4 ms·
Now this is amazing. Not because of the issue itself (both sides seem pretty idiotic), but because Facebook has become like a government with embassies that peo
by pron 15y ago
Now this is amazing. Not because of the issue itself (both sides seem pretty idiotic), but because Facebook has become like a government with embassies that people protest against over social rights.
Think about it: people are now protesting a (non-democratic) corporation for their social rights.
And another thing. This is the internet age, and people insisting on posting their photos in whatever compromising positions for the world to see should be at least somewhat technologically savvy. Why don't they just post their photos on tumblr (with a link on facebook) where they can even post photos of them having sex with their (non-minor) children?
When governments ruled the world it was hard to pick up your things and leave. But in the age of the nanny-conglomerates, why not just go to a competitor? I guess the answer is that the market isn't really competitive any more. Rather, it's become (just like in the archaic state-ruled world) segmented into influence blocs. You got a few superpowers, and lots of satellite "states".
- hengli 15y agoThis is not a new development. People have been protesting corporations for a long time.
- pron 15y agoAbsolutely, but over different things like work conditions or blatant discrimination. I think there is something new here. It's a social-cultural issue that in a government would have been handled by the supreme court.
- Avshalom 15y agoHow is "blatant discrimination" NOT a social-cultural issue that in a government...
- rsanders 15y agoOr over changing the formula of Coca-Cola. When you feel that the free market does not provide you with an acceptable substitute, it's in your interest to make your problem known. With any luck, you thereby make it in the corporation's interest to change. If not, perhaps you encourage the market to provide an alternative. If they had just silently stopped using Facebook, there's no chance that any change they wanted would occur. That would be idiotic.
- gjm11 15y ago> both sides seem pretty idiotic What seems idiotic about the "pictures of breastfeeding infants should be allowed on Facebook" side? (The fact that they don't give up on Facebook and use something else? But their goal isn't just to be able to post their pictures somewhere; they want to be able to participate in Facebook, where for good or ill much of the world's social life happens these days, without censoring themselves in pointless ways; and they want everyone on Facebook to have that freedom. Saying they should go elsewhere instead of protesting at Facebook would be, on a much smaller scale, a bit like saying that people unhappy with their country's government should emigrate rather than protesting at their government.)
- pron 15y agoIt's idiotic because it's pointless. I guess some people may be offended by it (after all, it's public!) Say that some people are offended by photos of people eating so Facebook decides to ban those. What's the big deal? It's not like it's racial discrimination or anything.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 15y agoSo, it's idiotic because you personally don't feel it's a big deal?
- pron 15y agoNo. It's idiotic because it is actually not a big deal. We have women who like publishing photographs of them breastfeeding their babies, and we have a corporation that thinks some people are offended by said photographs, so they take them down. The women insist on their right to publish said photographs on the very same website owned by the aforementioned corporation, so they stage a public protest. I find it entertaining, but I mostly think it is a nice cultural moment in the history of the West. But it is by no means a big deal.
- 15y ago
- noja 15y agoThis is hardly new. People have always protested companies. I wonder whether this protest will have the desired effect. Banning topless and breastfeeding photos leading to topless women descending on FBHQ might not be the stick the protesters are hoping for.
- pron 15y agoBut it's certainly great entertainment.
- dsr_ 15y agoA woman breastfeeding her baby is not in a compromising position. Comparing it to incest is ridiculously trollish.
- pron 15y agoI am not comparing it to incest. This was hyperbolic! And taking everything so seriously, especially such a minor matter (and it is a minor matter; people in other areas of the world have bigger things to protest other than their right to post breastfeeding pictures on a social network) is also a bit ridiculous.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoIt's not really about Facebook - IMO it's about combatting the harmful assumption that breastfeeding is not a normal part of society. Facebook is merely an element supporting the contrary view. Personally I suspect this to be mainly a USA issue born out of the promotion of women's bodies as sexual objects.
- canisterman 15y agoAssumption is not about role of breastfeeding in society, it's about whenever such public (including public accessible images) demonstration is acceptable. Death is normal part of society, but no sane person will consider posting pictures of decomposing bodies acceptable. (Another hyperbole).
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>Death is normal part of society, but no sane person will consider posting pictures of decomposing bodies acceptable. This was the point someone else tried to make (see my other comment). You've cut the proposition in half. Yes death is a normal (and natural) part of society. Presenting decomposing bodies in public is not generally considered a normal part of civilised society (sky burials aside I guess; though they have their own context). It's that 'a baby feeding in public' is normal. The equivalent is that 'a dead body in a morgue' or 'a dead body in a coffin' is normal.