and you use the correct test to establish an applicant's ability against that metric and hire from anyone qualified, then the tests are useful. They're even a way for skilled foreigners to test into qualification without having to jump through expensive credentialing hoops.
- Analemma_ 4y agoThe reason you haven't heard it is because nobody wants to say it out loud and get the resulting blowback: it's because college attendance is a proxy for IQ, which is far and away the strongest correlating factor with job performance. Since the Supreme Court ruled that employers can't use IQ tests in hiring decisions, they use the presence of a college degree instead.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoWouldn't it be easier and cheaper to use SAT scores, or are employers prohibited from using these as well?