10 ms·
Commenting on this particular troll is probably beneath the majority of us. However, on a general note, I think it is important to realize that every text mess
by bilbo0s 15y ago
Commenting on this particular troll is probably beneath the majority of us.
However, on a general note, I think it is important to realize that every text message you send, every cell phone conversation you have, every post to the CNN forum you make, every tweet you send ... is directly attributable to your IP whether you use your own name or not. With Facebook and Google tracking everything you do, whether you are logged in or not, I would go one step further, and say all of these things are directly attributable to you personally.
I would strongly urge young people to really think about what they are putting out there. Consider this, the military was doing the equivalent of credit checks for sensitive positions during the 60s. Now you need a credit check to do ANYTHING, even things that don't require credit. How long before an internet and phone background check is standard in the background checks organizations do before offering jobs?
I can tell you the military is doing this sort of screening right now for sensitive positions, but at least you are confronted about it. It still basically ends your career, but they will give you a chance to explain your posts. In the private sector in the future, they will just deep six your application and you won't know what happened. Or they'll let you in at entry level, maybe, and subsequently you'll start running up against an invisible barrier as you try to advance beyond the first or second layer of management. Or you will find resistance to you advancing into management at all.
Also be mindful, it can affect more than your professional life. Think about what the background checks for apartments will look like in the 2020s. Or what 'dating sites' will be like in the 2020s.
Please consider your future before you make comments on ... say ... Hurricane Katrina ... that might be misconstrued. Or post an opinion on ... say ... American soldiers in Afghanistan ... that could be taken out of context and viewed in a negative light.
All that said, the absolute best defense against these sorts of situations is just not to be a douche, which isn't very hard. If a guy or girl is dead...leave them in peace. If you can't say something nice...just don't comment.
- buro9 15y agoI've run forums for a long time and bullying surfaces frequently. Most trolls use Tor nowadays. Only very rarely do I get traceable IP addresses that can be dealt with in any meaningful way, and that's usually when there is an invasion of trolls for a day or two and some drop their guard. The only time I've ever successfully stopped a troll was about a decade ago when I traced it back to a uni and was able to raise a sysadmin. By and large, for the majority of forums and social sites out there (which is where most bullying happens) there is very little that the admins can do even if it's reported to us. About the only thing working is stopforumspam.com , whereby hundreds of forums are blocking IP addresses for a short while across all of the forums. It's made for spam, but I and others submit trolls to it too (when we're absolutely sure there's nothing of worth in the person and it's not just differing views).
- JoachimSchipper 15y agoTor is nice, but how long will it take until textual analysis against a large corpus becomes available to everyone with an interest? We already have fairly advanced plagiarism detection mechanisms and Bayesian spam filters; similar ideas allow author-identification. I would, in fact, be somewhat surprised if nobody has proposed deploying this kind of thing against, say, Anonymous.
- dlss 15y agoTrolls don't generally write enough for these approaches to work. From the article, we have a troll writing "Rest in piss" and "Rest in piss, you n*r". I'm pretty sure those won't personally identify anyone.
- blake8086 15y agoSomeone could use the exact same technique to write something and have it be attributed to someone else. Say you use an n-gram analysis at the word level. I can just build a tool that processes a corpus, and then as I type, suggests the most probable next word for me. I can simply accept those words when appropriate and look like a different person.
- joshu 15y agoFWIW we ended up tracking TOR exit nodes on Delicious, and then we used "account created on tor" as a flag to the bayesian.
- IanDrake 15y agoAs a real world example to back you up: One of my projects was shut down by Craigslist (NotifyWire.com). I took down the site and posted the details explaining why NotifyWire was going off-line. Six months later, while attempting to refinance my house, I was told to take my name off the mortgage application because my corporation was under legal threat by Craigslist and thus was a liability that the underwriters might cite as a reason to decline the application. That was an eye opener for me.
- joering2 15y agowow thats actually crazy! designing a simple bootstrap website that "failed" and later on Craiglist reported it somewhere that your future may depend on?? can you share some more details?
- IanDrake 15y agoNo, the mortgage broker did a google search on me, my wife, and my corporation. They found NotifyWire.com where I released the details of the Cease and Desist letter sent by Craigslist. Since my income comes from my company (though mostly from consulting activities) the broker thought the underwriters might think my income future was in jeopardy. He told me mortgage underwriters are doing web searches on applicants, which is the scary part.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>He told me mortgage underwriters are doing web searches on applicants, which is the scary part. Why wouldn't they? Why is it scary that they are?
- lwhi 15y agoBecause they have no need to declare everything they base a decision on, and the decisions they make will often be made at face-value without consideration of any other information that might offer a more rounded view.
- joering2 15y agoI agree with you other than in this part: > How long before an internet and phone background check is standard in the background checks organizations do before offering jobs? this is a typical scenario of unaware teen: he signs up for facebook, put bunch of pictures, then get in some sort of trouble due to that (stalker, troubles at work/home/school etc). That is like a cold shower. Most teens learns from first, second, third mistake. Then they stop posting photos OR at least think twice before clicking upload. Not only it would be incredible abuse on FB part to share your history in a way that your data could be as valuable as credit card history, I am sure people would stop using Facebook had known their _private_ facebook life stopped them from getting a credit card or some other benefits.
- AlexBucataru 15y ago> If you can't say something nice...just don't comment. That's great advice, both online and face-to-face. Well, probably "useful" rather than "nice", and say it respectfully; e.g. when debating an idea, arguing your position may not be seen as nice... It is all so true that what you say can come back to haunt you. It is the responsibility that comes with the freedom (of speech, in this case). You cannot have one without the other, but while it is important to understand and accept the responsibility, you shouldn't let it frighten you into giving away your freedom.
- redthrowaway 15y agoWhile your advice is generally sound, I'm concerned about the implied exhortation to self-censorship of controversial, but legitimate, views that it carries with it. Really, 20 years from now, if they're doing those kinds of background checks, will the checker care more that the checkee trolled some RIP group, or espoused support for Wikileaks? Will they care more that the checkee called someone "a fucking retard" on the comments of a blog post, or that they wrote a post arguing in favor of fighting back against cops who attack citizens? Ultimately, the obnoxious-but-innocuous comments are just noise; it's the political views that run counter to the mainstream that will raise the most flags, and which require the most freedom from censorship, self- or otherwise.
- rdouble 15y agoEach checker will not do the digging themselves, rather, companies like Palantir will offer info products like "Individual Troll Quotient" or "Online Political Summary" which will be used in the same way credit profiles are for lending. This already exists above board with systems like Klout, and in the background a number of companies sell services like these to marketers.
- gorgonville 15y ago> the absolute best defense against these sorts of situations is just not to be a douche, which isn't very hard ...unless one is already a douche, in which case it might be very hard. The behavior of insulting people for no reason, like bullying generally, seems to transmitted via anti-rational memes. Which means that the people who engage in it don't understand why they do so; they just know that it gives them some sort of psychological relief.
- dotBen 15y agoMany of us would say and do crazy things on Usenet (in my defense I was aged between 13-17 when I used Usenet). News servers would delete the posts after 30 days and there was little to worry about, or so we thought. ...until Deja News came out - a cached, searchable store of all Usenet posts, which Google later acquired. Everything we put out on the Internet can and probably will be stored by someone forever.
- stefanve 15y agothat every text message you send, every cell phone conversation you have, every post to the CNN forum you make, every tweet you send ... I don't know if it was on purpose, but when I read that the music of i'll be watching you popped in to my head