3 ms·
Calls to ban books hit highest level ever recorded in US
- guntars 4y agoNo doubt made by people who would screech at any whiff of their own First Amendment rights being infringed. What are we to do about these folks? Ban the Bible for child rape content?
- dpkirchner 4y agoResponding with bans won't help -- their whole identity is tied to victimhood (a lot of them wear a symbol to that effect). I think the only way to truly resolve this is to elect better representatives/school board members, or become one yourself.
- mildmotive 4y agoThat’s such a disingenuous argument because the books that the ”book banning” critics are talking about involve visual depictions of, among other things, fellatio between men. It’s hardly anything a grownup that’s not engaged in grooming would show a kid. Calling it ”book banning” as if ideas are being surpressed or something, is very dishonest and it’s getting quite transparent at this point.
- alecst 4y agoAt what age do you think it’s appropriate to read about sex, and at what age do you think it’s appropriate to read about gay sex? If those are different. For my part I read It, by Stephen King, when I was pretty young. Maybe 13-14 ish. There’s an edgy scene at the end of the book involving the young protagonists. I read it, I thought it was odd, and moved on. If it were more a popular book these days perhaps it would be banned too. Curious if you have thoughts on that.
- mildmotive 4y ago>read Visual depictions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jowday 4y ago[dead]
- neovialogistics 4y agoThis framing ignores the agency of the teenagers who read the books. Do you think the only media in their lives are media that an adult shows them, with no capacity to seek things out themselves?
- mildmotive 4y agoDo you think that showing a minor pornography is okay because they can seek it out themselves? Furthermore, do you think that buying alcohol to a minor is okay if they can seek it out themselves?
- anigbrowl 4y agoThere's a big difference between showing something to a person and that thing being available in a library whey they can seek it out or encounter it at random. You seem to be implying that library curators are leading minors to shelves and telling them to look at something they otherwise wouldn't.
- mildmotive 4y agoThey may not be actively showing this material, but at the very least they are facilitating porn use by minors. The same way as when a person offers to buy a minor alcohol, they are facilitating alcohol consumption by minors. There is no acceptable reason to keep pornography in a school library.
- anigbrowl 4y agoYou think it's porn, many other people do not. I grew up in a hyper-conservative milieu where commercial porn was simply not available, everything I learned about sex came from books. I discovered the existence of sexuality through reading the Bible; I literally had no idea there was anything more complicated to life than moms and dads until I I happened across all these stories of people being killed for engaging in 'abominations'. Magnetic poetry can 'facilitate porn use by minors'. I think you work toward a better-defined standard that doesn't pre-empt the rights of other people who don't share your point of view.
- hikawaii 4y agoWhat is and is not acceptable for minors to access is decided by parents or by politics. This is pretty standard and applying 1A concerns is weird.
- bruceb 4y agoAlternative headline could be more inappropriate books being pushed on pre teen & teen children. If the people doing most of the stocking of books were fans of Rush Limbaugh )https://www.amazon.com/Childrens-Books-Rush-Limbaugh/s?rh=n%3A4%2Cp_27%3ARush+Limbaugh https://www.amazon.com/Childrens-Books-Rush-Limbaugh/s?rh=n%...) or The Turner diaries, I am sure a different set of people would be angry about indoctrination and would want the books out. This debate needs a lot of context added. HN I hope is more savvy than that other news aggregation site.
- jowday 4y agoCan you add some more context on what you mean by “inappropriate”?
- bruceb 4y agoDo you think there is content that is inappropriate for 9 to 14 year olds? What would that be?
- clipsy 4y agoWhy didn’t you simply answer the question?
- wizofaus 4y agoI'd definitely accept there is content that some 9-14yos wouldn't have the necessary mental or emotional development to deal well with, and that risks negatively impacting their mental health and turning them towards troublesome behaviour if their home environment is less than ideal. But we've been exposing kids to religious texts that are full of all sorts of horrific descriptions for centuries and it doesn't seem to have done so much harm as to justify removing such books from libraries completely. From what I've read the new books mostly seem rather innocuous - is there really reason to believe they're likely to stir up never- before-seen levels of angst or self-doubt among schoolkids? Or encourage dangerous experimentation with irreversible downsides? That there may be some temporary negative side-effects I'd think is just a price all kids have to pay learning about the more complicated world of adulthood and sexual desires etc., and you can hardly hide that world from them forever.