13 ms·
'Devastating' melt of Greenland, Antarctic ice sheets found
- Daishiman 4y agoI continue to find it amazing that the destruction of the biosphere that supports human life as we know it barely makes the news.
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- tyfon 4y agoMost people are not capable seeing longer than the tip of their nose as we say in Norway. It is also very unpopular to tell people that they need to change.
- nomel 4y ago> It is also very unpopular to tell people that they need to change. Part of the problem is that the things a person can do are almost entirely negligible, compared to industry, or require systematic changes of how housing, cities, and jobs are structured, which isn't something an individual can really influence.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoAnother part of the problem is it means telling people to do the opposite of "keeping up with the Joneses".
- trgn 4y agoThis is why we need taboo-formation around environmentally damaging behaviors and nurture virtuous aspirations towards environmentally responsible spending. That is, if it means riding your bike to work, or it is a shift in ostentatious spending, from e.g. square footage to bespoke furniture, keeping up with the joneses can actually be an excellent forcing function. e.g. new england puritans were (are (?)) famously keeping up with the joneses by not buying flashy, wasteful things. Similar mindsets - that are environmentally responsible - need to take hold (and can take hold. be that example.)
- ognarb 4y agoI disagree. The industry is a big emitter of co2 but they obly respond to demand from consumer. The oil industry would not pollute as much if nobody was driving a car or flying. The meat industry would not pollute as much if we weren't eating as much meat. It's a society problem but unfortunately unless you force people to change their habits I don't see this changing.
- eecc 4y agoLots of people are calling for WFH and legitimization of remoting. Alas, it seems to be a matter of monkey power, and the managers want you to burn tons of fuel to sit your butt in the chains they provide and smell his armpits from a distance. shrug
- redprince 4y agoWhatever a single person does is except for a few cases negligible. The problems arise when a lot of people buy manufactured goods without regard for the consequences. The problems arise when a lot of people consume meat and thus create a huge demand for it. Or think that their own house in some sprawling suburb was always their dream and now they require a car too, because of poor public transport. People vote for all this with their life choices, by what they consume and literally at the ballot box. Saying otherwise is just a popular way to deny responsibility and the individual need to change.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 8ytecoder 4y agoEven friends of mine who are otherwise very conscious about social issues ignore climate change or push it all the way down. People seem to think corporations need to change and anything to suggest they need to change their lifestyle is basically drowned in cognitive dissonance. There’s also a significant amount of e we h as whataboutism even here in HN. Meat & dairy, car culture, fast fashion, consumerism especially that of low quality goods, travel, …etc are all things that could change or adapt. I just don’t see that happening.
- jshen 4y agoSadly, after seeing so many deny the threat of covid as it was killing hundreds of thousands, I’m not sure people are capable of seeing the tip of their nose.
- RandomLensman 4y agoPeople are not stupid but they also know that promises around benefits in the more distant future (50 to 100 years!) might never materialize. The physics don't even need to be in dispute for that. This all points to geoengineering at some point from a sociopolitical perspective.
- antibasilisk 4y agoWhy people insist on minimizing the fact that modern hyper-industrialized society (which people rely on to survive) is founded on cheap energy? Trying to execute degrowth at a pace and intensity that would be necessary for climate change to reduce the impact of climate change to the most ideal IPCC model would quite literally kill tens of millions in a year. Europe can barely deal with electricity becoming slightly more expensive.
- haizhung 4y agoYou’d have to think that this is by design.
- hn_version_0023 4y agoIt's seemed very clear to me the media seem to be positioning humanity for one last all-out war before the ecosystem collapses.
- idiotsecant 4y agoThe truth is more depressing - it isn't by design at all, it's by default- we ignore complex problems until they are existential threats. It's not a problem unique to modern society, it's just that our problems are much bigger now and approach faster. Our monkey brains and monkey social systems aren't equipped to handle these sorts of problems well.
- pkulak 4y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
- RGamma 4y agoAnd even worse, it barely makes the news when it concerns us. The stark reduction in ecosystem complexity and loss of animal life ("Holocene extinction") is much more concerning to me. Even though some may call it aesthetics, but that's pretty cruel in its shallowness. "Half of the world’s habitable land is used for agriculture"... https://ourworldindata.org/land-use https://ourworldindata.org/land-use
- myshpa 4y agoAgriculture production as a major driver of the Earth system exceeding planetary boundaries https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320356605_Agriculture_production_as_a_major_driver_of_the_Earth_system_exceeding_planetary_boundaries https://www.researchgate.net/publication/320356605_Agricultu... And animal agriculture is the biggest culprit of them all ... but suggest that people should switch to plant based diets, and even climate activists will want to stone you. People are the primary cause of climate change. We all want it to change, but too few wants to change.
- version_five 4y agoThe doomsday cult approach doesn't work. People wear out very quickly from having imminent destruction that never materializes pushed on them. Whatever one's position on what we should be doing about climate change, it should be obvious that regular alarmism is not the way to get people to do stuff.
- Daishiman 4y agoThe destruction is quite evidently materializing all over the world with new heat and drought records being broken constantly. A this point some people are actively refusing to see it.
- version_five 4y agoAre you advocating for just more alarmism then?
- chasd00 4y agoThe problem is timescale, the drought in California was pointed to as an example of a climate change disaster but now it's just about over. Over time the droughts and heatwaves will get worse and worse but human brains aren't geared to think on those timescales. Look at the changes in one year from the link below. https://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/CurrentMap/StateDroughtMonitor.aspx?CA https://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/CurrentMap/StateDroughtMonito...
- rufus_foreman 4y agoThere are heat waves and droughts but food production has tripled over the last half century, and the only thing I have ever seen during that period that kept the grocery store shelves from being fully stocked for more than a few days has been a pandemic.
- Daishiman 4y agoYou haven't seen it because you very likely live in a first-world country where neither subsistence farming nor farming exports are drivers of the local economy and welfare. Droughts and heat waves have a very real impact in global affairs in the Middle East, South America, India, and Asia.
- pengaru 4y agoHumans don't naturally have glacial attention spans, pun intended. The disaster is too slow-moving for human time scales to prepare for until it's too late. And our current systems of business and government aren't covering this natural blind spot when they're similarly incentivized to focus on short-term results/re-election. On a lighter note, watch Invader Zim's Walk For Your Lives [0] episode which cleverly speaks to this problem in the subtext. [0] https://zim.fandom.com/wiki/Walk_for_Your_Lives https://zim.fandom.com/wiki/Walk_for_Your_Lives
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- noiv 4y agoImagine some unstoppable force raises the water levels in your appartement by 1mm per year - starting next year. You'll probably buy rubber boots first week in January. When do you migrate?
- labster 4y agoWhen the hurricane’s storm surge enters your house. For now, the bigger coastal threat is from a longer, stronger tropical cyclone season. Moving extrema are always what you notice first.
- hnarn 4y ago> When do you migrate? Migrate where? This analogy doesn't make any sense, unless the apartment is our planet and the answer is "there's nowhere to go". It's not just about rising water levels, or temperature changes, or weather changes. It's about all of it and the fact that we're performing an experiment with no rollback that may or may not lead to the extinction of our species. Carl Sagan said in the late 80's[1], and I'm heavily paraphrasing, that by 1989 the US would have spent $1 trillion dollars on the cold war (enough money to buy "everything in the united states except the land") -- which is to say, defending against the potential threat of Soviet invasion. This was obviously a non-zero risk, but the real question is: how large was the risk compared to the money being spent, and what is the risk of climate change compared to the money being spent. [1]: https://infinite.mit.edu/video/carl-sagan-guest-speaker-sloan-symposium-management-year-2000%E2%80%9D-11141987 https://infinite.mit.edu/video/carl-sagan-guest-speaker-sloa...
- moffkalast 4y agoGood timing, the Gulf Stream shutdown will be the only thing preventing Europe from burning to ashes in the coming heat waves.
- labster 4y agoI’m pretty sure the ‘thermo’ part of the thermohaline circulation is going to dominate.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoThere are now predictions that the Gulf Stream won't shut down, but the Antarctic equivalent may, which would be just as bad. https://e360.yale.edu/features/climate-change-ocean-circulation-collapse-antarctica https://e360.yale.edu/features/climate-change-ocean-circulat... > Meanwhile the long-standing concern about a shutdown of the ocean circulation in the North Atlantic sometime in the 21st century appears to be subsiding. A Swiss study[1] published this month found that, contrary to past belief, the circulation did not fail at the end of the last ice age, suggesting, the researchers say, that it was more stable than previously supposed, and less likely to collapse. [1] - https://www.unibe.ch/news/media_news/media_relations_e/media_releases/2023/media_releases_2023/atlantic_meridional_overturning_circulation_was_more_stable_than_thought/index_eng.html https://www.unibe.ch/news/media_news/media_relations_e/media... > A new analysis by Australian and American researchers, using new and more detailed modeling of the oceans, predicts that the long-feared turn-off of the circulation will likely occur in the Southern Ocean, as billions of tons of ice melt on the land mass of Antarctica. And rather than being more than a century away, as models predict for the North Atlantic, it could happen within the next three decades. > It predicts a 42 percent decline in deep-water formation in the Southern Ocean by 2050. This is more than twice the 19 percent they predict for an equivalent event in the North Atlantic. > And after 2050, their model predicts that things will get even worse. Deep-water formation “looks headed towards collapse this century,” the coordinator of the study, Matthew England of the University of New South Wales, told Yale Environment 360. “And once collapsed, it would most likely stay collapsed until Antarctic melting stopped. At current projections that could be centuries away.”
- masklinn 4y agoWould it? My understanding was that the Gulf Stream shutting down would make European climate a lot more extreme, more similar to norther US and Canada. And “not burning to ashes” is something Canada has been failing.
- lisasays 4y agoNot to minimize, but to put in perspective (from the article): But because the world's oceans are so huge, the melt just from the ice sheets since 1992 still only adds up to a little less than inch (21 millimeters) of sea level rise, on average. Globally sea level rise is accelerating and melt from ice sheets has gone from contributing 5% of the sea level rise to now accounting for more than one-quarter of it, the study said. The rest of the sea rise comes from warmer water expanding and melt from glaciers. Though they're happy to call this "devastating", and it sure does sound bad -- that label by itself isn't helpful, because it doesn't tell what danger we're facing and how much time we have to brace for it. That is -- it's sounding the alarm, without providing specifics as to what even the approximate level of danger to anyone's survival is, in real terms. Which probably has a lot to do with why this stuff barely gets reported, and why people mostly shrug when they hear about it (on top of the psychological and other sources of denial).
- jeffbee 4y agoGlobal average rise seems like an uninteresting point. We recently read that on the highly populated US Gulf Coast, sea level rise was +5 inches since 2010, which is rather a lot. These are rates that amount to a noticeable difference in one lifetime.
- billiam 4y agoVery much so. Sea level has actually been falling on the coast of Greenland, for example, due to the gravitational effect of ice melting along with crustal rebound. But all that water has to go somewhere, and along low lying coastal areas like Florida, it will rise a lot.
- anonymouskimmer 4y agoFresh water melt-off isn't about rising sea levels, at least not in the short term, it's about the shutdown of ocean circulation. The repercussions are basically an increase in warming and a decrease in sea-life. The effects of these will be more temperamental weather, and less fish to eat. https://e360.yale.edu/features/climate-change-ocean-circulation-collapse-antarctica https://e360.yale.edu/features/climate-change-ocean-circulat... Mechanism: > The conveyor is driven by the descent of cold, salty water to the ocean floor in just two places: in the far North Atlantic near Greenland and in the Southern Ocean around Antarctica. In both regions, the mechanism is the same. In cold polar conditions, large volumes of water freeze. The salt in the water is not incorporated into the ice. It remains in the residual liquid water, which grows ever saltier. The saltier water becomes, the denser it becomes. So the residue is heavier than surrounding water and eventually sinks to the ocean floor. Consequence: > If there was no new deep water plunging to the ocean depths, however, there would be nothing to bring the nutrients back to the surface. Instead, the waters of the deep ocean would accumulate nutrients and become stagnant, while the supply of nutrients to sustain marine life at the surface would be drastically reduced, says one of the paper’s co-authors, Adele Morrison of the Australian National University. Marine ecosystems could collapse. This would not happen instantly. It might take centuries, but once in train could not be prevented. Consequence: > A shutdown would also accelerate global warming, says Rahmstorf. “The deep-water formation sites are conduits where carbon dioxide is brought down to the ocean abyss, where it is locked away safely from the atmosphere for centuries [and] currently helps slow down global warming. However, this mechanism is set to be weakened.” The IPCC estimates that the oceans altogether capture a quarter of our CO2 emissions, much of it through deep-water formation.
- pier25 4y agoEvery year we find out climate change is worse than expected and accelerating faster than expected. I'm not saying this as a way to minimize these findings but rather to point out that we should expect things to get worse. Humanity needs to act now.
- scotty79 4y agoNothing gets done until property prices are affected.
- yieldcrv 4y agoI love how the cookie popup takes up half the screen on mobile with a button saying “I’m OK with that”
- wlesieutre 4y agoI wouldn't pay much for property in Florida knowing the ongoing insurance situation https://www.pnj.com/story/news/2023/04/18/florida-insurance-crisis-why-home-insurance-rates-keep-going-up/70127553007/ https://www.pnj.com/story/news/2023/04/18/florida-insurance-...
- toomuchtodo 4y agoFlorida insurance costs were driven up, primarily, by rampant litigation and fraud [1], not climate change. With that said, insurers are starting to price in the realized risk [2]. Assuming built to modern code (post 2002) and elevation above flood and storm surge risk, homes in Florida are resilient to all but the most powerful storms (Cat 4, Cat 5). Of course, code will need to be revisited if housing must resist the occasional 200+ mph storm (primarily roof to wall attachment and roof shape, as well as shutters for doors and windows to resist impact [3] [4]; cinder block/concrete exterior walls are very common but not yet mandatory). [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-22/fraud-litigation-push-florida-s-home-insurers-into-insolvency https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-03-22/fraud-lit... | https://archive.is/Njkww https://archive.is/Njkww [2] https://www.mic.com/impact/climate-change-is-ravaging-florida-so-why-is-everyone-buying-homes-there-82748262 https://www.mic.com/impact/climate-change-is-ravaging-florid... [3] https://www.floir.com/siteDocuments/OIR-B1-1802.pdf https://www.floir.com/siteDocuments/OIR-B1-1802.pdf [4] https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/21/how-to-build-a-hurricane-resistant-house.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/05/21/how-to-build-a-hurricane-res... (one of my properties is insured by the state's high risk pool at an elevation 90 ft above sea level)
- scotty79 4y agoAre people already selling land inland and advertise it as future waterfront?
- Karellen 4y agoCosta del Lex, Luthorville, Marina del Lex, Otisburgh... Otisburgh?! OTISBURGH?!!
- chimpanzee 4y agoJokes aside, I suspect future waterfronts would be unstable and potentially toxic, due to shifting land caused by the weight of the water, erosion from the flow, and landslides from weather and vegetation loss. On top of that, toxicity may be an issue in some areas as the water overcomes man made structures (eg roadways and basements) and systems (eg sewage and fuel delivery) that were never intended to come into contact with water. But still…someone will market it.
- GiorgioG 4y agoThe sky is falling! The sky is falling! The sky is falling! Nobody cares. We're too busy trying to get through our lives. No, I'm not a climate change denier, I'm a climate-change not-care-er. I keep my heat/AC where I'm comfortable. I drive a large comfortable ICE vehicle. Would I buy an EV, solar panel roof, home backup batteries - if they were cheap and as convenient as what I have today? you bet. Persuade me with things that make my life easier, or cost me less than what I have today.
- gjm11 4y agoWell, then, congratulations on being smugly selfishly indifferent to everything other than your own convenience. But I don't understand why you expect anyone else to be interested in your lack of interest.
- pseg134 4y agoYou were interested enough to respond and so were many others. Seems like an interesting comment.
- jnmandal 4y ago> The sky is falling! The sky is falling! The sky is falling! > Nobody cares. We're too busy trying to get through our lives. No, I'm not a climate change denier, I'm a climate-change not-care-er. I keep my heat/AC where I'm comfortable. I drive a large comfortable ICE vehicle. Would I buy an EV, solar panel roof, home backup batteries - if they were cheap and as convenient as what I have today? you bet. Persuade me with things that make my life easier, or cost me less than what I have today. This is the perfect demonstration of the type of attitude that is pervasive among the high energy use, heavy emission segments of humanity. Most people simply do not like to face the consequences of their actions; they believe their lives must be constantly made easier and more comfortable as part of modernity, progress, human development -- whatever you want to call it. As became evident in the last few years, its far too late to avoid the effects of climate change. Now its a question of how bad it will get. Well as long as this is the prevailing attitude (and while I have no source to say it is, I feel this to be so), we are ensured to have no short term solutions; so we can count on a future with intermittent catastrophe. What I find most interesting about this wicked problem is that its loudest proponents also make themselves doubly vulnerable by emphasizing the importance of individualism and downplaying the need for communal response. So its interesting to me to see at what threshold the "make my life easier", "I want a big pickup truck", "I deserve comfort" sentiment starts to be the driver of demanding assistance for natural disasters, drought, famine, etc. We are already seeing it happen in parts of the US southwest, in south florida, and to some extent in the California central valley. Anyways, I would argue its wrong when people describe climate change as a technical or scientific problem. As we can see, its very much a social and cultural issue -- maybe secondarily an economic one. I think the above sentiment provably captures that.
- aurizon 4y agoI have speculated that the fracturing as well of the melting of the Greenland ice sheet could lead to large area ice slide-offs? I am not sure how rough the underlying terrain is, but I expect millions of years of abrasion by stone in ice might lead to this occuring in some areas? Ice is structurally weak, so any motion embodying fracture would break it into ice boulders/gravel - none of these scenarios look at all good - how likely are they?
- zw123456 4y agoI know I have said this before on here, but when I was in college in the 1970's... yes, I am and old fucker. I lived in a co-op house and there was this guy that was studying environmental science, which was a new thing back then. He explained global warming to me, the whole Co2 thing etc. I listened, and I said, I am sure that we will do something before then. that will address it. He was predicting exactly what has happened. It's not a new idea or a surprise, it's the classic frog in the pan of boiling water. I was wrong, no one has done anything. Or certainly not enough. Listen to the scientists.
- moffkalast 4y agoClimate scientist's journal, October 12th, 2045. Broken AC unit in alley this morning. Ambient temperature burst coolant loop. This city's afraid of tomorrow. I've seen its true face. The streets are extended beaches and the beaches are full of plastic and when the seas finally rise all the vermin will drown. The accumulated filth of all their emissions and pollution will foam up about their waists and all the deniers and oil execs will look up and shout 'SAVE US!'...and I'll look down and whisper 'No.'
- moltar 4y agoSo it got worse in the last couple of years just as the whole world was on pause. So maybe it’s not caused by humans then?
- wilg 4y agoAny intellectually honest person should be able to spot the flaws in your reasoning here.
- antibasilisk 4y agowhen i moved my hand and let go of the ball the ball kept going so balls spontaneously fly actually
- layman51 4y agoSearch for “aerosol masking effect”. It seems like it is generally accepted that small particles floating around in the air would help cool the planet down. It seems likely that this would be a geoengineering approach. When the world was generally on lockdown, I suppose there was much less air pollution and so the lack of the aerosol effect caused the problem to get worse. Now that I think about this, we are in a big dilemma because the efforts to stop air pollution could help make climate change be worse.
- merpnderp 4y agoBlame those who chose coal over nuclear in the 70’s. That choice killed millions from air pollution, gave us global warning, and stole a future of cheap plentiful energy.
- madman2890 4y agoAlaska will soon be the most desirable state to live in.
- FrontierPsych 4y agoWhy worry? Nobody is going to stop driving their car, nobody is going to stop taking plane trips. And those are utterly nothing as compared to the largest generators of CO2 --- children. Every single thing that a person can do is miniscule compared to having a baby. Are we going to convince every female from 15-years-old to 40-years-old to not have any children? If you are past childbearing age and have children, are you going to try to talk them into not having children, and therefore you will have no grandchildren? Let's all just sit back and watch the world burn, because that is exactly what is going to happen. As far as we know, we may have already passed the point of no return and just don't know it yet, as some things might take a decade or more to unwind, but it is too late to do anything. This is what I think is the case. There is no action that can be taken. It's too late. It doesn't even matter about trying to slow it down. It's like people saying to stop an avalanche with a cardboard box to catch all the snow. Too late, too late. The future is going to be bleak, people are going to be eating each other. The circle in the middle is for each child you have, or grandchild. Can you imagine how big that circle is with 2 or 3 or 6 children??? https://imgur.com/FmNUUeB https://imgur.com/FmNUUeB