5 ms·
Why make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. That's what everyone is really trying to achieve. Nobody really cares about any individual
by SoftTalker 4y ago
Why make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. That's what everyone is really trying to achieve. Nobody really cares about any individual's personal data beyond using it to try to sell him something. Ban using it for advertising and it becomes worth less than the cost of collecting and storing it.
Sites can just go back to content-based targeting for ads.
- amelius 4y agoYes, and as a result people might consume a little less than they did before and that will help the climate as a nice side-effect. I guess we'll get a ban on personally targeted advertising when Chinese companies start buying data brokerage firms in the U.S.
- unpopular42 4y agoNo, people won't consume less, as long as they have the same disposable income. Unless you mean that this will hurt the economy and people will become poorer. In that case yes, they will consume less, but not sure how it can be seen as a nice side effect.
- amelius 4y agoI mean, you don't have to always buy something. You could save some money?
- wnevets 4y ago> Why make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. Probably because they think that would cost the economy billions of dollars overnight. Very few politicians would want that on their resume.
- sjfidsfkds 4y agoMeasurement of conversions (ie. did somebody make a purchase after clicking the ad) is even more economically significant than targeting, and this is where ad publishers are most afraid of losing revenue due to privacy rules. The popular commentary on this subject is pretty detached from the business. The grandparent commenter’s “ban ad targeting” proposal manages to be both too extreme while also having little effect on data collection.
- falcolas 4y ago> The popular commentary on this subject is pretty detached from the business. That’s because personalized ads are hostile in the extreme and shouldn’t have been allowed in the first place. It pits millions of dollars of psychological manipulation against our “self control”. I’d rather the economy burn than continue this unethical practice.
- sjfidsfkds 4y agoMy point is that only a fraction of user data collection is done for the purpose of ad targeting. So whether or not ad targeting should be banned for ethical reasons, such a ban is not a replacement for regulations of user data collection like those proposed in the article we are discussing here.
- bluGill 4y agoWhat is wrong with the conversion estimates they used in the days of broadcast TV and radio? Or even newspapers? For that matter conversion metrics are not useful because the real high value purchase are not see ad buy thing. They are more of see many ads for SUV, when current car gets 'old' buy SUV. Many years of advertising are used in that targeting, and you cannot easily measure conversion.
- digging 4y ago> and you cannot easily measure conversion Easily, no. But you can, at least in theory. With enough data, you can essentially tell if a customer has seen your ads, plus when and where (and not just your online ads - billboards and dealerships could be identified by using the customer's car to track their location). If they buy your car, and you see that they viewed your ads, maybe they even clicked one or otherwise browsed your site at some point, you can get some data from that. With enough aggregate data, you can begin to see correlations between certain ad viewing behavior and certain purchases. Do they actually do this? Probably not, due to incompetence. But they could and eventually will if they aren't already.
- 4y ago
- breck 4y agoGo deeper. End copyright. If we had P2P publishing, the bad kind of advertising would largely go away.
- shagie 4y agoCalifornia can't end copyright. Ending copyright as you have suggested elsewhere would take the US dropping out of several important world trade treaties and make it undesirable for any company, publisher, author, or artist that does want copyright to be here. That aside, the current copyright approach does not prohibit P2P publishing (publish with a CC0 license and you're about as disclaimed of copyright as you can be). This would do nothing to change advertising.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoThe US is unique in its enormous bargaining power. US power underlies the whole framework of international institutions today. No international treaties poses a serious threat to the US. Just look at what consequences the US suffered for starting a war in Iraq.
- shagie 4y agoMuch of the US's bargaining power on the world stage comes from the bit that companies based in the US are responsible for a sizable portion of the intellectual property created in the world (patents, software, books, movies and other media). The US (and California) profits substantially from maintaining control of and allowing its citizens and companies to likewise maintain control of the IP that they create. Lets go back to the original part of this thread. California can't get rid of copyright. Suggesting it as a way of eliminating targeting advertising is a substantial leap of argumentation without any supporting material. For copyright to be gotten rid of, this would take a concerted effort from congress to withdraw from those treaties (and you can be sure that every company in California that creates copyrighted or patented works (e.g. Silicon Valley and Hollywood) would pack up their bags from what would be the the 5th largest economy in the world if California was a state and move to the other CA a few hundred miles north. Those treaties include Berne, UCC Geneva, UCC Paris, TRIPS as part of the WTO, and WCT. Meanwhile, how does copyright prevent P2P publishing? How would enabling P2P publishing (which isn't prohibited now) get rid of targeted advertising?
- advisedwang 4y agoPrivacy is about more than just targeted ads. That is just the most obvious application. Here are a handful of other practical privacy concerns: * Negative information about you floating free (mugshots websites, revenge porn, news articles about past behaviour) * Health and other behavioural information (e.g. used by health, life and auto insurance. These days your medical info might be used to sue you in another state even!) * Privacy in semi-public places (ring cameras, uber dashcams) * Financial information being used against you (credit ratings obviously, but also being deemed a fraud risk makes a lot of transactions difficult) * Criminal history is commonly used in job applications. I'm not saying we need to go to one extreme - how would loans work without credit ratings, and CCTV definitly improves safety in some situations - but I just want to point out the range of issues at play. Most of these already have some kind of legal compromise. Also beyond practical concerns there is a principal at stake too. We fundamentally deserve some degree of privacy just for it's own good.
- gumby 4y ago> * Negative information about you floating free (mugshots websites... I know that is embarrassing and subject to abuse, but making all arrests public is an important human right. The British used secret arrests against the 1770s rebellion in north america (and not to mention long before then and pretty continually since) which is why it's important in American law, though the British are hardly the only ones to use this tactic. Even the USA has done so too, most notably in the early 2000s, though not within US territory as far as I know.
- bsder 4y agoCan we please remember that things can be "public" without being "online"? The big companies don't want you to think about this because they benefit from being able to hoover up everything with a couple of clicks. There's nothing wrong with having to show up in person at a courthouse to see arrest records. Making a human have to physically show up to make a request for a record does a nice job of adding just enough friction that you can't create these abusable repositories quite so easily.
- unpopular42 4y agoI prefer relevant ads to random ads. Therefore no thanks, do not ban personally targeted advertising.
- digging 4y agoContent-based ads are relevant by definition. Alternatively, imagine this: you could opt-in to targeted ads if you really like them. (I find it hard to wrap my head around this as a person who avoids almost all ads, but you do you.)
- ChancyChance 4y agoYou don't use your real name, you go by SoftTalker. I run stylometrics on your HN posts, then on every document archived by a data broker, including highschool/college papers. I identify you. I can then use that information to extort, harass, or rob you. At scale, anyone who buys this data can do this to tens of thousands of people with scripting. DefCon has had some nice presentations in the past about software that takes this data as input, and generates harassment scripts -- practically as SCRUM tickets -- to do this at scale. Still think privacy / private data doesn't matter?
- bugglebeetle 4y ago“Targeted advertising” is how America does state surveillance, using tech companies as front organizations, so it will never be banned.
- wdr1 4y ago> Why make this so difficult? Just ban personally targeted advertising. That would have a significant impact on the earnings of publishers & creators.