5 ms·
Answer to your puzzle: because as soon as sideloading is allowed, sideloading will become required by the most popular apps. And then suddenly I lose all the p
by crazygringo 4y ago
Answer to your puzzle: because as soon as sideloading is allowed, sideloading will become required by the most popular apps.
And then suddenly I lose all the protections afforded to me by the Apple Store, such as easy cancellations of subscriptions, easy refunds of apps that don't work, a layer of protection against malware, and so forth. It also just makes my phone that much harder to use, as finding and installing apps becomes that much harder.
If everybody gets sideloading, that absolutely will impact me directly, and negatively. Does that make sense?
- enjo 4y agoWhy has that not happened on Android phones?
- qtzaz 4y agoIt has. Fortnite is not available in the Play Store. Given that iphone owners are more wealthy I expect this to happen much more often when sideloading is allowed on iphones since there's more money to be made. It's gonna get bad imo.
- badwolf 4y agoAndroid hasn't restricted cross-app tracking from Facebook and such as strongly.
- criddell 4y agoWhat about Fortnite? There are also some apps that are only available in particular (non-Google) app stores.
- toast0 4y agoSure, there's Fortnite, and a smattering of other apps that aren't in Play Store. But, even though Android has made sideloading easier over time, it's still not that common; most popular apps don't even offer an apk download outside the Play Store. Attempting to load an apk with the setting off used to just give a failure message that quickly disappeared; now it actually takes you to the setting and asks you if you want to do it (with scary text suggesting you don't). Certainly, Play Store doesn't feel as restrictive as the App Store, so that's probably a factor. But I doubt popular apps will drop Apple's store, because it will significantly reduce the number of people willing and able to install their apps.
- yamtaddle 4y agoHas Facebook publicly thrown a huge fit over Play Store rules trashing their revenue? They claimed that they expected Apple's rule changes a while back to cost them $10 billion dollars in 2022 alone. Things may work out as the have with Android sideloading, but they may not. Incentives definitely differ between the two. It's also not clear to me that if sideloading is forced via regulation, it'll look like it does on Android—both operating systems may be forced to make it easier than it currently is on Android.
- jeroenhd 4y agoApple lets big companies get away with behaviour smaller developers would get instantly banned for. I very much doubt that Facebook is not somehow bypassing iOS' special privacy rules. Every now and then Facebook breaks their servers and hundreds of common apps crash on startup on iOS (https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/10/app-crash-facebook-sdk/); https://9to5mac.com/2020/07/10/app-crash-facebook-sdk/); their network libraries are everywhere. And, to be honest, who is Apple to dictate what Facebook's users can and cannot pay their Facebook subscription with? If people are fine with Facebook's cyber stalking, let them install the stupid app. You can still use the web version from Safari with all of the ad blocking addons you can find. Apple isn't the government and they don't have power of attorney, so I know what basis they have to say what apps you can and cannot sideload onto your phone. Even still, I doubt Facebook will leave the app store because of this. They may provide some kind of "Facebook Plus" that you need to sideload, but the app store has too many eyes on it because it comes preinstalled.
- yamtaddle 4y ago> They may provide some kind of "Facebook Plus" that you need to sideload, but the app store has too many eyes on it because it comes preinstalled. The nightmare scenario, for the "please don't change it" side, is that one of a handful of big players does this but also uses it to push an entire alternative store. Facebook and Epic are the most likely to try. Maybe Google, outside chance Microsoft tries. I doubt any would bother to just push sideloading an app, without using it to make a play to become the second of an app store duopoly on the platform. Basically the same strategy Steam used to gain market share—"here's our new game that everyone wants... oh, by the way, to use it you have to install our store". I mean, Epic's been burning stacks of Benjamins for at least a couple years giving away tons of games (most of it not even cheap shovelware!) to buy marketshare for their desktop app store—it's not implausible they'd give away a lot of free games or other software to get iOS users to install their store, to make a play for the #2 (or #1!) app store position on the platform. And Facebook could probably get people to install theirs by just adding some visual bling to users' posts when they use the version from Facebook's store—might not even have to give them actual extra features to make it happen. Maybe none of that happens, sure, but it might. If these changes brought by regulations end up making sideloading easier than it currently is on Android, on both platforms, I'd say it's a certainty that something like that'll go down, at least on iOS (more money to be made there; store's more restrictive) and maybe on Android, too.
- alasarmas 4y agoYes, these kinds of “second-order effects” are real, and common. There is probably a good summarization of it in game theory, or economics.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> as soon as sideloading is allowed, sideloading will become required by the most popular apps Bingo. Chiefly worried about Facebook and my folks. As well as compliance deciding everyones' personal phones need antivirus spyware. That said, I think Apple has the playbook with SIP on Macs: make it scary to disable and clearly in power user territory.
- RedOrGreen 4y agoOof, yes, I didn't even mention corporate compliance.
- stametseater 4y agoHow hard is to to simply not install the Facebook app? I've been choosing to not use facebook for nearly 20 years. If somebody tries to socially pressure you, just say no. If they press, explain your reasoning and reassert the "NO" until they leave you alone. Good friends won't try to bully you into something after you've explained yourself; anybody who does is an asshole and you can tell them that. > corporate compliance I've never enrolled any of my personal devices in any sort of corporate network, and I never will. Just say no.
- alasarmas 4y agoYou can’t “just say no” to network effects, though. If you’re trying to, for example, attend a pickup game of baseball, and that game is organized on a Facebook group, what is your alternative? If you’re trying to get a job, and the recruiters are on LinkedIn, what’s your alternative? You have to go to where the other people are, in general…
- stametseater 4y agoHave somebody on the team [e]mail out the schedule like has always been done. It's not hard. If you feel the need to explain yourself, just tell them Facebook facilitates genocides in Asia or something like that. If you actually try saying no, you'll find that it's actually easy.
- comte7092 4y ago> sideloading will become required by the most popular apps. This point keeps being made in these threads on here, and the response I’ve seen made, which I agree with, is that this clearly isn’t the case when you look at Android. Sideloading already exists and it is far from a common way to distribute applications. From a business perspective, it really doesn’t make sense to force users to pull from outside the App Store, because you’re basically going to destroy your business. Most users are not all that technical and the moment you require them to fool around with apks or whatever other format, you’re going to lose a huge percentage of them.
- jasode 4y ago>, is that this clearly isn’t the case when you look at Android. Sideloading already exists The problem with using Android as a counterexample is that Apple iOS is more restrictive (e.g. privacy settings) than Android. E.g. Facebook admitted they lost billions in revenue because of the Apple iOS ad tracking permissions change. That might be an example of Facebook forcing users to "sideload" Facebook+Whatsapp+Instagram to get around the privacy restrictions. In contrast, the Android platform didn't financially hurt them like that so there's less incentive to ask Android users to sideload Facebook apps. So even a mega giant like Facebook has to follow Apple's rules because there is no sideloading to bypass them. A somewhat analogous situation in 2019 happened when Facebook violated Apple's app store policy and spied on teenagers by abusing their Apple developer account: https://www.google.com/search?q=apple+revokes+facebook+certificate+vpn https://www.google.com/search?q=apple+revokes+facebook+certi... >Most users are not all that technical and the moment you require them to fool around with apks I think some conversations about "sideloading" are muddy because casual conversation around it mentally includes alternative app stores rather than end users literally downloading raw ".app" bundle files
- hnra 4y agoThe first facebook issue that you mention is unrelated to the App Store, it’s an OS restriction. Side loading won’t affect this. Apple can clearly make the OS secure/privacy friendly if they want to. The only layer of security that you may lose is the dubious “review” process, which clearly doesn’t do anything considering the amount of scam apps on the store.
- orwin 4y agoLike all the popular android apps require sideloading? No, at most you'll pay more for the same app your coworker sideloaded. The price for apple protection, +30% on everything. Most people didn't extract pictures from their phone before apple cloud (or w/e their service is called) appeared. I know because i was the tech support for my family for those 5 years. How would they sideload?
- commoner 4y agoThe premium is actually 42.9%, since that is the amount a developer needs to raise their prices to offset the App Store's 30% fee.
- criddell 4y agoI wish Apple had attacked this from a different perspective. Instead of fighting side loading, remove the reasons that drive a lot of the demand for side loading. I should be able to buy a Kindle book in the Kindle app. If I download the Netflix app I should be able to sign up for Netflix in the app (or at least be redirected to their web site). Don’t charge fees to competitive services (ie music, books, movies, etc…). I originally thought I would never load a different App Store but now I might. If an App Store came out that was highly curated (ie no casino games, no subscription scams, no advertising against competitors), that listed exactly what the in-app purchases are before buying, and removed developers who get a lot of complaints in the store, I would be interested. Apple hasn’t been a good steward of the App Store.
- jonny_eh 4y agoAnd allow: Legal emulators, and alternative browsers (with their own rendering/JS engines)
- criddell 4y agoI kind of hope they hold out against alternative browsers. Safari on iOS is the last thing stopping a total takeover by Blink.
- Gareth321 4y agoThey can't. The DMA requires permitting alternate browser engines. See Section 43: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32022R1925 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A... I'm fine with it. Apple has been intentionally hindering WebKit development for years to hobble web apps and maintain their App Store dominance. They'll finally be forced to compete again.
- lxgr 4y ago> I wish Apple had attacked this from a different perspective. Instead of fighting side loading, remove the reasons that drive a lot of the demand for side loading. Couldn't have said it better. The only things I could see myself sideloading are indeed the Kindle app (I like being able to single-click buy books without having to switch to Safari), a full browser, and possibly some retro computer, calculator, and console emulators. All of these are (or at least have been, before I switched) been possible on Android via official apps from the Play Store.
- lxgr 4y ago> as soon as sideloading is allowed, sideloading will become required by the most popular apps. Android has always supported sideloading, yet in almost 10 years of using Android, I've never had to sideload any commercial app. Anecdotally, Amazon has tried to push their app store for a while by incentivizing installs with free games and the like, but none of these weren't also available on the official Play Store. Nowadays, it's all free-to-play anyway, but that's a different topic.