4 ms·
Huge loss leaves GM almost out of cash
- josefresco 18y ago"GM said it had burned through $6.9 billion during the quarter and warned that it "will approach the minimum amount necessary to operate its business" during the current quarter." Wow.
- omouse 18y agoWhat's amazing is that they aren't innovating and rolling out a crapton of electric or solar-powered cars or whatever else they can to save the business.
- nostrademons 18y agoIt takes a long time to roll out a new car, particularly if it uses a new technology like electric or solar power. Like years. If they started innovating when they first ran into problems around 2006, then it'd probably be 2011-2012 before new cars started appearing in showrooms. The Chevrolet Volt, first unveiled in 2007 and probably under development since 05-06, isn't expected to start selling until 2011. By then, it'll probably be too late.
- omouse 18y agoThey've had a long time to do this. A very long time. Electric cars are not a new idea. Check out the EV1 ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EV1 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EV1 ) which was in production in 1996.
- jerf 18y ago"Electric cars are not a new idea." - which supports the statement that electric cars are hard. In fact electric cars date back to the very beginning, before there was even an "automotive industry"; nobody's been able to build a practical electric car for over a hundred years now. It's hard. Battery technology has not been cooperating. If electric cars are your last-ditch hope to survive, you're just dead.
- maximilian 18y agoIt would almost seem that the battery, or even more simply, energy storage is really the problem holding back electric cars. If a company came up with a new kickass battery that was way better than what exists, they should just start a car company, or at least every car company on earth would buy their batteries as fast as they could get their hands on them.
- elviejo 18y agoThat is right. They had a commercial electric car in 1996 Now they expect to have the Volt save them which of course won't happen. Imagine the quality of electric cars they would be making today if they had kept the EV1 project going. But that is what a good part of corporate America. While Toyota was developing the Prius to be able to comply with the California 0 emissions mandate. GM had their lobbyists trying to change the law. Lobbyists succeeded, GM failed.
- Xichekolas 18y agoWell they have pretty much gone all-in on the Volt now, and have delayed or canceled all their other development projects. They are also planning to use same technology in many other models after the Volt debuts. The Volt (and cars like it from other companies) is possible now because battery technology is finally hitting that tipping point... the question is whether GM can survive long enough to get it out the door and to paying customers.
- hugh 18y agoElectric cars were a brief fad a few months ago. Right now I'm buying gas at $2.30 a gallon and nobody cares about fuel economy so much any more. Really, GM's US-based product lineup is pretty good at the moment (and don't forget, they still make the top-selling car in Europe). I'd be happy with an Astra, a Malibu, a Cadillac CTS, a Camaro, a G8 or a Corvette, and the cars I mentioned would be near the top of my list if I were actually car shopping in any of those market segments at the moment. How many other car companies have competitive entries in so many market segments? Even Toyota doesn't have a decent sports car any more. Product is no longer the problem (though it was ten or even five years ago). The problem is idiotic liabilities.
- Dilpil 18y agoYes, we could give a low interest loan (low relative to the risk of the loan) to GM. This might save some jobs and help the US economy. Or we could let GM fail, and invest that same money in energy and biotech. Many would lose their jobs, but many more would get new jobs. These would be higher paying jobs, but also higher skilled jobs. Lets not act like these loans are free. We should keep in mind that every dollar we loan to GM is a dollar we don't loan or invest in something else.
- anthonyrubin 18y agoI believe that a loan to GM would just delay the inevitable for a bit. Within a couple years they will be right back in the same situation. This seems obvious, but it makes the most sense to give money to groups that produce good results. I'm not sure what the logic is behind giving money to companies that fail to produce good results. I understand the emotion, but not the logic. That being said, I'm not in favor of any government bailouts. Removing risk from the market is a big part of what got us to this point.
- Alex3917 18y ago"We should keep in mind that every dollar we loan to GM is a dollar we don't loan or invest in something else." Don't pretend this is true, because it isn't, and to say otherwise is to be complicit in covering up a problem that's way bigger than whether or not we throw a couple bucks at GM.
- Prrometheus 18y ago
- gamble 18y agoNot sure what to think about this. On the one hand, I have nothing but antipathy toward GM for squandering every opportunity to modernize their business and fighting the regulations that would have forced them down that path. If any business deserves to fail, they do. What gives me pause is how much damage a GM bankruptcy will inflict. The auto industry represents about a third of the US manufacturing industry. If GM (or Chrysler) goes down, it may take everyone else with them. The job losses would be unbelievable. I don't really want to contemplate what the economy will look like after construction, finance, and manufacturing have all been wiped out.
- dangoldin 18y agoA bankruptcy won't necessarily kill the business. Look how many times airlines have gone bankrupt and they're still flying. What it will do is cause the business to be restructured and make it more in line with the foreign companies which have much lower legacy/union costs.
- alecco 18y agoPlease stop bashing the unions. GM has a sales problem. They can't sell any more SUVs.
- iigs 18y agoIt's death by 1000 cuts. The unions aren't the problem, but they definitely contribute, along side inflexible plants that can't be reassigned, never laying off white collar workers (until last month? wtf), not building cars people want, complete marque mismanagement (Pontiac and Chevy cars were virtually indistinguishable for 30 years), equating small cars with low quality (geo metro of the 90s, chevette of the 80s), abusive partnerships with other manufacturers (Daewoo), divesting themselves of key component manufacturing resources (Delphi) creating incentives for the independent company to attempt to squeeze for profit, a lack of commitment to quality, failure to tend successful brands (Ford's especially bad about this), fighting ecological and safety regulation instead of embracing it as a feature, coasting on their performance brands instead of cultivating new markets, and lukewarm attempts at innovation when they actually did something new. Fixing any one of those problems leaves all the rest. GM is facing downward pressure on production costs (among everything else) and the unions stand in the way. You can't blame the unions for trying, but as a disinterested bystander you have to wonder why GM wasn't firmer in their bargaining -- everybody's losing now.
- krschultz 18y agoWhy can't we stomach letting a big company die in this country? A lot of people will lose their jobs but in reality it might be for the best moving forward. Demand for cars won't go away, there just won't be a supply of GM ones. A lot of "foreign" cars are already built here anyway, let Toyota snap up the GM factories, reemploy their workers, and lets move on. The downside is that there are a lot of GM pensions out there, but if the government won't let GM fail because of the pensions, maybe the government should just take over the pensions and let this dinosaur die. How much more money would we have to spend to prop up this failing company again and again when all we really want to do is make sure a bunch of retirees don't go bankrupt?
- comatose_kid 18y agoAlthough their product line needs a lot of work, killing them would have huge ripple effects (forget about the stockholders, consider the suppliers and debt holders). So, yeah, we could let GM die, but the effects on the economy would be considerable. Why would Toyota buy GM's factories? Retooling them for a completely different line of cars probably doesn't make sense, and I doubt Toyota would be interested in selling most of what GM has today. I don't think there is an obvious solution.
- danteembermage 18y agoSometimes people wonder how the market value of a company can be less than the value of their cash reserves in an efficient market. GM is a case in point.
- mtw 18y agothe market value is tied to the amount of money that a company can generate (profitability). the profits are in theory given back to investors. this is why software companies which have very low capital expenditures have very high market value, since software companies are most of the time very profitable (Microsoft)
- etal 18y agoThe market value is related to current assets and expected future earnings minus liabilities. If the liabilities are greater than the expected future earnings, the company could be worth more dead than alive. Pension obligations are more brutal than most workers realize; the city of San Diego has had massive financial problems because of that too. It's usually dismissed by young employees (rationally), but it shows up on the supporting organization's balance sheet in a big way. And as far as future earnings go: gas prices shot up for enough consecutive summers that consumers finally adapted; the demand curve shifted. Gas prices have dropped recently, but consumer preferences have already changed, and economic concerns still aren't making SUVs and big trucks any more financially attractive. In short, investors are saying that GM should be stripped and sold for parts.
- ksvs 18y agoThe UAW must be worried. They're going to be like a parasite that kills the host if they're not careful.
- noonespecial 18y agoI think the age of big unions is past. Its an economic anchor that no one will be able to afford to drag. Time to start producing the kind and amount of cars the market demands, not the kind and amount agreed to in the last union contract renegotiation. I kind of hope the bailout doesn't happen and the "big 3" are split up and sold off into many smaller, more innovative car companies like the early days of car manufacture.
- timr 18y agoThis isn't solely the union's fault -- GM has been operating at a loss for four years in the US market. They've lost over 70 billion dollars since 2004. That's insane. General Motors, like all US car companies, has been content to survive off of government subsidy, and has been so intransigent that they successfully fought back all attempts to force them to create modern products, improve fuel efficiency, or otherwise invest in research and development. Now that the market has shifted from beneath them, the management is whining that they can't create new products fast enough to meet the "unanticipated" change in demand. They think they deserve new subsidies to rescue them from the consequences of their own bad decisions. The UAW can be greedy, and has certainly played a role in this, but I'm not eager to blame the auto workers for wanting to be paid a living wage when the management team has been systematically destroying the company around them.
- Xichekolas 18y agoWhile I generally agree with your post, I just wanted to clarify that GM has actually lost about $18 billion (or $25 billion with today's figure) since 2004. The rest of the 'loss' was simply a change in the accounting rules regarding how they valued pension and healthcare liabilities. So if you consider that $40-billion-or-so accounting change to be a loss, it was actually an accrued loss over a long period of time that was simply reported all at once. On the more general topic: I'm not a fan of bailing out companies either, but one has to be pragmatic and consider whether letting such a huge part of the nation's workforce become unemployed in an already-bad economy is wise. I think the better solution would be to let the companies go bankrupt, then create a massive program to retrain and re-employ the workers elsewhere (with unemployment pay contingent on showing up at training). The companies would eventually emerge from bankruptcy much smaller and healthier. This would allow them to focus on their electric car initiatives, and it would also allow them to fail without such dire consequences should they do so in the future.
- alecco 18y agoI don't understand how US still doesn't get it. You bail out Wall St. people who ran a pyramid loans scheme and now the company who was the worst in the big car madness. Their worse bit was selling the socially irresponsible Hummer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummer#Criticisms http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hummer#Criticisms Why are you going to bail them out and not the good tech startups? Or the sane VC, you know, the guys who risk money on new ideas that benefit the whole world economy. Judging how it is going with banks, this won't work for workers. The interest rates are not passed down to mortgages and I bet the GM bailout won't save that many jobs. Also remember what happened with the airlines bailout on 2001/2, they fired a lot of employees anyway.
- anamax 18y ago> I don't understand how US still doesn't get it. You bail out Wall St. people who ran a pyramid loans scheme It's not just the US - the EU's bank bailout was about 3x as large. The loan problem was a US govt idea - encourage banks to make loans to folks who didn't qualify under normal standards (including punishing banks that didn't do so) and have two huge govt sponsored enterprises (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac) buy many of them and "create a market". Which is where the EU got involved - EU banks and govts bought those loans too.
- iigs 18y agoOne thing that the US federal government could do to spur innovation is offer exempt categories (low volume) for vehicles that don't meet all safety or all emissions requirements. It's obvious that we don't want millions of people driving their children around in dirty, unsafe cars, but there was a lower testing / R&D burden for small companies (consider companies like http://www.arielmotor.co.uk/ http://www.arielmotor.co.uk/ in the UK), there would be a lot more opportunities for the fresh design the US industry needs, along with the manufacturing to support it. If the manufacturing industry that would support low volumes was built, it would be possible for the larger automakers to leverage those lines for JIT production of vehicles people want -- one of the big things Toyota has over the US domestics. Unfortunately I think this solution sits in the land of car-fan fairy tale -- the left wouldn't want it because it would relax eco concerns, and the right wouldn't want it because it would possibly restrict how much the larger automakers could take advantage of (low volumes, again).
- vaksel 18y agothe messed up part is that GM may be down in the crapper and begging for a hand out, but they are still looking to buy Chrysler. Why? Wouldn't you want to buy a successful car company? There is not one car that Chrysler makes that doesn't have a similar vehicle in the GM line up. Instead of pissing away billions on a crappy Chrysler brand that has been passed like a hot potato from one brand to the next, invest that money into getting the Volt out to the public sooner. Invest that money into expanding the line up to a whole line of Volt vehicles, Volt Sedan, Volt Convertible, Volt Pickup, Volt small SUV. Then spend some more cash to update the current models the new Camaro/Volt front/rear end.
- Xichekolas 18y agoWell that is exactly what they are doing. The talks with Chrysler have been called off until they find a solution to their liquidity issues. And the Volt and other Volt-like designs are getting all the attention while other programs company-wide have been put on hold. So to summarize, they are doing exactly what you said.
- ckinnan 18y agoThe don't have a "liquidity issue", they are utterly insolvent.
- Xichekolas 18y agoAh yeah, sorry. Part of my problem is that I actually believe the Volt would be great thing for them, so I look at their current problems and think: "if they can just last until the Volt comes out, they will make it". I realize that makes me a bit of a Pollyanna.
- hugh 18y agoI doubt they'll be able to sell the Volt at a big profit initially. They'll probably be forced to sell it at cost to keep the price from being too ridiculous -- and they're talking about the manufacturing cost being something like $40K.
- taw 18y agoIs there any big company that Congress is unwilling to bailout? Bailing out commercial banks makes sense. Then came investment banks. Then insurance companies. Now it's car makers? If every company gets political influence and free bailout just for being big then no wonder companies merge and want to become too big too fail - it's like free insurance.