10 ms·
We need female mice in neuroscience research
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- moonchrome 4y ago[flagged]
- rokkamokka 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RaimundoLS 4y ago[flagged]
- genaavrfshpxbss 4y ago[flagged]
- RaimundoLS 4y ago[flagged]
- concordDance 4y ago[flagged]
- genaavrfshpxbss 4y ago[flagged]
- Aaargh20318 4y ago[flagged]
- RaimundoLS 4y ago[flagged]
- f6v 4y agoI don’t know why it’s so difficult to understand. There’re social and biological components.
- Aaargh20318 4y agoAgain, it's not difficult to understand but you seem determined not to understand it. gender: how you feel about yourself: e.g. you could feel more masculine or more feminine, or something in between. Sex: the actual hardware you've got. Neither is binary.
- concordDance 4y agoNot binary, but pretty strongly bimodal. Using a single criteria like height already gets you an 80% accurate classifier in homogenous regions, adding a few more can easily get you to 99%. Also worth noting that "masculine" and "feminine" are heavily culturally constructed (e.g. wearing make up, long hair and dresses).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- genaavrfshpxbss 4y agoSex is binary though. We know this because there's no intermediate type of gamete between sperm and egg.
- skissane 4y ago> gender: how you feel about yourself: e.g. you could feel more masculine or more feminine, or something in between That seems to be assuming everyone “feels” they have a “gender”. Some people may know they have a biological sex, but without having any feelings about that fact. If “gender” is defined in terms of one’s own feelings, does a person who lacks such feelings have one? And I’m not talking about “feeling genderless” (as in a person who calls themselves “agender”), since that’s still a “feeling about gender”-I mean a person for whom “gender” (or “sex”) simply isn’t among the subjects upon which they have feelings about themselves. The idea that “sex” and “gender” are distinguishable is only widespread in certain cultures. A person who comes from a culture which doesn’t commonly distinguish them, the question of what “gender” they “feel” themselves to be may not make any sense give their own cultural understandings-they may know they have a “sex”/“gender”, but to them it may be a given about which it makes no more sense to have feelings than “feeling” one was born in a particular year, or born with whatever colour skin or hair or eyes
- drcongo 4y agoYou've conflated sex and gender there.
- ungamedplayer 4y agoHasn't everyone?
- fauxpause_ 4y ago[flagged]
- mc32 4y ago[flagged]
- logicalmonster 4y agoWhere should people have this discussion? Most comments on HN on this topic that veer outside of a narrow range of acceptable thoughts, even from those people that generally support this topic, are flagged and killed. It's very hard for anybody to be persuaded about any set of ideas where you see a large part of the discussion shut down. I'd be surprised if my comment that doesn't even weigh in on this topic, but merely voices support for discussion to expand mutual empathy, isn't similarly downvoted.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoProactively stating that nobody is willing to discuss things and will flag you for saying your opinion is just the weak version of flagging things when you don’t have the majority opinion to actually make it happen. Yeah no shit you’re going to get downvotes. This post does not read as asking for mutual empathy. It reads as bashing the other side and proactively claiming to be a victim if they dare to do the same to you, which they ought to, because this post does not contribute to the topic as you observe. I think you’re wrong about people’s willingness to discuss, but even if you were correct, this is not a helpful post.
- logicalmonster 4y agoI didn't say that nobody is willing to discuss things. I said that comments outside of a certain narrow range of acceptable opinion get shut down.
- fauxpause_ 4y agoThat simply isn’t true.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoFindings reveal that despite hormonal fluctuations, female mice exhibit more stable exploratory behavior than their male peers
- fauxpause_ 4y agoThe takeaway ought not to rely on a comparison of behavior stability but rather the fact that have studies on females is just intrinsically useful.
- tgv 4y ago> “People have been making this assumption that we can use male mice to reliably make comparisons within and across experiments, but our data suggest that female mice are more stable in terms of behavior despite the fact that they have the estrous cycle,” Datta said. Isn't this quote mixing up two uses of "stable"? They stuck with male mice to be able to compare to other studies, not to reduce variability within the study (which should not be a goal in itself). If this shows anything, it is that we know way too little about biological factors underlying behavior, and that variation in other factors (age is an obvious one, but there are also genes that affect this behavior) should be investigated too.
- sigmoid10 4y agoHe was actually referring to both aspects. It's all explained further down in the article: >Males also exhibited individuality of behavior, but they had more behavioral variation within a single mouse and between mice than females.
- Chris2048 4y agoHmm, what is "behavioral variation within a single mouse and between mice"? I get variation between mice, but is variation within a single mouse the range of behaviour?
- dopu 4y agoYes. Say today the mouse engages in 3 behaviors (groom, walk around edge of enclosure, then dart across it) but tomorrow spends the whole day huddled in the corner (1 behavior, not exhibited yesterday). That’s sort of what they mean by within mouse variability.
- altairprime 4y agoExpanding the article's scope from "we should study mice of both sexes" to boiling the ocean with "we should IDIC mice studies" doesn't help here. Invoking age makes researchers more resistant to accounting for female biology in their research, because it gives them a ready excuse to say "we can't afford the combinatorial matrix of sex and age, so we're just going to study healthy adult males". In a world of theoretically infinite resources, it absolutely makes sense to widen the scope of mice studies to include all possible variations of mice, by sex and by age and by genetics. In today's actual world, it does not.
- oifjsidjf 4y agoSince mice are not humans the gender of the mice might be irrelevant. So much nutritional studies have been done on animals and yet we know that different animals react totaly different to eg saturated fats and atherosclerosis. Animals are a garbage proxy for anything human related.
- slondr 4y agoMaybe we should be doing more invasive neuroscience research on humans.
- RaimundoLS 4y ago[flagged]
- RobotToaster 4y agoUnfortunately, with political correctness these days, people start whining about "ethics" and "human rights" when you experiment on human brains (fnord).
- stinos 4y agoDepending on what you define as 'experiment', there's quite some recent neuroscience research using invasive techniques in humans. Which as far as I'm aware is approved by an ethical committee, but that's not quite the same as 'whining' :)
- morkalork 4y agoThe gender of researchers also effects outcomes: https://www.science.org/content/article/male-scent-may-compromise-biomedical-research https://www.science.org/content/article/male-scent-may-compr...
- cubefox 4y ago... technically, the "sex" of the researchers.
- Zak 4y agoI'm reminded of the research from decades ago on the size of infectious particles for airborne disease transmission. Animals were exposed to droplets containing tuberculosis, producing a model for whether other diseases could be transmitted through the air. That model said COVID-19 could not, which we now know is entirely wrong. As it turns out, tuberculosis must travel deep into the lungs to produce an infection, which is not true for every pathogen. It's important to check the assumptions underlying new research and make sure they really apply.
- jamisteven 4y agoWe now know what is entirely wrong?
- Zak 4y agoThe model predicted COVID-19 could not be transmitted through the air. The model was wrong; COVID-19 is highly transmissible through the air.
- tough 4y agoThe map is never the territory
- peteradio 4y agoGood models are useful.
- tivert 4y ago> The model predicted COVID-19 could not be transmitted through the air. The model was wrong; COVID-19 is highly transmissible through the air. I'm not sure if that's the best way to put it. IIRC, the controversy was if COVID could spread through the air in the form of an aerosol or if it could only spread in the form of droplets. Droplets can't travel as far in the air, and their limitations were the basis of the "6ft social distancing" rules. It turns out COVID can spread as an aerosol, even though that was strongly denied during the early phases of the pandemic.
- seydor 4y agoWe only need identical clones . Everything else is mediocrity
- rpaddock 4y ago"… Men and women's brains are connected in different ways which may explain why the sexes excel at certain tasks, say researchers. A US team at the University of Pennsylvania scanned the brains of nearly 1,000 men, women, boys and girls and found striking differences. Male brains appeared to be wired front to back, with few connections bridging the two hemispheres. In females, the pathways criss-crossed between left and right. ... " https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1316909110 https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.1316909110
- jojobas 4y ago[flagged]
- zapdrive 4y ago[flagged]
- nonethewiser 4y agoSeems like a pretty fundamental difference
- bena 4y agoThis seems like a wicked study. By starting with 8 year olds, you've selected people who have already developed somewhat. It's quite possible these differences are developed. Partly by reinforcement of norms. We believe boys are more spatially oriented, so we treat them as such, and we implicitly train them to be, this then begins developing those pathways. But you can't run the study to see if you could develop girls in similar ways. The amount of controls and isolation required to run the study properly is a bit inhumane. You'd need 24 hour control over everything that child learns and encounters. So while the conclusions may be true, it's possible that it's not an inherent difference due to initial biology.
- ben_w 4y agoOne thing I wonder about whenever "the brains of men and women have systematically different structures" comes up, is what structures do the brains of trans people demonstrate?
- lamename 4y agoCompletely agree. Another issue plaguing some animal based neuroscience research is shoddy sample size. Understandable, given that some of the experiments are so damn challenging, but in the long run this does no favors to reproducibility. That being said, for both of these issues, grants should award more money to fund the expansion in research protocol. Expecting any change without additional resources doesn't help.
- hnrodey 4y agoPlot twist: the male mice were asked to state their gender identity and as a result the studies are still conducted using exclusively male mice. /s
- dang 4y agoPlease don't post ideological flamebait to HN. We're trying for something else here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dingi 4y ago[flagged]
- lettergram 4y agoMy wife works in the neuroscience field and has done research in this very topic. A few general thoughts she's expressed in the past: (1) Research often dismisses the sexual cycles as insignificant or play it down significantly, then generalize behavior they observe during experiments... without controlling for cycles. (2) Because of this I know she (and many others) will dismiss observational studies without replication. (3) Studying females requires extra care -- experiments involving females, should measure the cycle of each mouse to keep a record
- pessimizer 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nonethewiser 4y agoIf women are like mice and the behavior were measuring is “exploratory.”
- betimsl 4y agoDoes this mean that until now, they did experiments only on male mice?
- valgor 4y agoImagine it being 2023 and you are asking for more animals to torture. We should be demanding advancements in computational chemistry and biology, in vitro methods, and synthetic biology. Minor scientific advancements should not come at the expense of sentient creatures.
- nonethewiser 4y agoImagine it being 2023 and you are asking to torture specifically female animals more.
- valgor 4y agoWhat does being male or female matter? It is about adding to suffering in the world instead of removing suffering.
- zvmaz 4y agoWhy is the comment downvoted? Animal suffering is a legitimate moral concern, and I don't think the comment is inappropriate. Instead of downvoting, a better approach would be to point out to the author that Harvard has apparently a policy towards animal studies [1] that is worth exploring further. [1] https://research.harvard.edu/2021/02/04/animal-studies/ https://research.harvard.edu/2021/02/04/animal-studies/
- lusus_naturae 4y agoYou're right, but downvoted because it is much, much harder to do what you're asking. But it's just bad science to ignore or not want to do something because it's harder. Modeling biological or physiological systems is something we do via animal sacrifice as well. My own research uses mice. I think current versions of LLMs could be used for synthesizing the framework of such models, at the very least. It would certainly make for an interesting open source framework, and would be pretty valuable if done right. There are some options already, but they are too specialized and not geared towards systems biology or physiology. Mainly the way I think about it is that a mouse can't reason with you about why you shouldn't do what you do to it. So you, as the more analytically mature being have to make up your own reasons. Is it worth it? That would be a digression for this post. But more importantly, a lot of bad science is done while wasting away animal life. Regulatory bodies can at least do something to make it less cheap or harder to justify the use of animal models. Or at least ensure a higher standard of expectations for having used animal sacrifice.
- nonethewiser 4y agoI wonder what the variation looks like in social behaviors across hormonal states.
- leemailll 4y agoFemale research is quite harder than males using animals. The sex hormone could affect brain significantly which then ask for much big sample size. Besides due to the lack of previous studies, it might be hard to give a plausible explanation of the findings without test the sex cycle, but even with the knowledge of the cycle, which hormone?
- suslik 4y agoThe issue is rather complicated. Yes, you want to have a diverse sample, no questions here. However, there might be issues with the statistical design. Mice are territorial animals, and male mice get especially aggressive in a presence of a female. Put a couple of male mice in a cage, they'd be fine; add a girl in there, and there will be casualties. That creates extreme stress in both male and female mice, and stress is an important confounding factor in neuroscience and beyond. Grouping mice by sex in different cages is obviously incorrect - cage effect is a major factor in animal research. Not sure how these problems are solved now - maybe there are statisticians in the audience who can shed some light on that.
- digging 4y ago> Put a couple of male mice in a cage, they'd be fine; > Grouping mice by sex in different cages is obviously incorrect - cage effect is a major factor in animal research. What does this mean?
- suslik 4y agoTo simplify, this means: if you have a following setup Cage 1: male1-control, male2-control, male3-treatment, male4-treatment Cage 2: female1-control, female2-control, female3-treatment, female4-treatment and you see females responding to treatment better than males, what does that mean? It can be any of the following: 0: females respond differently to the treatment due to their biochemistry (say, some Y-chromosome gene is interfering with the treatment) 1: females respond differently to the treatment due to social effects (a male would respond to treatment but not in an environmnet where he has to compete with other males) 2: there is a cage effect (say, it is slighly warmer, or more light, or fresh breeze, or something else mice care about) that causes the animals in one cage to respond differently. Only with the above setup, you cannot know which answer is correct. Statisticians have a bunch of tricks to tackle some of the issues above. For example, you can crossover (swap cages after some time) or increase the number of cages and randomise across cage conditions (say, you have 20 cages, 10 all-male and 10 all-female, spread around the facility to cover the variability of the cage conditions). Still, you won't be able to distinguish between #0 and #1. This is not really my area though, so I want a knowledgeble reader to forgive my ignorance. I am a simple bioinformatician who was never too deeply involved into this type of pre-clinical biostatistics. I'm sure someone on HN has an answer how to properly design experiments like that. My message was that it's a bit more complicated than just 'we need female mice in research' - and I saw way too many irresposible biologists sacrificing 100s of mice in experiments where a correct inference couldn't be made.