4 ms·
By this reasoning, why would we need to do anything to grow food? Why not relax and enjoy nature's bounty? If your answer is anything but "we should indeed" th
by robertlagrant 4y ago
By this reasoning, why would we need to do anything to grow food? Why not relax and enjoy nature's bounty?
If your answer is anything but "we should indeed" then you're saying that a spectrum of technological aids are a good idea. This is one of them.
E.g. growing water-intensive herbs in the Middle East based on nature vs inside a water-recirculating vertical farm.
If it's not obvious, the answer isn't actually nature vs vertical farm, it's flying them in vs vertical farm. Your incredulity at people not just growing things where they're easy to grow should possibly diminish when you remember that we grow them where they're good to grow and then engage a global commercial, legal and freight industry to get them to us. That combination is what vertical farms are competing against.
- Ekaros 4y agoIt is not even flying them in vs vertical farm. But vertical farm vs more traditional greenhouse solutions. Where you can do all the circulation control, but also can use natural light and don't need large concrete structures. There is very few countries in the world that don't have enough land so that they need vertical farms.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoI've always thought it a bit odd that they picked up steam first in the U.S. for this reason. The economic case is vastly more sensible in Singapore or some other city-state.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CharlieDigital 4y ago> a bit odd that they picked up steam first in the U.S. for this reason My sense is that it was riding a wave of "local" and "farm to table". If you're in a city like LA or NY where there's a lack of space AND local demand for a premium priced product that can be delivered year round AND more awareness/marketability for such products (local + sustainable), the economics are different than versus growing a commodity product in Boise, Idaho. It's like the farmers in Asia that grow super premium fruits (Japan and Taiwan come to mind). It only makes sense in the context of a market that will pay the price premium.
- mikeryan 4y agoI’m all for farm to table but both NY and LA don’t need farms within city limits. All you’re saving by forcing that is a few hours of driving in a truck. If there’s an emissions concern then most farming regions are also good places for renewables like solar and wind. Electric or other carbon neutral vehicles seem like a more reasonable solution. Just a short trip outside of a city can probably get enough land for a large greenhouse if you want higher density farming with existing ag-tech and shorter transport.
- saalweachter 4y agoFor NYC, it's not even "few", it's a couple hours drive at most. Hell, you're still within the commuter rail radius and closer to the city than its main reservoir.
- CharlieDigital 4y agoIf it made sense, they would still be in business and thriving. I'm only offering one conjecture. Hindsight is 20/20, but I wouldn't make the case that it makes _zero_ sense; only that they couldn't prove the use case and find the right products and market. Definitely with a more high-value product that couldn't be sourced reasonably locally or even from the US, there may be a better economic case. It reminds me of this couple growing yuzu lemon in NJ and selling 5-10x the price to Michelin restaurants in the area: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwTc5929U5g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zwTc5929U5g
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThe odd thing is I haven't heard a single one of these startups target the luxury market. What you say makes a lot of sense.
- Scoundreller 4y ago> NY and LA don’t need farms within city limits. And generally speaking, I don’t want my food grown where it’s the most polluted. From the middle of nowhere with minimal population density, ideally upstream of any big city, is where I want my food coming from. (Will admit I start a garden at my mom’s in a medium sized city’s suburb, but when I run some containers on my balcony on a busy city street, the layers of dust from ??? concern me) Maybe this will get better once we don’t have the concentration of ICE vehicles in urban centres, but until then…
- szundi 4y agoThis is a misinterpretation of the parent comment. He states a lot of these services are free outdoors.
- tfourb 4y agoThe vast majority of humanity is living in places where basically all food can be grown locally, with some exceptions for luxury (tropical fruits in high latitudes) and seasonality (not alle produce does store well fresh, though practically all can be frozen, dried or canned in some way). There are some extreme exceptions like the United Arab Emirates etc. but they are home to only a fraction of the world population and building a city like Dubai in a desert was probably not a great idea to begin with.
- jackmott 4y ago[dead]
- tivert 4y ago>> all the fancy Startup babble does conveniently ignore that you lose access to thousands of dollars worth of free services provided by nature: irrigation, fertility, pest control, sun light for crying out loud. > By this reasoning, why would we need to do anything to grow food? Why not relax and enjoy nature's bounty? The GP got a couple things wrong (e.g. nature doesn't provide free pest control), but one thing very, very right: plants need lots and lots of sunlight that we can get for free with horizontal farming. Vertical farming throws all that away, and therefore is mostly nonsense. IIRC, all it can manage is low-calories crops like lettuce. You're not getting industrial-scale, vertically-farmed potatoes without a bunch of generators powering tons of floodlights.
- Gordonjcp 4y agoAll over Scotland - which is kind of centred around 55°N, way further north than these guys with their vertical farms - potatoes grow like crazy. Some types do well in Ayrshire, some do well up here in Angus (yes, like Aberdeen-Angus cattle). Different types of soil work well for different plants. You'd need literally megawatts of power to provide the same amount of light. Where are you going to get that from? Solar panels...?
- vidarh 4y agoIn Norway, Potatoes are grown as far north as the Northernmost region of Finnmark, around 70°N, and Norway is able to produce more potatoes than are eaten by people (Norway still imports potatoes because the growing season is short).
- Scoundreller 4y ago> Where are you going to get that from? Solar panels...? The usual answer is: nuclear power that is too cheap to meter. Still waiting for it…
- AYBABTME 4y agoIt's mostly non-sense in North America. In places like Japan, Korea, it makes a ton of sense. High population density, with relatively little arable land.