5 ms·
Since AI wants to be human, let's treat it more like a human. For humans going to school is mandatory. And typically humans have to take lots of exams before t
by amelius 4y ago
Since AI wants to be human, let's treat it more like a human.
For humans going to school is mandatory. And typically humans have to take lots of exams before they can work in various fields.
So, let's make that mandatory for AI too. Let government agencies design the exams. Of course, the creator of the AI has to pay for this.
And of course, the tests should be carefully designed and should also include a psychological test as we don't want to unleash psychopathic AI onto the masses. Also keep in mind that an AI that spreads false information can be harmful to society.
- ukuina 4y agoThis is a great idea. Tools have to undergo certification, as does some software. A certified AI model would then become applicable in permit-constrained fields like construction.
- gumballindie 4y agoLet's start with them having to pay for "learning" materials.
- Ialdaboth 4y agoIt will happen sooner than later, as the fees will go to the copyright mafia industry rather than to the artists.
- gumballindie 4y agoIt will trickle down /s
- echelon 4y agoNo way. Once we get base models going, we'll be able to create leaf training data on the cheap. Several iterations of this, plus research that yields better training with less data, plus multiple startups going after foundational models -- old copyright houses (eg. house of mouse) will fall in both value and power. If the copyright specters hold a shroud over us, then we'll create the data from scratch one last time. It's akin to a source code rewrite. And there will be lots of people doing this. Copyright is checkmated no matter how it plays the game.
- gumballindie 4y agoSuch fixation with ip theft. Why?
- echelon 4y agoYou're looking at this from a 1900's lens. The world of the future doesn't have IP. You ask an advanced AI to create a world from scratch and it will. Now fill in the blanks between here and now. Why would every invocation involve paying Sonny Bono's estate? Humans are another good analogy. If these machines will begin to approximate us, maybe the rules for them should be similar. We don't need to pay a licensing fee every time we write stories about evil characters, despite the fact many of us learned about evil from watching Disney villains on screen.
- gumballindie 4y agoWith all due respect but this sounds far fetched to put it mildly.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago> The world of the future doesn't have IP. This is a bold prediction, and far from certain
- RecycledEle 4y agoThere are many competing nations. If one can outlaw artificial scarcity, they will grow so much faster than the others that eventually they will take over. I predict we will either have a world without Intellectual Property or we will have a global government that enforces Intellectual Property laws.
- Ialdaboth 4y agoI'm convinced the future will have IP, that the IP houses will use AI to generate an infinite number of properties, copyright them, and use them to rob blind any creator daring enough to try something ;p
- sanxiyn 4y ago用于生成式人工智能产品的预训练, 优化训练数据, 应满足以下要求: 不含有侵犯知识产权的内容. China is getting this right.
- gumballindie 4y agoYup, they got that right.
- ben_w 4y agoOn the other hand: https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/10/09/an-end-to-copyright/ https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/10/09/an-end-to-c...
- nickwritesit 4y agoYup. I think the trick is collective rights management. From what I understand, creators form an org that licenses content out en masse and pays creators back from pooled licensing fees (which is what the music industry did when the radio first came out). Seems like a nice compromise where creators get paid and AI companies don't have to ask for individual licenses one by one.
- nickpp 4y agoExcept that countries letting people freely use AIs unencumbered will quickly outcompete luddites. You cannot regulate progress.
- amelius 4y agoNo, the regulation will ensure a certain level of quality and will require a serious effort from AI makers. Also it ensures that the AI doesn't spread false information and destroys our country in the process.
- nickpp 4y agoI doubt we can uphold those standards even in people. If the last 4 years have proven anything, it is that we cannot agree what is true and what is false for a population. And to have that across different countries… impossible.
- lgas 4y agoRegulation can't ensure anything, it can only change incentives.
- swexbe 4y agoGood, the current incentives are pretty perverse.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 4y agoAny country allowing people and organizations to steal things from other countries outcompete luddites. Drop all treaties. You cannot regulate progress.
- anonylizard 4y agoThat's exactly what the US is doing with China. China isn't going to play fair in high-tech no matter what 'regulations' you come up with, so the solution is simple, decouple.
- 4y ago
- mkl 4y agoAI doesn't want to be human, it wants to complete the pattern begun by your prompt. If the prompt is an exam question, the completion will likely be an answer to it drawing on similar material the AI was trained on.
- Jeff_Brown 4y agoThis makes no sense with the current tech. These models have no memory beyond the last few thousand words of input. They have no persistent self -- a copy pops into existence to answer a series of questions, then vanishes, with no cumulative effect on later copies. They have data, but not beliefs; they easily and radically contradict themselves. They have no preferences, no goals, and no plans, although they can invent some for you if you ask.
- Avicebron 4y agoMaybe we should take to calling them MayflAI...
- amelius 4y agoWhy does an AI need memory to cause harm? A self driving car obviously can. An LLM can talk a teenager into depression, or start new conspiracy theories by talking to humans. All without memory.
- Jeff_Brown 4y agoYes, they certainly can! I'm not saying they should be trusted. I'm saying they can't be taught.
- amelius 4y agoOk, you misunderstood. My comment was about exams more than about teaching. And if the AI fails the test, then the vendor can train the AI and try to do better next time, anyway.
- ben_w 4y ago> tests should be carefully designed and should also include a psychological test as we don't want to unleash psychopathic AI onto the masses "Sir, the AI has failed the psychiatric tests." "Which one?" "Bipolar disorder, schizophrenia, major depressive disorder, anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder, borderline personality disorder, Alzheimer's, … …and eating disorders? That can't be right." > Also keep in mind that an AI that spreads false information can be harmful to society Yes, though also true for humans spreading false information. If you have a solution to that, please share loudly at every opportunity, because the discourse I normally encounter is: Joe: "Absolute free speech is the only way!" Smith: "You've never lost a job after being personally defamed, have you?"
- amelius 4y ago> Yes, though also true for humans spreading false information. This exactly underlines the point that we need to treat AI and humans more equal: both must go to school and take exams before we put them in important places.
- ben_w 4y agoWhen cars were new, sometimes they shaped the front like a horse. This feels like the same kind of thinking. GPT4 beats most test takers in a wide variety of exams, so it's probably (I don't have access, just basing this on the reports) already better than most individual fresh graduates in those specific areas, just not at the "do literally everything by itself without supervision" level. Constant testing is a must, it just doesn't look like the tests or education you'd give a human. Not that everyone is even doing the most basic tests yet: https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aamazon.com+%22as+a+large+language+model%22&source=hp&ei=sJJCZKnPD42Txc8Px5GZyAs&oq=site%3Aamazon.com+%22as+a+large+language+model%22 https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aamazon.com+%22as+a+la...
- loa_in_ 4y agoThe way you put it, the world awfully looks a lot like it's run by autonomous agents that pass initial tests but are running unsupervised
- devsda 4y agoI agree with the general idea of testing and verifying an AI before integrating it into any field that can directly or indirectly impact a human(financially, psychologically etc). Tests designed for humans may not translate well for an AI. The real challenge will be in certifying an AI for such jobs.