10 ms·
Tesla Again Paints a Misleading Story with Their Crash Data
- clouddrover 4y ago> Tesla’s number give a very incorrect impression — so incorrect that it is baffling why they publish them when this has been pointed out many times by many writers and researchers. It isn't baffling, it's completely in character. Bullshitting is standard operating procedure for Tesla. It's simply the nature of the company. For example, Musk recently proclaimed "FSD soon!": https://insideevs.com/news/663396/elon-musk-tesla-fsd-potentially-solved-2023/ https://insideevs.com/news/663396/elon-musk-tesla-fsd-potent... And that's not new: https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-promises-full-self-driving-next-year-for-th-1848432496 https://jalopnik.com/elon-musk-promises-full-self-driving-ne... In 2016 Tesla claimed that all Tesla cars being produced "have the hardware needed for full self-driving capability at a safety level substantially greater than that of a human driver". That was a lie too: https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now-have-full-self-driving-hardware https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-tesla-cars-being-produced-now... Tesla will keep lying until the lies stop working, but there do indeed appear to be suckers born every minute.
- valine 4y agoPredicting when an algorithmic problem will be solved is a fools game. I don’t think Musk was intending to deceive with FSD, he’s just wildly over optimistic and partially blinded by the financial upside. That being said, just because they have repeatedly failed to predict when “FSD” will be solved, doesn’t mean they aren’t making progress. I’ve been very happy with their latest v11 release, it’s drives so freaking smoothly on the highway.
- clouddrover 4y ago> I don’t think Musk was intending to deceive with FSD, he’s just wildly over optimistic When he does it year after year after year it's no longer "optimism", it's just bullshit and lies.
- ra7 4y agoYou can’t be “wildly over optimistic” for 8 years in a row. That’s just called lying and deliberately misleading, especially when financial upside is involved.
- valine 4y agoI’d agree if it was a grift if Tesla was sitting on their hands and not making progress. Eight years really isn’t that long when it comes to solving hard problems. Tesla has a long attention span, and personally I think that’s a virtue which significantly increases their odds of success.
- ra7 4y ago> Eight years really isn’t that long when it comes to solving hard problems. I agree. But it seems Tesla and Musk don’t. Because Musk said in 2016 that autonomy is a “solved problem” and has been saying every year that they will have FSD by the end of the year.
- simondotau 4y agoYes, Musk said that in 2016. In 2016, Uber predicted it was just a few years away.[0] In 2012, Google predicted driverless cars for all by 2017.[1] In 2015, BMW predicted we'd have driverless cars by 2020.[2] In 2016, industry analysts and self driving experts predicted 2019.[3] [0] https://www.businessinsider.com/travis-kalanick-interview-on-self-driving-cars-future-driver-jobs-2016-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/travis-kalanick-interview-on... [1] https://www.theregister.com/2012/09/25/google_automatic_cars_legal https://www.theregister.com/2012/09/25/google_automatic_cars... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/sep/13/self-driving-cars-bmw-google-2020-driving https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/sep/13/self-driv... [3] https://www.businessinsider.com/report-10-million-self-driving-cars-will-be-on-the-road-by-2020-2015-5-6 https://www.businessinsider.com/report-10-million-self-drivi...
- ra7 4y agoThe difference is they didn’t take money from customers to deliver a promise at a future date.
- d23 4y ago> I don’t think Musk was intending to deceive with FSD If it were an outlier event, sure. But his entire motive seems to be to deceive; he's pathologically disingenuous. He has not earned the benefit of the doubt.
- ajross 4y agoArticle from 2020. There are something like 2.5x more Teslas on the road now than there were then. Needless to say the promised safety evidence never arrived. As far as anyone can tell then, and can tell now, the cars are in fact very safe. This is all so tiresome at this point.
- ra7 4y agoArticle is from today, not 2020. Tesla released new statistics.
- clouddrover 4y ago> Article from 2020. So.. an article from 2020 references the quarterly safety report for Q4/2022? You might want to check your dates.
- KomoD 4y ago> Apr 26, 2023,08:00am EDT
- guardiangod 4y agoThe article could be summarize as "Tesla used airbag deployment rate as accident rate. Airbags are mostly deployed in highway accidents so this is not a good metric. Tesla should release the raw data. FSD is bad." So many words for nothing we don't already know about. Also a bit ironic that the picture the author chose for highlighting FSD crashes didn't happen on a freeway.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe big deal about FSD is that unlike autopilot, it isn't restricted to freeways, so the picture makes sense. Your summary is missing many important details.
- bradtemp 4y agoIf you read the press yesterday you would see that the large majority of articles took Tesla's report at face value, so it needed much more explaining than you imagine.
- ndsipa_pomu 4y agoI keep hearing horror stories about Tesla vehicles and I'm amazed that they're allowed on public roads (in the U.S.) with what appears to be alpha-level software. I appreciate that the FSD mode is only to be used with the driver constantly monitoring and being aware, but that's an unrealistic expectation of people, not to mention a strange interpretation of "full self-driving".
- brianwawok 4y agoSo that's a good hunch. Where is the data showing that Tesla software is causing more crashes than say people driving base? Without data, why are you thinking that something should be not allowed on the roads? Opinions without data are just that.. opinions. Would be a pretty terrible way to regulate.
- NhanH 4y agoWait what? Tesla should be the one providing the data showing that it is safe for their software to be on the road, not the other way round. Vehicles have always need to be regulated to be on the road, rather than retroactive ban after they kill a bunch of people.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> rather than retroactive ban after they kill a bunch of people. I grew up in the US, in the 1970s-80s, when we had [optional] seatbelts, that would cut you in half, and snap your spine, exploding [leaded] gas tanks, glass that would slice you to ribbons, and steering wheels that would impale the drivers. It's always been retroactive. Ralph Nader made his name on Unsafe at Any Speed[0]. Money speaks very loudly in the US, and we have always been willing to sacrifice quite a few things (as long as the non-money-makers are making the sacrifices), and take huge risks (as long as the non-money-makers are taking the risks), for money. It's just the way we are. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsafe_at_Any_Speed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsafe_at_Any_Speed
- 4y ago
- pmorici 4y agoLots of things here are no longer true. For example FSD does work on the highway now not just city streets. Also note this is written on Fobes’s contributor aka blog platform also known for pumping crypto schemes and other nonsense points of view under the banner of “opinion” pieces from people who have no affiliation with Forbes. I’d guess we are seeing this here today because someone decided it was a good day to FUD the company so they can make a buck shorting the stock. Bottom line, Teslas are incredible cars and most people that have bad things to say about them seem to never have owned one.
- ra7 4y ago> Lots of things here are no longer true. For example FSD does work on the highway now not just city streets. FSD on highways has only been released recently. This report is as of Q4 2022. In fact, Tesla themselves say “FSD beta engaged in mostly non-highway miles” in the report. > I’d guess we are seeing this here today because someone decided it was a good day to FUD the company so they can make a buck shorting the stock. Ah, FUD and shorting. A classic and predictable response to anything negative about Tesla.
- optimiz3 4y agoBoth can be true.
- decafninja 4y agoThe Tesla investing community on Twitter has a lot of zealots that practically worship Elon and launch vitriolic crusade against even fellow "bears" who make minor criticisms at their god-emperor, his companies, or their products.
- ProAm 4y ago> Bottom line, Teslas are incredible cars and most people that have bad things to say about them seem to never have owned one. You can't argue about the stream of lies about capabilities and roadmap on Tesla. And everyone I know that owns one still complains about build quality, customer service and actual range. The only good thing I hear constantly is drive train.
- MetaWhirledPeas 4y ago> Tesla — time to accept this gauntlet. Provide real data, comparing the same thing in the same situation. Do other manufacturers provide the granular data being requested here? This feels like someone looking for a reason to single Tesla out, for obvious reasons: Tesla headlines get clicks.
- tsunamifury 4y agoOther fsd companies don’t give their beta software to drivers and say “lol let’s find out what happens” Jeeze is this so hard to understand? I live in pac heights where waze and others are fully driverless now and I am less scared of them than a Tesla with a driver in it today.
- steveBK123 4y agoYes. And the problem is that a lot of Tesla pumpers hold two contradictory positions in the forums, along the lines of: * It's perfectly safe, there's a human in charge * Any crazy stuff the human prevents it from doing, the human intervened too early so we don't really know that the car was going to follow through on the crazy thing It's too "uncanny valley" of how much rope you are supposed to give FSD. All crashes are the humans fault. The low number of crashes is purely FSD and has nothing to do with the driver heroics of preventing it from doing a dozen stupid things per drive.
- cptcobalt 4y agoWait isn't that exactly what's happening where you live? Cruise and Waymo are putting passengers in cars without drivers in the driver seat, and there is no shortage of well-reported situations where those cars have caused issues in the city—blocking roads, crashing into buses, etc. (Also, I don't believe Waze is operating self driving vehicles, but I am charitably understanding that you likely mean Waymo & Cruise.)
- rootusrootus 4y agoCruise, Waymo, and now Mercedes offer some level of self-driving where they have the liability. Tesla has no legitimate claim to any kind of FSD at all until they pick up the liability while it's in control. Zero.
- rvz 4y agoIt is already known that Tesla FSD (Fools Self Driving) is a scam. [0] The robotaxi claims are as empty as finding life on the moon as they are no where to be seen and Tesla still increasing the price of this snake oil feature to unsophisticated customers as a Level 5 FSD autonomous system. This system is begging to be investigated by the regulators urgently. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34853615 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34853615
- emmelaich 4y agoWow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brad_Templeton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brad_Templeton That's a name I had not heard for a very long time.
- bradtemp 4y agoYou make me sound like Obiwan Kenobi.
- XnoiVeX 4y agoThe author lost credibility due to his bio: I worked on Google's car team in its early years and am an advisor and/or investor for car OEMs and many of the top startups in robocars, sensors, delivery robots and even some flying cars. Plus AR/VR and software.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat means he has a possible conflict of interest, but a possible conflict of interest does not, by itself, destroy credibility. Credibility is lost when you say something that's wrong, not when you have a possible conflict.
- dev_tty01 4y agoOh no, he has actual experience in the field he is commenting on! This means he knows a lot more about this topic than most of us.
- fwlr 4y agoTesla will obviously want to make their product appear as safe as possible. Detractors will obviously want to make Tesla’s product appear as dangerous as possible. As long as they’re not outright lying, I don’t begrudge either side for obeying their incentives. The 10,000ft picture is that drivers using FSD seem roughly as safe as drivers without it.
- p4coder 4y agoAfter seeing ChatGPT and others hallucinate and make mistakes I was wondering if self-driving AI is inherently susceptible to similar behavior. Like hallucinating objects on the road and ignoring signs etc. If we can not fully understand these types of behavior for LLMs at a fundamental level, is the self-driving AI any different. Of course, it may be that the LLM architecture makes them susceptible for this, but not self-driving AI. But the question still remains, do we understand enough about it to trust human lives to the AI?
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoOh wow it’s that Brad Templeton. Cool.