4 ms·
This article is written as if the delays are some kind of gotcha, but is it really that bitter a pill to swallow? The goal was never to outcompete SpaceX on pri
by jeroenhd 4y ago
This article is written as if the delays are some kind of gotcha, but is it really that bitter a pill to swallow? The goal was never to outcompete SpaceX on price. The EU wants to have access to space technology that's not tied up to foreign governments or oligarchs, and reduce the launch cost in the process.
Obviously such a program will be more expensive than a private endeavor, no member state is going to invest into the program without some kind of return and that comes with delays and higher cost.
Shopping around for launches now that the Ariane 6 has been delayed isn't some kind of epic defeat in the battle for spaceflight, it's just an inconvenience necessary to keep other projects on track.
- nordsieck 4y ago> This article is written as if the delays are some kind of gotcha, but is it really that bitter a pill to swallow? The goal was never to outcompete SpaceX on price. Sort of. It's easy to forget, since SpaceX has such dominance over the space industry currently, but commercial space was mostly split between Europe and Russia before SpaceX. The goal of Ariane 6 was to help ArianeGroup maintain its marketshare - particularly of GEO/GTO launches - in the face of aggressive pricing by SpaceX. > Shopping around for launches now that the Ariane 6 has been delayed isn't some kind of epic defeat in the battle for spaceflight, it's just an inconvenience necessary to keep other projects on track. I think there may be some missing context here. There has been a somewhat strong movement to limit European institutional launches to European rockets, in the same way that the DoD/NASA does with US launchers.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoIn the Netherlands every single project goes vastly over budget. It's never been a bitter pill. There's always more money to throw at things and people forget. The entire European space program is but a rounding error in the grand scheme of things.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoI agree, pointing that something is running over budget, when it is done by public company. That might be surprising only for people outside of Europe.
- 0xDEF 4y agoKeeping the legacy Ariane 5 launch platform alive is fine. But Ariane 6 effort and funding should have been directed into a highest-priority ESA project to create SpaceX-style reusable heavy-lift launch vehicles. Europe cannot let an increasingly unstable Elon Musk be the de facto gatekeeper to space. I know Ariane 6 development goes way back but it doesn't make sense to invest more in the development of single-use heavy-lift launch vehicle. Edit: The initial concept art for Ariane 7 suggests it is a SpaceX-style reusable rocket.
- ren_engineer 4y ago>Europe cannot let an increasingly unstable Elon Musk be the de facto gatekeeper to space. unstable according to who, the media who are mad at him over Twitter? I keep seeing people make claims like this but if he was such a lunatic it seems like Blue Origin, Lockheed/Boeing, or the entirety of Europe should be able to beat SpaceX pretty easy if it's being run by a lunatic or just wait for it to collapse. Occam's razor would be that Musk isn't really as crazy as his public persona
- croes 4y agoAccording to his Tweets. Occam's razor would be that the real work at SpaceX isn't done by Musk but it's engineers.
- ren_engineer 4y agoand yet there are competitors with far bigger budgets who can't seem to poach those engineers doing the work. Or for some reason refuse to hire the engineers that are kicking their ass. So Musk is either a better manager(getting more done with equal talent) or better at finding talent that Boeing and Blue Origin reject. If Musk is actively impeding SpaceX, why can't these companies seem to beat him? SpaceX engineers should be jumping at the chance to take their knowledge to Boeing/Lockheed/Blue Origin/Europe and work for people who are better than Musk(according to the media)
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mardifoufs 4y agoAriane 6 also had the goal of being a competitive commercial launch platform, not just a strategic European launch platform.
- panick21_ 4y agoIts a nice bit of rewriting history. When Ariane 6 was first discuss politically it was all about how it would beat SpaceX in the market, how competitive it would be and so on and so on. Endlessly talking about how Arianespace was so superior to SpaceX in terms of launch cadence and reliability and so on. And now 10 years later its 'well we need to launch sats ourself, of course we can't compete with SpaceX on the open market'. If their goal had actually been assured independent access to space, doing the Ariane 5 ME was a better plan. Because the reality is, the cost for Ariane 6 is far greater then the money saved by going from Ariane 5 ME to Ariane 6. It will take a decade or more of flying Ariane 6 before this actual saves money. And by then the better have their next rocket in planning.