4 ms·
> If there was other global knowledge work available to Kenyans I’m sure they’d take it. These people are writing college level essays! They are probably better
by carlosjobim 4y ago
> If there was other global knowledge work available to Kenyans I’m sure they’d take it. These people are writing college level essays! They are probably better writers than most of us.
Shouldn't they be employed at improving their own country, since they are this smart? Instead of gaining from corruption and fraud on another continent?
If the smartest young people in your country have to move abroad or work remotely for foreign companies in order to make the most of their skills, then your country and society is a total failure - ask me if you want, I'm from one of those places.
- ta988 4y agoSo what, gathering capital from dumb kids so they can do things that matter to them is bad?
- DeusExMachina 4y ago> so they can do things that matter to them They can do what matters to them without cheating the system and getting rewarded a degree for it.
- maerF0x0 4y agoHowever the capitalist system is one in which you should be rewarded for outsourcing something you cannot do or cannot do inexpensively yourself. Organization and correct market theories are what's rewarded* in capitalism. Especially in business schools we should be focused on making people who have those skills and rewarding them for successfully doing it. IMO the real distortion is in overvaluing those who have a degree, many of which only proves they can show up on time, consistently, and do as their told. * (amongst other negative forms like rent seeking etc I'm talking about the positive case here)
- carlosjobim 4y agoIt's a lost opportunity and productivity loss. If the Kenyan writer was employed doing something that has a purpose, economic wealth would increase. Instead he/she is employed with helping incompetent people scam their way into jobs and positions where they will damage productivity.
- ant6n 4y agoThe Kenyan is exporting intellectual work. That this may damage the corrupt system in the West seems like a US problem.
- sempron64 4y agoThe question is how do you fix that situation?
- nivenkos 4y agoIt fixes itself over time. Now these people will have to find other sources of income, and that will create economic and political pressures.
- acadapter 4y agoNo, it doesn't fix itself because we have an unfair arrangement of opportunities around the world. Different passports give different amount of travel freedom. Some countries are stuck paying debts to other countries. And so on...
- 908B64B197 4y agoPassport travel freedom is often caused by security and fraud risk. This can be fixed by countries simply by making sure fraud and security risks can't end-up abroad.
- ghiculescu 4y agoI’m also from one of those places. I agree it would be good if local productivity improved. But I don’t think the solution is for the west to ban people from bad countries making an income and bringing it home.
- NineStarPoint 4y agoWell I don’t think it’s necessarily wrong for people in less developed countries to work for more developed countries. Even idealistically, the best state might be working for the first world to gain resources to send to the home country as it bootstraps itself into higher prosperity. The unfortunate fact is that highly educated people need infrastructure and stability to support that education, and therefore can gain many more resources working for developed countries than they can for their own. There just isn’t enough opportunity for education to push things forward without the infrastructure behind it. Of course, yeah, relying on corruption and fraud from another continent to try and make a living you can’t make in your own country is a problem. When the issue is that local corruption is not just having them work for more developed countries, but having them abandon their home countries entirely, yeah that’s a big problem. But I don’t think there’s a problem with having people work remotely for foreign companies while their own country isn’t yet able to properly utilize their own skills yet.
- carlosjobim 4y ago> "gain resources to send to the home country" The resources are already in their home country from the beginning. Then the local elite sell those resources to foreigners and leave their countrymen being poor. Since poor isn't stupid, those countrymen learn to write essays since learning is free. Then they work for foreigners to get some money, so they can buy resources. It's a circle of stupidity. Everything in life is step by step. I completely understand those who emigrate or work for foreign companies instead of working on improving their country - I had to do that myself after fighting for many years. Nobody can be so patriotic that they throw their life away in that manner. What I don't understand is how the rulers can decide to continue on this road to ruin.
- chii 4y ago> Instead of gaining from corruption and fraud on another continent? it's not corrupt nor fraud from the point of view of the kenyans. They are merely doing a transaction with a foreigner. As far as the kenyans are concerned, it's the foreigner who is defrauding the university for plagerism and cheating.
- SilasX 4y ago>Shouldn't they be employed at improving their own country, since they are this smart? Instead of gaining from corruption and fraud on another continent? Causing political change is hard, and a different skill. You might as well as Silicon Valley engineers why they're not improving American policy instead of making advertisers slightly better at getting clicks.
- carlosjobim 4y agoYet many people throughout the world have improved their countries massively and in short time. Note that I'm not saying these writers should make political change in Kenya - I'm saying that the people in power there should get their heads out of their asses and understand that they have to give better opportunities to skilled locals so that they don't waste their productivity by writing college essays for foreigners.
- darth_avocado 4y agoThis only works if your country is self sufficient, from a resources standpoint and a IP standpoint. If you lack either, you participate in a global economy. And if you participate in a global economy, you need capital. Say you’re the smart Kenyan who is willing to work. But there is no work in your country, or the only employment you can find is something that doesn’t use your intellect. You are that guy who can fix cars for a living, but there are no cars in the country. There are bicycles to be fixed, but they don’t pay enough to feed your family, or make progress. You can choose to write essays, make money in dollars and afford a car. You can spend money in the local economy so that others can afford education, grow themselves and afford a car. Eventually you can create your own business locally to fix the cars. Or even better if you manage to make a lot of money, you can build a business that allows others to build their own business. Or you could continue fixing bicycles, make no money and constantly worry about survival, and never do anything more than fixing bicycles. And this is how capital and modern economics works. I’m also from one of those places. :)
- paulryanrogers 4y agoGreat counterpoint. Though I fear there is a moral hazard if ones wellbeing depends upon corruption, even far away. Corruption undercuts a stable and healthy society. Taken too far the rule of law becomes weakened, and that doesn't generally end well. Maybe instead of fixing bicycles or facilitating scams they could just do honest remote work for richer societies?
- jimmydddd 4y agoRe: moral hazzard, it seems odd to me that the US college kids use this service without a second thought. I'm old (50's) and we thought having someone type (typewriter era) your essay after you hand wrote it was dishonest. :-) The only situation I can think of where I might have cheated without feeling bad was maybe using a calculator on math homework where it was forbidden?
- 908B64B197 4y ago> I fear there is a moral hazard if ones wellbeing depends upon corruption, even far away. I don't see it that way. There's no moral hazard on the Kenyan side (they aren't the ones submitting work as their own). The same way a gun or car manufacturer isn't and shouldn't be liable for the criminal use of his product. I could go on one of these market places and hire one of these Kenyan writer for completely legitimate reasons.