6 ms·
Wind and solar are now beating coal in the US
- yobbo 4y ago> including biomass, geothermal, and hydropower) is considered, renewables accounted for nearly a quarter (24.1%) of total generation and outproduced coal by 50.8%. Electrical production by the mix of renewables also surpassed that of nuclear power by 21.9%. Renewables: 24.1% Coal: 16% Nuclear: 19% Other non-renewables: 41%
- fitzie 4y agoeveryone cheers the demise of coal, and it is certainly the dirties modern energy source, but this is clearly a dangerous direction until we have enough grid level energy storage. we pay insane amounts for electricity compared to the rest of the world and we think it's due to a greener future, but it really is just bad policy. look how hard it is to get virtual power plants approved in this country or politicians turning off nuclear power generators.
- babelthuap 4y agoI've experienced a few major hurricanes in my life. Wind and solar will not beat anything in a major storm. It's ok to put all your eggs in one basket but you better defend that one basket as the saying goes. Who's taking down all the solar farms and wind farms before a hurricane? Might want to figure this out first before putting all the eggs in one basket.
- danans 4y ago> Who's taking down all the solar farms and wind farms before a hurricane? Nobody. Wind turbines blades can be locked to prevent damage in very high winds [1]. Many offshore turbines are already designed to withstand very high winds (like in the North Sea) and still operate. Practically speaking a few solar panels might be damaged in a hurricane but not likely the entire array. The damaged panels can be easily replaced. 1. https://www.energy.gov/eere/articles/wind-turbines-extreme-weather-solutions-hurricane-resiliency https://www.energy.gov/eere/articles/wind-turbines-extreme-w...
- Etrnl_President 4y ago[dead]
- epistasis 4y agoDo you think that wind farms and solar farms have not survived hurricanes? You might want to check on data before making smug and condescending false assertions.
- Etrnl_President 4y ago[dead]
- babelthuap 4y agoI know they do not because I have lived through several CAT 4/5 storms and have seen them fail. Also a brutal freeze in Houston recently where EVERYTHING failed to include wind turbines that froze solid. I'm for solar and wind but fossil fuels are still needed as a backup plan (another basket of eggs). Gotta have it. I survived the hard freeze in Houston with no electrical power with stored gasoline and a couple of generators for 5 days no problem. I just fueled up the other day. With additives the fuels last several years. Good to go for a freeze or a major storm for a couple weeks.
- ubermonkey 4y agoYou're going to need to show me a cite that wind turbines freezing was a major part of the problem during the big Texas freeze a couple years ago. Just because Abbott says it was doesn't make it so; he was outright lying (as he often does). It is more accurate to say that the real problem was the failure of ERCOT & etc to winterize any part of the grid, which led to failures of transmission and/or generation across the board, for every source type. https://www.texastribune.org/2022/02/15/texas-power-grid-winter-storm-2021/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/02/15/texas-power-grid-win... Gas is the biggest source of power in Texas. While all power sources were poorly winterized, the failure to prepare the fossil fuel infrastructure hurt the most because gas provides more power than wind or solar in the Texas grid. And, of course, almost NOTHING has been done about this failure despite how close the state came to a weeks-long power grid failure, and virtual no one has been held responsible.
- kube-system 4y agoThe problem you have in TX is that your utility providers haven't designed their equipment to work in cold temperatures. In parts of the country where we plan for cold weather, our natural gas flows and our wind turbines spin in the winter.
- 123pie123 4y agoplease explain "one basket" in a major storm context? are there storms that cover the entire US at the same time? or are there no interconnecting power cables between wind/ solar farms from different states? (ie other states farms still continue to function whilst one area is not)
- danaris 4y agoActually, Texas has made quite a big thing out of not connecting their grid to anyone else's. Because They're Real Men Who Go It Alone. Of course, that means when there is a natural disaster in Texas (with the existing, largely-fossil-fuel-powered grid!), they...can't really get help from anyone else. (My hazy understanding is that there are a few limited-duty linkages that can be activated, or something, but it's woefully inadequate to serve the whole state.) IIRC, the last time this happened, the only parts of Texas that were still getting power were a few that had wind & solar plants going. Because those were still operating just fine.
- tomxor 4y agoIf anything, a single solar farm, or single wind farm is more resilient due to being more distributed. Individually damaged solar panels and wind turbines do not necessarily take all power production offline for that site. Power lines are more likely to be a single point of failure, but that's the same for all power distribution.
- babelthuap 4y agoHave you ever experienced a CAT 4 or 5? There won't be much left standing. It looks like a nuclear blast. This is just wind damage. I've seen water move entire homes a mile with the height of water being as high as 30ft. It can take weeks to months to restore electrical power. To clean the mess up takes heavy machinery run by fossil fuels. And what if you want to start doing repairs to your property that may not be damaged that bad? You will need a gas generator. Solar will not cut it doing heavy power tool work hours on end...meh.
- shortcake27 4y agoSo your point is that the grid shouldn’t be powered by renewables because in a disaster you need to drive petrol powered vehicles and run a generator?
- fauxpause_ 4y agohttps://electrek.co/2023/03/14/cat-5-hurricane-proof-wind-turbines-gulf-mexico/ https://electrek.co/2023/03/14/cat-5-hurricane-proof-wind-tu...
- shadowgovt 4y agoMuch of the time required to restore power after a major storm is grid repair. More distributed wind and solar farms would imply less need to fully-connect the grid to get people back online.
- kube-system 4y agoElectricity generated by coal also requires power lines.
- 4y ago
- shortcake27 4y agoI’m confused about what your point is. Coal powerplants aren’t immune from natural disasters and is quite literally putting all your eggs in a very small basket. Distributed systems such as wind/solar distribute the risk across a larger area which seems to be the exact thing you’re in favour of.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoIn addition, would you like home solar for the week of downed power lines after the hurricane, or not? So many low intelligence likely astroturfing comments in this thread. Thing is, you know wind solar is winning the war because irrational AstroTurfing is all that can be parroted in response.
- usefulcat 4y agoTexas gets hit by hurricanes regularly yet still manages to generate a decent amount from wind and some from solar too. A lot of the turbines are near the coast--where there's more wind, and also more risk from hurricanes. About 1/3 of the electricity consumed in the state as I write this is being generated by renewables. That's with mild temperatures and lower than average wind generation. On a day like today with more typical winds it would probably be about half from renewables. http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_conditions.html http://www.ercot.com/content/cdr/html/real_time_system_condi...
- EamonnMR 4y agoBe pretty cool if a wind farm could be tough enough to run normally during a hurricane, though you'd need a lot of storage.
- babelthuap 4y agoYes. Exactly. What if they could retract into the ground? Now that would be awesome and a real advancement. Protect that bag of eggs!
- 123pie123 4y agowhat is this obsession with eggs and "green" energy are you trying to do some sort of propaganda thing implying green energy is fragile? fwiw - they're not, they're designed to a seriously stronge even in hurrican weather, but never let your personal opinions get in the way of your misinformation or story
- dukeyukey 4y agoI suspect wind turbines are already designed to deal with high winds, especially if you're building them in hurricane-prone areas.
- outworlder 4y agoAnd immensely strong turbines (aka expensive). We could do it, but there would be no point.
- kasperni 4y agoThe areas on earth where Tropical Cyclones occur are pretty limited [1]. And most of it is deep ocean where you wouldn't place wind turbines (or solar panels) anyway. [1] https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/learn-about/weather/types-of-weather/hurricanes/location https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/weather/learn-about/weather/typ...
- kube-system 4y ago> Who's taking down all the solar farms and wind farms before a hurricane? Just one more thing for ERCOT to add to their todo list after they shut down the gas power plants. But on a serious note, this is the most diverse the grid has ever been.
- nl 4y agoWorth noting in this context that the second worst energy disaster of all time (Fukushima) was caused by a natural disaster. If they'd been using green energy (or to be fair gas or coal) people would have been able to return to their homes by now. Wind farms are designed to survive hurricanes anyway. See https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-31/harvey-pushed-this-texas-wind-farm-all-the-way-to-the-max#xj4y7vzkg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-31/harvey-pu... There's some evidence that large off-shore wind farms reduce the severity of hurricanes too: > A large array of offshore wind farms can have significant impacts on precipitation during a hurricane. This claim is proven through a series of simulation cases, with different layout configurations, inter-turbine spacings, and wind farm parameterizations. Precipitation is found to be reduced inland and increased offshore in all the wind farm simulations. However, the amount of precipitation reduction varies in the different cases. The location of the wind farm also matters. https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aad245#erlaad245s4 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/aad245#...
- Vecr 4y agoThere's no actual reason why Fukushima should have been evacuated (beyond flooding, electricity loss, etc. caused by the tsunami, of course). The natural background radiation of the area is low, so outside the bounds of the plant the radiation is and always was fine, knowing that the radiation would go down over time.
- nl 4y ago> There's no actual reason why Fukushima should have been evacuated This is completely untrue. Even outside the exclusion areas there are signs of the damage the disaster has caused. The Japanese government has raised the acceptable radiation limit for people living in the area from 1 to 20 milliSieverts per year. No-where else is this amount considered acceptable. Even with this increase it's still dramatically below the measured amounts, which is up to 0.04 microSieverts per hour. > doctors have left the area because the government refuses to reimburse them when they list radiation sickness as the cause for nose bleeds, spontaneous abortions, and other ailments resulting from ionizing radiation. (The only acceptable diagnoses are so-called “radiophobia,” nervousness, and stress.) The spike in thyroid cancer among children in Fukushima is dismissed as a survey error, produced by examining too many children. https://thebulletin.org/2021/03/fukushima-today-im-glad-that-i-realized-my-mistake-before-i-died/ https://thebulletin.org/2021/03/fukushima-today-im-glad-that...
- herlitzj 4y agoNo one has to take anything down. Babcock Ranch weathered Hurricane Ian (cat5) just fine. Didn’t even lose power. Unlike their neighbors. https://www.cnn.com/2022/10/02/us/solar-babcock-ranch-florida-hurricane-ian-climate/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2022/10/02/us/solar-babcock-ranch-florid...
- merpnderp 4y agoThis is great, but keep in mind firming cost of renewables is quite expensive and not carbon friendly.
- shadowgovt 4y agoWhat is "firming cost of renewables?"
- acidburnNSA 4y agoProviding reliable power when it's dark and/or still.
- shortcake27 4y agoWhat’s your definition of carbon friendly? Wind turbines generate an equivalent of 5-26 grams of CO2 per kWh over their operating lifespan. Is it zero? No. But it’s significantly better than coal powerplants which generate 437-758 grams of CO2 per kWh.
- ricardo81 4y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/493797/estimated-levelized-cost-of-energy-generation-in-the-us-by-technology/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/493797/estimated-leveliz... - Estimated unsubsidized levelized costs of energy generation in the United States in 2021, by technology (in U.S. dollars per megawatt hour) The thing is, wind/solar costs have been decreasing and also have a predictable ongoing cost. Fossil fuel prices are volatile.
- sxcurry 4y agoCould you show some facts please? Everything I’ve seen shows the cost of solar especially to be much lower than carbon based generation.
- WheatMillington 4y agoThe word "firming" is important. Wind and solar cannot produce base load electricity.
- RC_ITR 4y agoThe problem is that they need to beat natural gas.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAt current rate of growth, that'll take (40%-16%)/6% = 4 years. Or 3 years if you include hydro.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoIf you look at the California grid, you’ll find out that the first 50% is the easy 50%. No grid runs on low-carbon sources that’s not hydro or nuclear today. The last 50% is a major challenge both in infrastructure and gCO2/kWh, as storage is not free in that regard.
- Bilal_io 4y agoBaby steps
- tenpies 4y agoIf they really want to be "green" then the don't just have to beat NG, they have to lap it several times. The issue is steel, which is a cornerstone of "green" energy. That steel must be made with metallurgical coal and while there are alternative processes, they require hydrogen. Hydrogen is currently impossible to generate efficiently (from an energy perspective), much less a cost-effective manner. Hydrogen will also need to be generated without fossil fuels, which is how most hydrogen today is generated. I see prices going up in the "green" future.
- retrac 4y ago> Hydrogen is currently impossible to generate efficiently (from an energy perspective) Thermolysis of water at high temperature directly driven by a nuclear reactor. Roughly a thousand tonnes of hydrogen per gram of uranium. Admittedly, this is somewhere between entirely theoretical and barely prototyped at the kilowatt scale in research reactors. But Atomic Energy Ltd. of Canada was investigating it as an application of their next generation CANDU design before it was shelved. Or use some other source of heat. Concentrated solar power has been proposed. https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-thermochemical-water-splitting https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/hydrogen-production-th... The economics are not necessarily favourable vs. fossil fuels. But they're not horrible either. Even something more conservative, like standard electrolysis of water, driven by traditional nuclear power, would be something like 2x - 5x more expensive than current hydrogen sourced from natural gas. In locations where electricity is very cheap, it is sometimes competitive already. Fossil fuel prices never really represented their full cost. We were paying far more than we thought.
- beastman82 4y agoheadline gore. Beating them at what? toxic waste generation?
- kalkr 4y agoProbably at the thing they're designed to do (generate electricity)
- shadowgovt 4y agoGenerating capacity.
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> Wind and solar combined now provide more generating capacity and produce more electricity than coal in the US, according to new data from the EIA
- otherme123 4y agoI bet coal still beat anything at toxic waste generation: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-radioactive-than-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/coal-ash-is-more-...
- VintageCool 4y ago> Together, wind and solar provided 16.1% of US electrical generation in the first two months of 2023; by comparison, electrical generation by coal dropped by 32.7% and provided 16.0% of total US electrical generation.
- nightski 4y agoI'd be curious, is this at the expense of coal? Or has demand just grown because of cheaper electricity due to more supply being available.
- philipkglass 4y agoCoal generated electricity peaked in the United States in 2007. Since then it has dramatically declined both percentage-wise and absolutely: https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-in-the-us.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-... https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.php?t=table_6_07_a https://www.eia.gov/electricity/monthly/epm_table_grapher.ph... In 2022 coal generated electricity was down to 854 terawatt hours from 2,016 terawatt hours in 2007. It's declining even more this year: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=55960 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=55960 In our March Short-Term Energy Outlook, we forecast the wind share of the U.S. generation mix will increase from 11% last year to 12% this year. We forecast that the solar share will grow to 5% in 2023, up from 4% last year. The natural gas share of generation is forecast to remain unchanged from last year (39%); the coal share of generation is forecast to decline from 20% last year to 17% in 2023.
- kube-system 4y agoThe increase of natural gas has been at the expense of coal. Many existing coal plants can be converted over to run on gas, which became economically viable as the shale boom has made natural gas more plentiful and it is easier to meet emissions standards. https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=44636 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=44636
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt's more complicate than that, because the renewables replace natural gas utilization much quicker than they replace natural gas capacity. Your link is about capacity, and it is not clear how much it has been used.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- learn_more 4y agoWind and solar are parasites. They can't exist without the fossil fuel energy sources handling the times when the wind doesn't blow and the Sun doesn't shine. Like the employee who gets all the easy shifts and never works weekends.
- oblio 4y ago1. Only a part of energy consumption is base load, the rest fluctuates anyway... mostly with the day/night cycle (shocker!). 2. The Sun always shines somewhere, the wind always blows somewhere. It's not just about your personal backyard, ironically named "learn_more". 3. We have the thing called The Grid™, and electricity transportation at far distances is very efficient. Building these long distance connections is cheaper than you'd expect.
- yobbo 4y agoBut what the parent is saying is true. Production from wind and solar is random and doesn't work without corresponding guaranteed (controllable) capacity, unless you are willing to accept so-called brown-outs and black-outs. (Increasing installed capacity of these random generators is not a solution since it leads to situations where the production exceeds demand ... which puts very different demands on the infrastructure.)
- jtaillon 4y agoWhat a strange take. It reads as "nothing is worth improving on if it cannot 100% completely replace the thing that we're trying to get rid of". If we can reduce our dependence (say 50%) on a power source that has huge negative externalities, isn't that a worthwhile effort?
- outworlder 4y agoI've seen this kind of thinking very often. Like the controversy when traffic light bulbs were replaced and incandescent were phased away in favor of LEDs. In some places where it gets very cold they got obstructed by ice. Because incandescent bulbs were so inefficient and generated so much heat, they didn't have the same "problem". So, because they could not handle the few days where this was a problem (just because it's cold, doesn't mean ice will form there), people were arguing that they were a bad idea. It didn't matter that for 300+ days they would save a lot of energy. It didn't matter that they were better (and in most locations this would never even be a problem in the first place). It mattered that they were different and had different issues that needed to be solved. In those places, having a different design (or adding a heating element, only active when temps were low) would solve the remaining problem. I've seen this sort of thinking in corporate settings too. A vastly inferior solution stays in place because a new solution doesn't solve all problems people can possibly think of - even when the existing solution doesn't solve them either! It boggles the mind.
- csense 4y ago1. What do we do if people want to use electricity, but the wind's not blowing and the sun's not shining? 2. What will happen to people and places who were economically dependent on coal mining? Something tells me the factories for solar panels and wind turbines aren't being built in West Virginia -- or perhaps not in the US at all. And I'm sure they require a completely different skill set.
- oblio 4y ago> 2. What will happen to people and places who were economically dependent on coal mining? Something tells me the factories for solar panels and wind turbines aren't being built in West Virginia -- or perhaps not in the US at all. And I'm sure they require a completely different skill set. What nobody really wants to tell you, the same thing happens that happened to people in deindustrializing area. As a group, they get stuck in poverty. The problem is... we can't really do much about it. Progress needs to happen, especially in this case. Everybody keeps yapping about it but in practice only the longshoremen, through their very powerful unions, managed to have a decent transition when their jobs died out. Everybody says "we should so something" but nobody's willing to sacrifice their money to actually do anything.
- perardi 4y ago1. It’s a very complex problem…and the solution isn’t coal. Because natural gas is cheaper than coal, and less polluting. 2. We build a robust safety net with worker retraining and…haha, I can’t even finish that sentence. It’s the same thing that tends to happen to the working class: nothing good.
- reidjs 4y agoFor 1, is it possible to fallback to non-renewables?
- quags 4y ago1) I don’t see how this is a problem. First we are not only dependent on these and have a mix of natural gas , nuclear as well as coal. Out of all coal is the dirtiest for direct pollution into the atmosphere. If we can reduce or eliminate coal by replacing it with wind and solar that is a good thing. Technology will improve to improve storage. 2) while this is an issue coal has been declining for some time. There are health issues with coal and the jobs have been shrinking and half of coal jobs have been lost since 2012. This is with coal usage higher today. The jobs will continue to be reduced regardless. Part of the 2 trillion dollar infrastructure plan includes training and assistance for jobs like coal miner lost. That is the best solution possible for jobs that will not exist in 100 years unless there is suddenly a new purpose for coal. Nacco industries for example is expecting the closing of one mine and plant this year in Texas. It is attempting to diversify into lithium and other minerals. There is a small fight from at least one state senator that may keep it another year but over all it’s not economically viable to keep it with other alternatives.
- alakep 4y agoThis is why climate accounting startups are dumb. Soon, very soon, clean energy and electric cars will literally be cheaper. Why track carbon credits anymore?
- danans 4y agoWe are far away from eliminating all CO2 emissions and GHGs are emitted from far more than EVs. Factories, commercial facilities, agricultural, all emit a lot of CO2. Not accounting GHGs at this point is just pretending those emissions don't exist.