6 ms·
Negative Mass
- retrocryptid 4y agoNice. But I when I clicked the link I thought it was going to be a bunch of jokes about Boston.
- readthenotes1 4y agoI didn't have the patience to weight for the punchline
- Freire_Herval 4y agoI don't know about the friction part. Seems like friction is modeled as a force that is dependent on mass but I don't think that's what's actually occurring.
- goldenkey 4y agoVery good point!
- brtv 4y agoAlso the last one: "Negative mass is attracted to positive mass". How? With gravity 2 positive masses attract to each other. I don't know what happens if 1 mass is negative , but to me it's not obvious that they still attract. And I don't see how this relates to the previous examples. In my mind, impact and friction has nothing to do with gravity.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> don't know what happens if 1 mass is negative , but to me it's not obvious that they still attract The physics of negative mass/energy are paradoxical to the point that they mathematically enable transluminal transport.
- daxfohl 4y agoBut are they more paradoxical than relativity itself?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> are they more paradoxical than relativity itself I think so. For most purposes, we can build intuition for special relativity without having to do the math. (General is more fucked.) We don’t understand negative energy/mass enough to even do that.
- phkahler 4y agoYeah I've never looked at collisions. But if you blindly plug a negative mass into newtonian gravity F=GM1M2/r*2. And then use F=ma or a=F/m you get a=GM/r*2 where M is the other mass, and a is our acceleration toward that mass. Positive masses attract everything where negative masses repel everything. One of each held at constant separation should accelerate together. This is why I want to know if antimatter falls up. Or I guess it might fall down but repel regular matter in which case it'll be very hard to detect.
- Dylan16807 4y agoAntimatter just has the opposite electrical charge. It doesn't do anything weird at all with gravity.
- sycren 4y agoSince it focuses on electrical charge, would it be worth renaming it to Anti-charged-matter Are there other types of Antimatter that focus on different properties?
- mayoff 4y agoAntimatter also has anti-color-charge. Quarks have a ‘color charge’ (unrelated to visible colors) which is ‘red’, ‘green’, or ‘blue’. An antiquark is antired, antigreen, or antiblue (and has the opposite electrical charge from its corresponding normal quark). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_charge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_charge
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoPositive mass draws things towards it (gravity) so negative mass would push things away (anti-gravity), therefore they would just cancel out if they were the same magnitude
- at_a_remove 4y agoAlright. We are supposing for the moment that both inertial and gravitational contexts for mass give the same number. The force between two masses, F is equal to G multiplied m-sub-1 multiplied by m-sub-2, and then all of that divided by the square of the distance between m-sub-1 and m-sub-2. Here G is the gravitational constant and the number being positive indicates a force toward, say, the first partner, m-sub-1. Now, imagine m-sub-2 is negative mass. Our force then becomes negative, so a force away from the first partner, m-sub-1. BUT ... Acceleration is equal to force divided by mass. Here the mass, m-sub-2 is negative, but so is the force. And so the acceleration is back to being positive and the negative mass "falls toward" the positive mass of m-sub-1. In other words, positive matter ends up being a "falling toward" field. Negative matter, however, well, run the numbers, only do everything from the m-sub-2 vantage point. The positive mass, m-sub-1, flees! Even as it attracts the other one. And so once you have a negative/positive pair, they lock on, one fleeing, one chasing. One ends up with ever increasing positive kinetic energy, the other with ever increasing negative kinetic energy (all starts to sound a little silly here) and they cancel out, from a distance. Gets wacky once you start imagining this for charged particles, which immediately bunch up into staggering Coulombs of negatively-charged nega-mass particles, and ditto for the positively-charged nega-mass particles. They just rapidly self-sort into these clumps due to the "electrostatic repulsion" going up against negative inertia. The EM force quickly dominates. These two blazing opposite poles of charge, Q-pos and Q-neg, should naturally attract one another, but for that pesky negative inertia again. And so all of the negative mass in the universe sorts into Q-pos and Q-neg, then promptly tries to approach the speed of light fleeing from one another, leaving just the slightest of electrical fields evident, but always asymptotically approaching zero as they more or less banish themselves to the further regions of normal matter. (Some normal matter would be torn along for the ride) It's a fun thought experiment.
- daxfohl 4y agoI feel like the first example plus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_spaceship_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_spaceship_paradox reveals a need for something beyond Newtonian gravity.
- wardedVibe 4y agoThey're literally just plugging in negative numbers for freshman physics equations. I wouldn't think too deeply about it..
- daxfohl 4y agoIt's wrong anyway. The friction force would be the opposite direction, but then the acceleration due to a force on the negative mass would flip direction again. So it would slow down like a positive mass.
- gus_massa 4y agoInside a crystal, electrons act weirdly like an electron that travels with a "perturbation" around it, so the mass for calculations is not the mass of an electron traveling in vacuum. It's call "effective mass" m* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_mass_(solid-state_physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_mass_(solid-state_ph... The weird part is that it can be negative, so we already know quasi-particles with negative mass. This quasi particle with negative mass and negative charge is a fermion so it's mathematically equivalent to a quasi particle with positive mass and positive charge. We call them "holes" and people that work with semiconductors think about "holes" instead of weird particles with negative mass. Anyway, inside semiconductors they slow down and follow the conservation of energy law, they don't get faster and faster like in the simulation. The weird behavior of the simulation is not realistic.
- daxfohl 4y agoOr just realize that the formula for stopping distance due to friction is independent of mass.
- canjobear 4y agoIt's interesting because negative mass is a prerequisite for superluminal travel via Alcubierre warp drives. What these examples show is that negative mass is an incredibly counterintuitive concept, probably impossible in the real world.
- hinkley 4y agoOr we drop the Higgs field to a lower state trying to create it, wiping out the entire visible universe at the speed of light and replacing it with something new.
- tomrod 4y ago> wiping out the entire visible universe at the speed of light and replacing it with something new ... and wonderful?
- kibwen 4y agoImpossible to say whether it would be wonderful, because it would change the physics of the universe in ways that we cannot predict. Here's a good video on it, comfortingly entitled "The Most Efficient Way to Destroy the Universe": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijFm6DxNVyI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ijFm6DxNVyI
- hinkley 4y agoYou wouldn’t know because you would turn to goo.
- tomrod 4y agoLess than that, if I understand right. Perhaps quantum foam.
- hinkley 4y agoTemporarily, then you’d explode or merge together into new kinds of matter. Some of your molecules would rearrange based on the new physics. The good news is you probably won’t see it coming because nerves are slower than the speed of light. Hard to say if you’d experience anything after.
- nimbius 4y ago"Let's weigh nikocado and some balloons" Who gave this absolute savage a website, I nearly choked on my coffee.
- colordrops 4y agoSo all you would need is a little negative mass to create endless energy? How does this not break the laws of conservation?
- CrampusDestrus 4y agoShow me something with negative mass and I'll tell you
- colordrops 4y agoI know you are joking but isn't the idea that negative mass works with current models of physics?
- DiscourseFan 4y agoI think that says more about the model than the world it's based on.
- CrampusDestrus 4y ago"Works" in what sense? Nobody is stopping you from plugging negative values everywhere, but the laws were formulated with sctrictly >=0 mass in mind. What would need to happen for you to claim that negative mass "doesn't work"? Some infinities somewhere? A division by zero in some place?
- k__ 4y agoIsn't "create endless energy" just "some infinities somewhere"?
- daxfohl 4y agoEndless negative energy
- ChrisClark 4y agoFlubber? (From the original? haven't seen the remake)
- eigenman 4y agoThis is a nice exposition, but it would have been more clear if they laid out the difference between inertial and gravitational masses. So far, these two varieties of mass are equivalent in all our observations, but they need not be so. Negative inertial mass is pretty weird, as the examples illustrate; but negative gravitational mass (i.e., normal and negative mass repel according to inverse square law) would be something exciting to observe. See, e.g., https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/8616 https://physics.stackexchange.com/a/8616
- nine_k 4y agoGravitational interaction of two small balls would be hard to show. A ball that flies upwards has been shown (as a balloon). A kind of stable replacement of orbital motion, if it exists, would be cool to see!
- tyronehed 4y ago[dead]
- joko42 4y agoWould negative mass make time contraction and length dilation possible?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- xwdv 4y agoAll negative mass that exists probably moved away in the opposite direction of the expansion of the universe. It’s out there, but we’ll never reach it.
- daxfohl 4y agoFirst example is wrong. Both would shoot off at infinite speed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elastic_collision https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elastic_collision
- nojs 4y ago> Negative mass is attracted to positive mass but it pushes it away when it gets closer. Uh, what?
- firstlink 4y agoThe best explanation is that this post is two days late.
- seiferteric 4y agoI believe that is believed to be true at least in some theories, don't remember which, but basically one mass ends up running away from the other.
- atonse 4y agoJust realized. It takes infinite amount of energy to accelerate something with mass to the speed of light. Which is why only photons can travel at the speed of light, since they have zero mass. But going with that idea, wouldn’t that mean that something with negative mass can then go faster than the speed of light? Would that explain why we can never observe something with negative mass? Because it’s going faster than the speed of light? This is exactly the kind of mind games why I loved cosmology so much in college.
- pdonis 4y ago> wouldn’t that mean that something with negative mass can then go faster than the speed of light? No. You can construct a theory of tachyons (particles that go faster than light) using special relativity, but they have imaginary masses! The key is that the quantity that actually appears in the equations you refer to in special relativity is the mass squared. So ordinary objects have positive mass squared, light has zero mass squared, and tachyons have negative mass squared. (Note that this means that some of the things that the article under discussion here says about "negative mass" are only valid in Newtonian mechanics, not in relativity.)
- atonse 4y agoSo in your example with tachyons, the negative number squared becomes positive? Thanks for that explanation!
- pdonis 4y ago> So in your example with tachyons, the negative number squared becomes positive? No. The negative mass squared means the mass itself, the square root of the mass squared, is imaginary.
- bsaul 4y agoi thought this was made by friends of jean-pierre petit and his Janus model... I love the idea of negative mass ( because i love symetries in the laws of nature) but i've got a hard time believing the geniuses of the early 20th century haven't already explored the idea.
- blatant303 4y agoRelated ActionLab short: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvihUBO7rGo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kvihUBO7rGo Cosmological model with negative masses: - https://januscosmologicalmodel.com/negativemass https://januscosmologicalmodel.com/negativemass Simulation: - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJgzH99t9w8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJgzH99t9w8 Based on Souriau symplectic geometry (where inverting energy is equivalent to inverting the arrow of time): - http://www.jmsouriau.com/Grammaire_de_la_nature.htm http://www.jmsouriau.com/Grammaire_de_la_nature.htm
- daxfohl 4y agoThe thing I can't get is how it falls in gravity (rate of acceleration in a gravity field is mass independent), but pulls a spring upward.