5 ms·
Eid Mubarak! > no food or water But really no water? That doesn’t sound healthy. Of course you can easily make it through a day without fluids but…
by Aeolun 4y ago
Eid Mubarak!
> no food or water
But really no water? That doesn’t sound healthy. Of course you can easily make it through a day without fluids but…
- mkoubaa 4y agoWithin 5 days I'm fully adjusted but there are some symptoms of dehydration before that. Leads me to doubt the conventional wisdom these days of "drink gallons of water per day to have a chance of being healthy"
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoPeople sit exams during ramadan, I don't know how
- jacooper 4y agoYou get used to it
- kioleanu 4y agoIn Germany, Muslim students had their exams excused this week, when everyone else wrote them. They can take them next week
- conradfr 4y agoTerrible idea and precedent IMHO.
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoWhy?
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoI wonder why, Muslims only make up 5% of Germany's population, fiscally this wouldn't make much sense given that they would have to make a second exam paper & provide more labour
- tstrimple 4y agoFor some people, not everything is reduced to being as cost effective as possible.
- IndigoIncognito 4y agoCome to think of it, it was quite nice how they accommodated Muslims; however, they could have just postponed the exams.
- lanstin 4y agothe German's regain some reputation for hospitality.
- fortuna86 4y ago[dead]
- elashri 4y agoI had 12 years of pre-college education, 4 for university, 2 for Masters and 2 years of classes in my PhD ( I am candidate now) and I think I had exams while I was fasting in each year and it wasn't a big deal. I rarely even see a Muslim student break fast for exams. And I think people saying they request accommodation this week, that's usually because of Eid and the couple of nights before that we believe it is the night that quran was revealed to the prophet Mohamed, so people want to pray more at night (it is a probability not specific night from 21,23,25,27 and 29 of Ramadan)
- permalac 4y agoHow does your focus evolve or progress while fasting? Any relevant difference between the first days and the last days?
- Aerbil313 4y agoSimply, when you eat 3 meals a day, your body and mind is way less performant than what it could be in a good portion the day. So having all daytime fully productive helps. I personally don’t feel any desire to eat or drink after 1st day.
- hqudsi 4y agoPeople play professional sports while fasting during Ramadan. I have no idea how they do it but having access to nutritionists probably helps.
- imjonse 4y agoReligious fasts are not held for health reasons :)
- mdp2021 4y agoSome of them are still for reasons within the range of "health".
- m5r 4y agoThat's usually the first question that pops up when explaining it to non-Muslims haha but yes, really, no water either.
- bena 4y agoFrom sunrise to sunset. Today, sunrise was about 6:30am and sunset will be about 7:30pm. That's only 11 hours with no food or water.
- somedude895 4y agoFun fact: The start and end of Ramadan shifts by something like two weeks each year. It was from 22 March to 20 April this year and 1 April to 1 May last year. So muslims in the northern hemisphere who are growing up or are very old now have it a bit easier since each year it's going more into Spring/Winter. I remember growing up in Europe we'd have one or two muslim kids in our class and I was horrified because they weren't allowed to drink any water on the hottest summer days.
- lanstin 4y agohottest and longest.
- psyfi 4y agoNot unhealthy, unless you don't drink enough before dawn
- kif 4y agoIt also depends on the level of activity, as with any other thing. Personally I've been well-hydrated throughout the days, going to the loo quite often.
- xeromal 4y agoI'm not a muslim, but I've done ramadan for my own edification and really it seems fine. Ramadan isn't prescribed for anyone who's on prescriptions or unhealthy. The worlds top soccer players fast and are still competitive. On top of that, a large part of the middle east was conquered while the soldiers were fasting. The human body is quite capable of more than we give it.
- joshmanders 4y agoI think society has gotten to a point that if we don't have 3 "well balanced meals" daily, drink a gallon of water a day, you're living unhealthy and bad. But people don't realize that fasting is important to your body... We store fat to use during that time... That's the whole point of storing fat. Energy and that while you don't have it. 12 hours a day is absolute cake-walk for our bodies.
- xeromal 4y agoYeah, fasting is great for letting our bodies recalibrate. 12 hours is nothing. It's parroted a lot but a large UK gentleman went an entire year on multivitamins, water, and a handful of other minerals to lose weight with no damage to his body. He was under doctor supervision so self-managed fasting is probably between 12 hours and 365 days.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoTo be fully hydrated you need to drink water for 24 hours in advance. If you drink a ton of water before sunrise and after sunset, every day, you can still be properly hydrated. Not ideal of course, but not necessarily unhealthy.
- hqudsi 4y agoAs long as you are properly hydrated before it's really not that bad. Even this Ramadan, when I went to pee later in the day, the color wasn't dark implying I wasn't that dehydrated.
- Aerbil313 4y agoIt’s fine bro! Like 2 billion people including me does it every single year. Nothing happens. You just drink at night more. We’re perfectly healthy.
- aws_ls 4y agoGood for you. But please don't generalize it for every one. Lack of water intake does multiply the hardship many folds. Especially now, when Ramzan(or Ramadan) falling in summer in the northern hemisphere. Know people who have had strokes or break the fast due to extreme hardship. Domestic helps who are Muslims, or people doing physical labor, simply can't observe it. Its one of the hardest fasts there is, and restraint from drinking water is the main reason.
- Aerbil313 4y agoI know, but if it poses a real and serious health risk you are religiously prohibited from fasting. Islam prioritizes health in this situation. So it’s not that much of a concern. In my country, physical laborers also fast and I didn’t heard one breaking fast due to hardship.