3 ms·
One interesting observation here is how long it took the ship to get off the pad from the T-0 mark. This is undoubtedly because some of the raptors on it appare
by somenameforme 4y ago
One interesting observation here is how long it took the ship to get off the pad from the T-0 mark. This is undoubtedly because some of the raptors on it apparently failed to ignite. I thought they were about to make a mess on the launch pad!
I'm also curious about what technically finally got it off the ground - was there a sufficient, but low, level of acceleration, was it a matter of reducing the rocket's mass (by burning through fuel), was it a matter of some of the engines reaching some peak level of performance. Or, probably most likely, maybe just a combination of everything.
- mwint 4y agoMore likely, holddowns on the pad until everything was stabilized. Probably takes a few seconds to vector/throttle the other engines to compensate for the lost ones. E: convery's reply below makes much more sense.
- convery 4y agoClamps were released at T-10min. IIRC compensating for engines are pretty fast. But they hold the engines at just below lift/weight to run some more checks before fully powering up.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoIt is extremely heavy and the engines do not all light at once, they sequentially start over 6-8 seconds.
- dzader 4y agothey said it would take ~6 seconds from engine ignition to takeoff in one of the streams. everything was working as planned at that point afaik
- malfist 4y agoDitto, this hover then takeoff was planned. That's why on the live stream you see T0 and then T+0:06 you see "liftoff". The hover was planned.
- CydeWeys 4y agoI was amazed at how resilient Starship was despite how many engines had failed, right up until the point they needed to yaw for stage separation and lost control. They've gotta improve the reliability of those engines (which I'm sure they will), but it's a testament to the quality of their control software how far they got despite having those malfunctioning engines.
- Aperocky 4y agoCommodity parts are going to run the future. Soon we'll have commodity rocket engines and it's going to be plug and play with software accomodating X% failure per launch. The Soviets only dreamed of such when they came up with the disaster that is the N1.
- nonethewiser 4y agoDoes SpaceX build the actual engines? Are they as complicated as airplane engines which are famously hard to produce?
- mjamesaustin 4y agoSpaceX designed and built all the engines. The Raptor engine is the world's first full flow staged combustion engine to fly in a rocket.
- jpgvm 4y agoi.e not only do they make rocket engines they make the worlds most advanced and complicated rocket engines and they make so many of them you could consider them mass produced. (as far as rocket engines go that is) These engines require a very delicate dance of chamber pressure, temperature, fuel/oxidiser mix, turbo pump speeds, etc to get started but it's all worth it in the end for their insane efficiency and thrust/weight.
- panick21_ 4y agoYes, SpaceX makes all their own engine, even inventing their own materials. They are building these very vertically integrated. SpaceX is pretty much the undisputed best rocket engine company in the world. They build more engines then anybody in the world and its not even close. And the Raptor is the most advanced engine in the world. Rocket engines have different challenges then airplane engines. They are as hard in some ways but easier in others. Rocket engine operate in a far more extreme environment, peak stressed are far larger, failures and issues far more violent. But the big advantage is that they only have to operate for a few minutes at the time (at least on the first stage). Jet engines need to operate for 1000s of hours. SpaceX has upped the level significantly, interdicting higher efficiency full flow stage combustion and making them reusable and being able to launch quickly and reliably. So they complexity of Raptor is much higher then your typical first stage rocket engine. I would say the complexity of a modern jet engine might still be higher, but its hard to estimate these things. Not sure how you would do that scientifically.
- echoer_lyrist 4y agoI believe this is intentional. They engines start with less thrust than is needed to launch the rocket and only throttle up fully after the system checks pass.
- physicles 4y agoThe startup sequence is indeed longer than with most other rockets, but I don’t think that’s the reason. 5-6 engines were gone since very early in the flight, and for most of those I suspect that’s because they were damaged by debris from the pad. Everyday Astronaut’s live stream had a different camera angle on the rocket, and you could see it actually slide sideways away from the tower a bit in the first few seconds. Uneven thrust would explain that. Elon said in the past that the rocket will leap off the pad (thrust-to-weight ratio of 1.5 or 1.6 iirc). But if you’re missing 20% of your engines, that ratio is ~1.2, or less than half the expected acceleration. A slow start indeed.