4 ms·
> Does it have to be in California rather than another state? If its not, they don’t pay California sales tax based on its location at the time of sale (but Ap
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> Does it have to be in California rather than another state?
If its not, they don’t pay California sales tax based on its location at the time of sale (but Apple meets the requirement too instead be required to collect and remit similar use taxes based on the California destination; in neither case, unless the applicable endpoint is in Cupertino, would that be Cupertino.)
> China could always put their fulfillment centers in favorable tax districts
I presume you mean “Apple” not “China”, but, sure, if they want to optimize sales/use tax rather than logistics and customer experience.
They could just have a centralized wherehouse for all California orders in Cupertino, if they want to make sure all their California sales tax is allocated there. Not sure they are willing yo do that for the current payment deal, and I’m not sure Cupertino would think that’s worth the revenue, either.
> California should really just tax where the product is definitely going rather than same vague notion of where it is could come from.
Where an item physically is when it is sold is not an “vague notion”
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe point is that the goods don’t need to and are often not in California when they are sold to someone in California, so it really is a difficult law to apply. But it sounds like California uses destination taxing in that case? So most of the time, wouldn’t Apple be stuck with that instead? But no, the Californian law from the 1950s actually says location of sale, not where the physical goods being sold are located, so we avoid the goods being out of state at time of sale problem. I don’t think Apple is going to lose this case, and California just needs better laws.