5 ms·
Apple cannot ban links to outside App Store payments, U.S. appeals court says
- usr1106 4y agoI wonder why a US appeals court is needed for that decision. This should be obvious to any laymen who has heard that antitrust legislation exists.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I wonder why a US appeals court is needed for that decision. Because it was an issue disputed in a US District Court case, and someone disagreed with the outcome. > This should be obvious to any laymen who has heard that antitrust legislation exists. The same decision (applying California unfair competition law on the headline question) also found Apple was not violating anti-trust law, so, your hypothetical layman would have come to the right conclusion only by coincidence, on the wrong basis.
- usr1106 4y agoMy comment was sarcastic. Of course the legal system works like you describe. The spirit of antitrust legislation is that competition should not be harmed by one or few dominant players. I would claim it is very clear that Apple (and Google) harm competition in the mobile space. If this cannot be prevented using the existing laws, new legislation is required. Monopolies and duopolies are harmful.
- crazygringo 4y agoYou might discover that even laymen disagree with each other far more often than you might think. Most things that make it to court, and especially to appeals, actually have important arguments on both sides. If it's in court, it's pretty much by definition non-obvious.
- usr1106 4y agoSo what is Apple's important argument? Hindering competition increases our earnings? We know best what the customer wants?
- halJordan 4y agoIf you want to shitpost, i guess no one can stop you. But this is the end, not the beginning. It's a little late to demand someone bottlefeed you the merits of the case.
- nightski 4y agoIt’s really sad that money always wins and the future of computing is a 30% tax from Silicon Valley behemoths. Congrats everyone we did it.
- stale2002 4y agoWell, this is just one battle. A "win" for Apple, in an individual battle, merely means that the status quo remains unchanged. They have to win every battle, to win the war. And Apple is already losing very significant battles elsewhere. For example, in the EU, with the soon to be in effect App Store laws, Apple is being forced to allow sideloading, and won't be able to charge the 300% fee, in the EU. In the USA, maybe this court case fails. But there are more court cases being brought against them, and also laws being considered that could force Apple to change anyway, even if they win the current court battles.
- acchow 4y agoApple lost the battle in the linked article
- dragonwriter 4y agoOf the 10 battles in the linked article, Apple won 9, and lost one of the less important ones. The article title focuses on the one they lost, but...
- no_wizard 4y agoI disagree its less important. A great majority of the most popular apps in the app store (not counting games) are SAAS businesses, they will benefit enormously by redirecting sign ups to their own websites. I think this will have a pretty big overall affect for developers on iOS if they can maintain good conversions this way.
- throwaway-blaze 4y ago
- belinder 4y agoDoes apple still take a 30% cut if there is a purchase made on the link outside app store, assuming it is still done on iOS?
- altairprime 4y agoPrior history from the Netherlands last year indicates that Apple offered to take 27%, rather than 30%, when payment is processed by a third party. The US judgment is compatible with that proposed practice.
- danielinoa 4y agoThat is currently unclear. Apple is likely to maliciously comply by allowing external links yet introducing new restrictions and guidelines that will dissuade developers from even trying. This would be in line with their attempt to charge further commissions in South Korea and the Netherlands after being forced allow alternative payment systems for certain app categories.
- solarkraft 4y agoI hope the EU learned from this extreme and obvious malice and won't let them get away with something like this in the Digital Markets Act.
- anonymouse008 4y agoAs a developer with more than a handful of apps on the AppStore, I can understand as one grows, desiring to move away from the 70-30 split, get better data around users and conversions, etc. This will become an interesting test if I flip. I'm not exactly thrilled about figuring out Paddle/Stripe/BrainTree/Paypal again, subscriptions and verifications, but there are a couple of struggling Apps in the portfolio that I need better data on the lack of conversion to standard price that it may be worth it. All this said, I think everyone forgets after the first year of continuous billing per customer on subscriptions the percentage drops down to 15%, from the 70-30 to 85-15, which gets pretty close to operational profit parity for small shops.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoIgnorant question: what percentage?
- throwaway-blaze 4y agothe percentage Apple takes off the top. If your app or subscription costs $1, you receive $0.70 for each sale. As mentioned, for subscriptions, the second year Apple only takes 15%, so you receive $0.85 per subscription dollar. It's even more complicated, if your company makes less than $1mm in revenue, Apple discounts their first year take to 15% also. This makes work for the MBAs at startups to make somewhat complicated revenue forecast spreadsheets.
- jjtheblunt 4y agothank you
- tzs 4y agoAlso sometimes forgotten is that although doing your own handling of payments through someplace like Stripe has a much lower percentage fee than Apple, it also has a per transaction fee that is typically around $0.25-$0.30. If the app is selling inexpensive things, such as things at the popular $0.99 price, 30% to Apple is going to be less than 2-3% + $0.30 to a third party payment processor.
- xn 4y agoIt's a fun puzzle trying to rent a movie from Amazon on an Android phone. In the Amazon app, the page for the movie will say "Available to rent or buy", but with no way to do either. Sometimes, it'll tell you that you have to rent or buy it in a browser. So then you get to try to figure out how to prevent Amazon links in the browser from opening the Amazon app. Before you figure it out, it's time to go to sleep.
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThe infuriating thing is that Amazon has its own app store, and I would happily install the Amazon app from there for a less frustrating experience, but the Amazon App Store doesn't even have the Amazon app.
- greatgib 4y agoThis is so depressing, seeing that justice does not look like to make sense anymore in face of money and political power plays. Like for the Assange case. Sure there is no proof, but I'm quite sure there is some form of corruption going on in getting that kind of justice decisions...
- dagmx 4y agoDuplicate of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35691771 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35691771 Though it is interesting how the same story has wildly different responses depending on the headline.