3 ms·
> Is it crazy? Copyright is the right to make a copy. Libraries can buy and loan books because none of that involves making a copy. Digitizing a book and loanin
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> Is it crazy? Copyright is the right to make a copy. Libraries can buy and loan books because none of that involves making a copy. Digitizing a book and loaning digital copies does involve making copies, so it's a violation of copyright. Seems very straightforward to me. Am I missing some major detail or catch or something?
The problem is that viewing copies that way completely trashes the rights people have for their digital goods. Displaying it is technically a copy. Reselling it is technically a copy. Format shifting is technically a copy. Lending is technically a copy.
If I make an ephemeral copy, and keep the original in a vault the entire time the ephemeral copy is loaned out, that should be good enough. (Maybe you want a minimum loan period, details details, but something that works just like a traditional library shouldn't be illegal for digital assets.)
- CobrastanJorji 4y ago> the rights people have for their digital goods People don't have any rights to their digital goods. Doesn't exist. They are not. It is wonderful to discuss ideas for how the system SHOULD be. I 100% support a legislated solution for digital ownership of copies of things, with a right to transfer and so on, but that's sadly a hypothetical discussion about what could be.
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoThat is insanity that was never envisioned when copyright was created. First-sale doctrine is well established. If you buy a book, you can give it away, sell it or lend it to anyone you want. Those rights should not simply disappear when you start dealing with a digital book.
- stonemetal12 4y ago> Displaying it is technically a copy. Format shifting is technically a copy. Both of which are legally not copyright infringement. Have long settled case history etc. >Reselling it is technically a copy. Not really, unless you keep a copy after you sell it.