3 ms·
> The problem is nobody wants to make a hundred purchasing decisions per day. Indeed. I wonder if something like Brave's idea of just creating a pot of money
by freedomben 4y ago
> The problem is nobody wants to make a hundred purchasing decisions per day.
Indeed. I wonder if something like Brave's idea of just creating a pot of money per month, and then paying that out is workable. As a user I'd love to throw $10 into my pot and not have to worry about cost exceeding that and not having to see ads. The network effect is a beast though. You need participation before you can get participation.
- efreak 4y agoFlattr?
- arcticbull 4y agoThat's explored in section 5.1 of the Szabo paper. tl;dr: you basically have to cap how much the sites can charge to avoid the pot getting drained by a bad actor, but that just creates an incentive for every site to charge the maximum - why wouldn't they? There's no human deciding after all. So then you're basically deferring to, and trusting, a central actor to set the price for all this content. Then premium content makers have to demand a higher price to make the economics work, which in turn, means everyone sets their prices to the new upper tier. That has its own serious implications, and comes with much of the same hazard as Google has today, IMO. By eliminating the agency in making that purchasing decision you eliminate much of the benefit of a market for content.
- tjoff 4y agoWhy would it have to be all or nothing. Maybe I can spend an extra literal 2 seconds for content I adore and spend an hour on, than on something I barely skim.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoSo you need to give the site a reason not to charge the maximum. Suppose the user can choose their monthly fee, but so can the site. Anyone paying $5/month can use any of the cheapest sites. Some sites require you to be paying $50/month. The sites that require a higher monthly fee get paid more per user, but they also lose out on any money at all from users paying less than that (because they don't have access). Mass market sites will choose low rates and make it up on volume. Specialized sites with premium content can choose higher rates and still get paid with a smaller number of users. But the user is still not getting nickle and dimed, because if you're paying $50/month, you get all the $50/month tier content.
- mst 4y agoThis sounds reminiscent of the Kindle Unlimited model, and author opinions as to its usefulness to them are ... varied. Then again my brain keeps generating what it's convinced are fairer ways to do it ... and all of them so far also introduce sufficient additional friction for the user that they'd be dead on arrival.
- harikb 4y agoThe collective value of your View/Clicks is far higher than $10 to advertizers per month. Most people wouldn't pay that amount. This is just like insurance. Old people are subsidized by young. A rich person's View in the developed country is subsidizing Google just being available to a poor person elsewhere. Don't assume that (a) people are ready to pay the true cost of running a site like Google without ads or (b) that it will even end up being a good thing for humanity overall.
- freedomben 4y agoVery fair point. The Law of Unintended Consequences could be a beast.
- bee_rider 4y agoWe should just let the market sort it out. If people don’t want to pay as much as a website needs to be run, they should just not use the website, it can go out of business if necessary, and space can be opened up for a more efficient service provider. I mean we’re basically allowing for an information asymmetry here, right? Which messes with supply and demand. Economists should be pissed.
- ponector 4y agoIsn't is already sorted out? Current model full of ads is the best for business.
- bee_rider 4y agoThe suppliers and the demanders can’t agree on an efficient price if the demanders don’t know what the price is.
- MereInterest 4y agoAnd while they haggle over the price of the megaphone, the rest of us who are about to be deafened don’t even factor into a market-based pricing.
- nonethewiser 4y agoA company called Coil offered this. They shut down recently though.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThis would be really interesting in combination with some zero knowledge proofs, so you can allocate your subscription fees to sites without the payment processor (or the site) knowing who you in particular are patronizing.
- mst 4y agozcash's shielded pool is probably the closest to a solution for that that exists today, and at the very least a bunch of the cryptography/math/overall model should be re-usable in a more traditional setup. (I remain basically a crypto skeptic but zcash appear to at least be -attempting- something focused and interesting enough for me to continue to pay vague attention)
- RandallBrown 4y agoGoogle actually used to offer this. I forget what it was called, but you put money in your account and it would big against other AdSense ads for display on websites. I think I remember being able to replace the ads with cat photos or whatever photos you wanted.
- slongfield 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Contributor
- RandallBrown 4y agoI could have sworn it existed prior to 2014, but I guess not!