8 ms·
POSSE: Publish on your Own Site, Syndicate Elsewhere
- RobotToaster 4y agoHaving tried to implement this on a blog, it seems difficult if not impossible to do for free with facebook and now probably twitter.
- leephillips 4y agoI don’t know about Facebook, because I don’t have an account there, but I do this with Twitter. A new item on my website gets automatically tweeted with using a script that calls a Twitter API. I certainly don’t pay Twitter anything. If they start charging for using the API, I’m out.
- RobotToaster 4y agoFrom the OP >"As of 2022-11, Twitter is rejecting new API access for applications used to POSSE/backfeed" No idea if they will cut off old keys.
- snarfed 4y agoYou don't have to automate it. "Manual until it hurts."
- superkuh 4y agoI'm really glad I've been doing this the last decade. It was just announced that imgur is deleting all images not uploaded by someone with an active account. I used imgur quite a bit for sharing images but always made sure to put them on my webserver first.
- yosito 4y agoIs there a turn-key POSSE blogging platform where I don't have to do more than pay, and sign in with each platform to start syndicating my posts? While I love the idea, I've always found implementing all of the integrations to be too much work.
- rascul 4y agoPerhaps https://withknown.com/ https://withknown.com/
- yosito 4y agoThat seems like an entirely different use case.
- mxuribe 4y agoIn addition to what @rascul noted (WithKnown.com), there are some other services listed here (and maybe even more beyond what is listed there): https://indieweb.org/Getting_Started#IndieWeb_Services https://indieweb.org/Getting_Started#IndieWeb_Services
- yosito 4y agoThe services listed in that section only enable a very small subset of syndicated platforms, which doesn't overlap at all with the platforms I'd actually like to publish on (Instagram, Facebook, Substack) and most of the mainstream social platforms aren't even supported.
- jamietanna 4y agoAs someone else mentioned on another thread, we've got services like https://brid.gy https://brid.gy which aim to be a central means for doing this, but there are also other apps for other platforms, and in some cases, you need to do it yourself
- dahwolf 4y agoPOSSE is great from a content ownership perspective, and having syndication is better than having nothing in place. That said, posting links to original content tends to get low engagement and is generally disliked on downstream social networks. It is often seen as not really participating in a native social network, instead spamming it for the sake of self-promotion. Even if the link is promising/worthwhile, the UX sucks. As it will be typically be consumed from mobile, it opens an in-app browser, your website loads, possibly with all kinds of distractions like cookie banners or a poor reading experience. Should your link contain yet other links, the experience pretty much breaks down. Any feedback from downstream systems (likes, comments) are not syndicated back whilst at least for comments they can definitely enrich the content. Unless you have some very sophisticated polling mechanism, that content does not syndicate upwards. Similarly, if you reply to somebody else's content, your reply in a way is also your original content, but it's not preserved on your blog. Should your link really have a high value, definitely don't expect that people pass down the link in distribution. They'll take quotes and make screenshots and post it natively. Nitty gritty local cultures matter. On Reddit just posting the link may get you banned. On other networks you need to pay for API access. On Medium, you shouldn't post short form, on Mastodon, you might need a content warning and hashtags. To handle the feedback of your syndication, you continue to need to deal with every local network personally. Manage their notifications, handle their replies and follow-ups. Your friends/followers are also not syndicated. When using native social networks directly, people often use multiple personas. The standup professional on LinkedIn, but also the toxic gamer dude on Twitter. Same person, different masks. Or even multiple personas within the same network. Very hard to setup with POSSE. Say you'd participate in a "#catphotooftheweek" competition that only is a thing on Twitter. You can post it on your blog but it makes no sense there. Syndication should only happen towards Twitter. Anyway, like I said, better than nothing, but automated syndication often sucks. The content ownership part is the truly important part. You can most definitely consider syndicating manually, in optimal form per social network.
- rascul 4y agoBridgy can help to bridge the gap between those social networks. https://brid.gy/ https://brid.gy/
- dwighttk 4y agoBeen talking my mom into putting her Facebook posts onto a blog… not quite the same, but similar
- Vinnl 4y agoThe only caveat I usually have with this is that this idea of "owning" your content by publishing it on your own site is the domain name, which you rent, rather than own.
- password4321 4y agoAny usable/realistic alternative to domains?
- Otternonsenz 4y agoNot to my knowledge at this point in time, though I wish there was. Gopher and other small web tech seem closer to the owned platform idea. I would love not having to rent my platform from anyone, but our current system does not support owned domains for a non-technical user who does not have the tens of thousands of dollars to apply for owning their own TLD.
- nayuki 4y agoDecentralized stuff like .onion, Ethereum Name Service, Namecoin, ...
- hammyhavoc 4y agoSure, but not commonly supported in the OOBE of the average browser.
- NoGravitas 4y agoNot really. There have been a lot of proposals, but it's not possible to do without tradeoffs (Zooko's Triangle). And in practice, most of the proposed alternatives are worse — not only do they not provide one or more of the desired features, they are also unacceptably complex, fragile, or resource-intensive.
- shadowgovt 4y agoWait, so we gave an acronym to "Making a blog post and then sharing a link to that blog post on Twitter, Facebook, and a Mastodon node?"
- kitd 4y agoNot a link, reposting the content.
- __derek__ 4y agoThis seems like a new skin on COPE (create once, publish everywhere), an NPR idea from 10+ years ago. Ironically, it fits to just rebrand someone else's established ideas like this. Editing to add: I see that they linked to COPE in the See Also section, although the Programmable Web link is broken (irony upon irony!). NPR still has a version up, fortunately.[1] [1]: https://www.npr.org/sections/inside/2009/02/clean_content_portable_content.html https://www.npr.org/sections/inside/2009/02/clean_content_po...
- snarfed 4y agoDefinitely the same era! Looks like COPE was 2009, POSSE concept was 2010 https://indieweb.org/timeline#2010 https://indieweb.org/timeline#2010 , term was 2012 https://indieweb.org/timeline#2012 https://indieweb.org/timeline#2012 .
- dugmartin 4y agoI've often wondered why Wordpress doesn't start a public social network that syndicates only Wordpress sites. Each new user could get a default wordpress.org site using a default social networky theme & plugin or you could point your profile at your own hosted Wordpress site that had a plugin to syndicate - maybe using PubSubHubbub?
- hammyhavoc 4y agoYou'll be interested to read this: https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/13/wordpress-com-owner-automattic-acquires-an-activitypub-plugin-so-blogs-can-join-the-fediverse/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/03/13/wordpress-com-owner-automa...
- philip1209 4y agoI've been building a personal website service [1] as an alternative to social media. I hadn't heard of POSSE, but I call my idea "Write once, share everywhere" - the idea being that your content should live on your site, but can be shared on other social networks. A tip for anybody building POSSE systems: OpenGraph images make a huge impact on engagement on social networks. I generate images on-the-fly with the post title and some images, which makes links take up much more space on feeds. [1] https://postcard.page https://postcard.page
- janeway 4y agoI prefer this but if you ever have some post that triggers keywords then your whole domain may be shadow banned and you will never know.
- turnsout 4y agoI love this philosophy, but question whether it needs an acronym that implies it's a system. Unless there's more to it than "have a personal blog, and promote it."
- josephd79 4y agoRSS has been and is still alive.
- goodpoint 4y agoWhat's the point of a new name? Isn't it just having a website with RSS & co?
- dang 4y agoRelated: POSSE: Publish on your own site, syndicate elsewhere - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29115696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29115696 - Nov 2021 (43 comments) Publish on Your Own Site, Syndicate Elsewhere - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16663850 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16663850 - March 2018 (26 comments)
- asplake 4y agoAlso mentioned today in the comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35633201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35633201 My comment on that comment: note that LinkedIn disadvantages content with links. A workaround is to put the links into comments, but you have little control over their prominence.
- RobotToaster 4y ago>LinkedIn disadvantages content with links I'm fairly certain facebook does the same
- hammyhavoc 4y agoAbsolutely, but I've seen much better results on verified FB Pages.
- barbazoo 4y agoWhat a beautiful thing if you think about it. You own your content and use Twitter, etc as a communication layer in your protocol. Restricted API access makes this difficult but what an evolution.
- snarfed 4y ago"silos as plumbing"
- HollowEyes 4y agoIt's great but for the interaction problem. And mixed contexts. The automated twitter accounts feel like a fire and forget. And you probably want to eavesdrop the conversation. This could be AI territory, who's mentioning this? Web mention is a flawed system, but reaches for the right target. I see people drifting back to Twitter from Mastodon as they crave previous circle interaction. They don't like missing conversation, and comment systems per blog can be sucky.
- pipo234 4y agoI have mixed feelings about "the conversation" and social networks. Frequently there is no conversation. There is the perspective that social networks are about connecting people, having deliberations, the town square. And then there is the influencer, marketing communication, discoverability, sales funnel, SEO, push perspective. The syndication perspective in a way frames social networks mostly as the latter. I think this is a pragmatic, realistic view of what social networks have (mostly become), but it is sad. Not sure if AI (as in summarize, aggregate, "sentiment analytics") has much to offer here that is actually meaningful.
- mejutoco 4y ago> Frequently there is no conversation. Very true. How many times someone asks for recommendations and then does follows up with the recommendation. It is used, at least on twitter, as away to get engagement without any intention of connection.
- nathias 4y agoI really like this concept and kind of think that it would be the ideal state of the web if a lot of people would be doing this, however the tech part of it is pretty bad, being reliant on external APIs sucks.
- foreigner 4y agoI like it in theory but if only some of my friends are doing it, or they're not all posting to the same silo, how can I consume their posts without seeing duplicates?
- azangru 4y agoRSS feed from their site, I imagine.
- prepend 4y agoI long for the olden days when I could rss feed Twitter, Facebook, and LinkedIn to a single rss feed to check on my friends doings. Also liked yahoo pipes to mix in git commits, jira, and wiki updates to have a “work stream” that I checked on during the day.
- blacklight 4y agoA related article I wrote a while ago for RSS->Mastodon syndication - but since it uses Platypush it works with any other supported social API: https://blog.platypush.tech/article/Create-a-Mastodon-bot-to-forward-Twitter-and-RSS-feeds-to-your-timeline https://blog.platypush.tech/article/Create-a-Mastodon-bot-to...
- TRiG_Ireland 4y agoIf you are publishing from a blog, you can enable ActivityPub directly in that blog.
- samsquire 4y agoI just use GitHub, not even GitHub pages. I use Typora on Windows which is a markdown editor which is good. When I'm on my phone, I sometimes use the GitHub web interface. I journal in a README.md and add a new entry to the end of the file. Links are on my profile.
- stared 4y agoI like this philosophy. Social networks platform come and go (and so do their audiences). For example, I moved Medium posts to my blog (https://p.migdal.pl/blog/2022/12/new-blog-from-medium-to-gridsome/ https://p.migdal.pl/blog/2022/12/new-blog-from-medium-to-gri...) - as well as archived some "evergreen" FB posts.
- cutemonster 4y agoWhat other places do people here syndicate to, or would you recommend?
- hoofhearted 4y agoFacebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Medium, Indie Hackers, and Reddit is a good start. I don’t syndicate all of my own website content automatically. For some blog posts, I will summarize my post and add additional content geared for that specific platform and audience. For example, I will write a long form of a blog post for Medium, and a short form version for Indie Hackers. I make sure to write similar but unique content for each platform so that Google doesn’t penalize the source website for duplicate content.
- cutemonster 4y agoThanks! > long form for ... short form ... for ... Hadn't thought about. And on my own website, there could sometimes be "Click to expand", for those who want to expand some paragraph, and get the long version. > write similar but unique content That sounds tricky. How do you decide where a piece of unique content in a longer text, fits best :-) Hmm, if it's related to bigger workplaces, then I guess, LinkedIn? If it's applicable to one-person-projects, maybe IndieHackers? Flamebait: Reddit? (Or how do you decide)
- vdddv 4y agoas opposed to PESOS: Publish Elsewhere, Syndicate (to your) Own Site
- prepend 4y agoThis philosophy has been around in data management for a long time and applies to social media or personal content as well. I keep a master and am judicious with who is allowed to change it. And I like lots of replicas (hopefully with some registration to know about use) that can sync and derive products that selectively sync with updates or are pinned to a release. I think this fits into the splitter vs lumper philosophy where things are separated off and handled independently with clear interdependencies rather than lump everything together into a single issue to be solved overall. This means I don’t need to fix all the problems in the replicas of my data in order to go about my work or life.
- sureglymop 4y agoDoesn't the main issue lie in platform specific features? For example, after syndication on Twitter someone DMs you with relevant information to your post. It's imo the problem with something like GitHub as well. Git is already decentralized and if you push to GitHub you still have your local copy of the repo. But then if someone creates a pull request on the platform not only do you have to use the platform but some data will stay on and only exist on the platform.
- leephillips 4y agoBut you don’t have to monitor or respond to DMs. Your profile can contain a suggestion to use email. On Github, the README or whatever for your project can ask developers to please email patches, or fork, but that you don’t pay attention to Github pull requests.