5 ms·
Brit cops rapped over app that recorded 200k phone calls
- musha68k 4y agoMaybe someone local could explain to me why “living inside the panopticon” has been so widely accepted? Is this historically derived from loyal trust in the monarch?
- arcticbull 4y agoLikely the same reason folks in China and Singapore accept a panopticon. It's a safe, comfortable environment. I feel dramatically safer at 2am in Shanghai than I do in any US city. It's not the trade-off I want for myself, but it's understandable - and were I born there, I might even endorse it. To the extent that the economy is doing well and folks feel like the country is headed in a positive direction they're generally willing to accept an awful lot from the state. When that inevitably changes though (due to cyclicality), things tend to get spicy. Don't suspect this has much to do with the King.
- latexr 4y ago> I feel dramatically safer at 2am in Shanghai than I do in any US city. To be fair, the US is a poor example. I’d feel safer in any European city at 2am then in a US city in the middle of the day. At least I don’t have to worry about being shot for no reason.¹ In the US I was reminded of that possibility every time I walked into a museum. ¹ https://text.npr.org/2023/04/18/1170593395/kaylin-gillis-new-york-driveway-kevin-monahan https://text.npr.org/2023/04/18/1170593395/kaylin-gillis-new...
- Silhouette 4y agoIt is historically derived from trust in the government, police and security services. High profile failures aside, that trust has mostly been earned and respected for a long time. It doesn't change the principles or deeper dangers of course but it does affect public perception. Most people simply have bigger things to worry about when they believe these tools are usually being employed with good intentions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- musha68k 4y agoYes, it’s understandable that most don’t (have the time/energy) to worry. I’m Austrian though and hence have a deep distrust of any bureaucracy that records “everything” and generally works too well. I think it’s a fallacy that these systems can’t / won’t ever be exploited on a larger scale (pretty large already telling from the article..)
- Silhouette 4y agoI think your distrust is probably wise. Even if things are trustworthy today there is always a chance of that changing with a new government tomorrow and history provides too many examples where that didn't end well. Unfortunately part of the problem is that different types of people experience these systems very differently. I'm unremarkable and unlikely to attract the interest of the authorities by association either so most of the ongoing problems you do see in the news don't tend to affect me or those close to me. I remember how one similarly unremarkable person I know was shocked and quite upset when they were challenged by a huge scary-looking guy to show some kind of ticket while travelling in London even though they had one and hadn't done anything wrong. And then I wonder how often a mid-teens black kid living on the estate 25 metres overhead has been "profiled" by the Met and what their experience of being challenged by authority must feel like. Until we fix the glaring inequalities in our society there will always be big problems lurking underneath sadly.
- anigbrowl 4y agoLook up 'collective action problem'.
- throwawayuk5435 4y agoPanopticon!? Why do Americans routinely still believe the UK is an exceptional, universal surveillance state? There were two studies done (in Kings Lynn in Norfolk and in a section of Putney) that are full of mistakes, that US media has picked up as some kind of indication that the UK is down some dark path the same as China. People believe every residential street has police cameras (not even close to true) or that the _government_ operates "millions" of cameras (not true), or that there's nowhere you can go in the UK where you can't be immediately followed on camera. Most of the "millions" of cameras in the studies are, like most of the millions of cameras in the USA, pointing from the back of shop out through the glass at the front. If the police want those they have to ask, on foot, to the manager of the store, and the store manager may require them to have a warrant. See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance_in_the_United_Kingdom#Number_of_cameras https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_surveillance_in_the_Unite... And then ask yourself: how different is it in the USA? (Throwaway because I am really done with commenting here, but this CCTV misunderstanding always makes me laugh. Here's a tip: the USA is not really very different. (Except that our police aren't armed to the teeth, you don't get nearly shot to death for going to the wrong house while black, and our politicians don't plan to put prisons next to theme parks to score points)
- mardifoufs 4y agoYour comment is basically just whataboutism. Bringing up racism in the US for no reason (in a way that subtlety denies the massive racism problem in the UK/europe) just to deflect from the debate of surveillance powers in the UK is quite the take. Especially when the comment you are replying to seems to be written by an austrian not the american boogeyman. It's weird that you only focus on the issue of CCTV cameras, when the debate is about much more than that. British authorities are allowed by law to engage in massive surveillance that does not happen even in the US (or at least, not overly and not fully allowed by the law). You might be ok with that, but it's weird to downplay it. >but it will also introduce new domestic powers, including a government database that stores the web history of every citizen in the country. [..] >Police officers will then be able to access a central search engine known as the "request filter" to retrieve this information. [..] >The key point about this power, though, is that it has no judicial oversight. Access to citizens’ web history will be solely at the discretion of the police, with a specially trained supervising officer approving or denying requests https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/23/13718768/uk-surveillance-laws-explained-investigatory-powers-bill https://www.theverge.com/2016/11/23/13718768/uk-surveillance... But I guess CCTVs are not as bad as internet discourse says they are, so whatever.
- eynsham 4y agoThe US has a very different intellectual tradition arising from a deliberate act of rebellion and a fairly static constitution. Many European countries have a history of fascist dictatorship. Britain has neither, so in my view is somewhat lackadaisical about the risks of state power. We’re rightly proud that we didn’t succumb as Italy or Germany did, but of course that means that dictatorship is something that happens to other people or comes from Brussels. It’s true that our electoral democracy is relatively safe (redrawing of constituencies is normal, new ID card requirements are dubiously motivated) but that leaves a lot of scope for far more intrusion with far less constitutional oversight than many other Western liberal states. Notably, there is less scepticism about state power in other democracies where there is a similar lack of scepticism for historical reasons—e.g., France, where the legacy of Vichy is often downplayed relative to the resistance, or Japan, which never really confronted its past.
- bragr 4y agoThis uses some awfully passive language about how the app came to be installed. Did the officers install it themselves from the list of approved apps, or did someone push it down onto a bunch of devices? If the officers installed it themselves, that somewhat discredits the idea the individual police officers had no idea.
- quijoteuniv 4y agoThis seems all a bit of a joke. They are now pretending they did not know, they apologise and thats it. Not on mayor media either… hopeless
- dewclin 4y ago> Not on major media either… Guardian have something: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/apr/18/surrey-and-sussex-police-unlawfully-recorded-phone-calls-through-app-watchdog-finds https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/apr/18/surrey-and-s...
- darreninthenet 4y agoAs well as the Guardian link somebody else has posted, the BBC are reporting it: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65309114 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65309114 And it was a story on the news section of the radio station (Classic FM, a nationwide one) I am listening to just now
- maerF0x0 4y agoAnd should be treated as a pretty major policy gap in policing... Officers should not be using BYOD, they work with far to sensitive of data both in the sense of leaking what they're working on (giving privy folks a preview to investigations), but also leaking "customer" (the public's) sensitive data to those without authorization.
- caiusdurling 4y agoThey likely have work issued mobile phones, I know my local force does that. Edit: reading the judgement shows the phones were issued by the force: > While it is acknowledged that the App was downloaded onto officially provided encrypted mobile devices, evidence was provided during the investigation to indicate that copies of call recordings had been manually transferred onto removable media
- vorticalbox 4y ago> but instead opted for its revised public sector approach in which it seeks to help entities learn from their mistakes because "that was naughty don't do it again" has worked out wonderfully so far.
- trebligdivad 4y agoThe problem is fines dont work either since it's just one gov dept fining another.
- setr 4y agoFines should still have an impact; it’s basically a reallocation of budget, and any org presumably wants to maximize their slice of the pie to achieve whatever their goals are (personal or otherwise). Ofc, the usual story is that the fines aren’t that high, and can be effectively treated as a cost of doing business, so they do little to nothing for incentives.
- alistairSH 4y agoAll the fines eventually get paid by the tax-paying public, so it's a no-win to fine government agencies.
- eynsham 4y agoI think that’s missing the point that the department fined is unlikely to recover the whole fine and most departments respond to incentives to maximise their longevity and budget, so there is a meaningful incentive from intra-governmental fines of sufficient size.
- alistairSH 4y agoMaybe this is different in the UK, but in the US, most police settlements are paid in one of three ways... 1. Insurance. The department isn't out any money and the public gets stuck with higher premiums going forward. 2. General funds. The department isn't out any money and the public has to top up the general fund or forgo other programs. 3. Bonds. The department isn't out any money and public gets double-fucked because they now have to pay fees to the financial industry plus interest.
- kbutler 4y agoWondered about "rap" in this context: From Collins dictionary of British English """ Rap: 2 (verb) in the sense of reprimand Definition to rebuke or criticize sharply """ Other interpretations would have been too good to be true.
- ip_addr 4y agoF the police?
- twic 4y agoHelp the Police! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZyqwOOmETI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZyqwOOmETI
- bheadmaster 4y agoHelp the Police, coming straight from the downtown! Young cop eating donuts, so he's round.
- jaclaz 4y agoYep, I expected a link to a TikTok or Youtube video with the officers singing and dancing ...
- badcppdev 4y agoI feel "The Register" specialises in headlines that can be parsed in more than one way.
- pjdesno 4y agoThey hold to the best traditions of British tabloid journalism. My favorite is Every! Single! Headline! About! Yahoo!
- a4isms 4y agoUS-flavoured English has this type of "rap" as well, as in Raganwald faced the rap for making too many reddit-esque puns on Hacker News. The mods reviewed his rap sheet and determined that permanent expulsion was warranted for this transgression. I believe both descend from "rap" as a form of rebuke, in one case synonymous with criticism, in the other synonymous with a conviction in a court of law.
- kleiba 4y agoSurrey Police and Sussex Police were given access to the Another Call Recorder app [...] The police officers were themselves unaware that calls would be recorded. Yeah, I guess that wasn't clear from the name of the app...
- imjonse 4y agoWell, the app name suggests that another call will be recorded.
- Waterluvian 4y agoAs an iPhone user in a region where single-consent is the law, are there any convenient ways to record phone calls without extra hardware or jail breaking?
- mrcheesebreeze 4y agospeaker mode + separate device to record. Either that or use a computer to do the call and record using software on the computer. I don't know how the latter is done but I know many companies do that.
- ummonk 4y agoCan't one stick a recording device between the headphone and phone?
- Zigurd 4y agoIf you have a headphone jack and a splitter that could work. I do not know of any "two sided" Bluetooth devices that could sit between a phone and headset.
- rcme 4y agoWhy couldn't your bluetooth mic / headset record?
- filoeleven 4y agoYes, I’ve read that this is what most reporters do. There are a number of devices built for it. I’ve never used any so have no recommendations.
- aastronaut 4y agojust patch inputs and outputs to audacity (or your recording software of choice). for pipewire theres helvum[0] or qpwgraph[1]. for JACK there's Catia[2]. [0]: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/helvum https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/pipewire/helvum [1]: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/rncbc/qpwgraph https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/rncbc/qpwgraph [2]: https://kx.studio/Applications:Catia https://kx.studio/Applications:Catia
- cmilton 4y agoOne of the downsides to have a device for both personal and business use with no easy way to separate the two.
- rcme 4y agoThe part I'm missing is: why is this bad? I expect police officers to wear body cams, for instance. I automatically assume any interaction I have with a police officer is being recorded. I didn't realize these was an expectation of privacy.
- d1sxeyes 4y agoIt’s bad because it discourages “off the record” tips given to police officers. Not everyone who talks to a police officer is a criminal.
- rcme 4y agoDon't you have a right to meet your accuser, however? I know this typically only applies in court, but encouraging off-the-record communication is basically encouraging parallel construction is it not?
- jack_pp 4y agoNot when you're a gangster able and willing to send goons to kill or hospitalize your accuser.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Don't you have a right to meet your accuser, however? It only applies to those who give testimony against you in court. If an informant's tip leads to enough hard evidence to convict, they may not need to testify and thus are not your accuser; your accuser is whoever's testifying about that evidence (forensic tech, detective, etc.) Anonymous tips are a thing, after all.
- noxvilleza 4y agoThat's generally (as in, both in the US [6th amendment] and the UK [Article 6 of the ECHR]) regarding witnesses offering testimony during trials (and the right of the defendant to cross-examine them) - not people giving anonymous tips which might inspire police to do investigations of their own. In the UK, even if a witness is giving direct testimony in a trial there are situations which, for safety reasons, the witness might be allowed to be anonymous: https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/witness-protection-and-anonymity https://www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/witness-protection-and... outlines this.
- olliej 4y agoI read that wrong and was disappointed there weren't a bunch of "cool" police officers interacting with The Youth.