5 ms·
Yep. This is, in part, why not only won't I ever own a Tesla, but I won't be owning cars that are too new.
by JohnFen 4y ago
Yep. This is, in part, why not only won't I ever own a Tesla, but I won't be owning cars that are too new.
- dcow 4y agoDid you know a locksmith can unlock your car, too? You should add cars with physical keyed entry to your list too.
- JohnFen 4y agoWhat a strange point. The ability to break into a car is rather different than having a constant data connection to the car.
- dcow 4y agoI’m trying to discern your point. If it’s about cars having a data connection then my point makes no sense, obviously. But your comment was in response to someone complaining about “remote control” which is just “remote unlock” (that’s all Tesla does remotely in the context of GGP). So that’s how I interpreted your response.
- JohnFen 4y agoYes, sorry, I could have been more clear. I see a huge difference between the ability to physically break into a car and having a datastream to a company that can be used to unlock the car. The latter is much more problematic -- especially if I can't choose who does or does not have that ability. This is all a subset of the problem that modern cars are surveillance platforms.
- seretogis 4y agoIt seems you're being deliberately obtuse. There is a clear and obvious difference between "well someone can break that" and "someone has built a backdoor into this thing you purchased, for their own use".
- dcow 4y agoNo, there is just no foundation to the claim that there is a backdoor in Teslas for their own use. There’s remote unlock and remote software updates, both features that are for my benefit and use. And they don’t come with some naïve backdoor that attackers can exploit. They’re cryptographically secure and don’t expose me to vulnerabilities. There’s a difference between the government legislating obscure and weak backdoors into all microchips so the NSA can spy on you, and a car company providing features consumers want, agree to, and pay for, in a secure way. One is a surveillance platform, the other is a good product. It’s silly to equivocate the two. Thats what I’m responding to.
- JohnFen 4y ago> just no foundation to the claim that there is a backdoor in Teslas for their own use. If it's not for their own use, whose use is it for? It's literally just for their use. They may promise that they won't use that backdoor for purposes that aren't for your benefit, but that's just their promise. And how do they define "for your benefit"? How secure from other attackers that back door is is only one aspect. It's important (and important to remember the truism that "if there's a way to access it legally, there's a way to access it illegally"), but not the only issue. Even if we assume that hackers really can't get in that way, the backdoor and the data collection are still unacceptable to me.
- dcow 4y agoI don't know if we’re arguing semantics or what at this point but it’s not a backdoor if it’s advertised as part of the product that consumers pay for. It’s just a product feature that needs to be secure like any other—frontdoor. If you’re not comfortable with that feature then don’t buy the car. But don’t go spewing certifiable nonsense about how Tesla backdoors your car and steals your personal data for profit. There is nothing in their terms or privacy policy that indicates this is happening, and data collection that could expose PII is opt in. Like research the product before making crazy claims… It would help me understand your concern if you pointed to the data collection and use thereof that you consider unacceptable. The way I see it, you’re essentially uncomfortable with Tesla being able to update the software on your system (which is also opt in BTW). Do you feel this way about all products that auto-update?
- ranger_danger 4y agoMost new cars do have a constant data connection though, including directly to the main CAN bus, where it has been proven that people can steal your car without a key or even disable it remotely. You shouldn't buy any of those cars either...
- JohnFen 4y agoIndeed so. And I've said clearly several times that I wouldn't. I'm not actually singling Tesla out (especially not commenting on a story that is about Qualcomm, not Tesla). But Tesla's also not some sort of special exception.
- amelius 4y ago> but I won't be owning cars that are too new. Nobody will "own" their car, anyway.
- JohnFen 4y agoI will, because there is a wealth of used cars that don't have any of that stuff in them.
- amelius 4y agoYes but at some point combustion engine cars will probably be banned.
- JohnFen 4y agoPerhaps, but by the time this happens, I'll probably have died of old age. And if it happens sooner, then I expect that there will be electric cars that, either as designed or through aftermarket modifications, won't phone home. And if that doesn't happen, then I guess I won't be using a car. Which is probably the best idea in terms of environmental impact, anyway.
- dcow 4y agoJust snip the LTE antenna in a Tesla and you have an offline car. I can't claim to know if Tesla has built in any actively hostile features like the car going into a maintenance required mode if it's been too long since a ping home, but I do know that the car is fully operational without connectivity (not including features that required connectivity, like navigation data, of course). There are even physical RFID keys.
- JohnFen 4y agoThat would count as the "aftermarket modification" I mentioned.
- jandrese 4y ago