30 ms·
I think government should be promoting workers cooperatives by waiving business and salary taxes for them. Otherwise they can't compete with traditional busines
by scotty79 4y ago
I think government should be promoting workers cooperatives by waiving business and salary taxes for them. Otherwise they can't compete with traditional businesses that can squeeze out additional value from workers at workers expense.
- derelicta 4y agoThe State should straight up take over regular businesses and make 'em into workers co-ops. And make sure to have labour courts to keep 'em operating within the republican norm. But I'm mostly dreaming.
- refurb 4y agoSo basically what happens is the workers get more money, but everything they male costs more so everyone ends with the same standard of living?
- scotty79 4y agoWhat happens now is that things produced by workers cooperatives can't cost more because they wouldn't find customers so if the workers don't want to exploit workers they won't be competitive. Tax break would give them the edge that normal businesses get when they fuel themselves with never ending rotation of exploited workers. The end goal is not to make lives more or less affordable. Just make the work more reasonable by putting working people in charge of how work is organized and rewarded, more often.
- refurb 4y agoSo what happens if a bunch of businesses then decide to become worker cooperatives? No more taxes paid? So personal taxes go up?
- greenie_beans 4y agoyou're basically explaining how this already works under capitalism.
- scotty79 4y agoYeah, no more business and work taxes. But also zero wealth captured by very few capital owners. Money stays in the hands of the workers/consumers so they have money to fund stuff bottom up or if necessary pay higher taxes. It's way easier to effectively tax the workers than tax the capital owners when it comes to it.
- refurb 4y agoSo no more external investment? If a worker cooperative needs $20M to build a factory it comes from where?
- scotty79 4y agoBank. Basically lenders not gamblers that want to risk capital for equity.
- refurb 4y agoYeah, not going to happen. Banks don't make risky loans like that, investors do. And who owns the banks? Investors?
- scotty79 4y agoBanks can also be co-owned by the workers, perhaps some less risk averse depositors. Risky is a relative term... what are banks going to do with their money if that's one of the only few investments available? Also some loans might be guaranteed by the government, like it happens with some today, if they are for companies in a inherently risky but promising industry.
- refurb 4y agoI'll be honest, none of this sounds very well thought out. If a bank tanks a risky loan, then they need a high interest rate. That's going to accumulate capital in the hands of the lenders, not the workers. And now the government is going to back these super risky loans? So socialize the loses, but privatize the profits?
- greenie_beans 4y agoyeah. also need less structural barriers for legally forming a cooperative. it's so confusing and obtuse if you want to form one, and a lot of states make it hard for some reason (we need something like stripe atlas for worker cooperatives). plus a lot of folks don't even realize organizing a business like this is an option. and a lot of folks wrongly assume that cooperative == less money / less efficient. we've been brainwashed by the capitalist organization of enterprise.
- nonethewiser 4y agoThey can’t compete with businesses because they are more expensive yet generate less profit.
- greenie_beans 4y agocan you please explain what you mean by this with some examples? there are worker-owned cooperatives that run as efficiently as businesses when considering expenses and profit.
- scotty79 4y agoFirst of you said the same thing twice because profit is revenue minus expenses so higher expenses with the same revenue mean less profit. I said the same thing that workers cooperatives aren't competitive because they have lower profit because they can't get expenses (on salaries) get that low because they can't exploit workers like the usual business does.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoAs I point out in a sibling comment, the main challenge is that they have more difficulty raising capital for creation or growth. In my experience, co-ops can be pretty efficient otherwise.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI love co-ops I think the government should do more to Foster them. I would start by waving corporate tax first. Basically the same as a pass-through chapter S Corporation. Waving salary taxes is a different story though. I don't see why someone working for a regular company should have to pay for Medicare and Roads but someone working at a co-op should get these for free. I've been on the board of directors for a co-op in the main challenge is Raising funding. If you want to start a housing Co-op or a auto repair Co-op, those both require capital. If folks want to see more co-ops, I would look for ways to make Capital more available.
- scotty79 4y ago> I don't see why someone working for a regular company should have to pay for Medicare and Roads but someone working at a co-op should get these for free. Mostly to send a message that you shouldn't work at a regular company. Unless it pays so much that you are better off even after tax. > If folks want to see more co-ops, I would look for ways to make Capital more available. Capital goes to where one can get return on capital. To get more capital to coops you need to make them competitive first.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe capital question is more complex then returns. Co-ops can pay return on Capital Lending and be competitive. The challenge is finding people willing to take on a loan. Housing is a really good example. If you have a down payment, most people would not want to use it and take on a mortgage to create a housing Co-op. They would prefer to simply buy a house. A housing Co-op is attractive for people that can't buy a house by themselves. You can band together with other people to make a down payment, but again, this is unattractive for most people because there is no good exit strategy to cash out. This is the downside of co-ops. They still take investment and risk to create. Regarding your first point, I assume you were talking about worker co-ops. I don't see why society would want to incentivize people to join them beyond the benefits that those people would naturally see from working at one. on the flip side, why punish workers are aren't part of co-ops? If it is a good deal for the workers, they should do it. If it is a bad deal for the workers they shouldn't.