3 ms·
Many US SUVs can not be sold globally. If they make a "normal" one, they will have the same problem. Car manufacturers don't need to sell the same model everyw
by marcosdumay 4y ago
Many US SUVs can not be sold globally.
If they make a "normal" one, they will have the same problem.
Car manufacturers don't need to sell the same model everywhere anyway. Regional markets are large enough to absorb a full model's production.
- threeseed 4y agoAnd yet Porsche, Range Rover, Rivian etc manage to sell the same cars globally. I'm not a rocket science/engineering/business genius like Musk but pretty sure having one design that may require some minor regional modifications is going to be significantly cheaper than having two completely different cars.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoPorsche (~300k units/year) and Range Rover (~90k units/year) are niche brands, Rivian isn't even profitable and a volume manufacturer. Conversely, the Model Y was the US' 6th best selling vehicle last year [1], is currently the 4th best selling vehicle in 2023, and will likely the world's best selling car in 2023 [2] based on demand and supply forecasts. [1] https://insideevs.com/news/629993/tesla-model-y-6th-bestselling/ https://insideevs.com/news/629993/tesla-model-y-6th-bestsell... [2] https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/1177/tesla-model-y-set-to-take-top-spot-as-world-s-best-selling-car-in-2023 https://www.notateslaapp.com/news/1177/tesla-model-y-set-to-... > According to a report from Focus to Move, the Model Y is now the fourth best-selling vehicle worldwide after an astonishing 88 percent jump from 2021 to 2022. There were 759,000 Model Ys sold last year, just 28,000 units behind the third-place Ford F-150 which has been the best-selling truck for the previous 46 years. Toyota claimed the top two spots, with the RAV4 at 870,000 and the Corolla selling 1.12 million. (waiting on my cybertruck)
- matthewdgreen 4y agoThe Model Y has a very conventional style, so the fact that it sells well would seem to be a point in favor of the GP’s argument. It also sells in many continents, which Cybertruck might not be able to do.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoConsider Tesla did not copy existing manufacturers. They built their own markets (S->X->3->Y). People complain online loudly about the touchscreen, quality, but I'll be damned, these units get moved regardless (well on our way to almost 3M/year [1]). For example, Harley can't woo younger riders to the brand because their attempt to acquire them turns off older Harley fans who are slowly dying out. Tesla doesn't have to attract legacy truck owners (Ford, Ram, Chevy), they're targeting young buyers and then locking them into the brand [2]. Buying a car is an emotional purchase [3], they're not going to convert older folks, they're going entrench themselves in youth purchasers as older, sticky auto buyers age out with their legacy preferences. Cybertruck doesn't have to sell well, it just has to have greater demand than supply globally. Global pickup truck market is ~4M/units annually, so Tesla should do just fine carving out some of that for itself. [1] https://cleantechnica.com/2023/01/03/tesla-sales-up-40-to-record-1-37-million-but-thats-not-seen-as-enough/ https://cleantechnica.com/2023/01/03/tesla-sales-up-40-to-re... [2] https://electrek.co/2023/02/27/tesla-dominates-brand-loyalty-us-electric-cars-taking-over/ https://electrek.co/2023/02/27/tesla-dominates-brand-loyalty... [3] https://martecgroup.com/emotional-car-buying-journey/ https://martecgroup.com/emotional-car-buying-journey/
- philwelch 4y agoThe original Tesla Roadster was based on a Lotus chassis, and the models after that weren’t major deviations from the norm (aside from maybe the gull wings, but even those have some design heritage). Elon was a car guy before Tesla—one of his first splurges when he got rich was a McLaren F1, which he infamously crashed with Peter Thiel in the passenger seat—and as a result, Tesla cars all seem reminiscent of European sports cars. He’s not a truck guy, though. So while his personal tastes have been beneficial for Tesla in the past, I think they miss the mark with Cybertruck. Also, trucks are functional vehicles, and Cybertruck violates a lot of common functionality that most “legacy” trucks have. There are probably a lot of people who drive trucks who don’t need that functionality—i.e. poseurs—and maybe some of them will buy Cybertrucks. Cf. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23331546 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23331546
- 4y ago
- threeseed 4y agoPorsche and Range Rover are popular in the SUV space. But please explain the thought process. That if a company is popular and profitable they should always build an entirely different product for each country. Makes you wonder why tiny companies like Apple and Nike don't follow this brilliant idea.
- dingosity 4y agoAnd the cybertruck (~0 units/year) is a mainstream brand...
- timeon 4y agoIs there a point to sell 'trucks' globally?
- Fuzzwah 4y agoProfit?
- rsynnott 4y agoI think their point is probably that the personal-use pickup truck (_presumably_ the Tesla truck isn't intended as an actual utility truck) is _mostly_ an American phenomenon; the idea of having a personal pickup truck is just far less common in most countries (I think it's somewhat a thing in Australia). So there may not be much of a global market for this _anyway_.