5 ms·
If you have spent a meaningful amount of time on this site over the last few years you will have seen that the general user sentiment has shifted pretty far rig
by paxys 4y ago
If you have spent a meaningful amount of time on this site over the last few years you will have seen that the general user sentiment has shifted pretty far right. The standard discussion isn't too far from what you'd come across on a Fox News/Elon Musk/Infowars/Joe Rogan forum.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI completely disagree with almost all of this assertion, based on my experience. There is an entire spectrum of political views, a good example would be stories about incarceration and homelessness which result in fairly left swinging opinions and very little blaming of the people involved.
- nicpottier 4y agoI agree that HN is still pretty liberal but I also agree with GP that the swing to the right in the past few years has been very real.
- rongenre 4y agoThere were a ton of people here really into Ivermectin in the late 2020's.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI’d wonder if that was sample bias, people not into it were probably less vocal about their opinion. I do find the correlation between vaccine hesitancy and conservative political views interesting though.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoIt feels like our current political parties are the result of force-teaming and meaningless labels creating unhappy and fragile alliances ready to split. Imho this would be great as the manufactured left/right dichotomy never helped anyone. Is a parent far-right for demanding high standards from drugs they put into their children, or a leftist for not just accepting big-pharma's word? I personally saw a lot of people be ejected from "the left" because of questioning the medical response to Covid. Many different circumstance, but they'd all run into the mandatory acceptance of the message. Some had been vaccine "wary" before and remained that way, others were pro-vax but doubted the safety given its minimal testing time, etc. All of these people were your average west-coast hippy type and they're now being told they're allied with unite-the-right anti-jew stuff in the USA. I can't wait until the new affiliations drop and we can ditch the legacy groupings.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI’m fairly uninformed with politics (I’m not American either). Please don’t interpret this as passive aggressive, but more of a question / passing thought: Wouldn’t republicans believe more in ‘each to their own, survival of the fittest’ (I want the best for my children) where democrats would be more ‘value for everyone’ (I should get vaccinated regardless of risk to protect my neighbours) I imagine the Christian religion is more popular with republicans, which if true is equally interesting given it would contradict the above assertions (love thy neighbour, etc)…
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> Wouldn’t republicans believe more in ‘...’ where democrats would be more ‘...’ With only two parties I don't think the parties themselves are good proxies for the views of the people who end up voting for them. I think generally most people would want 1) each to their own 3) success of the hardworking 3) equality for everyone. With only two parties for the whole political spectrum neither group is actually that distinct. Many people vote on the key issues that impact their day-to-day and so there's generally no real difference on issues that aren't in the news. Anyways, being on the west coast I assume that most of the Americans I'm talking about are Dems, and in Canada, probably 'Liberals'. I think their (perfectly reasonable) hippy distrust of government and corporations makes them doubt the "benefits" meaning they had no reason to do it for neighbors either. (This was 2+y ago now, who knows where they are now.) A community meeting I went to a few years ago spent twenty minutes or so discussing microwaved water, and if the venue used a microwave and whether some people were "safe to drink the tea", and went downhill from there in a science sense. Everyone was very eager to help but it wasn't a terribly well informed group.
- LawTalkingGuy 4y agoThere were a lot of promising studies into using it for Covid then - large-scale retrospective cohort studies of pre-existing ivermectin trials going on as Covid started to spread. It just turns out that it mostly didn't apply to the first world because most people don't have parasitic comordidities. This was really annoying because the reaction to Trump's casual mention of it injected virulent American politics into everything around the world. We should have been able to discuss this and other topics without Rep/Dem nonsense spilling over, but instead any discussion of covid became nearly verboten, with even simply statements of obvious fact being banned. (ie, we haven't yet checked the Wuhan lab to see if Covid did in fact leak from there.)
- DonHopkins 4y agoNo, general user sentiment hasn't shifted. It's not that people's opinions have changed, it's that people who were already right wing bigots now feel it's ok to openly express their right wing bigotry, thanks to Trump.
- sebzim4500 4y agoI don't think there is a shift to the right, but rather a shift towards authoritarianism. It's pretty surprising to see people on 'hacker'news so in favour of government surveillance/censorship.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago> I don't think there is a shift to the right, but rather a shift towards authoritarianism. In my opinion, that may be a fairly contrary-to-fact opinion to hold. Take the contentious issue of transgender human rights, for example: the HN discussions that I’ve seen quite heavily tended towards right-wing principles of distrust of intellectuals [0] (vis-a-vis completely discounting readily available scientific information). I presume that much of the indignation towards trans topics also stems from a the right-wing principle of religious traditionalism [0]. Granted, that’s just based on my experiences in the comments. I’ve not done any sort of in-depth analysis to arrive at the above opinion. Alternatively, perhaps the latest stage of right-wing politics could be defined as the replacement of democratic law-and-order with righteous authoritarianism, rendering the quote somewhat nonsensical, in my hypothetical opinion. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right-wing_politics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right-wing_politics
- LawTalkingGuy 4y ago> Take the contentious issue of transgender human rights [...] tended towards right-wing principles of distrust of intellectuals There's a weird form of "intellectual"ism going on these days. I've gotten insanely mad pushback on my contention that we simply cannot know if Covid leaked from Wuhan. (Or, back in 2020 we couldn't - who knows where we're getting now.) It could be easy to show there was a leak, but would be almost impossible to show there wasn't. Note that I wasn't saying "we shouldn't take the vax" or anything, just the leak issue. Total rabid culture war. Similarly, there's a huge push that "trans women are women" and that there's science for this, gender spectrum and so on, but there's no ability to look behind the curtain. The studies don't show what they purport to, and don't match the claims they're being used to defend. Nobody has attempted to show a midpoint on the sex spectrum, and even if they did - the argument has moved on and now trans is an issue of self-id that doesn't require any physical issue. Bring this up and you're "literally saying trans people shouldn't exist", etc. In both cases there's no depth to the argument, despite that it apparently comes from the best scientific minds in the world - it claims to be a factual claim but when you ask to see the facts it becomes a purity issue where you're then shamed for not simply believing. I was told I was a Covid denier because of not simply accepting the no-lab-leak story. > perhaps the latest stage of right-wing politics could be defined as the replacement of democratic law-and-order with righteous authoritarianism One side makes "facts" a matter of righteousness and the other side simply eschews facts for their religion.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smrtinsert 4y ago100% agree. Most appear to be non-technical as well so all we get for the tedium of groaning through their comments Tucker "truth telling" detritus. Not even a billion dollars will convince them they're wrong though...
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago> Not even a billion dollars will convince them they're wrong though... It might wake some of them up, though. Pardon the sheep, for they are asleep. Dreaming dreams of nightmare fences.
- norgie 4y agoIt was always generally leaned right, but the overall HN has definitely turned more aggressively right wing over the last few years. I think some of this is down to a number of high profile tech execs openly embracing far-right positions, including people associated with YC/HN.
- zamnos 4y agoOf course, simplifying the political spectrum along a 1-dimensional axis is an oversimplification. In particular, during the most recent SVB crisis, people associated with YC/HN called for a bailout, which is not a traditionally held GOP right wing position, given the president during the banking crisis in 2008.