7 ms·
Google ordered to pay $500K to Montrealer over links calling him pedophile
- Aeolun 4y agoWhile nice for him to get justice, I don’t think it’ll stop Google from doing it again.
- avsteele 4y agoThe article doesn't do a great job of explaining the legal issues or what the current status is. Can anyone here do a better job? Can any Canadian request links be taken down?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sclarisse 4y agoAs an American who enjoys America’s freedom of speech, I find it distressing that the largest companies, who play a real role in the distribution of that speech, are so very large and global that they are beholden to the law of other jurisdictions, who then afflict US residents with their extraterritorial censorship. We need many viable not-Googles, instead of just one behemoth.
- zht 4y ago[flagged]
- counttheforks 4y ago[flagged]
- sclarisse 4y agoWe fought a revolution against self-righteous European moralism (and taxes), so, yes.
- sclarisse 4y agoNo, this is called looking beyond the single issue in front of us, to see the broader trend which confronts us Some day it may be fines for carrying links tho content that says mean things about a noted UK author with controversial opinions, under the notoriously plaintiff-favorable UK libel law, often used to bully critics. Some day it will be fines for US-visible links to content critical of the Chinese Communist Party, and other threats to its business.
- counttheforks 4y ago[flagged]
- ianbutler 4y agoWhat a well thought out, useful, and totally not incendiary response. You should be proud of your wit and apparent deep capacity for thought. Oh also, this is directly against HN guidelines. > Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes. > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.
- counttheforks 4y agoAs is the parent comment. Playing moderator is also against the HN guidelines.
- cmeacham98 4y agoFalsely accusing somebody of a criminal act is defamation per se in the US. I'm unsure if a US court would agree that search results would constitute defamation as well, but it certainly seems possible, especially if the search query was entirely neutral (i.e. just looking up this victim's name).
- sclarisse 4y ago“Restoring a link to content Google had indexed which called someone a pedophile” is a lot different than the content itself and was just fined $500k. That’s a lot of liability for a link. That means any time someone asks for content to be taken down there’s a lot of risk in saying No. The censors will win. The reputation management firms hired by billionaires will win. They will silence criticism, even true criticism. Even, especially, when they are in fact pedophiles, they will win a fight with Google, demand the Google AI take down all content that suggests they are anything but saints. This world is coming. It may be here within a decade or two. HN used to be a place where people thought this was a bad thing.
- fndex 4y agoAre you implying that calling someone a pedophile is freedom of speech?
- Pigalowda 4y agoOf course it is. You see all those people charged with defamation for calling GWB a murderer?
- sclarisse 4y ago“JK Rowling critic forced to publicly apologize for calling her a Nazi after lawsuit threat. Self-professed 'drag queen' and 'jazz hands enthusiast' apologized to JK Rowling 'for causing potential upset'” Can’t wait for the rich to shop around to the best defamation venue and take down all the Google links with a $500k-ish threat each.
- fndex 4y agoWhat does this have to do with my initial question? I'm not arguing that the links should've been taken down.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fndex 4y agoI was not asking if calling someone a pedophile is freedom of speech under the current legislation of the US, but more on the philosophical idea of freedom of speech.
- rbetts 4y agoYou mean for the deaths of over 7,000 Iraqi civilians by US armed forces because of the invasion he started on false pretenses? Or are you thinking more about the roughly 300,000 Iraqis who died in that conflict? Or maybe you're thinking about 100+ Iraqis who died while in US detention centers, several of which resulted in actual homicide charges? Or perhaps you are deeply concerned about the distinction between murder and torture authorized by GWB?
- vertis 4y agoWhile freedom of speech is protected in the United States, it is not an absolute right, and defamation laws are an example of a legal restriction on speech that is permissible under the First Amendment. Defamation laws are common amongst most democracies that enjoy some level of free speech.
- sclarisse 4y agoThis is an action that applies to Google, not the defamer, using Quebec law, where American law would not find liability. This fine included liability for posts that were visible in America, invisible in Quebec. The fact libel law exists in America generally is true but minimally informative and not really germane.
- vertis 4y agoThe Quebec court disagrees. Google is defaming the plaintif, and doing so in a global manner. Both in their ranking that information as important and additionally in refusing to remove that information when requested. I'm really glad that American companies can't just operate with impunity in other countries. Google and other US multinationals SHOULD be bound by the superset of laws for all of the countries they operate in. If they can't accept those laws, for example in the case of authoritarian states, then they shouldn't be operating in those markets at all.
- sclarisse 4y agoAnd indeed as I have said: A reason this is a big problem is that we have like 1.5 competitors out there (for search: Google, Bing) and they’re all trying to sell ads into all the jurisdictions ever. As a result all of us who have nothing else to use find we are practically limited by the set-intersection of all the extraterritorially enforced liberties in the world. Our set of liberties is getting smaller. I will be upset at that even if today it’s a marginally better reason than most.
- goldcd 4y agoCan I call you a paedophile here then? Maybe suggest that anybody who took the time to view your post history would clearly see this? I'd like to stress I'm not accusing you of anything - and wouldn't want to be responsible for the conclusions others might arrive at.
- bena 4y agoIf you just outright called him a pedophile and I saw your post accusing him of it, I would assume you're just an idiot.
- knallfrosch 4y agoJustice Azimuddin Hussain also ordered the company to remove links to the post from its search results in Quebec search results in Quebec in Quebec
- ptero 4y agoAs an American who used to enjoy the freedom of speech 20 years ago and whose freedom of speech has been greatly eroded by (among others) the big tech I strongly support this verdict. If Google provides a neutral search it should not be responsible for what the found search results say. If those are illegal, courts should go after the author. But should Google search suppress and promote specific viewpoints beyond clearly neutral pagerank-style search, their top links become promotions. And Google can be held liable for what those show. My 2c, IANAL.
- joseph_grobbles 4y agoFreedom applies to both parties. Your freedom to swing your fist ends where another's nose begins. Similarly, your freedom to baselessly disparage and slander has similar restrictions, because the other person has the freedom against such attacks. Libel is very restricted in the United States as well. Indeed, the whole "section 230" argument that keeps getting revived deals specifically with this topic (paradoxically by the "freedom" party), so clearly your "freedom" isn't quite as absolute as you imagine it is. Further, Google was ordered to restrict the content in Quebec, and the fine they are paying is a tiny fraction of the money they make in Canada, which is a country where they have offices and significant business. I see zero reason why you decided to make this American centric.
- Karawebnetwork 4y agoGoogle has offices and operates out of Québec. https://careers.google.com/locations/montreal/ https://careers.google.com/locations/montreal/
- jpambrun 4y agoGoogle has offices and employees in Canada, have .ca domains, sell customers good, etc. You don't think they should be subject to local laws? Is the reciprocal? Should Chinese company operating is the US be only subject to Chinese laws?
- jxi 4y ago> Hussain awarded the man — who had originally been seeking $6 million in damages — $500,000 in moral damages. He should have gotten nothing.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoCan you explain why? If his life has been negatively impacted by something false, and that impact has come at the expense of job opportunities, general quality of life, why should he not be reimbursed for damages?
- vertis 4y agoI don't understand how the website in question can avoid a direct defamation suit. While I don't really sympathize with Google in this case because they're somewhat kingmakers as they craft their search algorithms, and therefore not impartial, surely he can find someone to target in an actual defamation case. Either the author of the article or the owner of the website. If it's not possible to determine the owner of the website then the registrar needs to be raked over the coals. We all have to keep our details up to date every year, presumably for exactly this kind of reason (and yes, I know you can lie, but at that point you lose the domain).
- YawningAngel 4y agoThe website owner might not have 500k to fork over if they lose the suit.
- knallfrosch 4y agoYou're defaming the plaintiff as greedy. It's not enough be falsely accused of being a pedo for 15 years?
- YawningAngel 4y agoI didn't make any claims about the plaintiff's state of mind. For the record I think the plaintiff acted reasonably and in good faith in seeking a remedy against Google based on what I know about the case.
- vertis 4y agoGiven that this has been going on since 2007 this doesn't seem like the kind of frivilous lawsuit just going after Google's money. In fact it looks like the plaintiff made good faith attempts (and partially successful ones) with Google on a number of occasions.
- bena 4y agoThe man sought $6 million. It was reduced to $500,000 for "moral" damage by the court. Punitive damages were rejected because they believe Google was also acting in good faith.
- logicalmonster 4y agoJust speaking strictly on a moral level, there seems to be a qualitative difference between Google saying "Joe is a pedophile" versus "That guy Bob over there is saying that Joe is a pedophile". The first statement is either true or false. The second statement is inarguably factually true and casts no moral judgement on Joe.
- richthegeek 4y agoKeeping the metaphor, it's responding to the question of "Do you know Joe?" with "Yes, and that guy Bob over there says Joe is a pedophile" whenever asked.
- brvsft 4y agoHow about, "What do you know about Joe?" "I know that guy Bob over there says Joe is a pedophile."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackernewds 4y agoThis is a rational take. And worth considering, fwiw I agree with it I'm distressed further by other threads that begin to point this out being derailed with comments like "America should to keep to its own borders" and unrelated factoids about oil wars. This is not just an American precedent.
- cmeacham98 4y agoYou are missing the part where Google ranks search results. If you Google "Joe" and the first result is "Bob says Joe is a pedophile", Google is implicitly saying that is the single most important result about Joe. Thus, I reject this argument unless Google is willing to argue its search result ranking is no better than random chance and that results on the first page are equally as relevant and useful as those on the last.
- hammyhavoc 4y ago
- wildrhythms 4y agoThe article doesn't make it clear what happened to the, apparently, two publications at the source of the defamatory statements, only that Google no longer include those publications in its results in Quebec (specifically). Did the plaintiff find who was making the false statements and have them brought to justice?
- pseudolus 4y agoThe decision (in English) is available online [0]. Essentially the Court determined that provisions of Quebec's Civil Code relating to defamation were applicable to the case and not US Federal or State law. [0] http://citoyens.soquij.qc.ca/php/decision.php?ID=8DC675577FCB5A9703ACA18C78BF1609&captchaToken=03AKH6MRGjeDsp2Dyt-FDPTP_IKm1e3XMsEOGzWMKxtaVMVXuBW4238hIwPimp8jyqOMQQ8VaHOYkCqD3B_FtRo4O9vh2F5y-XGhijnc1odn3vuy-DPrk5ceUB6d04-HnI1JaSTQCWQjOn1x59X15eFo0qXc31RKYlSZTXcLqPYSg8M_hJMxQArJANdUhRyqd-_RBKOBaZQpqMxDNX768NpsoiR5X4XM2RnyX3gXW6QjpCnAH0GzQPz2_bUjlrI6cx0rKaL1Qy1gxytRrIU9JPV4DrfHjxnTT4tVBZsVKWliCDwtwP4TIpfyhFX1NjES_35x2OqrPz9kcXLtbu8ZkD5kl7sMwVtdm4sOyXnAnT_KF_8yodxVchWZLf-IilBtCC0Jj9jQ3Y6Z8LexATqZKgGayWbUvo3T_lDzksOWfmyKlBL5fLyB-osl0uW2Ww1BoEOO63G5MzasQsR-hBH406txC55zg3IuJ0Oyx34jk9qr2mt-QKUpnn4rZQWY-_AgAk-I7u-g_SiCu2GSVAZhYYd7rbtd1_iLEdSg http://citoyens.soquij.qc.ca/php/decision.php?ID=8DC675577FC...
- mdrzn 4y agoThe fact that some comments are defending Google is insane to me. My only guess is that they are all from USA and have a very "american" view of things. Google has an ethical and moral responsibility to not allow its platform to be used for defamatory purposes. While Google is an American company, it operates in many countries around the world and should be held accountable for its actions in each of these countries. The issue is not about one country telling another what to do but rather about a company being held accountable for its actions in a particular jurisdiction. The Canadian court system has the responsibility to enforce Canadian laws and protect the rights of its citizens, including the Montrealer in this case. If you don't agree with that, don't offer your service in Canada.
- ChatGTP 4y agoThis sentiment I see more and more on HN. My theory is it’s because tech is braking rules more and more often, and we all just love tech so it’s easier to just victim blame rather than address the actual issues.
- red-iron-pine 4y agoEveryone secretly thinks they're a tech (or general) genius and will (eventually) be a tech tycoon. An extension of the "temporarily embarrassed millionaire thing".
- windexh8er 4y agoI love tech. But you're implying that what tech means to me is basically just a large company. And in fact I don't love large tech companies. The Internet was much more enjoyable before a sales person got a hold of it. And while I do understand that a lot of really great engineering has come from within these companies it doesn't matter if they are abusing their users. Because Google loves it when their brand is associated with something positive. But Google should also be responsible for owning all of the negative their company and employees build. Finally, I'm an American. I have a very dim view on the positive that Google, Facebook/Meta, Microsoft contribute to society. They're all for profit companies no longer being run with a strong engineering or customer focus. Their goal is to turn more profit. That's not the spirit of tech in my mind. I don't consider any of these companies strong technology contributors anymore. They employ a number of great engineers that still do amazing things. But the companies (the executives, the senior management, the board of directors, etc) are not in it to move the industry in a positive direction. They're in it to make more money. The cost of that misdirection is very high to all. These companies have impacted many lives in very negative ways even though many have never intentionally wanted to use, or be part of, their services. These companies need far more accountability. Hiding behind a company logo should not be something society continues to support.
- rrdharan 4y agoWhat would stop a pair of people from colluding such that one defames the other with good SEO, they extract money from Google, and split the difference?
- mdrzn 4y agoOnce a link is reported as defamatory, Google could investigate the claim and, if necessary, remove the link and avoid any financial liability.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eviks 4y agoReality would intervene, it's very hard to extract the money outside of a thought experiment
- throw_m239339 4y ago> What would stop a pair of people from colluding such that one defames the other with good SEO, they extract money from Google, and split the difference? First suing Google is expensive, and you'd have to prove actual damages (loss of business, reputation, divorce) before a court a law. Cases such as these aren't a slam dunk. Why would anyone want to risk their reputation over that kind of unhinged and risky scheme? A man's reputation is everything. Your thought experiment is far fetched.
- rgbrenner 4y agoIn the article it says Google stopped removing the links because of a CA Supreme Court case on an "unrelated matter". It's not unrelated. It's Crookes v Newton and it said hyperlinks aren't defamatory: https://bc-injury-law.com/supreme-court-canada-clarifies-hyperlinks-defamatory/ https://bc-injury-law.com/supreme-court-canada-clarifies-hyp... I'll save you some time: Defamation in Canada requires: "(1) that the impugned words were defamatory, (2) that the words referred to the plaintiff and (3) that they were published." And the court said linking is not publishing. So Google stopped removing the links at his request.
- makeitdouble 4y agoFTA > He also asked Google to remove links to the website, as well as a short extract from the site, on the search engine’s results page. Emphasis mine. I'd argue laws and rulings can be contradictory in the first place, that's one reason there's judges. But here it's simpler than that: it's not just about linking, and the defamatory part was probably visible without having to follow the link.
- thunky 4y agoI wonder if a lot of the posters defending Google here cheered for Dominion to stick it to Fox News. Or vice versa.
- tzs 4y agoI wonder how many of them would say the same thing if instead of Google being the aggregator of third party information it was Equifax, Experian, or TransUnion, the false third party information being published by the aggregator was that the person routinely failed to make bill and loan payments, and the consequences was their credit score was so low they have to use cash for everything and prepay all their utilities. Would it be acceptable for the credit reporting agencies to tell them it is not the agency's problem and if they want to fix it they need to get the third parties the reported the false information to the agencies to fix it?
- ChoGGi 4y agoI won't link to it, but if anyone is curious; ripoff report has one entry for pedophile in Montreal, CA.
- Karawebnetwork 4y agoThe title is not very accurate. It was not ordered to pay because the links exists. It was ordered to pay because they restored links it had previously removed. "A Quebec Superior Court judge has ordered Google to pay $500,000 to a Montreal man who sued the company after it restored a link to an online post falsely accusing him of being a pedophile." "Google removed a link to the post from the search results that appeared on its Canadian website. Google would remove links twice more at the man’s request — later that year and in 2011 — after the post resurfaced in its search results. oogle removed a link to the post from the search results that appeared on its Canadian website. Google would remove links twice more at the man’s request — later that year and in 2011 — after the post resurfaced in its search results."
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSo who should be liable here? Google restored links to the defamatory content but the content was unable to be removed from where it was hosted. Do you try to go after the person who posted the content? What if you cannot? It's easy to end up in a place where victims have no recourse because Section 230 protects the platforms and the original poster cannot be tracked down to answer for their libel.
- vivegi 4y agoTangentially related. https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/delhi-high-court-aaradhya-bachchan-youtube-video-226795 https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/delhi-high-court-aaradhya... TLDR; The Delhi High Court on Thursday restrained various YouTube channels from disseminating, publishing or sharing videos or any fake content relating to the child of a Bollywood celebrity couple. Google LLC was one of the parties that was issued a legal notice to comply with removing the misinformation.
- jaclaz 4y agoReading the court paper that someone else (wildrhythms) linked to (thanks): http://citoyens.soquij.qc.ca/php/decision.php?ID=8DC675577FCB5A9703ACA18C78BF1609 http://citoyens.soquij.qc.ca/php/decision.php?ID=8DC675577FC... it is trivial (at least from outside Canada) to find via Google the actual post using some other keywords (instead of the anonymized name of the plaintiff). The post, though clearly defamatory, is as vague and generic as such posts can be. Without entering the debate on the actions or lack of actions by google and/or the actual site publisher, what I find almost incredible is that it had such a heavy impact on the plaintiff (see the court paper points [407] onwards) and his reputation. To only list a few, being removed from advisory board of an institute, being not recommended by old time friends for some jobs, the parents of his son's fiancee refusing to meet him, having promising business agreements canceled, influencing the reputation of his sons, the list is long. All for a single anonymous post? (presumably from a disgruntled ex-worker) Are people so stupid, do they believe the contents of this (single) data point and as a consequence take the actions that have been described? EDIT: corrected "removed from presidency of an institute" to "removed from advisory board of an institute"
- rchaud 4y agoWould you have appointed someone to lead an institute if you knew that there would be a PR fiasco the moment his name was announced? No, you would have told them, "I can't do this unless you sort out this other thing". Which the man has been trying to do for 15 years.
- jaclaz 4y agoSorry, I probably mixed up the description, seemingly he was removed from the advisory board of the institute, where he already was: >He was removed from the advisory board of the prestigious Roosevelt Institute, which manages the Franklin D. Roosevelt presidential library. And no, if anyone could be removed from the advisory board of a prestigious institute through a single (defamatory) post, all advisory board places would be vacant.
- __derek__ 4y agoInteresting. It seems like this sort of precedent could make ChatGPT's defamation habit[1] expensive for OpenAI. [1]: https://jonathanturley.org/2023/04/06/defamed-by-chatgpt-my-own-bizarre-experience-with-artificiality-of-artificial-intelligence/ https://jonathanturley.org/2023/04/06/defamed-by-chatgpt-my-...